E ~ B ~ .
~ ~o .
355 .
FD C F Fig~ ~ Fig. 2 .
Fig. 3 .
Fig. 4 .
GC D~ II .
An Account of some Experiments shown before the Royal Society ; with an enquiry into the cause of the Ascent and Suspension of Water in Capillary Tubes .
By James Jurin , M. D. and R. Soc. S. SOme Days ago a Method was proposed to me by an ingenious Friend , for making a perpetual Motion , which seemed so plausible , and indeed so easily demonstrable from an Observation of the late Mr. Hawksbee , said to be grounded upon Experiment , that , tho ' I am far from having any Opinion of attempts of this Nature , yet , I confess , I could not see why it should not succeed .
Upon trial indeed I found my self disappointed .
But as searches after things impossible in themselves are frequently observed to produce other discoveries unexpected by the Inventer ; so this Proposal has given occasion not only to rectify some mistakes into which we had been led , by that ingenious and useful Member of the Royal Society above named , but likewise to detect the real Principle , by which Water is raised and suspended in Capillary Tubes , above the Level .
My Friend 's Proposal was as follows .
Fig 1 .
Let ABC be a capillary Siphon , composed of two Legs A B , B C , unequal both in length and Diameter ; whose longer and narrower Leg AB having its orifice A immerst in Water , the Water will rise above the Level , till it fills the whole Tube A B. and will then continue suspended .
If the wider and shorter Leg B C , be in like manner immerst , the Water will only rise to some height as F C , less than the entire height of the Tube B C. This Siphon being filled with Water , and the Orifice A sunk below the Surface of the Water D E , my Friend reasons thus .
Since the two Columns of Water AB and F C , by the Supposition , will be suspended by some Power acting within the Tubes they are contained in , they cannot determine the Water to move one way , or the other .
But the Column B F , having nothing to support it , must descend , and cause the Water to run out at C. Then the pressure of the Atmosphere driving the Water upward through the Orifice A , to supply the Vacuity , which would otherwise be left in the upper part of the Tube B C , this must necessarily produce a perpetual Motion , since the Water runs into the same Vessel , out of which it rises .
But the Fallacy of this reasoning appears upon making the Experiment .
Exp. 1 .
For the Water , instead of running out at the Orifice C , rises upward towards F , and running all out of the Leg B C , remains suspended in the other Leg to the height A B. Exp. 2 .
The same thing succeeds upon taking the Siphon out of the Water , into which its lower Orifice A had been immerst , the Water then falling in drops out of the Orifice A , and standing at last at the height A B. But in making these two Experiments it is necessary that AG the difference of the Legs exceed F C , otherwise the Water will not run either way .
Exp. 3 .
Upon inverting the Siphon full of Water , it continues without Motion either way .
The reason of all which will plainly appear , when we come to discover the Principle , by which the Water is suspended in Capillary Tubes .
Mr. Hawksbee 's Observation is as follows .
Fig. 2 .
Let ABFC be a capillary Siphon , into the which the Water will rise above the Level to the height C F , and let BA be the depth of the Orifice of its longer Leg below the Surface of the Water D E. Then the Siphon being filled with Water , if BA be not greater than C F , the Water will not run out at A , but will remain suspended .
This seems indeed very plausible at first sight .
For since the Column of Water FC will be suspended by some power within the Tube , why should not the Column B A , being equal to , or less than the former , continue suspended by the same Power ?
Exp. 4 .
In fact , if the orifice C be lifted up out of the Water D E , the Water in the Tube will continue suspended , unless BA exceed F C. Exp. 5 .
But when C is never so little immerst in the Water , immediately the Water in the Tube runs out in drops at the Orifice A , tho ' the length AB be considerably less than the height C F. Mr. Hawksbee in his Book of Experiments has advanced another Observation , namely , that the shorter Leg of a Capillary Siphon , as ABF C , must be immerst in the Water to the depth F C , which is equal to the height of the Column , that would be suspended in it , before the Water will run out at the longer Leg .
Exp. 6 .
From what mistake this has proceeded , I cannot imagine ; for the Water runs out at the longer Leg , as soon as the Orifice of the shorter leg comes to touch the Surface of the stagnant Water , without being at all immerst therein .
