IV .
An Experiment touching the Weighing of Bodies of the same Species , but of very unequal Surfaces , in Common Water , being of an equal Weight in Common Air .
By Mr. Fr. Hauksbee , F. R. S. I Took a Piece of Sheet-Brass ( which I take to be more close and solid than that which is cast ) of an exact Square Inch , weighing just 482 Grains .
I then cut as many Square Inches of Brass Tincel , as were equal to the same weight : The Number of these Square Inches were 255 .
Now these being of an equal weight with the other single piece in Common Air , I concluded from the inequality of their Surfaces , that a considerable disproportion in their Specific Gravities would ensue , by weighing them in Water ; the Water in one touching so many Parts of the Superficies more than in the other : And twas from what is generally asserted , That the smaller Bodies are , so the Disproportions of their Bulks to their Superficies increase ; and that supposing them infinitely small , or as Gold dissolved in Aqua Regis , or Silver in Aqua Fortis must be , then their Superficies being touched by so many Parts by the including Menstruum , which is in such a Disproportion to their Diameters or Bulks of Matter , as disposes them to remain suspended in it .
This I take to be the General Solution of that Phenomenon ; and it was these Considerations that gave Birth to this Experiment .
Yet when I came to bring it to the Test , I found , to my great surprise , ( being prepossessed on the contrary ) but two Grains difference , the single Piece weighed in the Water about 422 Grains ; all the other Bodies together , hardly two Grains less : And this upon two or three Trials succeeded much the same , notwithstanding they were made with all the Caution imaginable .
Now since so small an Inequality is the Matter of fact , between Bodies of the same Species weighed in Water , whose Disproportions of Surfaces are , as 1 to 255 , ( for I reckon the Sides of all the Tincel Bodies to be equal to the Sides of the single Brass piece , ) I must conclude , That those Bodies must be infinitely small , whose inequality of their Surfaces to their Bulks does exceed those in this Experiment : For supposing one of these thin Squares should be wrought into the form of a Globe , I am very apt to think , That the Disproportion then of its Surface to its Bulk of Matter , would not be so great as its present form renders it .
Moreover , That altho the Disproportions of the Surfaces of Bodies , to their bulk of Matter be very great ; yet , that that is the only Reason why a Metalick Body should be suspended in a Menstruum specifically lighter than it self , is very doubtful : For certainly if it was so , we might reasonably have expected to have met with a much greater Difference in the Bodies made use of in the newly recited Experiment : For there it should seem necessary , that where we had so great a Difference in point of Superficies , there we should also have had a Difference something proportional in point of weight ; which did not happen .
I think therefore that there must be some other Agent , or Quality , not only to assist , but Govern in the Case .
And what we call a corroding Menstruum , I take to be a Fluid adapt to attract such , or such a Body , ( as we find no one of them to operate alike on all ; ) but , as I said before , Aqua Regis for separating the Parts of Gold , Aqua Fortis for Silver : Now this Separation of their Parts by Attraction , seems to proceed from the Menstruum 's Affection to the BodyImX x2 mers 'd , mers 'd , and the Body reciprocally to the Menstruum , and both to act on one another with greater Vigour , than either of their own Particles do upon their contiguous Fellows ; by which means a Separation of Parts must ( I think ) consequently follows .
Thus being at liberty , they with the Menstruum become as one Body , and remain suspended in any part of it by their Mutual Attraction .
And that one Menstruum in this Case should affect one Body more than another , is no more than why the Magnet should affect Iron only .

