Tab. II .
Fig:4 .
N 22 27 14 Feb. 15 20 16 10 18 11 18 4 6 17 15 Jan 16 Nov. 10 ~ 16 March 4 23 18 E1WE Dec. 30 29 Nov. 8 28 22 21 9 23 24 June 7 19 6~ 26 Dec. 11 ~ Sept. 5 17 Sep. 12 16 4 Fig. 1 .
~..~.no .
330 AE Fig : 3 .
a b fgq N d ~ 4 ~ ~ ~ 19 ~W ~ ~~~~~~ ~~~~ 26 ~ ~~ 8 10 Fig. 2 .
II .
Observations upon the Spots that have been upon the Sun , from the Year 1703 to 1711 .
With a Letter of Mr. Crabtrie , in the Year 1640 .
upon the same Subject .
By the Reverend Mr William Derham , F. R. S. WHEN Spots on the Sun were more rare , than for these three or four Years last past they have been , this most Illustrious Society was pleased to accept of my Account of some of the first that for divers Years had been seen : Which for their Novelty were published , with some others , in the Phil. Transact. No. 288 .
But for as much as those Observations of mine were imperfect , as I there confessed , therefore to make some amends , I will give a better Account of the Spots and Faculae that have been seen on the Sun since ; there having~ I suppose , few of those Appearances escaped my Sight , since their first being seen in 1703 ; and because I am now better provided with competently good Instruments to take their Places on the Sun , viz. a Micrometer ( after Mr. Gascogin 's manner ) to take their distance from the Suns Nothern or Southern Limb , which is parallel with the Pole of the Earth ; and an Half-Seconds~ Movement , to measure their distance from the Suns Eastern or Western Limb .
In this following Table , may be seen at one view , what Spots or Faculae fell under my cognisance .
A Table of all the Spots and Faculae on the Sun , visible ~ Upminster , since July 1703 .
Jun. ~ .
none 1703 .
22 ~ 1707 .
27 Some 24 Octob. 9 Vanished 25 * 23 April 2 Feb. 14 No Spot 28 10 July 18 June 22 Vanished 3 nor * 15 11 20 23 June 7 16 Octob. 31 Nov. 19 21 24 8 18 Nov. 1 22 * 23 26 July 24 24 4 Sept. * 10 27 25 March 68 1704 28 nothing 14 Sept. 49 10 Jan. 16 18 30 11 N.B. This 15 5 Nov. 15~ 17 * 21 July *16 12 another 16 18 * Spot arose 17 Nov 17 37 14 on the 19 18 24 8 18 Eastern 18 21 side of the 19 22 Sept. 30 10 21 Disk , whilst 20 Faint ~ Dec. *2 Octob. 2 Jun. * 29 this was on the 22 23 Extinct 12 Extinct 30 Western .
1705 .
5 Oct. * 29 July 1 Jan. 30 Jan. 16 Nov. 5 Languid 2 Feb. 23 27 Faint 6 Scarce 4 25 * 3 25 *8 visible Mar. 75 26 28 More 5 8 * 25 30 29 ~ 9 Feb. * 19 31 30 Extinct 6 10 11 March 14 Nov. 2 Dec. 1~8 * 13 16 42 10 ** April 1 21 3 Aug. 31 4 Sept. * 12 April 11 May 5 ~ .
5 16 12 6 13 7 Feb. 7 22 Spot &amp; * 17 May 18 Mar. 7* 31 19 * 11 * 10 27 21 In this Table the Faculae are noted with an Asterisk ; and the duration of every Appearance of the same Spots or Faculae , or the time they disappeared , with a Line : And where any thing remarkable occurred , that could be briefly noted , I have taken notice of it in the Table .
There are many other things that I took notice of in viewing the Spots and Faculae , which would be troublesome to the Society , and indeed needless to particularly mention , since so many Accounts have been already given of them .
But some things I shall select , as may be of use to , and gratify such as are curious in these Matters .
And first , as to the Figure of the Sports .
They are well known to change frequently ; and therefore I think it of little use to give their Figures every time I observed them .
