IV .
A Letter from Mr. Colin Mac Laurin , Professor of Mathematicks at Edinburgh , and F.R.S. to Martin Folks , Esq ; V. Pr .
R. S. concerning AEquations with impossible Roots .
SIR , I Wrote to you last Winter , that I had thought of a very easy and simple way of demonstrating Sir Isaac Newton 's Rule , by which it may be often discovered when an AEquation has impossible Roots .
This Method requiring nothing but the common Algebra , and being founded on some obvious Properties of Quantities demonstrated in the following Lemmata , without having recourse to the Consideration of any Curve whatsoever , which does not seem so proper a Method in a Matter purely Algebraical , I hope it will not be unacceptable .
Lemma 1 .
The Sum of the Squares of two real Quantities is always greater than twice their Product .
Thus a2+b2 is greater than 2a b ; because the Excess a2+b2-2 ab is eqaal to ~2 a-b , and therefore is Positive ; since the Square of any real Quantity , Negative or Positive , is always Positive .
Lemma 2 .
The Sum of the Squares of three real Quantities is always greater than the Sum of the Products , that can be made by multiplying any two of them .
Thus a2+b2+c2 is always greater than a b+a c+b c ; for it is plain , that the Excess a2+b2+c2-a b-a c-b c =2 a2+2b2+2 c2-2 a b-~ a c-2 b c/ 2 = a2 2a b+b2+a2 a c+c2+b2/ 2 2b c+c2 = ~2 ab ~2 a-c ~2 b-c/ 2 that is , half the Sum of the Squares of the Differences of the Quantities a , b , c : But since these Squares are Positive , it follows , that the Excess of a2 + b2 + c2 above a b+a c+b c is Positive , and that the Sum of the Squares of three Quantities must be greater than the Sum of the Products made by multiplying any two of them .
Lemma 3 .
The triple Sum of the Squares of four Quantities is greater than the double Sum of the Products , that can be made by multiplying any two of them ; for 3 a2 +3 b2 +3 c2 +3 d2 2ab2ac2ad2 bc 2bd2cd= a2 2ab+ b2 + a2 2ac+ c2 + a2 2ad+ d2 + b2 2bd+ d2 + b2 2bc+ c2 + c2 2cd+ d2 = ~2 ad+ ~2 a-c + ~2 a-d + ~2 b-c + ~2 b-d +~ c-d2 , the Sum of the Squares of the Differences of the four Quantities a , b , c , d. Therefore 3 a2 +3 b2 +3 c2 +3 d2 is greater than 2ab+2ac+2ad+2bc+2bd +2c d , the Excess being always Positive .
Lemma 4 .
Let the Number of the Quantities a b , c , d , e , &amp;c. be m , the Sum of their Squares A , and the Sum of the Products made by multiplying any two of them B. Then shall ~m~~ A/ 2 be always greater than B. For by adding together the Squares of the Differences a-b , a-c , a-d , b-c , b-d , c-d , &amp;c. you add a2 as often to it self as there are Quantities more than a ; the same is true of b2 , c2 , d2 , e2 , &amp;c. But the Rectangles -2 a b , -2 a c , -2 a d , -2 b c , -2 b d , &amp;c. arise but once each .
Therefore the Sum of all the Squares ~2 a b , ~2 a c , ~2 b c , ~2 b d , &amp;c. =~m~~ a2 +~m~~ b2 +~m~~ c2 , &amp;c. 2a b-2 a c-2bc , &amp;c. =~m~~A2 B. But ~2 ab + ~2 ac+ ~2 a d. &amp;c. is always a Positive Quantity ; therefore ~m1~A2B is Positive , and consequently ~m1~ A/ 2 greater than B. Cor. It appears from the Demonstration that the ~ of ~m1~A above 2B is always equal to the Sum of the Squares of the Differences of the Quantities a , b , c , d , &amp; c and that when the Quantities a , b , cd &amp;c. are all equal , then ~m1~A2B= 0 , and with this restriction the preceding Lemmata must be understood .
It is to be observed , that tho ' we have supposed in these Lemmata the Quantities a b , c , d , &amp;c. Positive , they are a fortiori true of Negative Quantities , whose Squares are the same as if they were Positive , while the Sum of their Products is either the same , or less than it would be , were they all Positive .
PRO P. I. In a Quadratic AEquation that has its Roots real , the Square of the second Term must be always greater than the quadruple Product of the third and first Terms .
Let the Roots of the Quadratic AEquation be represented by +a and + b ; and if x be the unknown Quantity , then shall x2 ax+ab=0 bx Now since a2 + b2 is greater than 2a b , by Lemma ~ , therefore a2 + b2 +2ab is greater than 4a b ; therefore ~2 a+b ~ x2 , the Square of the second Term , will be greater than 4ab~ x2 the Quadruple Product of the first and third Terms .
PRO P. II .
