Observations on a Treatise wrote by Mons. Helvetius of Paris , designed to prove that the Lungs do not divide and exspand the Blood , but that on the contrary , they cool and condense it .
By F. Nicholls , M. B. Prael .
Anat .
Oxon &amp; F. R. S. THE Matter in Question between the Author and Signior Michellotti is , whether the Lungs cool and condense the Blood , according to the Opinion of the Ancients , or whether they mix , attenuate , and of Consequence expand it , according to the System of Dr. Pitcairn .
The Author , in order to support the Opinion of the Ancients , brings several Arguments to confute the System ofDr .
Pitcairn : The most considerable of which ( and which indeed he makes his Argumentum crucis ) is , that the right Auricle and Ventricle being considerably larger than the left Auricle and Ventricle , and the pulmonary Artery having a larger Capacity than all the pulmonary Veins taken together , the Blood must evidently occupy a greater Space before than after its Passage thro ' the Lungs ; and because the Difference in the Capacity of these Vessels cannot be balanced by any Increase of the Velocity , he concludes , that the Blood is not attenuated and expanded , but must be condensed in its Passage through the Lungs .
And this the Author conceives is done by the Air , which ( as a Fluid relatively cold ) must cool and condense the Blood , to which it is so nearly applied in the Action of Inspiration .
Had the Author of this Treatise been contented with supporting the Opinion of the Ancients , without endeavouring to subvert the System of Dr. Pitcairn , he would probably have found many Advocates for his Doctrine , and few Opposers .
That the Blood is cooled by the Action of Inspiration , is a Matter of which I believe few Physicians doubt , when they consider that in Inflammations of the Lungs , nothing is more earnestly desired than the breathing cool and fresh Air , nor does any thing more evidently conduce to the Cure of these and other Inflammatory Dispositions , than the Use of fresh Air .
But that this is the sole Use of breathing , or that this cooling Power can over-balance the Expansion from the Action of Expiration , is what I can no ways conceive .
If we consider the State of the Blood at its Return to the Heart , and how careful Nature has been , not to use this Blood for the Nourishment of the Lungs before it has passed through the pulmonary Vein and Artery ( though it would in that Case have been as effectually cooled in the Bronchial Arteries as in the pulmonary Vessels ) we are naturally led to believe , that it is some other Quality which has rendred it improper for Nourishment , and which is to be destroyed by the Action of the Lungs .
I have before allowed , that it seems almost evident that the Blood is cooled , and of Consequence condensed in the Action of Inspiration ; but for the Reason mentioned , and from considering the Structure of the Parts subservient to breathing , it seems equally true , that the Blood is mixed , attenuated , and consequently re-expanded in the Action of Expiration .
I shall now consider whether the Action of Inspiration so far overbalances the Action of Exspiration , as to condense the Blood into a less Bulk than it had before its Passage through the Lungs .
The accurate Santorini of Venice , in the 8th Chapter and 3d Section of his Observations , has carefully examined the Fact as stated by Mons. Helvetius ; and finding it true in that one Subject , as to the Auricles and pulmonary Vessels , but false as to the Ventricles , he proceeds to prove that this Difference in the Capacity of the pulmonary Vessels , could not be designed on Account of the Blood 's being condensed in its Passage through the Lungs ; because , if so , the right Ventricle ought to have been larger than the left Ventricle ; and the pulmonary Artery ought , not only to have been larger than the pulmonary Veins , but it ought likewise to have been larger than , or at least equal to , the two Venae Cavae ; whereas in his Subject , the two Venae Cavae were to the pulmonary Artery , as 228 to 188 .
In the mean time , he recommends the repeating the Enquiry to other Anatomists , as doubting whether the Fact is constantly so in healthy Subjects .
Ut caeteri diligentiores Anatomici disquirant utrum ea firma &amp; perpetua sint ?
an in corporibus integris .
As such an Enquiry may be of Consequence , not only in settling the Point in Question , but in explaining other Parts of the Animal OEconomy , I doubt not but it will be agreeable to the Society ; and the rather , because the Subjects from which I have taken the several Calculations , are here produced before the Society , and submitted to a Re-examination , if desired .
The Measure which I have here used is the 113th Part of an Inch .
I have taken the Triple of the Diameter for the Periphery , and computed the Area by multiplying the nearest whole Number to 1/ 4 of the Diameter into the Periphery .