But it is somewhat remarkable , that the Spots generally appear longish near the extreme Parts of the Disk .
If they are never so round near the middle of the Disk , they become longer and longer towards the Extremes , till ( at going off ) they seem to be nearly a strait Line , nearly parallel so the Suns Limb .
Which is a manifest Argument , that the Sun is a Globe , and that these Spots are on , or very near its Surface .
Another thing remarkable is , The Mutability of the Shape of the Spots .
I have more than once manifestly perceived them to change in the very time I have been looking upon them .
Thus Nov. 19 .
1703 .
I saw three or more Spots not far off the middle of the Disk ; and whilst I was looking upon them , they seemed to vary , both as to their Shape and Strength ; sometimes seeming longer , sometimes shorter ; sometimes spiss , sometimes languid .
And this they seemed to do , not only through my 16 Feet Tube , ( which I thought at first was from the different Disposition of my Eye ) but also when I received the Suns Image through a Six Feet Telescope , lescope , on a white Paper , in a darkened Room .
These mutable Spots the Weather hindred me from seeing again till November the 22d .
following ; and then they were become only like a thin Smoke , or Nebula .
So again April 11 .
1704 .
there were divers Spots with Umbrae about them .
These Umbrae , or Nebulae , I could plainly perceive , whilst I was looking on them , to be sometimes very faint and thin , and sometimes much darker and thicker .
These Maculae and Umbrae I observed suddenly brake out in the Sun : For , on April 9 .
the Disk was free .
But this April 11 .
last mentioned , I perceived them advanced near a quarter part on the Disk : And consequently they brake out in the Sun within 48 hours before .
On April 13~ the Spots were become Umbrae , in the Morning ; and at Four of Clock in the Afternoon , there were no Remains of either Maculae or Umbrae .
From this short continuance of these Spots on the Sun , it is more than probable , they were in a perpetual Flux and Change ; and that those Mutations which I perceived in them , whilst I was looking on them , were real , not imaginary .
Also it may be farther remarked , ( which I have frequently observed , and which as I remember Scheiner observed long ago ) That those Spots and Umbrae which suddenly arise , do as suddenly decay , and are soon extinct .
And such Spots , I have farther observed , do seldom turn to Faculae , as they commonly do when longer on the Sun , as I shall observe by and by .
Again , May 5 .
1705 .
I could perceive two Spurs or Branches ( running from a Spot ) to change , and be sometimes darker , sometimes thinner .
So March 30 .
1706 .
I observed such another Variation .
This Day , or but little before , Spots with Faculae arose in the Sun , which remained not above three Days on him .
One of these Spots I could manifestly , perceive ceive to be sometimes quite extinct , and then again immediately to appear : And the Faculae also , in half an hours time , had plainly altered their Shapes .
October 29 .
the same Year , I could plainly perceive the Maculae and Faculae both to change : And whilst I was carefully viewing them , I saw a Spot arise in one of the brightest Faculae , and again nearly disappear ; and then again appear strong and spiss .
I should have been glad to have seen how they appeared next Day ; but the Weather was Stormy , Cloudy , and Wet for several Days after .
Another thing I have observed ( and not having the Book by me , I forget whether Scheiner observed the same or not ) is , That the Maculae do generally , if not always , become Nebulae or Umbrae before they quite vanish ; and after that , very frequently turn to Faculae , or bright golden Spots , more illustrious and fulgid than the other Parts of that glorious Globe .
If the Spots are of short duration , Faculae seldom ensue : Or if they do , they are commonly the Remains of some Spots that had before been on the Sun , and vanished perhaps on the side opposite to us .
But Spots that long continue , if they vanish before that part of the Sun revolveth out of our sight , do very often become Faculae .
Of which the Table affords several Instances , particularly July 3 .
1705 .
From these preceding Particulars , and their congruity to what we perceive in our own Globe , I cannot forbear to gather , That the Spots on the Sun are caused by the Eruption of some new Vulcano therein ; which at first , pouring out a prodigious quantity of Smoke , and other opacous Matter , causes the Spots : And as that suliginous Matter decays and spends itself , and the Vulcano at last becomes more torrid and flaming , so the Spots decay and grow to Umbrae , and at last to Faculae ; which Faculae I take to be no other than more flaming brighter Parts than any other Parts of the Sun .
