II .
A Letter to Dr. Mead , Coll. Med. Lond. &amp; Soc. Reg. S. concerning an Experiment , whereby it has been attempted to show the falsity of the common Opinion , in relation to the force of Bodies in Motion .
By Henry Pemberton , M. D. R. S. S. SIR , PErusing the Learned Polenus 's Tract de Castellis , you were pleased to send me ; I have found in it several curious Experiments , among which I reckon that of letting Globes of equal Magnitude , but of different weights , fall upon a yielding Substance , as Tallow , Wax , Clay or the like , from heights reciprocally proportional to the weights of the Globes .
This Experiment engaged in particular my Attention , as it is brought with design to overturn one of the first Principles established in Natural Philosophy .
And the Knowledge I have of your great Esteem for that part of Science , emboldens me to trouble you with my Thoughts upon this Experiment ; for I cannot by any means admit of the Deduction that is drawn from thence , that because the Globes make in this Experiment equal Impressions in the yielding Substance , therefore they strike upon it with equal force : whereby it is attempted to prove the Assertion of Mr. Leibnitz , that the force of the same Body in descending is proportional to the height from whence it falls ; or , in all Motion , proportional to the Square of the Velocity , and not proportional to the Velocity it self , as is commonly thought .
On the contrary , I think this very ExperiN meant meant proves the great unreasonableness of Mr , Leibnitz 's Notion .
I am surprised , that so careful a Writer as Polenus appears to be , from the accuracy wherewith he delivers his Experiments , should not rather suspect his reasoning in an intricate Case , than thus contradict a Principle in Philosophy , that has been directly proved by a multitude of Experiments , in particular by those Sir Isaac Newton recommends for that purpose ( a ) ; and that is moreover abundantly established by its exact Agreement with all Observations ; as being the Principle upon which all appearances , hitherto observed in the motion of Bodies , are accounted for by just and undeniable Arguments ; and we shall find on Inquiry , that the present Case comes also under the same Rule .
As the use of Experiments in Natural Philosophy is to discover the Causes of Things , by exhibiting more simple Effects of those Causes , than occur in the ordinary course of Nature ; so for this end it is necessary , that our Argumentation upon Experiments be perfectly just , otherwise they may lead us into Errors .
The first thing necessary for making right Deductions from an Experiment , is to determine the proper use thereof ; which I think in this before us is not rightly understood .
Certainly this Experiment of Polenus is much more fit to inform us of the Law , by which these yielding Substances resist the motion of Bodies striking upon them , than to show the forces , with which Bodies strike ; for whatever those forces be , the Effects must be very different , according to the Difference there may be in the Rule observed by such resistance .
( a ) Princip .
Philos. .
Not .
p. 19 .
Now this Experiment shows , that if two Globes in Motion bear against equal Portions of the yielding Substance , the Opposition , that Substance makes to the Motion of the Globes , will be the same in both~ however different the Velocities be , with which they move~ This I shall demonstrate as follows .
Let A and B be two Globes , equal in Magnitude , but of different Weights , which are equally immersed into a yielding Substance .
Suppose the Velocities , with which they move in their present Situation , to be reciprocally in the Subduplicate ratio of the Weights of the Globes ; that is , let the ratio of the Weight of the Globe A to the Weight of the Globe B , be Duplicate of the ratio of the Velocity of the Globe B , to the Velocity of the Globe A. Since therefore the ratio of the quantity of Motion in the Globe A , or of the force with which it moves , to the quantity of Motion in the Globe B , or to the force with which that Globe moves , is compounded of the ratio of the Weight of the Globe A , to the Weight of the Globe B , and of the ratio of the Velocity of the Globe A , to the Velocity of the other Globe B , the force , with which the Globe A moves , is to the force , with which the Globe B moves , as the Velocity of this Globe B , to the Velocity of the other Globe A. But if the same Opposition be made to the Motion of the Globes , when they bear upon equal Portions of the yielding Substance , the Effect of that Opposition , while the Globes enter farther into the Substance by equal Spaces , will be proportional to the time , in which the Globes are moving those Spaces , or in which the Opposition is made , if we consider those Spaces while nascent or in their first Origin ; the Effect therefore of this Opposition will be reciprocally proportional to the Velocity of each Globe : namely , the momentaneous loss of force in the Globe A will be to the momentaneous loss of force in the Globe B , as the Velocity of the Globe B , to the Velocity of the Globe A ; and the whole force of the Globe A has been found to bear the same ratio to the whole force of the Globe B ; consequently these Globes , while they penetrate equal Spaces into the Substance , lose parts of their force , which bear the same proportion to the whole : and therefore , if their Velocities be at any time reciprocally in the Subduplicate ratio of their Weights , so that the forces or degrees of Motion , with which they move , be reciprocally proportional to their Velocities , the forces , with which they press into the yielding Substance , at equal Indentures made in the Substance , will continue in the same Proportion ; and therefore upon the Theory of Resistance here supposed , when the whole Force and Motion of both these Globes is entirely lost , they will be plunged into the Substance at equal Depths .
