I. Part of a Letter from Mr. Deverel Surgeon at Bristol ; concerning a Case in Chirurgery , which is commonly mistaken for a Fracture of the Patella .
RICHARD BURT , a Gardiner , living with Mrs. Lloyd of Stoke near Bristol , was thrown from his Horse , and in the fall received such a hurt in one of his Knees as made him incapable of remounting : He felt somewhat crack in that Knee ( as he expressed it ) before it touched the ground .
Upon examining the Part I found ( as I then thought ) the ends of the broken Bone drawn above four fingers distance from each other : But upon a stricter examination of the parts , I found the Patella ( which was drawn upwards by the extensors of the Leg ) retained its natural Figure , and that the hardness which was felt below was the end of the torn Ligament that ties it to the Tibia .
The ends of the Ligament were brought as near as possible , and kept so about three Weeks without any very remarkable accident intervening .
He then began to walk , which was a little too soon , causing thereby some pains , and loosening the Cicatrix , which made it the longer before it was perfectly firm ; however he walks without any perceptible lameness .
I have met with two others in the same case , the one a Person of distinction , who has not met with the good Fortune of walking so well as she used , tho ' not for want of all the care and circumspection imaginable ; for it is hardly to be expected that one in ten , to whom this Accident happens , should ever go right , it being next to an impossibility that the ends of the torn Ligament should be so exactly placed , and retained as not to lie one over the other .
Paree in the 22d Chapter of his 15th Book affirms , that he never saw one of those who have had this Bone broken , but that halted during the rest of their lives : I am very apt to believe what this excellent Author affirms about the halting , and am sorry I must dissent from his notions of the case , and the cause of the Lameness .
Hildanus in his Observationes Chirurgicae .
Cent. 5th .
Observe .
88 .
P. m. 485 , has given us a History of a transverse Fracture of this Bone , which , after all the Symptoms were removed , was cured .
Sed claudicatio ac summa imbecillitas totius cruris secuta est , ita ut non nisi maxima cum difficultate ambulare possit .
He afrerwards mentioning the cause of the Lameness makes a Quaery , if what Paree ( to whom this Observation is dedicated ) says in his Exc .
lib. de ossibus , lib. 4 .
cap. 2 .
can be the cause of the Lameness ; his words are , Etsi vero Opinionem hancce rationi consentaneam ~ in dubium revocare minim conabor , unus tamen restat scrupulus , videlicet , an , fracta patella , extuberantia calli talis esse possit , ut cavitatem hancce ( quae inter femur &amp; os tibiae magna est ) adeo adimpleat , ut motum actionemque genu impedire possit ?
Videmus enim ut plurimum in reliquis ossium fracturis , ( nisi contritio ossis &amp; periostei fuerit maxima ) naturam tam decenter &amp; eleganter connectere ossa , ut raro relinquatur vestigium fracturae .
Periostium enim , quam diu integrum est , materiam calli retinet , quo minus in extuberantiam excrescere possit , nisi , &amp;c. Deinde in hoc nostro AEgro callum non fuisse causam claudicationis ex sequentibus apparebit : quapropter distinctione hie opus est .
After this he goes on to show us how many ways this Bone may be fractured , but doth not observe that he ever saw it any other way broken , ( unless in a Gunshot shot-wound ) than transversly ; if he had , I am persuaded , that this curious Observator would never have omitted it in his Observations .
~ in his Centuria observationum Anatomico-Chirurgicarum 4c .
observatio 3 , writes as follows .
Patellam propter duritiem suam haud frangi posse nonnulli perverse asserunt .
Nos vero eandem non solum ~ casu graviori in genu frangi experti sumus , verum etiam sine casu ; cujus rei Historiam recensere animus est .
Ante tres praeterpropter annos , visitavi cum Magistro Petro Adriani filio , viram satis robustum , qui a ponte descendens in terram fere ceciderat ; uno pede lubrico , resistens tamen quantum potuit , in Terram non fuerat prolapsus ; sed ab illa re~ vehementissima transversim fracta ejus patella , &amp; adeo quidem evidenter , ut inter utrumque locari potuerit manus , una ~ supra altera infra genu sentiebatur .
This Observation is so like in all its circumstances to that which I related above , especially in that the Fracture was made without a fall , that I am very apt to believe it is the same ; and do imagine he might be deceived by mistaking the hard end of the Ligament for the broken Bone .
And when these sort of Accidents , which are now called Fractures of the Patella , come to be nicely examined ; they will perhaps be found to be generally of the same Nature .