These Faculae I have observed never continue long on the Sun : And the reason I conceive is , because the Vulcano , after its Smoke is over , doth not long emit its Flames ; by reason the fiery Pabulum is then near spent , when once it begins to flame : After which the torrid Vulcano soon returns to the Natural Temperature of the Sun , so nearly at least as to escape our sight , at so vast a distance as the Sun is from us .
Another thing that may be accounted for , and indeed doth in some measure confirm also what I have said , is the ~ , or darker part of the Spots ; generally in most Spots , and towards the middle of them .
Now it is very usual in Culinary Fires in this our Globe , when they emit Smoke , that the middle is the darkest part .
If , for Instance , we were from aloft in the Air , to see a thick Smoke come tumbling out of a Chimney , or the Mouth of a Vulcano just kindled , we should find the middle part , just over the Mouth of the Chimney , or Vulcano , to be the most spiss and dark , and towards the extremes clearer and thinner .
And so I take it to be in the ~ of the Sun ; that the Nucleus is just over the Mouth of the ignivomous Cavern , and that the misty Parts of the Spot are the thinner Parts of the Smoke , swimming about in that Fluid , or Atmosphere , which I suppose doth surround the Sun , as well as our Globe , and the Moon manifestly ; yea , and in all probability , every Planet of this our Solar System .
From what hath been said , we may give a reason why there are sometimes Spots frequently on the Sun , and sometimes none in many Years .
One thing I believe there is in this , That there may be Spots , but not always seen .
But there are doubtless great Intervals sometimes when the Sun is free ; as between the Years 1660 and 1671 , 1676 and 1684 .
In which time Spots could hardly escape the sight of so many curious Observers servers of the Sun , as were then perpetually peeping upon him with their Telescopes in England , France , Germany , Italy , and all the World over ; whatever might be before , from Scheiner 's time .
The reason , I say , of this long disappearance of the Spots , I take to be from the want of extraordinary Eruptions in that fiery Globe .
The Sulphureous , or other Matter , or Pabulum of those Eruptions , is spent or dissipated , and that Globe continues in its natural ordinary burning State , till there happens to be a fresh Collection of Smoaking , Displosive , and extraordinary Matter , that causes a new Eruption .
Which Eruptions generally happen between what we may call the Suns Tropicks , or in his Torrid Zone : For I never observed any Spots to be near the Suns Poles .
And if I misremember not , the Spots in Scheiner 's Cuts are all about the middle Zone of the Disk .
The greatest Evagation I ever observed of them was March 8 .
1703/ 4 .
On which Day , besides the dark Spots in the usual Zone , I perceived some faint Spots , scarce visible , much nearer the Southern Pole than I ever had seen them .
But this was , no doubt , in some measure owing to the Position of the Earth in respect of the Sun , as well as to the Southerly Place of the Spots on him : For , about the Equinoxes , the Spots seem to march pretty far towards the Poles of the Sun , as may be seen by the annexed Schemes .
( Tab. II .
) Having thus observed what part of the Sun the Spots commonly possess , I shall next take notice of their Stages and Path over the Sun .
That the Sun moves round his own Axis , is manifest , beyond doubt , from the Motion of the Spots .
And that the Spots seem to traverse the Sun , sometimes in Strait Lines , sometimes in Curve Lines , curved this way , and that way , is as manifest also , and well known to the Curious , and is set forth in the annexed two Figures ; Which Figures show the Stages of the Spots every Day that I observed them , and the Lines they describe in several Months of the Year .
The daily Stages in both Figures are exact ; or if they seem otherwise , it is by reason the Observations were made at different times of the Day ; as one in the Morning , the other some following Day in the Evening , or Afternoon .
But the Declinations of the Spots , or their distances from the Suns Northern or Southern Limb , are less exact in the second Figure than the first ; in which latter they are very near the truth .
And the Causes of the Defects in the 2d Scheme I shall mention , to prevent the same Errors in others I my self ran into .