Now whereas in the Experiment of Polenus , the Globes , falling from Heights reciprocally proportional to their Weights .
strike upon the yielding Substance with Velocities reciprocally in the Subduplicate proportion of their Weights , and the Effect is in all Cases found to be , what is here deduced from the Theory of Resistance , I have proposed ; it is a sufficient Confirmation of the Truth of this Theory .
Only here , Sir , I ought to observe to you , That I have supposed the Globes to be stopped by the whole Resistance of the Substance , they move against ; although in strictness they are stopped only by the excess of that Resistance above the Action of Gravity upon them .
But I have neglected the Consideration of the Action of Gravity , that being but small in Proportion to the Resistance , as will appear from the Globes being much more speedily stopped by this Resistance , than they would be by the Action of Gravity , if its force were applied upwards ; for by that force alone , the Globes would not be stopped , till they had measured Spaces equal to the heights above the resisting Substance , from whence they fell ; which heights bear a great Proportion to the depths , the Globes in this Experiment are immersed into the yielding Substance , as I have found upon trial .
Thus , if I mistake not , may be removed the Difficulty attending this Experiment .
But as Mr. Leibnitz 's Opinion is deduced from it by Means of this Axiom , that Effects are proportional to their Causes ; so that here the Effects being thought the same , the Causes are concluded to be so likewise ; it will not be amiss to mention in this place an Experiment , where this Axiom may be more jnstly applied , than it can be in our present case , from which Experiment the received Opinion may be proved .
This Experiment is mentioned by ~ from Mersennus , though tried by him somewhat rudely ; but has been often since made in the following manner .
To one end of the Beam of a Balance is hung a Weight , and from a proper height is let fall upon the other extremity of the Beam another Weight , which by striking thereon shall raise the end , to which the Weight is suspended , to such a height , as is just sufficient to set free a certain Spring .
If then a different Weight be hung in the room of the former ; the height , from whence the fallingWeight must descend , in order to raise the Extremity of the Balance , to which this otherWeight is suspended , to the same height as before , that is , high enough to set the forementioned Spring at liberty , is found to be such , that the Velocity , with which the falling Weight strikes upon the Balance , in this latter Case , will be to its former Velocity , as the latter Weight to the former , ( a ) except only that , agreeably to what Mersennus himself remarked , when the Weight descends from great heights , an Altitude somewhat greater than this Rule implies is required to raise the other Weight as much as is desired .
But whether the bending of the Arm of the Balance , when acted upon with a great force , or whether any increase of Friction in this Case , occasion the Irregularity here mentioned , we need not strictly enquire ; for this Irregularity is yet less reconcileable with the new Opinion , than the regular Effects of the Experiment .
Hence therefore we may see , that the very Method of reasoning , which being applied erroneously , is supposed to prove Mr. Leibnitz 's Sentiment concerning the force of Bodies in Motion , will , when justly used , confirm the other Opinion in relation to that Matter .
But as I have asserted in the beginning of this Letter , that the very Experiment of Polenus is not only reconcileable to the common Doctrine of Motion , as I have now demonstrated ; but even that it does it self make manifest the great unreasonableness , if not the absolute Absurdity , of Mr. Leibnitz 's Opinion ; it remains that I briefly make proof of this .
