IV .
Observations upon the Generation of Plants , in a Letter to Sir Hans Sloane , Bart. Pr .
Coll. Med. By Patrick Blair , M. D. F. R. S. Boston , Dec. 31 .
1721 .
Honoured Sir , IT is no small Satisfaction , that what I advanced in my Botanick Essays is now so fully confirmed by Experiments made by some curious Gardeners , among whom is Mr. Philip Miller , who writes me , November 11 , 1721 .
1 .
That in Pursuance of my Advice he separated the Male Plants of the Spinage from the Female ; the Consequence was , that the Seeds did swell to the usual Bigness ; but when he sowed it , it did not grow afterwards .
He searched into the Seed , and found it wanted the Punctum Vitae , which perhaps might have been the Case with Mr. Geoffroy ; but if not , the female Embryones might have been impregnated another Way , as he experimented with twelve Tulips , which he set by themselves about six or seven Yards from any other , and as soon as they blew , he took out the Stamina so very carefully , that he scattered none of the Dust , and about two Days afterwards , he saw Bees working on Tulips , in a Bed where he did not take out the Stamina , and when they came out , they were loaded with the Duston their Bodies and Legs : He saw them fly into the Tulips , where he had taken out the Stamina , and when they came cut , he went and found they had lest behind them sufficient to impregnate these Flowers , for they bore good ripe Seed ; which persuades him , that the Farina may be carried from Place to Place by Insects , and when they happen upon a Flower , whose Uterus is capable to be impregnated by such a Dust , it may be thus effected .
I am of Opinion , this will not suit with Mr. Morland 's Scheme .
For tho ' we may suppose the Stamina of every Flower to be loaded with a due Proportion of the Farina , yet this accidental Conveyance of it to a neighbouring Flower , may be rather less than greater than is necessary : So that , if wanting , then those Embryones , which had not received its determined Particle into their Bosom , must be defective in Bulk , or barren in growing , but here all were equally filled .
2 .
By a Second Letter , October 19 .
1721 .
he informs me , that he bought a Parcel of Savoy Seeds of a Neighbour , which he sowed , and planted out the Plants ; but was surprised to see the Production : For he had half of them red Cabbages , and some white Cabbages , and some Savoys with red Ribs , and some neither one Sort nor other , but a Mixture of all Sorts together in one Plant .
He went to the Gardiner and told him his Tale , who showed him , that he was in the same Condition , but did not know how it should come to pass , for he was sure he took special Care in saving of the Seed .
Being asked how and where he planted them for Seed , he showed him them under a South-West Hedge , and told him the Manner in which he planted them .
First , a Dozen of white Cabbages , then a Dozen of Savoys , and then a Dozen of Red .
Then he immediately thought how it came to pass , by the Effluvia impregnating the Uterus of one another ; and it is very common for our Gardiners to plant white and red Cabbages together for Seed , and they are as often disappointed by having a Degeneracy of both Kinds , which they attribute to the Soil , and think that is the Cause : They send to Holland for a fresh Supply of Seeds , and say our Soil will not continue that Sort Good .
He told them his Opinion , and they laugh at him for it , and will not be turned out of their Road , although they should have never so many Experiments showed them .
This Experiment is a most convincing Argument for the Effluvia ; for did each Grain of the Farina enter the Pistillum to its proper Uterus , this mongrel Kind would never be produced .
For if the individual Plant be in each Grain of the Male Farina , how can it be so far dismembered , as that one Part shall go to the making up of the Ribs of red Cabbage , and another to compose the rest of a Savoy Plant .
Analogous to this , is what I lately observed in a Spaniel Bitch , of so good a Kind , that when she became proud , Care was taken to let her have good Dogs .
The Litter she produced , consisted of Puppies some Piebald , like one of the Dogs that had lined her , of the same Shape , Colour and Spots ; others like another ; and a third partaking of both , with Spots from the Bitch interspersed .
This is a farther Confirmation of what I have advanced , Essay 4 .
where Page 310 .
I only assert , that several Faetus 's partake equally of Male and Female ; but here two Males concur with one Female in the Composition of a fourth Body , made up of all the three : And one Seed produces a Cabbage consisting of three different Species , which could never happen , did these organiz 'd Animalcula , or Granules of the Farina , be4 come come a Faetus , or contain the Folia Seminalia of a Plant .
This methinks is sufficient to answer what the ingenious Mr. Bradley has so strenuously contend ed for , Works of Nature , p. 9 .