1 .
The Diminution of the Suns vertical Diameter by the Refractions was the principal cause of my Errors .
This , altho ' I was sufficiently aware of , yet I did not think had been so considerable , for want of experimenting , or well considering the Matter : For I have sometimes found the perpendicular , or vertical Diameter of the Sun diminished , from 32~ 21~ on the Meridian , to 26~ 3~ at the Horizon , in one and the same Day .
2 .
For the same reason I was not aware of the time being so long before the Sun goes round , as I found ~ .
3 .
Another Error was measuring the Suns Image on the Scene of white Paper , with the Shade of the Micrometer ; and not by looking through the Tube , and so clasping the Limb of the Disk with the parallel edges of the Micrometer .
The former , altho ' practised by some eminent Astronomers , is a far more easy and indulgent , than accurate way .
A further Account of the Solar Spots to the Year 1711 .
SINCE my foregoing Account was drawn up , I have seen other Spots on the Sun , whose times are expressed in this following Table .
1707 .
1709 .
Decemb. 4 Jan. 15 10 21 * 29 22 * 30 August 13 * 17 1708 Octob. 8 July 31 November .
1 August 1 2 5 64 5 22 6 23 24 1710 .
28 Jan. 22 Septemb .
1 April *6 November .
5 Octob. 14 Dec. 14 * 18 26 From the Spots in this Table 1 had frequent occasions to be assured of my Opinion , in the foregoing Paper .
Particularly in viewing the Spots of August 1 .
1708 .
( represented inTab.11 .
Fig. 3 .
) where some were large and dark , others less and thinner , and all encompassed with Nebulae : In viewing these , I say , I observed great alterations at the very time I was looking on them .
Sometimes the Nuclei were very dark and black , sometimes less so ; and the same , thing I observed also in the Nebulae encompassing them .
One of the lesser Spots b. in Fig. 3 .
which the Day before was sufficiently visible and strong , was this Day , now thick and strong , and anon languid and less visible .
And from the two Spots a. and d. I could plainly see a Smoke issuing out to c. and f. sometimes visible for 5 or 6 Minutes , and then disappearing for a quarter of an Hour , or more ; and then again smoaking out , and again disappearing , as before .
All which Particulars , I saw over and over again repeated , for a good while together , till I was weary of the Observation .
These Spots I was hindered from viewing until Aug. 5 .
following : And then I found the Spot b. quite extinct , ( as I expected , ) as also some of the other Spots ; together with the Nebulae grown less .
But the great Spot a. continued dark and strong , only sometimes fainter , and then again stronger ; and sometimes like a half , or horned Moon ; sometimes roundish , or rather of an Oval Figure ; of which latter Figure they commonly are , when they are near the Suns Limb , which this Spot was not far off at this time .
These particulars are Confirmations of what I said , That the Solar-Spots are no other than a Smoke rising out of the body of the Sun .
Of which Opinion I have been almost ever since I first observed them , and find that I am not singular in this Opinion , as I shall show from a Letter ( which with some others is lately fallen into my Hands ) from the admirable Mr. ~ to the no less admirable Mr. Gascoigne , the ~ of the Micrometer ; which I presume will hardly be ungrately to this most illustrlous Society .
The beginning of the Letter hath been torn off ; but I find by that part of it that is ~ , it was Mr. Crablrie 's first Letter to Mr. ~ , and that the ~ part was only Compliments for his Writing to him , being a Stranger , &amp;c. After which it follows in these Words .
I writ also to Mr. Townley at that time my Opinion in brief of the Suns Spots , ( which you conceive to be Stars , ) and it seems he , or Mr. Kay , writ to the same purpose to you , desiring your Opinion : Which you freely deliver ; for which I cannot but commend you , and especially for preferring Reason before any Mans Authority .
Yet give me leave ( pace tua Amice desideratissime ) to speak my mind likewise freely concerning these Appearances .
I do not value the Authority of Galilaeus ( though reputed the greatest Speculative Mathematician in Europe ) nor yet Kepler ( though Astronomorum facile princeps ) further than either Demonstrative , or the most probable Reasons confirm their Opinions .