If two Globes A and B , of equal Magnitude but of different Weights , striking on a yielding Substance with equal force , in every Case lose all their Motion at equal Depths , it is necessary that at all times , during their Motion , they lose equal Degrees of force , when they bear upon equal Portions of the Substance , in entring equal Spaces into the Substance .
This will be easily seen from what has before been said .
Now whereas Mr. Leibnitz supposes the power of Gravity to ( a ) Vid. 's Gravesande Physic .
Elem .
Tom. I. p. 39 .
give to the same falling Body Degrees of force proportional to the height from whence it falls ; according to his Opinion , by the power of Gravity , equal Degrees of force are added in the descent of the same Body through equal Spaces ; and in different Bodies descending through equal Spaces , the Degrees of force added will be as the quantity of Matter , or as the weight of each Body .
Therefore while the Globes A and B penetrate equal nascent Spaces into the yielding Substance , by the Action of Gravity , were not that Action overcome by the Resistance of that Substance , additional Degrees of force would be communicated in such proportion , that the force added to the Globe A , would be to the force added to the Globe B , as the weight of the Globe A , to the weight of the Globe B , or in the Duplicate ratio of the Velocity of the Globe B , to the Velocity of the Globe A. But since the Globes lose the same Degrees of force in entring equal Nascent Spaces into the yielding Substance , the Effect of the Opposition made by this Substance to the Motion of the Globes , during the time of their passing through such Nascent Spaces , will be both the taking from them that same Degree of force , and moreover the additional force , which would otherwise have been given them by their own Gravity .
But farther , the Opposition made to the motion of the Globe A , to the Opposition made to the motion of the Globe B , will be in the ratio compounded of the ratio of the Effect of the Opposition , the Substance makes to the motion of the Globe A , to the Effect of the Opposition , the Substance makes to the motion of the Globe B , and of the ratio of the Time , in which the Opposition is made against the latter Globe , to the Time in which it is made against the former ; which latter ratio is the same with the ratio of the Velocity of the Globe A , to the Velocity of the Globe B. But since it is shown , that the Effect of the Opposition made by the yielding Substance to these Globes is two-fold , and that one part of the Effect of the Opposition made to the motion of the Globe A , is equal to one part of the Effect of the Opposition made to the motion of the Globe B ; and that another part of the Effect of the Opposition made to the motion of the Globe A , to another part of the Effect of the Opposition made to the motion of the Globe B , is in the Duplicate ratio of the Velocity of the Globe B , to the Velocity of the Globe A. One part of the Opposition it self made to the motion of the Globe A , will be to one part of the Opposition against the motion of the Globe B , as the Velocity of the Globe A , to the Velocity of the Globe B , and another part of the Opposition to the motion of the Globe A , to another part of the Opposition to the motion of the Globe B , will be as the Velocity of the Globe B , to the Velocity of the Globe A. So that when the Globes bear upon equal Portions of the yielding Substance , the Opposition to their Motion will be in part as the Velocity of the Globes , and in part reciprocally as their Velocity .
Hence , because the resisting Substance is of an uniform Texture , the Opposition to the Motion of either of the Globes in its present Situation , and when moving with its present Velocity , will be to the Opposition it would meet with in the same Situation , if it moved with any other Velocity , partly as the present Velocity to that other Velocity , and partly as that other Velocity to the present .
But by that part of the Opposition made against the motion of the Globe , which is directly as the Velocity , the Globe can never be wholly stopped ; for upon the stopping of the Globe , that part of the Opposition tion to its Motion will likewise totally cease , and consequently the Globe 's Weight will carry it further down , unless the other part of the Opposition against its Motion prevent it .
But I say again , neither can this latter part of the Opposition made to its Motion be ever great enough to stop the Globe ; for the Degree of this Opposition being reciprocally as the Velocity of the Globe , when the motion of the Globe is wholly taken away , it will become infinitely greater , than at any time , while the Globe is in Motion ; so that when the Globe should be stopped by this part of the Opposition made to its Motion , the Opposition to the Globe 's Motion will become infinitely great ; insomuch , that no Degree of force whatever could be able to impel the Globe further into the Substance , but this can never come to pass .
Besides , it is not necessary to apply any such refined Argument against this part of the Resistance ; it would be alone sufficient to consider , how unreasonable a Supposition it is , that a Resistance should increase , when the Velocity of the resisted Body decreases .
