IV .
A short Dissertation concerning the Child 's Crying in the Womb .
By the Reverend Mr. W. Derham , F. R. S. I Have already given the Society a Relation of the most material Circumstances of the Vagitus Uterinus that happened lately near me .
That Account was somewhat hastily written , without considering the manner of the Faetus 's Life , and the Disputes about it among some of the most Learned Anatomists .
And having since more maturely considered the Matter , and made some farther Enquiries into the Case , I hope a short , and farther Dissertation upon that Subject will not be unacceptable ; especially because I find the Case near me to be more considerable , or at least that a better Account may be given of it , than I find of any in the Authors I have consulted about it ; and it may perhaps conduce in some measure to the ascertaining the Fact , which some of the most considerable Members of our Society ( as some of the most Learned Authors ) called in Question .
Among the Authors that question the Fact , two of the most considerable are Etmuller and Diemerbroeck .
The Learned Etmuller declares Diemerbroeck 's Opinion , as well as his own , in his Dissertation de abstruso Respirationis Humanae negotio , Ch. 9 .
Where he treats of our famous Dr. Harvey 's Problem , Why the Faetus after Delivery , and before it hath Breathed , can live for some Hours in its After- burden , &amp; c ; but having breathed but once , cannot live scarce a moment in that manner ?
Etmuller 's Words to our purpose pose are , Vagitum Uterinum invincibile nonnulli existimant argumentum pro Respiratione Faetus in Utero demonstranda .
Sed cum muliercularum , quae plerumque in hisce casibus invocantur testes , sublesta admodum fides , nec satis circumspecta sit observatio , ut pro basi Problematis hujus resolvendi inservire queat ; merito suspicamur cum Clariss .
Diemerbroecio , Vigitum , siquis certo observatus fuerit , e sibilo intestinorum flatulentorum a faetu compressorum ortum duxisse , qui saepe mirus auditur , suspiria gemitusque in quibusdam mentiens .
Similia quoque ad pipientium Pullorum , intra ovi testam adhuc existentium , sonum , quem editum ferunt aliquando , reponimus : Praeprimis cum extenuatus aquae vapor ad corpora tenuiora allisus non minus sibilum excitare observetur : uti id experimento probat Illustr .
Boyleus .
The Matter of Fact being thus called in Question , may in my Opinion receive an Answer , in some measure , from the Case I have spoken of , and into which I have made some farther Enquiries .
Concerning which I must needs say , that notwithstanding I should be as much inclined as any Man to doubt of the Fact , being clearly of Opinion that the Faetus doth not live in the Womb by Breathing , yet the Evidence is so clear to me in the present Case , that I am fully satisfied it was really Crying of the Faetus , and not Groaking of the Guts , or Womb , or the Effect of any Feminine Imagination .
For here we have a thing happening not once , or twice only , but a great many times ; almost every Day , and divers times in the Day ; and that for near five Weeks together .
Enough to have discovered any Mistake , or to have undeceived even a fanciful Person .
In the next Place , we have the Child heard to Cry aloud , so as to be distinctly heard by Persons in another Room .
Consequently the Hearers could more easily , and ~ distinguisn whether the Noise was Crying or Croaking .
The Description the Mother and others gave me thereof was , ` ` That the Noise the Child made , was as if a Born-Infant had Cried eagerly , shut up close in a Tub .
In the third Place , The Crying seemed to be so eager and hearty , as to end in Sobbing , like what is observable oftentimes in Born Infants .
In the fourth Place , It was heard not alone by the Father and Mother , or one or two besides , but by many , or most of the Neighbourhood , both near and farther off , and many of them Persons long used to Children ; who do all with the greatest Assurance affirm it to have been as manifest Crying , as ever they heard from a Born-Infant , and nothing like any Noise of Wind , or the Guts : As on Enquiry they all particularly told me .
And in the last Place , The Midwife told me , that laying her Hand on the left side the Woman 's Belly , where the Child lay when it Cried , she could plainly feel a Motion under her Hand , like that of Respiration , every Blast of the Child 's Crying sensibly touching upon her Hand .
These Particulars being considered , do not only prove the reality of the Thing , but show the Case to be very considerable .
I have met with many Instances of this Nature in divers Authors , but not one that was of so long Continuance , and in which there were such frequent Reiterations of the Crying .
Some of the best attested Cases I have met with , may deserve to be recounted here .