Nor will I stick to subscribe to the Man whosoever shall bring better Reasons for his Opinion .
I must acknowledge you say more for the stellifying of these Solar Obscurities , than I have heard before ; yet I conceive not sufficient , either demonstratively or probably to countermand those which Galilaeus , Kepler , and others have produced to the ~ ; nor yet such as can be cleared from such Objections , as Reason , Demonstration , and Observation may lay against them .
My Occasions will not admit a full Disquisition hereof at this time ; yet something I would say for the present , the better to furnish you where to object when I see you ; that so by diligent Inquisition , the desired truth may ( may we have that happiness ) be better found ~ by us .
I have often observed these Spots ; yet from all my Observations cannot find one Argument to prove them other than fading Bodies .
But that they are no Stars , but unconstant ( in regard of their Generation ) and irregular Excrescences arising out of , or proceeding from the Suns Body , many things seem to me to make it more than probable .
For first , for their Form ; they are seldom round , but of irregular Shapes , and , as I have often seen , one side , or end of the Spot more thin than the rest , like to a certain misty darkness , and by degrees thicker , grosser , and darker , nearer to the main body of the Spot ; just as the Smoke of some pitchy Fire , which is in one part very gross , and in another more rare and thin , turning~ at last into mere Air : Or like a Cloud , Fog , or Mist , more thick , dark , and gross in the midst ; and more ~ , fluid , penetrable , and transparent towards the sides ; which I suppose is not compatible with any of the Stars .
Secondly , for their Colour : The lighness thereof differenceth them from Stars , or Planets ; they being never of such absolute darkness as I observed Venus the 24th of November last : Tho ' I have seen spots sometimes little less than she , yet always of a far paler and whiter Colour , looking ( at least in some Parts ) like some thin dissipated substance .
Thirdly , for the manner of their appearance~ I have seen many Spots , which in the middle of the Sun appear of a round body , but coming towards the side of the Sun , appear long .
Which ( if you rightly consider it ) is a demonstrative Argument that they are not Globes , as all the Planets and Stars are : For Globes always appear of one form ( round ) in every Position ; but Exhalations , or such like fluid Substances , extended to a broad flat form , like our Clouds , which being over our Heads , and so in their full breadth , appear large and broad ; but driven with ` the Wind , till they turn one edge upon us , ~ of a long shape .
So these Solar-Clouds , being turned about the Sun , may in the middle ~ their full breadth to us , and about both edges of the Sun , turn their edges to us : Which answers to the appearance .
Fourthly , for their continuance .
Some of these Spots , arising at the East-side of the Sun , vanish before they come to the midst of the Sun .
Others appear first in the middle of the Sun , and vanish before they come to the Western Limb ; and for the most part they vanish before they have made a full revolution about the Sun .
Which argues them to be but thin , vanishing , fading Substances , not like the permanent bodies of the Stars .
But to take off these Reasons , you answer , That you conceive these Spots to be Stars moving regularly in their own Orbs , which are many , though none of greater extent than about 1/ 10 of the ~ Semidiameter from its Circumference ; and that the swifter Movers in the lower Orbs , overtaking the slower in the higher Orbs , cause an appearance .
You seem therefore to think , that they being so thin bodies , the Suns Rays pass through them , and so one cannot be seen alone , till more being together , one heaped behind another , they stop the light of the Suns Rays , and so cause an appearance .
This I conceive is you meaning : Or else ( as you seem to infinuate afterwards ) that the Higher reflects the Suns Rays strongly enough upon the Lower ( when they come within the Angle of Reflection ) to make the interjacent Planet indiscernable .
But to these I answer , 1 .
` ` If it be by their coming within the Angle of Reflection , that the light of the Sun reflected from the outer Planet upon the inner , doth make it ( as you speak ) indiscernable , then that Light so reflected is reflected either upon all places , as the Moons and Planets Light ; or but upon one , as is the Reflection of a plain Looking-Glass .
If the first , there would never be many seen ( seldom above one or two~ ) because the outermost would continually make the inner undiscernable .
