I. Remarks upon some Dissertations lately published at Paris , by the Rev. P. Souciet , against Sir Isaac Newton 's Chronology .
By Dr. Edmund Halley , Astronomer Royal , F. R. S. THere has been lately put into my hands a Book published last Year at Paris by Father Soucier , Jesuit , against our late President Sir Isaac Newton his Chronology , without waiting till the Book be published , and without knowing the Contents thereof , otherwise than by a short Extract , made at the desire of a very great Person , and without intention that it should be publicly seen .
However , a Copy thereof having been ( as I suppose ) surreptitiously obtained and carried over into France , the same was first translated into French , and then printed at Paris with a pretended Refutation thereof by the same P. Souciet .
Since then , Sir Isaac having answered , as he thought , his Objections , has thereby given him a handle to publish five other Dissertations against the new System of Chronology , as he calls it ; the first and last of which , being chiefly Astronomical ( since the great Author is no more ) seem properly to fall under my examination , both on account of the Post in which I have the honour to serve his Majesty in quality of his Astronomer , as also from the long Acquaintance and Friendship that has subsisted between the Deceased and my self .
And first , I observe , that P. Souciet readily allows what seems to be the most exceptionable part of the whole System , viz. that Chiron the Centaur fixed the Colures , in the ancient Sphere of fixed Stars , in the same places as Hipparchus tells us they had been supposed by Eudoxus many Centuries of Years after Chiron .
His words are these , ~~~~~~~~ ~~~ ~ , ~~~~~~ ~ .
This , undoubtedly , was the Position of the Colure of the Vernal Equinox many Ages before Eudoxus ; but whether so old as Chiron , and the Argonautick Expedition , I shall not undertake at this time to enquire ; but only observe , that P. Souciet in his Fastes du Monde , or Abridgment of his Chronology , prefixed to these Dissertations , makes the Argonautick Expedition 1467 Years before our AEra of the Birth of Jesus Christ ; and the taking of Troy 1388 Years before it , which Date is 120 Years sooner than the Parian Chronicle , read and published by our Learned Selden in his Marmora Arundeliana , makes it ; and above 500 Years earlier than the time assigned by Sir Isaac Newton .
Now both of them making use of the same Premises , it may seem strange that their Conclusions should be so widely distant : And indeed upon a Praepossession that the Argonautick Expedition and the Siege of Troy could not have been less than 1000 Years before Christ , I must own , I was at first somewhat prejudiced in favour of P. Souciet , taking his Calculations for granted ; and not having seen Sir Isaac 's Work .
But observing that he quotes Sir Isaac , as saying , that in consequence of what Hipparchus has recorded from Eudoxus , the Equinoctial Colure in the Old Sphere was about 7~ 36~ from the first Star of Aries , I was resolved to examine the matter with due Attention , especially since the Good Father seems to triumph over his Adversary , and to treat a Man of his Figure in the Common-wealth of Learning in a very ludicrous manner , notwithstanding the several fine things he says of him to palliate it .
I find I find the Dispute to be chiefly over what part of the Back of Aries the Colure past : The Words of Hipparchus , as from Eudoxus , are simply , that it past over the Back , without saying over what Star , or over what part of the Back it past .
And the same Hipparchus shows , that if it past over the Star in the middle of the Back , it greatly differed from the Situation thereof in his time ; and conceiving thence that the AEquinoctial Points might have a regressive motion , he was the first that attempted to define their motion ; but having no Observations older than those of Timocharis , made within less than 200 Years of his own time , and very course withal , he was not able to determine the quantity thereof , but guest it to be about a Degree in 100 Years ; which length of time and the more curious Observation of the Moderns has now proved to be 1~ 24~ .
or rather 50~ per Annum .
In a word , Sir Isaac takes the Colure to have past over the middle of the Constellation of Aries , and very near the Star in the middle of the Back ( v Bayero ) .
