Philosoph. Transact No. 363 .
AA Fig. 2 .
A Fig. 3 .
Fig. 1 .
DEFGC FG daca BC DEB BC AA C Fig. 4 Fig. 5 .
Fig. 6 .
AB D CE E BBD C Fig. 8 .
A ABACDB OF H C GA Fig. 7 .
Fig. 10 .
Fig. 9 CD II .
An Account of some new Experiments , relating to the Action of Glass Tubes upon Water and Quicksilver .
By James Jurin , M. D. Reg. Soc. &amp; Coll. Med. Lond. Soc. IN a* Discourse formerly presented to the Royal Society , I maintained , that the Suspension of Water in a Capillary Tube was owing to the Attraction of a small annular surface on the inside of the Tube , which touched the upper part of the Water .
Among the several Experiments made use of to prove this Assertion , was that of a Glass Funnel of several Inches Diameter , having its small end drawn out into a very fine Tube , which Funnel being inverted and filled with Water , the whole quantity of Water therein contained was sustained above the Level by the Attraction of that narrow Annulus of Glass , with which the upper surface of the Water was in contact .
Soon after that Discourse was printed , came out a Book published by a very Learned and Ingenious Member of this Society , in which that Experiment was accounted for in the following Manner .
If there be a Funnel , as AB C , Fig. 1 .
full of Water , and whose wide end stands in a Vessel of Water as B C ; and the Top of the Funnel A ends in a Capillary Tube open at A , the whole Water will be sustained : the Pillar Aa by the Attraction of the Circle of Glass within the Tube immediately above it ; and all the rest of the Pillars of Water , as F f , D d , E e , G g , &amp;c. in some measure by the Attraction of the parts of the Glass above them , as F , * Philos. Transact. No. 355 .
D , E , G : And hat the small Pillars or Threads of Water D d , and E e , do not slide down to F f , and G g , and so go quite down , seems to be owing to their Cohesion with the Pillar A a , which is sustain d by the Capillary Tube A : For if you break off the said Tube at D E , the whole Water will presently sink down .
As this Solution was very different from what I had before given , and the Reputation of that Gentleman , whose great Knowledge in Experimental Philosophy is generally known , was sufficient to give weight to any of his Opinions , I thought my self under an Obligation to examine his account of the Experiment , in order either to demonstrate its insufficiency , or to retract my own Solution .
Accordingly at the next meeting of the Society , I produced the following Experiment .
The Funnel , AFGB C , Fig 2 .
whose lower part BCF G , was Cylindrical to a considerable height , and whose top was drawn out into a fine Tube at A , being filled with Water to the height B F , so that the surface of the Water F G , did not reach to the arched part of the Funnel , I touched the end A with a wetted Finger , whereby a small quantity of Water being insinuated into the Capillary Tube at A , the Water contained in the Funnel was suspended above the Level of the Water in the Cistern D E , as in the former Experiment .
In this Experiment it is manifest , that the little Columns , into which we may suppose the Cylinder of Water , FGB C , to be divided , are no way sustained by the Attraction of the arched part of the Glass above them , since they have no contact with it .
Nor is there any such middle Pillar of Water , which , by its contact with the Tube at top is both sustained it self , and helps to support the Pillars about it .
Upon the supposition of which two Particulars that Gentleman 's Solution was founded .
This Experiment may be thus accounted for .
The Cylinder of Water FGB C , by its weight balances a part of the pressure of the Atmosphere , which is incumbent on the Water in the Cistern , and endeavours to force that Cylinder upwards .
The rest of that pressure is balanced by the Spring of the Air , AF G , which is included between the Cylinder of Water FGB C , and the little Column of Water in the Capillary A. But , as this Air by its Spring presses equally every way , it must balance as much of the pressure of the Atmosphere upon the little Column of Water at A , as it does of that upon the Water in the Cistern .
The remainder of the pressure of the Atmosphere upon the Column of Water at A is sustained by the force with which that Column adheres to the Capillary Tube , which therefore does exactly balance the weight of the Cylinder of Water FGB C , and is the real , though not the immediate , cause of its Suspension .