Thus may this Experiment be made use of to invalidate that very Opinion it is brought to support .
But another use may likewise be made thereof : For it will serve to illustrate what the great Sir Isaac Newton has more than once hinted~ that the Resistance of Fluids , which arises from the Tenacity of their Parts , decreases in a less Proportion than the Velocity of the resisted Body decreases ( a ) ; for as this Resistance bears a great Analogy to the Resistance of the yielding Substances we have been here treating of , so we have found , that the Resistance of these Substances does ( a ) Vid. Philos. Not .
Princip .
Math. Prop. 52 .
lib. 2 .
in Schol .
Opticks .
Qu .
28 .
p. 339 , 340 .
not much depend upon the Velocity of the Body , against which the Resistance is applied .
And thus , Sir , we may see how all Experience conspires in confirming and setting forth that stupendious force of reasoning , which has enabled our great Philosopher most surprisingly to search out , and distinguish the Springs of Natural Operations ; a Work infinitely more difficult to accomplish than even the great Improvements he has made in pure Mathematicks , which were previously necessary in order to his succeeding in his Searches after the Knowledge of Nature ; for in this last Pursuit he has given Proof , not only of a more unbounded Invention , than is required in the subtilest Geometrical Speculations ; but has also there discovered the greatest Discernment , and most consummate Judgment ; since in his Philosophical Writings , he has never been once imposed on by an Hypothesis , nor by any other of the various Fallacies , which my Lord Bacon in his Novum Organon , has reckoned up as the Causes , that had hindred the Improvement of the true Philosophy .
But here I shall put an end to this long Letter ; for the Freedom of which , I know , I need make no Apology to you , Sir , of whose great Candour I have for some Years past been a constant Witness ; and as I have frequently admired , how amidst the vast Empolyments of your Profession , you should find time to pursue with so great Success such various sorts of Learning ; so I have as often been delighted to observe with what Benignity you receive those , who have made any the least part of useful Knowledge their Study .
I am , Sir , &amp;c. POSTSCRIP T. A Bout a Week after I had sent you the Letter , containing my Observations on Polenus 's Experiment , I had the good Fortune to hear an excellent and learned Friend of yours , to whom you had been pleased to show my Letter , give a very curious and weighty Argument to confirm Sir Isaac Newton 's Sentiment in relation to the Resistance of Fluids , which I had deduced from the above mentioned Experiment ; and as this very much pleased me , I shall here endeavour to send you an Account of it in the following manner : Suppose pieces of fine Silk , or the like thin Substance , extended in Parallel Planes , and fixed at small Distances from each other .
Suppose then a Globe to strike perpendicularly against the middle of the outermost of the Silks , and by breaking through them to lost part of its Motion .
If the pieces of Silk be of equal Strength , the same Degree of force will be required to break each of them ; but the Time , in which each piece of Silk resists , will be so much shorter as the Globe is swifter ; and the loss of Motion in the Globe consequent upon its breaking through each Silk , and surmounting the Resistance thereof , will be proportional to the Time , in which the Silk opposes itself to the Globe 's Motion ; insomuch that the Globe by the Resistance of any one piece of Silk will lose so much less of its Motion as it is swifter .
But on the other Hand , by how much swifter the Globe moves , so many more of the Silks it will break through in a given Space of Time ; whence the number of the Silks , which oppose themselves to the Motion of the Globe in a given Time , being reciprocally proportional to the Effect of each Silk upon the Globe , the Resistance made to the Globe by these Silks , or the loss of Motion , the Globe undergoes by them in a given Time , will be always the same .
Now if the Tenacity of the Parts of Fluids observes the same Rule as the Cohesion of the Parts of these Silks ; namely , That a certain Degree of force is required to separate and disunite the adhering Particles , the Resistance arising from the Tenacity of Fluids must observe the same Rule as the Resistance of the Silks , and therefore in a given Time the loss of Motion , a Body undergoes in a Fluid by the Tenacity of its Parts , will in all Degrees of Velocity be the same ; or in sewer Words , that part of the Resistance of Fluids , which arises from the Cohesion of their Parts , will be Uniform .