Having proceeded thus far in obedience to the commands of this illustrious Society , I beg leave to go a little farther , and to enquire into the cause of the ascent and suspension of Water in capillary Tubes .
That this Phenomenon is no way owing to the pressure of the Atmosphere , has been , I think sufficiently proved by Mr. Hawksbee 's Experiments .
And that the cause assigned by the same ingenious and inquisitive Person , namely the attraction of the concave Surface , in which the suspended Liquor is contained , is likewise insufficient for producing this effect , I thus demonstrate .
Since in every capillary Tube the height , to which the Water will spontaneously ascend , is reciprocally as the Diameter of the Tube , it follows , that the Surface containing the suspended Water in every Tube is always a given Quantity : but the Column of Water suspended is , as the Diameter of the Tube .
Therefore , if the attraction of the containing Surface be the cause of the Waters suspension ; it will follow , that equal causes produce unequal effects , which is absurd .
To this it may perhaps be objected , that , in two Tubes of unequal Diameters , the circumstances are different , and therefore the two Causes , tho ' they be equal in themselves , may produce effects that are unequal .
For the lesser Tube has not only a greater Curvature , but those parts of the Water , which lie in the middle of the Tube , are nearer to the attracting Surface , than in the wider .
But from this if any thing follows , it must be , that the narrower Tube will suspend the greater quantity of Water , which is contrary to Experiment .
For the Columns suspended are as the Diameters of the Tubes .
But as Experiments are generally more satisfactory in things of this nature , than Mathematical reasonings , it may not be amiss to make use of the following , which appear to me to contain an Experimentum Cru~ .
Fig. 3 .
The Tube CD is composed of two Parts , in the wider of which the Water will rise spontaneously to the height B F , but the narrower Part , if it were of a sufficient length , would raise the Water to a height equal to CD Exp. 7 .
This Tube being filled with Water , and the wider end C immerst in the stagnant Water A B , the whole continues suspended .
Exp. 8 .
Fig. 4 .
The narrower end being immerst , the Water immediately subsides , and stands at last at the height DG equal to B F. From which it is manifest , that the suspension of the Water in the former of these Experiments is not owing to the attraction of the containing Surface : since , if that were true , this Surface being the same , when the Tube is inverted , would suspend the Water at the same height .
Having shown the insufficiency of this Hypothesis , I come now to the real cause of that Phenomenon .
which is the attraction of the Periphery , or Section of the Surface of the Tube , to which the upper Surface of the Water is contiguous and coheres .
For this is the only part of the Tube , from which the Water must recede upon its subsiding , and consequently the only one , which by the force of its cohesion , or attraction , opposes the descent of the Water .
This likewise is a cause proportional to the effect , which it produces ; since that Periphery , and the Column suspended , are both in the same proportion as the Diameter of the Tube .
Tho ' from either of these particulars it were easy to draw a just Demonstration , yet to put the matter out of all doubt , it may be proper to confirm this assertion , as we have done the former , by actual Experiment .
Fig. 5 .
Let therefore EDC be a Tube , like that made use of in the 7th and 8th Experiments , except that the narrower Part is of a greater length ; and let AF and BG be the heights , to which the Water would spontaneously rise in the two Tubes ED and D C. Exp. 9 .
If this Tube have its wider Orifice C immerst into the Water A B , and be filled to any height less than the length of the wider Part , the Water will immediately subside to a Level with the point G ; but if the Surface of the contained Water enter never so little withen the smaller Tube E D , the whole Column DC will be suspended , provided the length of that Column do not exceed the height A F. In this Experiment it is plain that there is nothing to sustain the Water at so great a height , except the contact of the Periphery of the lesser Tube , to which the upper Surface of the Water is contiguous , For the Tube D C , by the Supposition , is not able to support the Water at a greater height than B G. Exp. 10 Fig. 6 .
When the same Tube is inverted , and the Water is raised into the lower extremity of the wider Tube C D , it immediately sinks , if the length of the suspended Column DH be greater than G B ; where .
as in the Tube DE it would be suspended to the height A F. From which it manifestly appears , that the suspension of the Column DH does not depend upon the attraction of the Tube D E , but upon the Periphery of the wider Tube , with which its upper Surface is in contact .
