IV .
A Letter from the Reverend Mr. Edmond Barrel , Rector of Sutton in Kent , to Sir Hans Sloane , Baronet , President of the Royal Society and the College of Physicians , concerning the Propagation of Misselto .
SIR , IT hath been my Purpose , ever since the Death of our late worthy Friend Mr. Hill , to communicate to you , ( if you would please to accept of it ) an Account of the Growth of Misselto from the Seed : and I have delayed it from Year to Year , not only to be better assured in my Experiments , and to find whether the World had not already , or would not be in the mean Time , better informed of this , by some other Hand : But I was also in hopes to have been so successful some Year or other , as to have been able , to send you and the Royal Society , some Specimens of the seedling Plants , both of the first and second Years growth together .
I am sorry that I cannot do this now , and for that reason should have delayed this Account , till another Year .
But your kind Acceptance of so small a Curiosity as I sent lately , obliges me to a present Compliance with your Request .
The Berries of Misselto have within their viscid Pulp a Kernel covered with a thin whitish Skin ; the inward Substance whereof is deeply green , and harder than the Substance of a Pistachio-Nut 's Kernel .
It is flattish , and shaped sometimes like a Heart thus ~ ; sometimes oblong thus , O ; both are as truly Seed , as any Plant can have .
Those of the oblong Shape put out but one Germen ; those like an Heart , have two , which prove two distinct Plants .
Sir John Colebatch recommends the sowing this Seed by way of Inoculation : Accordingly in Feb. 1718/ 9 , I endeavoured to place the Berries , within the Bark of Oak , Ash , Beech , Pear , and Apple-trees , by making several Cuts and Gashes in the upright Sides of the Trees .
The whole Berries would not stay in any of them ; and when I broke them , the Seed always slipped out to the Edge of the Cut , and then it stuck to the Bark , by virtue of the slimy substance wherewith it is encompassed .
I also stuck one Seed on the bare Bark , without any cutting at all : This succeeded best , and being the Heart-like shape , gave me two Plants .
For about the 28th of March 1719 .
this , with two more on the Apple-tree , and one on the Pear-tree , began to shoot ; and the Growth was in this manner : The Viscous Matter having stuck the Seed on , and ( as it dried ) drawn the Seed close and flat down to the Bark of the Tree , there began , in March and April , to spring out of that end of the Seed , which had been toward the Eye of the Berry , a small deep green Shoot or Twigg , very like a short Piece of a little Clasper of the Vine .
At first , it arose upward from the Bark , and then turning again as it approached the Tree , it swelled out somewhat bigger round about the End ; yet leaving the very Tip or Bottom , quite flat , forming ( as it were ) a Foot to stand upon ; not unlike the bottom of some Brass Pestles .
This Foot , when it came to the Bark , which was about May or June 1719 , fixed it self thereon .
Being thus fastned at both Ends , it made a little Arch , whose Diameter was as long as the Seed , or about ~ of an Inch .
In this Condition , it remained all that Year , till about March or April 1720 , and then that part or end of our little Seedling , which was joined to the Bark , at the place where the Seed first shot forth , let go its hold , and raising it self upward , put forth Leaves , and became the Head of the Plant : and the other end , which sprung out first , and had taken footing in another Place , became the Root of the Plant .
It is no uncommon thing , for Seeds of Ever-greens to be two-Years before they spring out of the Ground .
And the change of the Ends , first one of them shooting out , and then the other , was what surprised me most at first ; but on further reflexion I found , that Nature , even in this strange Plant , is uniform to her other Productions ; in carrying the Sap first one way to form the Root , and then turning the Course of it back again to send out the upper parts of the Plant .
The strangest and most wonderful part is , that the rooting End should make its first shoot into the open Air , and then turn it self down to find a proper Place to fix upon .
Who could have supposed , that a Plant , whose Berry is the most orbicular of any , and therefore the least likely to lie quiet in any Situation , and whose proper place of growth is a round and wavering Bough , or upright side of a Tree , should after it is once fixed , leave its first footing , and seek out a new point in the Bark to grow upon .
This is indeed the great Secret of the matter , and seems to be the very thing that hath kept the World in Ignorance , about the growing of this Seed .
For by requiring a new smooth Place of the Bark whereon to fix the rooting Part , it hath frustrated all attempts of sowing it in the usual way of other Seeds .
Theophrastus , ( about two Thousand Years ago ) seems to endeavour at a Reason , why this Seed could not grow in the Earth : But all that he , or any one since , hath said upon it , is only to agree , that in Fact it doth not , and to wonder why so perfect a Seed should not grow in the Earth .