In any Cubic AEquation , all whose Roots are real , the Square of the second Term is always greater than the triple Product of the first and third .
If the Cubic AEquation has all its Roots real they may be represented with their Signs by a , b , c , and the AEquation will be expressed thus : y3 a y2 +abyabc=0 b y2 +acy c y2 +bcy But by Lemma 2 , a2 + b2 + c2 is always greater than a b+a c+b c ; and consequently adding 2a b+2 a c+ 2bc to both sides , a2 + b2 + c2 +~ab+2ac+2bc~= ~2 a+b+c ) will be greater than 3a b+3 a c+3 b c ; and therefore ~2 a+b+c ~ y4 must be greater than ~3ab+3ac+3bc~ y4 , that is , the Square of the second Term must be greater than the triple Product of the first and third Terms .
Cor. 1 .
In general , it appears from the Demonstration , that the Square of the Sum of three real Quantities , ~2 a+b+c is always greater than the triple Sum of all the Products , that can be made by multiplying any two of them into one another .
Cor. 2 .
It follows from the Proposition , that when the Square of the second Term is not greater than the triple Product of the first and third Terms , the Roots of the AEquation cannot be all real ; but two of them must be impossible : And this plainly coincides with one Part of Sir Isaac Newton 's Rule for discovering when the Roots of Cubic AEquations are impossible .
He desires you may write above the middle Terms of the AEquation the Fractions 1/ 3 , 1/ 3 as in the Margin ; and placing the Sign ~+ under the first and last Term , he multiplies the Square of the second Term by the Fraction 1/ 3 that is above it ; and if the Product is greater than the Product of the adjacent Terms , he places + under the second Term ; but if that Product is less , he places under the second Term , and says , there are as many impossible Roots as changes in the Signs .
Now by this Proposition , if p2 x4 is not greater than 3q x4 , or 1/ 3 p2 x4 greater than q x4 , the Roots cannot be all real .
The same Supposition makes two Changes in the Signs , whatever Sign you place under the third Term , since the Signs under the first and last are both + ; and therefore this Proposition demonstrates the first Part of Sir Isaac Newton 's Rule , as far as it relates to Cubic AEquations .
1/ 3 1/ 3 x3+px2+qx+r =0 +*+ Cor. 3 .
If the second Term is wanting in a Cubic AEquation , and the third is Positive , two of the Roots of the AEquation must be impossible : For the Square of the second Term ( equal to nothing in this Case ) will be less than the triple Product of the adjacent Terms .
But this will better appear from considering that , when the second Term vanishes in an AEquation , the Positive and Negative Roots are equal , and when added together , destroy each other .
Suppose the Roots to be +a and b , c ; then in this Case a=+b+ c , and the Coefficient of the third Term will be abac+bc = b2 2bc c2 +bc= b2 bc c2 , and consequently Negative .
Or , if you suppose two Roots Positive and one Negative , let them be -a , + b , + c , then the Coefficient of the third Term will be still b2 bc c2 .
Therefore when the Roots are real , the Coefficient of the third Term is negative ; and if the Coefficient of the third Term is not affected with a negative Sign , it is a Proof that two of the Roots are Impossible .
PRO P. III .
In any Cubic AEquation , all whose Roots are real , the Square of the third Term must be greater than the triple Product of the second and fourth Terms .
In the same Cubic AEquation , whose Roots are a , b , c , the Square of the third Term is ~2 ab+ac+b c , the Product of the second and fourth Terms is a2 bc+a b2 c +ab c2 , as is plain from the Inspection of the AEquation ; and it is obvious that a2 b c+a b2 c+a b c2 is the Sum of the Products of any two of the Terms a b , a c , b c ; and therefore by Corol .
1 Prop. 2 .
the Square of the Sum of these Terms , that is , ~2 ab+ac+bc must be greater than 3 a2 bc+3a b2 c+ 3a c2 b. So that ~2 ab+ ac +bc~ y2 must be greater than ~3 a2 bc+3a b2 c+3a c2 b~ y2 ; that is , the Square of the third Term must be greater than the triple Product of the second and fourth Terms .
Cor. 1 .
It follows from the Demonstration , that ~2 ab+ac+bc is always greater than 3abc~~a+b+ c. Cor. 2 .
If the Square of the third Term is found to be less than the triple Product of the second and fourth Terms , then the Roots of the AEquation cannot be all real Quantities ; and this concludes with the second Part of Sir Isaac Newton 's Rule for finding when the Roots of a Cubic AEquation are impossible : For this Case gives to be placed under the third Term , and 1/ 3 1/ 3 x3+px2+qx+r =0 +*+ consequently two Changes of the Signs , whatever Sign is placed under the second Term .
Schol .
After the same manner , it may be demonstrated , that in a Cubic AEquation , whose Roots are all real , if the second Term is wanting , the Cube of the third Part of the third Term taken positively , is always greater than the Square of half the last Term .