For the sake of those , who are pleased with seeing the same thing succeed in different manners , we subjoin the two following Experiments , which are in substance the same with the 9th and 10th .
Fig. 7 .
ABC is a Siphon , in whose narrower , and shorter Leg A B , if it were of a sufficient length , might be suspended a Column of Water of the height E F ; but the longer and wider Leg BC will suspend no more than a Column of the length G H. Exp. 11 .
This Siphon being filled with Water , and held in the some Position as in the Figure , the Water will not run out at C the Orifice of the longer Leg , unless D C , the difference of the Legs AB and B C , exceed the length E F. Fig. 8 .
Exp. 12 If the narrower Leg BC be longer than A B , the Water will run out at C , if DC the difference of the Legs exceed E F ; otherwise it will remain suspended .
In these two Experiments it is plain , that the Columns DC are suspended by the attraction of the Peripheries at A , since their lengths are equal to E F , or to the length of the Column , which by the supposition those Peripheries are able to support ; whereas the Tubes BC will sustain Columns , whose lengths are equal to G H. Tho ' these Experiments seem to be conclusive , yet it may not be improper to prevent an Objection , which naturally presents it self , and which at first view may be thought sufficient to overturn our Theory .
Fig. 5 .
For since a Periphery of the Tube ED is able to sustain no more than a Column of the length A F , contained in the same Tube ; how comes it to sustain a Column of the same length in the wider Tube D C , which is as much greater than the former , as the Section of the wider Tube exceeds that of the narrower ?
Fig. 6 .
Again , if a Periphery of the wider Tube DC be able to sustain a Column of Water in the same Tube , of the length B G ; why will it support no more than a Column of the same length in the narrower Tube E D ?
Which Queries may likewise be made with regard to the 11th and 12th Experiments .
The answer is easy , for the Moments of those two Columns of Water are precisely the same , as if the sustaining Tubes ED and C D , were continued down to the Surface of the stagnant Water A B ; since the velocities of the Water , where those Columns grow wider , or narrower , are to the velocities at the attracting Peripheries , reciprocally as the different Sections of the Columns .
Fig. 9 .
Exp. 13 .
From which consideration arises this remarkable Paradox .
That a Vessel being given of whatsoever Form , as AB C , and containing any assignable quantity of Water , how great soever ; that whole quantity of Water may be suspended above the Level , if the upper part of the Vessel C be drawn out into a capillary Tube of a sufficient fineness .
But whether this Experiment will succeed , when the height of the Vessel is greater than that , to which Water will be raised by the pressure of the Atmosphere , and how far it will be altered by a Vacaum , I may perhaps have the honour of giving an account to the Society some other time , not being perfectly satisfied with those Trials which I have hitherto had the opportunity of making .
Having discovered the cause of the suspension of Water in capillary Tubes , it will not be difficult to account for the seemingly spontaneous ascent of it .
For , since the Water , that enters a capillary Tube as soon as it 's Orifice is dipped therein , has it 's gravity taken off by the attraction of the Periphery with which it 's upper Surface is in contact , it must necessarily rise higher , partly by the pressure of the stagnant Water , and partly by the attraction of the Periphery immediately above that , which is already contiguous to it .
It might now be shown , how naturally the various , and seemingly contrary appearances of the above mentioned Experiments are deducible from this Theory ; but this is so easy , that it is needless to insist upon it ; and our discourse upon this minute Subject has been already so tedious , that we could scarce hope for Pardon , unless it were directed to those , who are sensible to how many of the greater , and more considerable , Phenomenon of Nature this Doctrine is applicable .
P S. When this Paper was reading before the Society , I found that our incomparable President was already acquainted with the above-mentioned Principle , and I have since met with several Passages in the ~ Query subjoined to the late Edition of his Opticks which plainly show , that he was Master of it , when they were written .
I must do the same Justice to that excellent Mathematician Mr. John Machine , Professor of Astronomy in Gresham College .
To these two worthy Persons I am obliged for the following Observation , That , what I call a Periphery , or Section of the concave surface of the Tube , is really a small Surface , whose Base is that Periphery , and whose height is the distance , to which the attractive power of the Glass is extended .
Cccccc III .
De