But Gassendus affirms , there are seen sometimes 40 at once in the Suns body .
If the 2d , there would always be many seen , because the reflected Light would but occupy a little room , and that but for a small time , till the swifter were past the place of Reflection : Whereas many Days there are none at all seen in the Suns Hemisphere : And in both these cases , the outermost Planet of all would always in the space of 27 Days , be seen in the same place , being never obscured , none of the inferior being able to reflect Light upon it .
Add hereunto , if any kind of Reflection should make them to appear bright like the Sun , and so not distinguishable from the Light of the Sun , what should ( a ) hinder , but we should see them also bright Bodies by the side of the Sun , when they are passing either by the West , or East-side of the Suns Body ?
~ The Light being then reflected upon them by the inferior Planets as well as at other times , and that also upon much of that side of them which we should behold .
( a ) N. B. Mr Gascoigne having , against these Words , insert ed a rough-drawn Figure in the Margin of Mr Crabtrie Let~ ter , I have also represented it in ~ .
2 .
Fig. 4 .
imagining it may somewhat explain Mr Gascoigne 's Hypothesis , and what Mr. Crabtrie saith against it .
But if you wave this conceit , as insufficient , and fly to your former , That the swifter Movers in the lower Orbs , overtaking the slower in the higher Orbs , cause an appearance .
To this I answer .
1 .
The thing you suppose seems to me neither necessary nor probable , nor do I conceive why they should not be seen , being themselves alone , as well as conjoined , seeing all other Stars and Planets are so .
2 .
If it be because they are of a thin , transparent Substance , till many , being one behind another , make them to seem grosser ; Then they are not of the nature of other Planets , as is proved in ~ and ~ , who of themselves appear dark Bodies , when they come between us and the Sun ; nay , they must be more thin than our Clouds , which will easily be seen between us and the Sun , and hides it from us .
3 .
If it be because they are so little , that the Imperfection of our Glasses cannot discover one alone , there must be , without doubt , many Millions of them ; which how they can be included within the compass of 1/ 10 of the ~ Semidiameter , we shall consider anon .
I have seen one of an ordinary darkness , ( yea darker than many greater ) yet not above 5~ Diameter .
If this consist of two , or many , of themselves invisible , how many were in those which Gassendus saw of 1~ Diameter ? ?
4 .
The Figure of these great ones ( being necessarily composed of Stars of such different Orbs and Motions ) would quickly vary , by reason of the diversity of their Motions ; like as we see in a Flock of small Birds .
But 5thly , you say the furthest of these Orbs is not above 1/ 10 of the Suns Semidiameter from its Circumference .
But there would not , in that small space , be room enough for so many Orbs of Planets , as have been seen at once .
Which I prove thus .
1 .
Gassendus affirms there are sometimes some of about the 1/ 10 part of the ~ Semidiameter ; which the whole space allowed by you for them all .
And I my self have seen of ~ of the ~ Semidiameter : And yet you must confess these great ones could only be the Conjunctions of some , not all .
2 .
There are many times seen in the ~ Superficies , a great number of Spots , whose Diameters added together , would do more than twice fill the space you speak of .
I my self have seen it , and so I believe have you .
Gassendus affirms , there are sometimes 40 seen at once : If this was by Conjunction of Planets , in every Appearance , there was at least 80 Bodies at once on this side the ~ ; it may be as many on the other side , besides those unseen ( by your Reflection or otherwise ) which doubtless must be far more than seen .
For it is a most rare , and I think unheard of thing to see but 3 ( which is less than the half ) of our Planets , conjoined in visible ~ at once : So that without question , if they be Planets , they are many hundreds ; which must have so many several Orbs , and which certainly cannot be done in so narrow a compass , as the 1/ 10 of the ~ Semidiameter .
And that they cannot have any larger ( I suppose not so large an ) extent from the ~ Superficies , may be proved by their motion through the visible Hemisphere of the Suns Spherical Body , by comparing the swiftness of their motion towards the middle and sides together .
6 .