Though this Method is not sufficiently exact to show the real Contents of Circles , yet as my Design here , was only to find nearly the relative Contents ~ of the several Vessels , I have chose to avoid embarassing the Sums with Fractions .
The first Heart is of an Adult in which The Diam. Per .
&amp; Areas are Of the Vena Cava descendens 79 237 4740 Pulmonary Artery 115 345 10005 Superior left pulm .
Vein 69 207 3519 ~ Inferior left pulm .
Vein 73 219 3942 Superior right pulm .
Vein 49 147 1764 12477 Middle right pulm .
Vein 40 120 1200 Inferior right pulm .
Vein 57 171 2052 Aorta 110 330 8910 The ascending Cava being tied above the Diaphragm , could not be measured in this Subject .
As Mons. Helvetius no ways mentions the Disease of which the Subject died from whom he took his Observation , so I cannot say how proper it was for such an Examination ; but it is evident , his Observation does not tally with the Calculations made from this first Heart ; where the pulmonary Artery is to the Sum of all the pulmonary Veins as 10005 to 12477 .
And yet this Subject ( besides a cancerated Ovary , and a Putrefaction of the right Kidney from the Ureter 's being compressed ) had her Lungs full of small Tubercles , and the Glands lying between the great Divisions of the Trachaea almost petrified by atheromatous Concretions : By all which it is highly probable , that the Passage of the Blood through the Lungs was very much impeded , and of Consequence , the pulmonary Artery much dilated beyond its natural Capacity .
And this I am the rather induced to believe from examining the second Heart , which is of a Child nearly twelve Months old .
As to its Death , I can say nothing more , than that its Lungs appeared perfectly sound , and of a pale clear Colour ; and therefore the more proper for an Examination of this Kind .
In this second Heart the Diam. Per .
&amp; Areas are , Of theAorta above theCoronaries 43 129 1419 Pulmonary Artery 43 129 1419 Superior left pulm .
Vein 29 87 609 ~ Inferior left pulm .
Vein Superior right pulm .
Vein 26 78 507 2088 Middle right pulm .
Vein 17 51 204 Inferior right pulm .
Vein 32 96 768 We may here observe that the Aorta , after giving off the Coronary Vessels , is equal to the pulmonary Artery .
As to the Proportion between the pulmonary Artery and Veins , the Artery in this Subject is to the Sum of all the Veins here measured , as 1419 to 2088 , and yet the lower left pulmonary Vein is here omitted , as being tied too close to admit of being measured .
But if we suppose the inferior left pulmonary Vein to be to the superior left pulmonary Vein in the same Proportion as in the first Heart , we shall then find its Diameter nearly 31 , and its Area at least 700 , which will make the pulmonary Artery in this Heart , to the Sum of all the pulmonary Veins as 1419 to 2788 ; and in that Case , the left pulmonary Veins will be to the right pulmonary Veins , but as 1309 to 1479 .
The 3d Heart is of an Abortive nearly of 5 Months : By its Appearance , I judged it suffocated by too much Blood .
In this Subject the Diam. Per .
Areas are , Of the Vena Cava descendens 14 42 197~ 629 Vena Cava ascendens 24 72 432 Aorta above the Coronaries 16 48 192 Pulmonary Artery 20 60 300 Canalis Arteriosus 12 36 108 Right pulmonary Branch 11 33 99~ 198 Left pulmonary Branch 11 33 99 Superior left pulm .
Vein 11 33 99~ Inferior left pulm .
Vein 9 27 54 294 Superior right pulm .
Vein 7 21 42 Middle right pulm .
Vein 11 33 99 The inferior right pulmonary Vein is here cut too close , and otherways injured , so that its Area cannot be measured .
Nevertheless we find the remaining pulmonary Veins to the pulmonary Branches of the pulmonary Artery , as 294 to 198 .
We may here observe a remarkable Difference between the Capacities of the two Venae Cavae taken together , and the pulmonary Artery ; the two Cavae being more than Double the pulmonary Artery , and the pulmonary Artery still one Third larger than the Aorta .
As this Difference could not arise in this Case from the Blood 's being condensed by the inspired Air , so it seems a Proof , that had the Fact been true , as stated by Mons. Helvetius , it had nevertheless been an insufficient Demonstration of his System .

