VI .
A Letter to Dr. Halley , Astronomer Royal , R. S. Soc , in answer to some Objections made to the History of the Antiquity of the Venereal Disease .
By Mr. Beckett , Surgeon , F. R. S. SIR , I Was of opinion that what I had said in my two former Letters , had been so full and satisfactory that I should have had no occasion to have given my self or any body else , any farther trouble upon this head : But forasmuch as I find there have been two Objections made against what I have advanced by one or two learned Gentlemen , I shall take upon me to answer them , and endeavour to prove they do not in the least invalidate the Authorities I before produced .
The first is , that the Venereal Disease so well known among us now , and the Leprosy of former Ages , could not be the same Disease , because the Leprosy is not to be conquered by Salivation , which the other generally very readily yields to .
In answer to this .
I am to observe , that the Leprosy , which we have among us at this time , affects only the surface of the Body , the Skin generally appears scaley , with a certain deep red colour , or small Sores upon removing the Scales , and sometimes a Scabbiness , with a redness of the Skin , which affects different parts of the Body .
I have known both the Cheeks only affected , both the Arms for the breadth of the Palm of the Hand , sometimes the Breast , the Legs , and other Parts ; but this may continue upon the Patient during his Life , as it frequently does , and never make any farther Progress ; which shows it to be a cuticular Disease : In these Cases upon Salivating the Patients , the Scales generally fall off , the redness disappears , and the Cure shall seem to be completed ; but in a Month or two the same inconveniences generally attend them as before .
But one ought not to conclude , that because our Leprosy will but rarely be cured by Salivation , and the Pox generally will , that many of those Persons the Ancients judged to be Leprous , were not really Venereal ; for their Leprosy , as they called it , was a quite different Disease from ours , Had there been any Proof brought that Persons had been Salivated in their Leprosy , and failed of Cure , it would have determined the Case ; but on the contrary , we are assured by the learned Dr. Pitcairn , in his Dissertation concerning the Ingress of the Lues Venerea , That the Leprosy , before the Neapolitan Disease was talked of , was cured by Mercury , and now since it changed its Name , it is no longer heard of .
Thus we find that their Leprosy and our Venereal Disease would be cured by the same Method , but their Leprosy and ours , being absolutely different Diseases , we by no means ought to expect the Success , from the same process of Cure , should be the same .
I dare be positive that no body ever observed our Leprosy to be attended with falling of the Hair , hoarsness of the Voice , the Patient speaking as though he spoke through the Nose , Consumption of the Flesh , Ulcers all over the Body , corruption of the fleshy Parts , and of the Bones themselves , filthy Ulcers of the Throat , corrosion and falling of the Nose , all which are reckoned as Symptoms of their Leprosy ; on the contrary , ours is a mild and almost inofsensive Disease , which a Person may be affected with during his Life , and never become worse ; whereas the other by displaying it self under the Symptoms before enumerated , brings the Patient to the most miserable end ; besides this , their Disease was got by Coition as their Authors assure us , but in our Leprosy , a diseased Husband may cohabit with his Wife as long as he lives , and he shall never be able either by Coition , or the immediate contact of the diseased Parts with those that are sound , to communicate any Evil .
Had what our Predecessors called the Leprosy been the same Disease we call by that Name now , they had not been so solicitous of making such large Provision for them , or shutting them up from Humane Society ; for one of our Leprous Persons might have been among them , and no body have known he laboured under any Infirmity at all .
From hence it is evident the Disease so common among them , was entirely different from our Leprosy , the Appearances of which bear no manner of Analogy with the former : It is from the Symptoms of the Disease , and the manner of its being received , that we generally know one Disease from another ; but the Symptoms of most of their Leprous Persons , and the manner whereby the Disease was gotten , will be found in no other Disease that attacks the humane Body , but in the Venereal Disease only ; for here they so exactly agree , that we must in a manner do violence to our own Reason , if we deny them to be the same .
I proceed now to answer the second Objection , which indeed was long ago falsely asserted by Dr. Fuller the Historian ; which is , that the Leprosy was brought into England from the Holy War , by some of our Countrymen , and that the Disease was altogether unknown among us before .
This , as I take it , does not so immediately concern me , since all I take upon me to prove is , that what They called the Leprosy , is not the same Disease we call by that Name now , but another .
However , I shall in a few Words make it appear that this Objection is likewise groundless , by observing that the first Englishmen that went over to the Holy War , made their first Voyage in the Year 1096 , as our Historians generally agree , and that some of them returned in 1098 , two Years after that Expedition ; but most certain it is , we had the Leprosy among us before , for Wharton , de Episcopis Londinensibus , and other Historians assure us , that Hugo de Orivalle , one of the Bishops of London , died here of the Leprosy in the Year 1084 , which proves our Countrymen did not bring that Disease first from the Holy War , because we had it among us before .
The account William of Malmesbury gives of this Bishop 's Disease , is as follows .
Is post ~ ordinationis annos in morbum incurabilem incidit .
Siquidem regia Valetudo totum corpus ejus purulentis ulceribus occupans ad pudendum remedium transmisit .
Nam credens asserentibus unicum fore subsidium si vasa humorum receptacula , verenda scilicet , exsecantur , non abnuit .
Itaque &amp; opprobrium spadonis tulit Episcopus , &amp; nullum invenit remedium , quoad vixit leprosus .
Now its highly probable , had this been a new Disease the Bishop died of , the mention of it as such , would not have escaped our Historian , but on the contrary it seems to have been anciently known among us , because the Remedy made use of for it was so , it having been recommended by AEtius , and other Physical Writers several hundred Years before this time ; and I think its very plain that the cutting off the Testicles , and with them the Vessels formed for the receiving the Humours as expressed in the former Case , was by them looked upon to be of peculiar Service , because its probable that observing the Disease to begin in these and the neighbouring Parts , they thought the very Minera ~ , would be by this means destroyed , and the Disease either cured or the spreading of it prevented .
I am , SIR , Yours , &amp;c. William Beckett .