If one of these ( imagined ) Planets be swifter than another , as they must needs be , then the ~ of 2 or 3 swifter ones would make a Spot of speedier motion than the ~ of 2 slower ones : But the motion of all about the ~ Center , is always equal ; yea , and the Spots retain the same Position one to another , ( considering the Suns Sphericity , and the Angle of their appearance to us ) just like the Fixed-Stars .
So affirms Gassendus , Moveri omnes eodem &amp; uniformi motu , adea ut , cum plures fuerint , nulla antevertat aliam , sed eunU u ` ` dem dem tenorem in disco ~ perinde servant inter se , ~ Servant Fixae in firmamento .
As for that other annual Motion of the Spots , you speak of , from West to East , upon their Axis inclined above 8 Degrees to the Ecliptic ; I suppose it is not any real Motion of the Orbs of those Solar Planets or Spots , but only a visible Motion so appearing , caused ( in Kepler 's Systeme ) by the Suns rolling upon its own Center in the midst of all the Orbs , not exactly in the way of the Temporary Ecliptic , but in the Via regia ( as Kepler calls it ) inclined certain Degrees to the Temporary ; thereby turning about with him , the same way , his Adventitious , or Excrementitious Parts , the Spots , by his Magnetical or Sympathetical Rays .
And hence may be demonstrated the appearance of that Annual Motion in the Suns Spots you speak of .
See Galilaeus , Syst. Cosm .
p. 339 , &amp; seq. So also in Ptolemie 's and Tycho 's Systeme , the same Ap. pearance may be demonstrated , supposing the ~ fixed in the middle of the Universe , and the ~ rolling round upon the same Poles of that Via regia ( or way of the Spots ) and keeping his Axis in Parallelism continually towards one and the same Part of the Universe .
This may be certainly demonstrated , altho ' Galilaeus there affirms the contrary .
Other Hypotheses of that Motion may be feigned , as by the annual conversion of the Poles of the Via regia about the Poles of the Ecliptic in the Suns Body : But none I conceive so compendious , as the one of the former .
For my part , I incline to the first : Yet if when we see you , you show us any more likely Theory , for my part I shall be ready to consent to you in any thing with reason .
Thus you have , what for the present , I conceive of these Maculae Solares .
Fromundus mentions one Jo. Tarde Gallus , who thinks them to be Secondary Planets ; who hath written a Book of that Subject , and calls them Astra Borbonia : But I could never yet see it .
What you , or he , or others may allege for that Opinion , I know not .
In the mean time it were too much levity in me , against my Judgment , to acknowledge them Stars ; unless I see at least some possibility how they may be so , or some probability why they should not rather be Spots .
Which when you , or they do produce from better grounded Reasons , Optical Experiments , or Demonstrations , I shall willingly recant my Opinion .
In the mean time , let me encourage you to proceed in your noble Optical Speculations .
I do believe there are as rare Inventions as Galilaeus Telescope , yet undiscovered .
My living in a place void of apt Materials for that purpose , makes me almost Ignorant in those Secrets ; only what I have from Reason , or the reading of Kepler 's Astron. Opt .
and Galilaeus .
If you impart unto us any of your Optical Secrets , we shall be thankful , and obliged to you , and ready to requite you in any thing we can .
It is true which you say , That I found Venus Diameter much less than any Theory extant made it .
Kepler came nearest , yet makes her Diameter 5 times too much .
Tycho , Lansberge , and the Ancients , about 10 times greater than it was .
So also they differ in the time of the ~ as far from the truth .
By Lansberg the ~ should have been 16th 31~ before we observed it : By Tycho and Longomontane 1d 8h 25~ before .
By Kepler ( who is still nearest the truth ) 9h 46~ before .
So that had not our own Observations , and Study , taught us a better Theory than any of these , we had never attended a that time for that rare Spectacle .
You shall have the Observation of it , when we see you .
The Clouds deprived me of part of the Observation , but my Friend and second Self Mr. Jeremiah Horrox , being near Preston , observed it clearly from the time of its coming into the Sun , till the Sun 's setting ; and both our Observations agreed , both in the Time and Diameter , most precisely .
If I can , I will bring him along with Mr. Towneley and my self , to see Yorkshire , and you .
