I. Considerations on the Change of the Latitudes of some of the principal fixed Stars .
By Edmund Halley , R. S. Sec. HAving of late had occasion to examine the quantity of the Precession of the Equinoctial Points , I took the pains to compare the Declinations of the fixed Stars delivered by Ptolomy , in the 3d Chapter of the 7th Book of his Almag .
as observed by Timocharis and Aristyllus near 300 Years before Christ , and by Hipparchus about 170 Years after them , that is about 130 Years before Christ , with what we now find : and by the result of very many Calculations , I concluded that the fixed Stars in 1800 Years were advanced somewhat more than 25 degrees in Longitude , or that the Precession is somewhat more than 50~ per ann .
But that with so much uncertainty , by reason of the imperfect Observations of the Ancients , that I have chosen in my Tables to adhere to the even proportion of five Minutes in six Years , which from other Principles we are assured is very near the Truth .
But while I was upon this Enquiry , I was surprised to find the Latitudes of three of the principal Stars in Heaven directly to contradict the supposed~ greater Obliquity of the Ecliptic , which seems confirmed by the Latitudes of most of the rest~ they being set down in the old Catalogue , as if the Plain of the Earths Orb had changed its Situation , among the fixed Stars , about 20~ since the time of Hipparchus .
Particularly all the Stars in Gemini are put down .
those to the Northward of the Ecliptic , with so much less Latitude than we find , and those to the Southward with so much more Southerly Latitude .
Yet the three Stars Palilicium or the Bulls Eye , Sirius and Arcturus do contradict this Rule directly : for by it , Palilicium being in the days of Hip~ in about 10 gr of Taurus ought to be about 15 Min .
more Southerly than at present and Sirius being then in about 15 of Gemini ought to be 20 Min .
more Southerly than now ; yet e contra Ptolomy places the first 20 Min .
and the other 22 more Northerly in Latitude than we now find them .
Nor are these errors of Transcription , but are proved to be right by the declinations of them set down by Ptolomy , a observed by Timocharis , Hipparchus and himself , which show that those Latitudes are the same as those Authors intended .
As to ~ , he is too near the Equinoctial Colure , to argue from him concerning the change of the Obliquity of the Ecliptic , but Ptolomy gives him 33~ more North Latitude than he now has ; and that greater Latitude is likewise confirmed by the Declinations delivered by the abovesaid Observers .
So then all these three Stars are found to be above half a degree more Southerly at this time than the Ancients reckoned them .
When on the contrary at the same time the bright Shoulder of Orion has in Ptolomy almost a degree more Southerly Latitude than at present .
What shall we say then ?
It is scarce credible that the Ancients could be deceived in so plain a matter , three Observers confirming each other .
Again these Stars being the most conspicuous in Heaven , are in all probability the nearest to the Earth , and if they have any particular Motion of their own , it is most likely to be perceived in them , which in so long a time as 1800 Years may show it self by the alteration of their places , though it be utterly imperceptible in the space of a single Century of Years .
Yet as to Sirius it may be observed that Tycho Brahe makes him 2 Min .
more Northerly than we now find him , whereas he ought to be above as much more Southerly from his Ecliptic , ( whose Obliquity he makes 2 1/ 2 greater than we esteem it at present ) differing in the whole 4 1/ 2 Min One half of this difference may perhaps be excused , if refraction were not allowed in this Case by Tycho ; yet two Minutes , in such a Star as Sirius , is somewhat too much for him to be mistaken But a further and more evident proof of this change is drawn from the Observation of the application of the Moon to Palilicium Anno Christi 509 Mart .
~ .
when in the beginning of the Night the Moon was seen to follow that Star very near , and ~ to have Eclipsed it , ~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~ ~ .
i. e Stella apposita erat parti per quam ~~cabatur lmbus Lunae illuminatus , as Bullialdus .
to whom we are beholden for this Ancient Observation has translated it .
Now from the undoubted principles of Astronomy , it was impossible for this to be true at Athens , or near it , unless the Latitude of Palilicium were much less than we at this time find it .
Vide Bullialdi Bullialdi .
Astr , page 172 .
This Argument seems not unworthy of the Royal Society 's Consideration , to whom I humbly offer the plain Fact as I find it , and would be glad to have their Opinion .
But whether it were really true .
that the Obliquity of the Ecliptic was , in the time of Hipparchus and Ptolemy , really 22 Min .
greater than now , may well be questioned ; since Pappus Alexandrinus , who lived but about 200 Years after Ptolemy , makes it the very same that we do .
Vide Pappi Collect .
Lib. VI .
Prop 35 .