Suppose that the Roots of the AEquation are + a , -b , -c , or -a , +b , + c , and that a=b+c , then the second Term in the AEquation will be wanting , and the other Terms will be expressed thus : y3 *-b2 y~b c~~ b+c -b cy -c2 y The Square of b-c is always positive , since b and c are real Quantities .
Suppose it , ( viz. b2 2bc+ c2 ) equal to D , then b2+b c+c2 =D+3 bc , and ~ b+c2 =D+4b c. Therefore ~b2+bc+c2 3/ 27 = D3/ 27 + D2bc/ 3 + Db2 c2 + b3 c3 , and b2 c2 ~ ~b+c2/ 4 =D b2 c2/ 4 + b3 c3 .
Now'tis obvious that D3/ 27 + D2 b c/ 3 +D b2 c2 + b3 c3 is greater than Db2c2/ 4 + b3 c3 , since D is positive , and bc also positive , b and c being Roots having the same Sign .
Therefore the Cube of ~ of the third Term having its Sign changed ( =~b2+bc+c2 3/ 27 ) is always greater than the Square of half the last Term ( = b2 c2 ~~b + c2/ 4 ) .
In the Cubic AEquation x3 *+qx+r= o , if q be positive , or if it be negative and +q3/ 27 be less than 1/ 4 r2 , it appears that two Roots of the AEquation must be impossible , from this Corollary , and from Cor. 3 .
Prop. 2 .
taken together .
PRO P. IV .
In a Biquadratic AEquation , all whose Roots are real Quantities , 3/ 8 of the Square of the second Term is always greater than the Product of the first and third Terms ; and 3/ 8 of the Square of the fourth Term is always greater than the Product of the third and fifth Terms .
1 .
Let the AEquation be x4-p x4+q x2 r x+s = ~ ; and since the Roots are supposed to be all real , let them be represented by a , b , c , d , then p=a+b+c+d , and q=a b+a c+a d+b c+b d+c d But it is plain from Lemma 3 , that 3 a2 +3 b2 +3 c2 +3 d2 is greater than 2ab+2ac+2ad+2bc+2bd+2c d ; and consequently by adding 6ab+6ac+6ad+6bc+6 bd +6cd to both , we shall find that 3~ ~a +b+c+ d2 must be greater than 8ab+8ac+8ad+8bc+8 bd+8c d ; that is , 3 p2 greater than 8 q ; and therefore 3/ 8 p2 x6 greater than q x6 .
2 .
Since r=abc+abd+acd+bc d , and s= abc d ; and since qs is equal to a2 b2 cd+ a2 c2 bd+ a2 d2 bc+ b2 c2 ad+ b2 d2 ac+ c2 d2 a b , which are the Products can be made of any two of the Quantities ab c , ab d , ac d , bc d , whose Sum is r multiplied by one another ; it follows , that 3 r2 is always greater than 8q s : So that 3/ 8 of either the Square of the second Term , or of the Square of the Fourth Term , must alP 2 ways ways be greater than the Product of the Terms adjacent to them .
Cor. Multiply either the Square of the second Term , or the Square of the fourth Term of a Biquadratic AEquation by 3/ 8 , and if the Product does not exceed the Product of the adjacent Terms , some of the Roots of that AEquation must be impossible .
PRO P. V. In an AEquation of any Dimension expressed by m , the Coefficients of the second , third , last , last but one , and last but two Terms , being respectively A , B , E , D , C , if the Roots of the AEquation are all real , then shall ~m-1 ~ A2 always be greater than 2m B , and ~m-1 ~ D2 greater than 2mC E. 1 .
For supposing the Roots to be a , b , c , d , e , &amp;c. then by Lemma 4 , shall ~m-1 ~ a2 + ~m-1 ~ b2 + ~m-1 ~c2 &amp;c. be greater than 2ab+2ac+2a d , &amp;c. and adding ~2 m2 ~a b+ ~2 m2~ac+ ~2 m-2 ~a d , &amp;c. to both , the Sum ~m-1 ~ a2 +2 ~m-2 ~a b+ ~m-1 ~ b2 + &amp;c. ( =~m-1 ~ ~a +b+ c , &amp;c. 2 ) must be greater than 2mab+2mac +2ma d , &amp;c. that is , ~m-1 ~ A2 must be greater than 2m B. 2 .
In general , it follows from this Demonstration , that the Square of the Sum of any Quantities whose Number is ( m ) multiplied by m-1 , must be greater than the Sum of all the Products can be made by multiplying any two of them , multiplied by 2 m. But it is easy to see from the Genesis of AEquations , that C , E is the Sum of the Products can be made by multiplying any two of the Terms whose Sum is D : From which it follows , that ~m-1 ~ D2 must be always greater than 2mC E. To be continued .
V. A.