You shai ' also then have my Observation of the Sun 's last Eclipse here in Broughton , Mr. Horrox 's between Liverpoole and Preston , and Mr. Foster 's at London .
Langsberg in Eclipses , especially of the ~ , comes often nearer the truth than Kepler , yet it is by packing together Errors ; his Diameters of the ~ and ~ being false , and his variation of the Shadow being quite repugnant to Geometrical Demonstration .
His circular Hypotheses Mr. Horrox ( before I could persuade him ) assayed a long time with indefatigable Pains , and Study , to correct , and amend ; changing and turning them every way ( still amazed and amused with those lofty Titles of Perpetuity and Perfection , so impudently imposed upon them ) until we found , by comparing Observations in several places of the Orbs , that his Hypotheses would never agree with the Heavens for all times , as he confidently boasts ; no , nor scarce for any one whole Year together , alter the equal Motion , Prosthaphaereses , and Excentricity howsoever you will .
Kepler 's Elliptic is undoubtedly the way which the Planets describe in their Motions : And if you have read his Comment .
de motu ~is , and his Epit .
Astron. Copern .
I doubt not you will say his Theory is the most rational , demonstrative , harmonious , simple , and natural that is yet thought of , ( or I suppose can be ; ) all those superfluous Fictions being rejected by him , which others are forced so absurdly to introduce .
And although in some respects his Tables be deficient , yet being once corrected by due Observations , they hold true in the rest : Which is that argument of Truth , which Lansberge 's and all others want .
Your conceit of turning the Circle into 100,000,000 Parts , were an excellent one , if it had been set on foot , when Astronomy was first invented .
Mr. Horrox and I have often conferred about it .
But in respect that all Astronomy is already in a quite different form , and the tediousness of reducing the Tables of Sines , Tangents , and all other things we should have occasion to use , into that form ; as also some Inconveniences which we foresaw would follow in the composing the Tables of Celestial Motions , together with the greatness of the Innovation , deterred us from the conceit .
Only we intend to use the Centesmes or Millesmes of Degrees , because of the ease in Calculation .
I have turned the Rudolphine-Tables into Degrees and Millesmes , and altered them into a far more concise , ready , and easy form , than they are done by Kepler .
My Occasions force me to put an abrupt End to my unpolished Lines , and without more Compliments , to tell you plainly , but sincerely , I am Your Loving Friend , From my House in Broughton near ( though de facie ignotus ) Manchester , this 7 .
August 1640 .
WILLIAMCRABTRI E. The Superscription of this Letter is , To his Loving~ Friend Mr. William Gascoigne , at his Fathers House in or near Leeds in Yorkshire .
This with most of the Letters between Mr. Crabtrie and Mr. Gascoigne , together with other very valuable Papers of Mr. Horrox , Mr. Towneley himself , Mr. Collins , Mr. Shuse , and other great Men , were imparted unto me , the last Month , by the great favour of Charles Towneley Esq ; Son of the late most Ingenious Rich .
Townley Esq ; of Lancashire .
And forasmuch as every thing of Mr. Crabtrie 's is valuable , I have taken this occasion from my own Observations of the Solar Spots ( for the most part drawn up near 4 Years ago ) to give Mr. Crabtrie 's Letter at large , containing as well some things of another Nature , as what relates to the Spots ; not doubting but the one will be acceptable to the Curious , as well as the other .
I have two other of his Letters concerning the Spots ( with Mr. Gascoigne 's Answers .
) One contains his Theory of their Motion and Appearances ; the other his way of observing them .
But being long , I have not time at present to fit them up for the Societies Use ; but intend ( God willing ) to do it as soon as may be , if this Specimen be acceptable .
N. B. Tab. II .
Fig. I. Shows the Stages and Lines described by the Spots upon the Sun in Sept. and November .
1706 .
and in Feb. and March , 1706/ 7 .
and in Sept. and November .
1707 .
Fig. II .
Shows the Stages and Lines described by the Spots upon the Sun in Jan. 1703/ 4 .
and in May , June , and Octob. 1705 .
The other Figures in this Table are explained in the foregoing Discourse .