The experiment succeeds in the same manner when a Column of Quicksilver is raised into the Funnel , instead of the Column of Water FGB C , the top of the Tube being touched with a wet Finger as before .
But then the height of the Quicksilver in the Funnel must be as much less than that of the Water , as irs Specific Gravity is greater .
I proceed now to acquit my self of a Promise I made in the Discourse abovemention 'd , of examining whether the Experiments therein contained would succeed in Vacuo ; and whether Water could be suspended in a wide Tube by means of a Capillary at Top , at a greater height , than what it can be raised to by the Pressure of the Atmosphere .
In order to this , I boiled some Water , and afterwards purged it of its Air by means of the Air-pump ; which being done , those Experiments all succeeded in the exhausted Receiver , in the same manner as in the open Air .
The 13th Experiment in particular was made with a Tube of about 35 Inches in length , and a quarter of an Inch Diameter , the top of it being drawn out into a fine Capillary , Which being filled with Water purged of its Air , as before mentioned , the whole quantity continued suspended in the exhausted Receiver .
This plainly shows , that the success of that Experiment does not depend upon the Pressure of the Air , since the small quantity of Air left in the Receiver was by no means capable of sustaining the Water at so great a height , and consequently that the height , at which Water may be suspended in this manner , is not limited by that Pressure .
But here I must not omit taking notice of a consirable Difficulty , which presents it self to those who attentively consider this Experiment .
In order to make which the better appear , it will be proper to observe what happens , when a simple Capillary Tube is filled with Water purged of Air , and enclosed in the exhausted Receiver .
In this case the whole Column of Water contained in the Tube AC B , Fig. 3d .
is suspended by the Attraction of the Annulus at the top of the Tube , A. And though that Annulus does not immediately act upon any part of the Water , except what is either contiguous to it , or so near as to be within the Sphere of its Attraction which extends but to a very small distance ; yet it is impossible , that any other part of the Water , as for instance that at C , should part from the Water above it and sink down , because its descent is opposed by the attraction of the contiguous Annulus at C. For this , being equal to the upper Annulus at A , is capable of sustaining a Column of Water of the length A B , and consequently is more than sufficient for supporting the Column of Water below it , C B. From which it is plain , that no part of the Water contained in the Tube can possibly descend , unless the upper part , assisted by the weight of the Water below it , be sufficient to overcome the Attraction of the Annulus of Glass at A. But in such a compound Tube as that made use of in our Experiment , Fig. 4th AC B , the case is very different , and it does not easily appear , why in a Vacuum any part of the Water in the wider part of the Tube , as for Example at C , should not leave that which is above it , and descend ; since the Annulus at C is by much too wide to sustain a Column of Water of so great a length as C B. The best answer I can give to this difficulty is , that the Cohesion between the Water contained in the Capillary and that below it , is sufficient to balance the weight of the Column suspended .
But how far this Cohesion may depend upon the Pressure of a Medium subtle enough to penetrate the Receiver , is worthy of Consideration .
For though such a Medium will pervade the Pores of the Water , as well as those of the Glass , yet it will act with its entire Pressure upon all the solid Particles , if I may so call them , of the surface of the Water in the Cistern ; whereas so many of the solid Particles of the Water in the Tube , which happen to lie directly under the solid Particles of the Water above them , will thereby be secured from this Pressure ; and consequently there will be a less Pressure of this Medium upon any surface of the Water in the Tube below the Capillary , than upon an equal surface of the Water in the Cistern .
So that the Column of Water suspended in the Tube may be sustained by the difference between those two Pressures .
This Explication seems to be favoured by the following Experiments , which may all be accounted for in the same manner , though I shall anon mention another Cause , which contributes to the Success of the first and second .
The first I shall mention , is the famous Experiment of the suspension of Mercury purged of Air , to the height of 70 or 75 Inches , in the Torricellian Tube , in the open Air .
To which we may add the sustaining of Mercury likewise purged of Air within the exhausted Receiver , as related by that Learned and Successful Promoter of Natural Knowledge , Mons. Papin , in his Continuation du Digesteur .
