VI .
A Remark upon the New Opinion relating to the Forces of moving Bodies , in the case of the Collision of Non-Elastic Bodies .
By Mr. John Eames , F. R. S. 1 .
T HE ancient Opinion , and most generally entertained , is , that the Forces of Bodies in Motion are as their Quantities of Motion , i. e. as their Quantities of Matter multiplied by their respective Celerities .
2 .
The new Opinion is , that the Forces of Bodies in Motion are as their Quantities of Matter multiplied by the Squares of the Velocities ; so that in equal Masses the moving Forces will not be as the Velocities themselves , but as their Squares .
3 .
Hence it follows , that a Body moving with five Degrees of Velocity , moves with five and twenty Times more Force , than when it moves but with one Degree ; whereas according to the common Opinion , it has but five times as much , i. e. proportional to its Velocity .
4 .
The latest Experiments brought to prove the truth of the new Opinion are made upon sost , or yielding Substances .
Now these have been already observed to be a little complicated , and improper for this Purpose .
The proper Use of Experiments of this kind being rather to discover , and settle the Laws , which such kind of Substances observe in the Resistance they make to Bodies moving in them , than the Forces themselves , with which the Bodies move , which ought to be determined before hand by some simple Experiment , fit to determine that Matter .
5 .
A variety of Experiments have been made , and reasoning used in Ergland and France , to prove the Truth of the common Opinion ; but they do not entirely satisfy all the Gentlemen on the other side of the Question .
The present ingenious Professor of Mathematicks and Philosophy at Utrecht tells us in the Preface to his Epitome Elementorum Physico-Mathematicorum , published this Year , Anno 1726 , In corporum motorum viribus supputandis amplexus sum sententiam Cl. Leibnitsii , Hugenii , Poleni , S. Gravesandii , &amp; antiquae valedixi , quam hactenus foveram , &amp; docueram : Neque me retinuerunt argumenta doctissimorum virorum in Galltis &amp; Britannia eandem defendentium .
Et quando experimenta a Poleno &amp; 'S Gravesandio descripta examinantur &amp; inspiciuntur , tam manifesto evincunt vires corporum percutientium esse in ratione composita ex quadrata velocitatum , &amp; simplici massarum , ut illis subscribere teneamur , nisi apertissimis contradicere studeamus .
6 .
I beg leave to examine the truth of the new Opinion in the Case here proposed , viz. Vires corporum percutientium ; and I shall endeavour to show from their own Principles , that it cannot be true in all the Cases of Non Elastic Bodies .
7 .
It is allow 'd , that the common Rules of finding the Velocities of Non-Elastic Bodies after the Stroke are true : For thus the ingenious Mr. S. Gravesand tells us in Paragraph 251 , of his Supplementum Physicum ; Ex hoc principio ( i. e. multiplicando massam per velocitatem ) deduxere Philosophi ipsas illas regulas n. 234 .
s. 237 .
s. quas nos variis modis ex principiis nostris deduximus ; mirum hic quid contigit , error erroris fuit destructio , &amp; duplex error ad veritatem conduxit ; falsum de mensura virium secuti sunt principium , &amp; quod veritati etiam minim congruum est , nullam vim intro premendo parts , &amp; harum superando cohaesionem corpora amittere posuere .
8 .
Now the Rule for finding the common Velocity of Non-Elastic Bodies moving the same way after the Collision , is , to divide the Sum of the Quantities of Motion in the two Bodies , by the Sum of the Quantity of Matter .
9 .
It is also granted , Motu duobus corporibus communi corpora haec in se mutuo agere non posse .
In Sect. 215 .
Supplement .
Phys. 10 .
Pendet ergo ictus a velocitate respectiva , qua manente intensitas impactionis eadem erit , quomodocunque celeritates absolutae varient .
11 .
Ab intensitate hac pendet partium introcessio , quae ergo semper eadem erit , si duo corpora eadem velocitate respectiva in se mutuo incurrunt , quibuscunque velocitatibus moveantur .
12 .
These Principles furnish us with an Argument against the new Opinion .
For if it be true , then equal Causes may have unequal Effects , and that in their own sense of an Effect : The Proof shall be taken from Instances of the Effects of the Collision of Non-Elastic Bodies , whose respective Velocities shall be always equal .
13 .
Let ( A ) and ( B ) stand for two Non-Elastic Bodies of equal Quantities of Matter ; and let ( B ) be at rest , while ( A ) moves towards it with 8 degrees of Velocity .
1 .
Here the common Velocity after the Stroke will be half the Velocity of ( A ) before the Stroke , i e. 4 degrees .
Consequently the force in ( B ) thus communicated by the Stroke will be as its Square , or 16 .
2 .
Let ( B ) move forward with two degrees of Velocity , and ( A ) follow it with 10 degrees ; the respective Velocity will be 8 as before ; consequently by Paragraph 10th of this Paper , the Strokes in both cases are equal .
The Velocity in ( B ) after the Stroke will be half the Sum of the Velocities before the Stroke , or 6 degrees , by Paragraph 8th .
According to the new Opinion , the Forces being as the Squares of the Velocities , the Force of ( B ) before the Stroke will be to its Force after the Stroke , as the Square of 2 is to the Square of 6 ; i e. as 4 is to 36 .
Subduct the Force in ( B ) before the Stroke , from the Force it has after the Stroke , and you have the Degrees of Force communicated by the Stroke : Which , if this Opinion were true , would be 32 , i. e just double the Number of Degrees communicated by the same Force in the former Instance , which was but as 16 .
Thus equal Strokes produce unequal Effects in our sense of Effects .
14 .
The following Table gives several other Instances .
In the three first Columns you have the Velocities of the two Bodies both before , and after the Stroke ; in the two next , you have the Forces in ( B ) both before , and after the Stroke ; and in the sixth , the Difference of those Forces , or the different Degrees of Force effected by the same Stroke ; and in the last Column , the Proportion of those Forces , or Effects of the Cause or Stroke .
Force comThe Velomunicated The Forces Proporcity in by the in B. Stroke .
tion .
ABB 8040 16 16 1 10 264 36 32 2 14 6 10 36 100 64 4 18 10 14 100 196 96 6 22 14 18 196 324 128 8 26 18 22 324 484 160 10 Before After Before After the Stroke .
the Stroke 15 .
If it be said , that I have not considered the other part of the entire Effect of the Stroke , the Intropression of the Parts ; I reply , this will make but a small Alteration in the matter ; since the Intropressions in all these Cases are equal , ( Paragr 11 .
) the relative Velocities being by supposition the same : So that notwithstanding upon the whole , one and the same , or equal Causes , will produce unequal Effects .