And the Learned Verzascha of Basil hath given us so good a Catalogue of them in the third Observation of his Observe .
Medic .
that I shall go no farther for more .
And passing by the Cases he mentions , attested only by vulgar illiterate Persons , I shall name only a few that seem to have more sensible Persons for their EviD ddd dence .
dence .
Ant. Deusingius in his Dissert .
de Generat .
~ tell us ( he saith ) ` ` how that he had it from his Colleague Monaeus , that the Child cried in his Wife 's Womb , and the same befel the Wives of Mr. Salmuth , and Mr. Graenwolt .
His next Relation is that of our Dr. Needham , of the Faetus crying in the Womb of an English Woman of Quality , as she , her Husband , and Chaplain were together at Supper .
Which being a Story that every one is acquainted with , that hath seen the Doctor 's excellent Book De formato ~ , I shall not mention the Particulars of it .
The last Instance is of Christian Il .
King of Denmark , who was heard to Cry before he was Born .
Now these being Cases attested by Persons that may be supposed of better Understanding than the fanciful Vulgar , seem to claim somewhat more of Credit : The latter being the Case of a King , and in all probability heard by some of the best Quality about the Court ; the next heard by the Chaplain as well as Persons of Quality themselves , and that three times one after another ; and the former coming within the Cognisance of Gentlemen , and they probably Men of Learning too .
Upon this whole Evidence ( and more I could have added , even from the time of Hippocrates , I say from hence ) I conclude , That the Faetus doth really Cry sometimes in the Womb ; although how this is performed is hard to account for : Surely not without Respiration .
And therefore I am apt to think , that although the Faetus doth not ordinarily breathe in the Womb , yet it is possible for it to have an occasional , temporary Respiration there .
But whether in such Respiration , any of the Blood passes into the Lungs , or whether it doth not continue its Circulation through the Foramen Ovale only : Or if any more than ordinary Blood should by such Respiration get into the Lungs , whether it may not easily , and without Inconvenience be discharged thence , during that State of Life the Faetus leads in the Womb : All these Doubts I must confess my self unable to determine .
But however thus much favouring my Opinion , may be observed in the Sea-Calf , and such other Animals as have the Foramen Ovale , That the Circulation of their Blood is continued , notwithstanding the discontinuance of their Respiration for a long time .
As to the Peeping of Chickens in the Egg , about which Etmuller hath the same doubt , as of the Vagitus Uterinus , I have my self divers times heard that , both from Chickens and Ducks .
And a Person more Conversant in such Matters than my self assures me , That a little before the Hatching , she hath often , and can at any time cause some Chickens , and Ducklings to peep in the Egg .
She saith , that sometimes whole Nests of Eggs will yield a Cry , sometimes only ~ some particular Eggs : But that such Eggs as have once afforded a Peeping , may be made to Peep and Cry at any time , by shaking the Egg , and putting the Youngling into a disorder .
And sometimes where there hath not been any Noise before heard , the Bird hath been made to Cry , by shaking the Egg in which it was enclosed .
The Cause of this Peeping in the Shell , I take to be from some Uneasiness the young Bird may find there .
It being arrived to its perfect State in the Egg , is either weary of its Confinement therein , and desires more liberty ; or else it lies uneasily , or is offended with shaking , and therefore Peepeth and Cries , as when uneasy out of the Shell .
And after some such manner I take it to be with an Humane Faetus ; that it is in some Disorder , and uneasy in the Womb , and therefore Cries as well in , as out of it .
Thus I am apt to think it befel the Faetus I have so often spoken of , viz. That it lay very uneasily in the Womb all the while it Cried there , the Mother being in great Pain before , and during the time of the Child 's Crying , and the chhild it self being closely confined , and pent up on the Left-side the Mother 's Belly , all the time of the Crying only , and not all the 5 Weeks , as by mistake I told in my former Letter .
Perhaps also the Child might find some Uneasiness from a Bone the Midwife told me she found to stick out somewhat farther than ordinary : Which , upon Examination , I take to be one of the Vertebrae of the Back-bone .
And if this Bone caused Uneasiness to the Child , it might also by that means occasion perhaps the Woman 's Pains I spake of .
But these Suppositions and Guesses , which are only Imaginations of my own , may probably disagree with the Observations and Notions of Persons better skilled in Anatomy than my self , and are therefore submitted to their better Judgments by Their Humble Servant , W. Derham .