I forbear to mention the suspension of Water purged of Air , in the Vacuum , which he describes in the same Book ; because there is little difference between that Experiment and our own abovementioned , the very top of the arched part of his Tube , which top we may suppose as small as we please , supplying the place of the fine Capillary at the top of our Tube .
But we must not omit the Experiments made by the famous Mons Huygens , and described by him in Phil. Transact. No. 86 , of the cohering of polished Plates with a considerable force in the exhausted Receiver ; as likewise of the running of Water and Mercury , when purged of Air , through a Siphon of unequal Legs in the Vacuum : All which he accounts for from the same Principle , and much in the same manner , as we have used for explaining the Experiment above .
As to the Existence of such a Medium , I shall content my self to refer to what has been said by our Illustrious President in the Queries at the latter end of the last Edition of his Opticks : and as I have lately had the Honour to entertain the Society with some Experiments upon Quicksilver , which were exactly the reverse of those made by Dr. Taylor , the late Mr. Hawksbee and my self , upon Water ; by which I am now enabled to throw this whole affair into a little System by it self , I shall beg leave to lay it down in the following Propositions , the Proof of which is contained in the Experiments annexed .
PROPOSITION I. The Particles of Water attract one another .
This , I think , is now universally acknowledged , and therefore needs no Demonstration ; the Sphericity of the drops of Rain , and the running of two drops of Water into one another upon their contact , manifestly proving it .
PROPOSITION II .
The Particles of Quicksilver attract one another .
This is likewise manifest from the Spherical Figure , into which a drop of Mercury forms it self upon a Table ; and from two of them immediately running together , as soon as they come to touch .
PROPOSITION III .
Water is attracted by Glass .
This plainly appears from all the Experiments , that we have shown upon this Subject .
PROPOSITION IV .
Quicksilver is attracted by Glass .
Experiment I. If a small Globule of Quicksilver be laid upon a clean Paper , and be touched with a piece of clean Glass ; upon drawing the Glass gently away , the Quicksilver will adhere to it , and be drawn away with it .
And if the Glass be lifted up from the Paper , the Quicksilver will be taken up by it , in the same manner as a piece of Iron is drawn up by the Loadstone , and will stick to the Glass by a plain Surface of a considerable breadth , in proportion to the bulk of the drop , as manifestly appears by an ordinary Microscope .
Then if the Glass be held a little obliquely , the drop of Mercury will roll slowly upon its Axis along the under side of the Glass , till it comes to the end , where it will be suspended as before .
Exp. 2d .
If a pretty large drop of Mercury be laid upon a Paper , and two pieces of Glass be made to touch it , one on each side ; upon drawing the Glasses gently from each other , the drop of Mercury will adhere to them both , and will be visibly drawn out from a globular to an oval Shape ; the longer Axis passing through the middle of those Surfaces , in which the drop touches the Glasses .
PROPOSITION V. The Particles of Water are more strongly attracted by Glass , than by one another .
This manifestly appears from the rising of Water in small Tubes above the Level .
For when the Water begins to rise into a Capillary Tube , all the Particles of Water , which touch the small Annulus at the bottom of the Tube , must have quitted the contact of the other Water , and have risen contrary to their Gravity , to come into contact with the Glass .
After the same manner the other Experiments of Dr. Taylor , Mr. Hawksbee and my self , upon this Subject , are easily explicable .
For upon a careful Examination , it will be found in them all , that some parts of the Water quit the contact of the other Water , and join themselves to the Glass .
PROPOSITION VI .
The Particles of Quicksilver are more strongly attracted by one another , than by Glass .
Exp I. Fig. 5 .
If a small Tube as A B , open at both ends , be dipped into a Glass Vessel filled with Mercury , and be held close to the side of the Vessel , that the rise of the Mercury within it may appear ; the Mercury will partly enter into the Tube , but will stand within it at some depth , as C E , below the Surface of the Quicksilver in the Vessel , C D ; and this depth will always be reciprocally as the Diameter of the Tube .