That Ancient Author rationally concluded , from its having a Seed , that the Plant must come from that Seed : Whereas latter Times have been so fond of allowing Chance a share in the Productions of Nature , that Scaliger hath not only experimentally confuted the common Notion of Misselto 's being sown in the Dung of the Thrush ; but argues also , very stenuously against the Possibility of this Plant 's growing from its Seed .
Even the great Lord Bacon , Sir Thomas Brown , Lobel , and the inquisitive Mr. Ray ( so late as 1673 , ) do all give into it , that this Plant , hath a spontaneous and aequivocal , rather than a seminal and univocal Generation .
Scaliger 's strongest Objection is , Quod e Ramis quibusdam exit Viscus , quo in loco nullis modis vel stercus consistere , vel semen unquam potuerit haerere Nihilo enim commodius consistere quam in re proclivi Globum .
Lobel objects against it , because of the Imperfection of the Berry Acinulo illo pallido pellucido .
Mr. Ray 's Argument is , Viscus innatus etiam in prona Ramorum part .
It is the property of true Experience to clear up Doubts , and answer Objections : And if Nature had been well examined , it would have appeared , that this Seed is of a substance equal to other Kernels ; and that the Pulp of the Berry , wherewith the Seed is surrounded , is of a more clammy sticking nature than the Pulp of other Berries , for this very Purpose , that it might be of strength sufficient to fix the Seed on any Tree , how moveable or upright soever the Bough or Twig should be whereon it chanced to light .
And And doubtless the Birds are ( tho ' not by their Dung ) Sowers of this , as they are of many other Seeds , which they carry away for Food ; but often drop in Places where they could otherwise never have come .
While I was writing this out for your Perusal ; I went to gather some Misselto-Berries ( this being the Season that they are ripe , and fittest to be sown ) and found a Leaf ( which I send you which hath a Seed sticking thereon ; doubtless by a casual Fall out of the Bill of some Bird , that has broken the Berry as she was eating it .
There is both a dry string of the Slime , and a dry spot of the same , upon the Leaf , that show how the Seed was detained there , in this Case ; and how it must be done in like manner any where else .
When I acquaint you , Sir , that I have sown these Seeds , on near thirty sorts of Trees and Shrubs , and yet never had above ten Plants , that held out the second Year ; you will not wonder , at the little success , that others have had , in their trials of this Seed ; and will also see the Reason , why I have not been able to make many other Experiments about the growth of this Plant .
However , some Casualties have furnished me with two or three ; which I beg leave to relate ; because they do somewhat further explain the Nature of this Plant 's growing .
One of my little Plants sown in Apr. 1724 .
which was fixed at both Ends in its Arch-like Form , had in Sept. 1724 , the middle part broken off ; the two Ends keeping still fast to the Tree .
Which shows , how firmly the two Ends adhere , while it is in that state ; and they both continued green some time , and then withered away .
2 .
That one Seed , which grew on a Pear-tree , in ~8/ 9 , was the next Spring 1719/ 22 , loosened from the Tree at one End , as the others were : Yet this seedling sprout , never put out any Leaves at all ; but continued in the same state , neither bigger nor less , near six Years ; that is , till it was broken off by chance in July 1725 .
This seems to me a very strange thing : For , a seedling Plant ( of any kind ) is , but as it were an Embriyo , till it have put forth Leaves .
3 .
My most thriving pair of Plants , of the Year 1718/ 9 , being about three Inches in length , were on the 21st of May 1722 , struck off , by the falling of a Rake-handle against them .
They took away with them , only the outmost thin skin of the Tree ; and I could not see any signs , of deeper Rooting .
But as I looked , now and then , on the Place , where the Misselto had grown , I thought , I observed the Bark to swell up a little ; and on the 12th of March 1722/ 3 , I perceived 3 or 4 little Budds , putting forth , and another Bud was put out by the 18th of March .
They all grew on , to have Leaves that Summer ; and now Febr. 1726/ 7 , they are a Cluster of Boughs , of 4 or 5 Joints in heighth , and bore Berries this Winter ; whereas two others , on the same Tree , and which were also sown at the same time , in 1718/ 9 , and are 6 or 7 joints in heighth , have not yet born any Berries .
The thriving of these Plants , so well again , after they were broken off ; made me reflect , on the Druids way , of cutting Misselto from the Oak , with a Golden Instrument ; a Metal not apt to take a good Edge , and possibly , the bluntness of the Instrument , might be a means , to preserve , a future growth , of the same Plant ; which , doubtless , they as well as we , find to be very rarely upon the Oak .
I might suggest some