&amp; seq. But since that worthy Gentleman has not thought fit to answer what I have already advanced upon that Subject , I may hereafter answer his Objections more at large .
I could descant yet more upon this Observation , and consider how far this may lead us into the infinite Variegations and Stripes , in not only annual Flowers , such as Poppies , Consolida Regalis , and Bottles , but also in perennial Roots ; such as Auricula 's , Couslips , &amp;c. of a lower Size , which is hinted by Mr. Bradley ; he having received that Notion from the ingenious Mr. Du Bois , as I have been credibly informed ; and in Plants of a larger Size , not of a Bulbous , but Carnous Root , such as Columbines ; where there is a vast Variety : And in this Plant it is most especially to be observed , that though the indigenous one , from which all the other seem only to be Variations , and not determinate Species , be of a blue Colour , consisting of ten Alternate Petala , viz. five corniculate , and five plain ; yet into how many other Kinds of Flowers is it subdivided ; such as pale yellow , with bluish red , purple , dark Stripes vastly double , blue , blackish red , &amp;c. Some with Corniculate Petala , and some only with plain , and how in single Flowers it imitates all the Colours we see Pigeons endowed with .
I say it is worthy of Consideration , whether the Farina may do this , since I do not understand there has been much Art used in making these Flowers break , as Tulips , or to cultivate a Set of Breeders ; but that a richer Soil may produce a double Flower ; and a suitable Loam may produce the Variety of Colours ; the Farina from several Flowers may occasion the Stripes , and the Stamina arising from the plain Petala , rather than the Cornicula , pouring out the Farina , may cause the Flowers with the plain Petala .
So that were I to extend this to a great many other Plants , and were there proper Observations made upon them , considerable Improvements might be made upon this Doctrine of the Sexes of Plants .
For after the Flowers , we come next to the Variegation of the Seed of some Plants , particularly the Phaseoli , whose various Spots and Colours , and even the Bigness too , may very much depend upon the Effluvia from the Farina , when several Kinds are sown together .
For do but consider three plain Colours , a White , Red , and dark Blue , and you may observe how many Descendants , and whata Variety of Spotsmay proceed from them .
The Lupines also in some Measure may be brought in here , and I know not but that the Medica Cochleata Falcata Lunata , may be multiplied in its Variations after the same Manner .
But it is Time to proceed to another Experiment of my Correspondent Mr. Miller .
Being persuaded to it by an ingenious Gardiner , he pulled off all the Male-Flowers of some Melon Plants so soon as they appeared ; but instead of finding , as his Friend informed him , that these Flowers exhausted the Nourishment from the Fruit ; he found that , without these Flowers , none of the Melons would grow , so that he was deprived of the Fruit which he expected .
As this Experiment is a plain Indication of the Necessity of the Fariaa , so it confirms the Use I have assigned to the Leaves , viz. that by entring the Capillaries of the Leaves , and returning , the nutritive Particles may be more attenuated : So here , the Petala of the Male-Flowers may serve for the same Purpose , for by the Largeness of the Tubuli in these Pomiferae Scandentes , a gross viscid Sap is received , which even the Leaves themselves are not sufficient to attenuate , so as to be fit for composing the more subtle Part of the Fruit ; until by repeated Circulation through the Petala of the Male-Flowers , it may be rendered fit for such a Purpose .
Indeed , the Female-Flowers upon the Top of the Rudimentum Fructus , may in some Measure serve for this Purpose .
But as the MaleFlowers are , generally speaking , more numerous than the Female , so their being removed must deprive the Embryones of a very great Assistance towards its being perfected : I may add , that the Orifices of the Pedicles , when the Flowers are pulled off , must lose so much of the Sap , that the whole Plant must be thereby so impoverished , as not to be able to bring forth the designed Fruit ; all this , beside the Want of the considerable Supply of the Farina Faecundans .
I designed to have given a few Thoughts concerning the Variegation of Leaves and Flowers , being unwilling to admit of Mr. Bradley 's Sickness or Weakness of the Sap : But I shall reserve that to a more convenient Opportunity , being at present intent upon making some farther Improvements upon the Generation and Nourishment of Plants , which I hope to have well confirmed by Experiments made by my good Correspondents the Gardiners , especially this Mr. Miller and my self .
I shall expect your Sentiments of these , which will be a great Encouragement to proceed , to Your Most Obliged ,