In this Experiment a Column of Quicksilver of the height CE endeavours to force the Mercury higher into the Tube ; and as Glass has been already proved to attract Quicksilver , the Attraction of the annular Surface on the inside of the Tube , which is contiguous to the upper part of the Mercury , will likewise conspire to farther its ascent .
What opposes the ascent of the Quicksilvet , is the Power , by which that part of it , which endeavours to rise into the Glass , is drawn back by the Attraction of the other Mercury , with which it is in contact laterally , and this does not only balance the Attraction of the Glass , but likewise the weight of the Column of Mercury of the height C E , and consequently this Attraction is considerably stronger than the Attraction of the Glass .
The cause therefore , that suspends the weight of the Column of Mercury C E , being the difference between the Attraction of the annular Surface of the Tube at E , and that of an equal Surface of the Quicksilver in the Cistern , from which the Mercury , that endeavours to rise into the Tube , must recede , in order to unite it self to such an Annulus of the Glass , will always be proportional to that annular Surface , or to the Diameter of the Tube .
And since the Column sustained must be proportional to the Cause that suspends it , that Column must likewise be as the Diameter of the Tube .
But the Column suspended is as the Square of the Diameter of the Tube and the height CE conjointly ; from which it follows , that the height CE must be as the Diameter of the Tube reciprocally , as it is found to be by Experiment .
The Experiment of the Ascent of Water above the Level in a Capillary Tube , is just the Reverse of this .
Exp. II .
Fig. 6 .
Quicksilver being poured into the inverted Siphon AC B , one of whose Legs AC is narrower than the other C B ; the height C E , at which the Mercury stands in the wider Leg C B , is greater than the height C D , at which it stands in the narrower Leg C A. On the contrary , Water stands higher in the narrower Leg , than in the wider .
Exp. III .
Fig. 7 .
ABCD represents a rectangular plane of Glass , which makes one side of a wooden Box .
On the inside of this is another Glass plane of the same size , which at the end AC is pressed close to the former , and opens to a small Angle at the opposite end B D. When Mercury is poured into this Box to any height as C E , it insinuates it self between the two Glass planes , and rising to different heighrs between the Glasses where the opening is greater or less , it forms the common Hyperbola CG F ; one of whose Asymptotes OF is the line on which the Surface of the Mercury in the Box touches the inner Glass ; the other is the line A C , in which the Planes are joined .
This Hyperbola being carefully examined by Mr. Hawksbee and my self , the Rectangle EH G , wheresoever taken .
proved always equal to it self , to as great an accuracy as could be expected , when the Planes were opened to any considerable Angle : But when the opening was very small , the inequalities of the Planes , though the best I could procure , bearing a greater proportion than before to the distance between them , occasioned a sensible variation .
Which , by the way , I take to be the reason , why the Ordinates found by the late Mr Hawksbee , in examining the Curve produced in a contrary situation , upon dipping two Glass Planes so joined into Spirit of Wine , do not answer to those of the Hyperbola .
Exp. IV .
Fig. 8 .
AB is a perpendicular Section through two Glass Planes joined at A , and opened to a small Angle at B. C represents a pretty large drop of Mercury , the larger the better , which , being made to descend as far as C , by holding the Planes in an erect posture , with the end A downwards , retires from the contact of the Planes to D , upon inclining the Planes towards an horizontal Situation ; and the distance CD becomes greater or less , as the Planes are more or less inclined towards the Horizon .
A drop of any Oily or Watery Liquor moves the contrary way , as has been shown by the late Mr. Hawksbee .
Exp. V. Fig. 9 .
AB is a Tube open at both ends , and a Foot or two in length , whose lower part is drawn out into a fine Capillary at B. This Tube being filled with Mercury , the whole Column of Quicksilver will be sustained in it , provided the Capillary Tube at B be sufficiently small .
But if the Mercury in the end B be suffered to touch any other Mercury it runs all out of the Tube .
If , without letting it touch any other Mercury , a small part of the end B be broken off , the Mercury will run out , till it comes to some lesser height as B C , at which it will again stop , the height BC being nearly in a reciprocal proportion to the Diameter of the small end of the Tube .