And P. Souciet will have it , that it past over the middle of the Sign or Dodecatemorion of Aries , reckoning the Sign to begin with the first Star of the Constellation ; and by consequence his Colure must pass about midway between the Rump and first of the Tail of Aries ( ~ and ~ Bayero ; ) which Situation could never be said to be over the Back : But whilst Sir Isaac makes the Colure but 7~ 36~ , from the first Star of Aries , which P. Souciet makes 15 Degrees from it , the difference 7~ 24~ at 50~ per Annum , makes 533 Years difference in the result .
Let us now examine when the Stars in question did actually pass under the Colure of the Vernal AEquinox , assuming their places as they are in Mr. Flamsteed 's British Catalogue , fitted to the beginning of the Year 1690 .
He places the first Star of Aries in 28~ 51~ of Aries 7~ 9~ .
North Latitude .
And supposing the Obliquity of the Ecliptic 23~ 29~ , it will be as Radius to the Tangent of 23~ 29~ : : so the Tangent of 7~ 9~ to the Sine of 3~ 7~ 1/ 2 , the ~ of Longitude between the Star and the Point in the Ecliptic which past under the Colure at the same time with the Star ; so that this Point was , Anno 1690 ineunte , in ~ 25~ 43~ 30~ , and therefore allowing 50~ per Annum , the Star was under the Colure 1852 Years before the Epoch of the British Catalogue , that is , 162 Years before our AEra of the Nativity of Jesus Christ , in which very Year Hipparchus began to observe the AEquinoxes recorded by Ptolemy , Lib. III .
Cap. 2 .
If therefore with Sir Isaac we add 7~ 36~ to the Long. of the first Star of Aries , as it was in 1690 , we shall have 36~ 27~ , which the Colure moves in 2624 Years : And deducting 1690 ~ , we shall have 934 Years before Christ for the Argonautick Expedition .
And if to 7~ 36~ we add 3~ 7~ 1/ 2 we shall have 10~ 43~ 1/ 2 , that is , 772 Years before the first Star of Aries past the Colure .
Next let us inquire when the Star in the middle of the Back of Aries ( ~ Bayero ) past the Colure .
Its Longitude Anno 1690 ineunte , was 9~ 48~ 35~ of Taurus , with North Lat. 6~ 8~ ; but by the foregoing Analogy , the Point in the Ecliptic , over which the Colure past at the same time with it , was 2~ 40~ 1/ 2 before it , that is in ~ 7~ 8~ .
Now 37~ 8~ give 2674 Years nearly , or 984 Years before Christ , when that Star was under the AEquinoctial Colure , being but halt a Century earlier than Sir Isaac places the Argonautick Expedition ; and shows that he took the middle of Aries over which the Colure is supposed to have past , to be the middle of the Constellation , and not of the Dodecatemorion , and in so doing , no doubt , had reason to place this Colure 7~ 36~ in consequence of the first Star of Aries , instead of 8~ 17~ as it was when the Star in the middle of the Back of Aries was under the Colure .
But if with P. Souciet , you make the Colure to intersect the Ecliptic 15 Degrees from the first Star of Aries , or 43~ 51~ from the AEquinoctial Point , as it was Anno 1690 , we shall have the time nearly 1470 Years before Christ ; but then the Colure will be very far from the middle of the Back of Aries and leave only his Tail to the Eastward , as it leaves the Head of the Whale to the Westward , so as by no means to agree with the Description we have of it from Hipparchus ; which it were to be wished had been more definitive , and as well circumstanced as what Hipparchus has left us of the Position of the Colures in his own time , which upon examination I find to be very consistent , and the Observations made with sufficient care .
Thus I hope , I have shown P. Souciet , that there was no Affectation of Mystery in Sir Isaac 's placing the Colure 7~ 36~ from the first Star of Aries , nor any occasion to drole as he does Page .
131 , 132 .
on that account ; as also that he ought to have deducted 3~ 7~ 1/ 2 out of the 15 Degrees he assumes for the distance of his Colure from the first Star of Aries , which will bring him 255 Years nearer to Sir Isaac Newton 's time .
He is likewise entreated in the next Edition of his Dissertations to be a little more careful of his Numbers than he has been Page .
134 , 135 , and inform himself in the Sphericks , so as to give us the Right Ascensions of the Stars truly , from their given Longitudes and Latitudes .

