4 Fig. 3 .
Fig. 4 .
L DMK E C N FBI X. Remarks on some Attempts made towards a perpetual Motion , by the Reverend Dr. Desaguliers .
F. R. S. THE Wheel at Hesse-Cassel , made by Monsieur Orfireus and by him called a perpetual Motion , has of late been so much talked of , on Account of its wonderful Phenomenon , that a great many People have believed it to be actually a self-moving Engine ; and accordingly have attempted to imitate it as such .
Now as a great deal of Time and Money is spent in those Endeavours , I was willing ( for the Sake of those that try Experiments with that View ) to show that the Principle , which most of them go upon is false , and can by no Means produce a perpetual Motion .
They take it for granted , that if a Weight descending in a Wheel , at a determinate Distance from the Centre , does in its Ascent approach nearer to it ; such a Weight in its Descent will always preponderate , and cause a Weight equal to it to rise , provided it comes nearer the Centre in its Rise ; and accordingly as it self rises , will be overbalanced by another Weight equal to it ; and therefore they endeavour by various Contrivances to produce that Effect , as if the Consequence of it would be a perpetual Motion .
But I shall show , that they mistake one particular Case of a general Theorem , or rather a Corollary of it , for the Theorem it self .
The Theorem is as follows : Theor .
If one Weight in its Descent , does by Means of any Contrivance , cause another Weight to ascend with a less Momentum or Quantity of Motion than it self , it will preponderate and raise the other Weight .
Cor. 1 .
Therefore if the Weights be equal , the descending Weight must have more Velocity than the ascending Weight , because the Momentum is made up of the Weight multiplied iuto the Quantity of Matter .
Cor. 2 .
Therefore if a Leaver or Balance , have equal Weights fastened or hanging at its Ends , and the Brachia be ever so little unequal , that Weight will preponderate , which is farthest from the Centre .
SCHOLIU M. This Second Corollary causes the Mistake ; because those , who think the Velocity of the Weight is the Line it describes , expect that that Weight shall be overpois 'd , which describes the shortest Line , and therefore contrive Machines , to cause the ascending Weight to describe a shorter Line than the descending Weight .
As for Example , in the Circle ADBa ( Fig. 5 .
) the Weights A and B being supposed equal , they imagine , that if ( by any Contrivance whatever ) whilst the Weight A describes the Arc A a , the Weight B is carried in any Arc , as B b , so as to come nearer the Centre in its rising , than if it went up the Arc B D ; the said Weight shall be overpois 'd , and consequently , by a Number of such Weights , a perpetual Motion will be produced .
This is attempted by several Contrivances , which all depend upon this false Principle ; but I shall only mention one , which is represented by Fig. 6 .
where a Wheel having two parallel Circumferences , has the Space between them divided into Cells , which being carved , will , ( when the Wheel goes round ) cause Weights placed loose in the said Cells , to descend on the Side AA A , at the Circumference of the Wheel ; and on the Side D to ascend in the Line Bbb b , which comes nearer the Centre , and touches the inner Circumference of the Wheel .
In a Machine of this Kind , the Weights will indeed move in such a Manner , if the Wheel be turned round , but will never be the Canse of the Wheels going round .
Such a Machine is mentioned by the Marquis of Worcester , in his Century of Inventions in the following Words , No. 56 .
To provide and make that all the Weights of the descending Side of a Wheel , shall be perpetually farther from the Centre , than those of the mounting Side , and yet equal in Number , and heft to the one Side as the other .
A most incredible thing , if not seen ; but tried before the late King ( of blessed Memory ) in the Tower by my Directions , two extraordinary Ambassadors accompanying his Majesty , jesty , and the Duke of Richmond , and Duke of Hamilton , with most of the Court attending him .
The Wheel was fourteen Foot over , and had forty Weights of fifty Pounds a Piece .
Sir William Balfore , then Lieutenant of the Tower , can justify it , with several others .
They all saw , that no sooner these great Weights passed the Diameter Line of the lower Side , but they hung a Foot farther from the Centre ; nor no sooner passed the Diameter Line of the upper Side , but they hung a Foot nearer Be pleased to judge the Consequence .
Now the Consequence of this , and such like Machines , is nothing less , than a perpetual Motion ; and the Fallacy is this .
The Velocity of any Weight is not the Line , which it describes in General , but the Height that it rises up to , or falls from , with respect to its Distance from the Centre of the Earth .
So that when the Weight ( Fig. 5 .
) describes the Arc A a , its Velocity is the Line A C , which shows the perpendicular Descent ( or measures how much it is come nearer to the Centre of the Earth ) and likewise the Line BC denotes the Velocity of the Weight B , or the Height that it rises to , when it ascends in any of the Arcs B b , instead of the Arc B D : So that in this Case , whether the Weight B in its Ascent be brought nearer the Centre or not , it loses no Velocity , which it ought to do , in order to be raised up by the Weight A. Nay , the Weight in rising nearer the Centre of a Wheel , may not only not lose of its Velocity , but be made to gain Velocity , in Proportion to the Velocity of its counterpoising Weights , that descend in the Circumference of the opposite Side of the Wheel ; for if we consider two Radij of the Wheel , one of which is Horizontal , and the other ( fastened to and moving with it ) inclined under the Horizon in an Angle of 60 degr .
( Fig. 7 .
) and by the Descent of the End B of the Radius B C , the Radius CD by its Motion causes the Weight at D , to rise up the Line p P , which is in a Plane that stops the said Weight from rising in the Curve D A , that Weight will gain Velocity , and in the Beginning of its Rise , it will have twice the Velocity of the Weight at B ; and consequently , instead of being raised , will overpoise , if it be equal to the last mentioned Weight .
And this Velocity will be so much the greater , in Proportion as the Angle ACD is greater , or as the Plane Pp ( along which the Weight D must rise ) is nearer to the Centre .
Indeed if the Weight at B , Fig. 5 .
could by any Means be lifted up to ~ , and move in the Arc ~ b , the End would be answered ; because then the Velocity would be diminished , and become ~ C. Experiment ( Fig. 7 .
) Take the Leaver BC D , whose Brachia are equal in Length , bent in an Angle of 120 degr .
at C , and moveable about that Point as its Centre : In this Case , a Weight of two Pounds hanging at the End B of the horizontal Part of the Leaver , will keep in AEquilibrio a Weight of Four Pounds hanging at the End D. But if a Weight of one Pound be laid upon the End D of the Leaver , so that in the Motion of D along the Arc p A , this Weight is made to rise up against the Plane Pp ( which divides in half the Line AC equal to C B ) the said Weight will keep in AEquilibrio two Pounds at B , as having twice the Velocity of it , when the Leaver begins to move .
This will be evident , if you let the Weight 4 hang at D , whilst the Weight ~ ies above it : For if then you move the Leaver , the~ Weight I will rise four times as fast as the Weight 4 .