The Seventh Experiment in Phil. Trans. No. 355 is the Reverse of this .
Exp. VI .
Fig. 10 .
Is the same in substance with the former , but made with a large Glass Funnel A B , instead of a Tube .
The Reverse of this in Water is the thirteenth Experiment in the same Transaction .
In all these Experiments it is easily seen , that the Effect is owing to the difference between the two Attractions , by which Mercury tends to Glass and to its own body ; they being always opposed to one another , so that a particular Explication is no way necessary .
But perhaps it may save some little trouble to the Reader , to remove the following Objection , which will readily occur to him .
In the Experiments brought to demonstrate the fourth Proposition , the Globule of Mercury adheres to the Glass in a plane Surface , which cannot be done without increasing the Surface of the Globule , and consequently removing some of its Particles from the contact of one another .
If therefore they tend more strongly to one another than to the Glass , why do they not recede from the Glass , and assume a figure perfectly Spherical , that they may all have the greatest possible contact with each other ?
To this we may answer , that the Power , by which Mercury is attracted either by Glass , or by other Mercury , is proportion to the attracting Surface ; and therefore , though , caeteris paribus , the tendency of Mercury to Glass is not so strong as its tendency to other Mercury , yet in this case a much greater number of Mercurial Particles coming into contact with the Glass , than what recede from the contact of one another , it is no wonder , that the Attraction of the Glass prevails , and causes the Globule to adhere to it .
For the number of Mercurial Particles which lose their contact with the other Mercury , is no more than what makes up the difference of Surface , which arises from changing the figure of the Drop : whereas the Particles , which by this means come to adhere to the Glass , are all those that constitute the plane Surface , in which the Globule touches it .
Which Consideration ought likewise to be applied to the Suspension of Quicksilver in Glass Tubes , either at extraordinary heights in the open Air , or at lesser heights in a Vacuum , as above mentioned .
For the top of the Tube being Spherical , or nearly so , it will be found , that the contact of the Mercury with the extremity of the Tube , is to the contact with other Mercury , which would be gained by its leaving the Top of the Tube and descending a very small space , in a Ratio infinitely great ; and consequently that the contact of the Mercury with the top of the Tube is one cause of its Suspension .
Coroll 1 st. From this Proposition it appears , that in a Barometer made with a narrow Tube , the Quicksilver will never stand at so great a height as in a wider .
Which accounts for the Phenomenon so often mentioned in the Yearly History of the Royal Academy of Sciences at Paris , by Monf .
De la Hire ; that in the Barometer , which he constantly made use of for his annual Observations , the Quicksilver did not rise so high , as in another he kept by him , by about three Lines and a half , which is near a third of an Inch our Measure : For he tells us , that the Tube of his Barometer is very small .
So that there is no need to have recourse to any peculiarity either in the Quicksilver or the Glass of which that Tube was made ; or to an unperceived remnant of Air left in the Tube , from some of which causes that Effect and some others of the same kind were imagined to proceed .
Cor. 2d .
In a Barometer made with a small Tube , the Mercury will rise and fall irregularly .
For , as the height of the Mercury depends partly upon the Diameter of that part of the Tube that touches the upper Surface of the Mercury , it is plain , that the unavoidable inequalities in the Diameter of the Tube will be more considerable , in respect to the whole Diameter ; and consequently will affect the height of the Mercury more in a small Tube than in a wider .
And this I take to be the reason , why it is so very difficult not to say impossible , to make two Barometers , which shall exactly agree in the height of the Quicksilver in all constitutions of the Air , especially if the Tubes be very narrow .
This irregularity is still more considerable in the Pendent Barometet , in which the Quicksilver moves through a large space , in order to make a small alteration in the length of the Column suspended : The same consideration is easily extended to those Levels , that depend upon the rising of Mercury to the same height in the opposite Legs of a bent Tube ; an Instrument of which kind has been lately offered for the service of the Public .
And as the effect is just contrary in Levels made with Water or Spirit of Wine , due regard ought to be had to this Property in the construction of those Instruments , by making the Tubes sufficiently wide , in order to diminish the Error as much as possible .

