I. Some Remarks on a late Essay of Mr. Cassini , wherein he proposes to find , by Observation , the Parallax and Magnitude of Sirius .
By Edmund Halley , LL. D. R. S. S. IN the Memoires of the Royal Academy of Paris , for the Year 1717 .
but now very lately published , there is one very remarkable Essay , by Mr. Cassini , concerning the Annual Parallax of the Fixed Stars , and particularly of Sirius ; and in conclusion , he determines the Diameter of Sirius to be as much bigger than that of the Sun , as the Sun 's is greater than that of the Earth , which he supposes to be 100 times : And the distance from the Sun to the Earth being certainly about 100 Diameters of the Sun , it will follow , that the Globe of Sirius must be a Sphere , whose Diameter must equal the distance between the Earth and Sun .
To prove this , he tells us that he made use of an excellent Telescope of 34 French Feet , or 36 English , leaving an Aperture of but an Inch and half , to take off the spurious Rays of the Star , which then appeared round , and sufficiently well defined ; and comparing his Body to that of Jupiter , which he says , was then 50 Seconds Diameter , he found that the Diameter of Jupiter was ten times greater than that of the Star , which by consequence was seen under an Angle of about 5 Seconds ; which is his first Position .
Then he tells us , that to make the Observations of the Parallax of this Star with all the exactness possible , he employed a Telescope of three Foot , in a Copper Tube , having fixed in the common Focus of the two Glasses , four threads crossing one another in the Center , under Angles of 45 Degrees .
This Tube he firmly fixed to the Plain of a Mural Arch , which had been for above 30 Years immovably cemented to the Wall of the Royal Observatory , to which he chose to fix it , because of the great Solidity thereof , and its being therefore the less liable to shake ; and that after having stood 30 Years , there was no fear of its settling any further in the space of one Year ; besides , that it was easy to perceive if any such alteration should happen to it .
Having therefore fixed his three Foot Tube as above , so that , about the beginning of April , 1714 .
New Stile , ( I suppose , because then Sirius was in Square to the Sun ) the Star being exactly in the Meridian , past over the Center of the Tube , he observed that on the 20th of April the Star touched the Horizontal Thread with its under edge , being apparently all above it , in the inverting Tube , but really below .
On the 15th of May , and 6th of June , it past again by the Center .
On June the 27th it appeared a little under , and on July the 9th it was found to touch the under part of the Thread .
On October the 5th it again past by the Center ; but on December the 29th , it touched the upper part of the Thread .
January the 18th , 1715 , being the coldest Day of that Winter , it past exactly by the Center ; and on the 27th of March , and the 1st of April , it almost touched the upper side of the Horizontal Thread , from which it seemed a little separated .
But on June the 7th , it past a little under the Center ; and on June the 29th , the Sun being then in conjunction with Sirius , it past under the Thread , so as to touch it with its upper edge .
Whence it appears , that in the space of the whole Year , there had been no other variation of the Meridian Altitude of Sirius , than the breadth of the Thread , which appeared equal to the Diameter of the Star , which he takes to be five , or at most six Seconds .
Supposing this to be so , he then shows that the whole Diameter of the annual Orb is to the distance of Sirius , as the Sine of 6~ to the Sine of 39~ 33 the Latitude of the Star , whence the aforesaid immense magnitude of the Body thereof , is a necessary Consequence .
But before this obtain a full assent , it may not perhaps be amiss to enquire whether the supposed visible Diameter of Sirius , were not an Optic Fallacy , occasioned by the great contraction of the Aperture of the Object Glass : For we all know that the Diameters of Aldebaran and Spica Virginis , are so small , that when they happen to immerge on the dark Limb of the Moon , they are so far from loosing their Light gradually , as they must do were they of any sensible magnitude , that they vanish at once with their utmost Lustre ; and emerge likewise in a Moment , not small at first , but at once appear with their full Light , even tho ' the Emersion happen very near the Cusp ; where , if they were four Seconds in Diameter , they would be many Seconds of Time in getting entirely separated from the Limb .
But the contrary appears to all those , that have observed the Occultations of these bright Stars .
And tho ' Sirius be bigger than either of them , yet he is by far less than two of them ; and consequently his Diameter to theirs is less than the Square Root of 2 to 1 , or than 14 to 10 ; whence , in Mr. Cassini 's excellent 36 Foot Glass , those Stars ought to be about four Seconds in Diameter ; and they would undoubtedly appear so , if viewed after the same manner ; whereas we are aliunde certain , that they are less than one single Second in Diameter .
The great strength of their native Light , forming the resemblance of a Body , when it is nothing else but the spissitude of their Rays .
As to the other part of the Argument , that the alteration of the declination of Sirius , on the score of the access of the Earth in December , and its recess in June , amounts to 6 Seconds ; I can only remark , that , besides that a Radius of 3 Feet , as it seems that made use of was no more , is somewhat too small for so extremely nice an Observation , 6~ being subtended by the 1/ 1000 part of an Inch , some of the Observations before recited do plainly show , that the Refraction of the Medium did intermix with those Differences that might be occasioned by the Parallax .
But the principal Objection against the Conclusion of this Argument , seems to be , that the Meridian altitude of Sirius at Paris being under 25 Degrees , the ordinary Refraction of the Star is 1~ 55~ or 115 Seconds ; and the Barometer rising and falling above two Inches in Thirty , shows that the density of the Air , on that score , may be a 15th part more at one time than another .
Whence the Refractions being always proportional to the density of the Medium , as we have all seen it often demonstrated by Mr. Hawksbee , both in Vacuo , and in a aoubly and trebly condensed Air , it is plain that in that Altitude the Refraction of a Star may differ about 7 or 8 Seconds , or the 15th part of 115~ , which is more than the whole Parallax supposed to have been observed .
It were to be wished that Mr. Cassini would please to try this Matter by the Lucida Lyrae , instead of Sirius , which , tho ' somewhat less than him , is as near to the Sostitial Colure , and has much greater Latitude , being but 28 grad .
from the Pole of the Ecliptic , whence its Parallax would be so much greater ; and being at Paris within 10 grad .
of the Zenith , the grand Objection of the difference of Refraction , would be almost wholly removed .

