Philosoph. Transact. No.346 Fig. V. bbbbbbb Fig. I. AA ccccc Fig. VI .
d d d d ddd A Scale of Inches 123456 E Fig. VII .
Fig. II .
E s s Fig. III G G ~ 67899 1/ 2 Fig. IIII k HH V. Remarks upon the aforesaid Letter and Teeth , by Thomas Molyneux , M. D. and R. S. S. Physician to the State in Ireland : Addressed to his Grace the Lord Archbishop of Dublin .
MYLOR D , WHEN your Grace was pleased to communicate to me a Letter you received some while since , containing an Account of an extraordinary Natural Curiosity , lately discovered in the North of Ireland , in the County of Cavan , you desired I would give you my Thoughts concerning it , and the Purport of the Letter : but truly when first your Grace gave me the Opportunity of perusing this Account , and I considerd the Imperfect Sketches of the Teeth annexed to it , I was not a little concerned , that upon the making so surprising a Discovery , I could not command a Sight of the Originals themselves , from whence the Draughts were taken ; or that so great a Curiosity should be expressed by the Hand of an Artist that showed so little Skill : however , by the best Judgment I could make from so imperfect an Information , I told your Grace then , I was pretty well convinced they must have been the Grinding Teeth of an Elephant : Yet I engaged , if hereafter I might be so lucky as to procure a View of the Teeth themselves , I would be more positive in my Opinion , and give the Reasons on which I groun ded my Conjecture ; as likewise I would have the Shape of the Teeth expressed in their full Dimensions , by more true and exact Figures .
Since that , the four Teeth , with some of the Fragments of the Bones that were found with them , have been brought here to Dublin , where , by the Favour and Assistance of my ingenious Friend Sir Thomas Southwell , I procured the Loan of them , so long as to examine them particularly , make some Remarks , and take the following correct Sketches , that express their Form truly , just as big as the Life ; and your Lordship seemed well satisfied with the Performance of the Artist , when at the same time I produced the Draughts and the Originals from whence they were copied , that we might compare them both together .
Upon the whole , I am now fully convinced , and I can upon sure Grounds affirm to your Lordship , that they must certainly have been the Four Grinding Teeth in the lower Jaw of an Elephant : and that the many loose Fragments of those large Bones that were found with them , must have been Remains of the same Animal .
This I take to be one of the greatest Rarities that has been yet discovered in this Country .
In order to clear this Matter 'twill be first requisite to have recourse to , and explain the annexed Figures Figure the 1st .
AA is the large Grinder of the under Jaw on the right Side , weighing two Pounds and three Quarters of a Pound .
b. b. b. b. b. b. b. are white , rough , indented Borders , Seven in Number , of an irregular Shape , rising about the tenth of an Inch higher than the hard black shining Surface of the Tooth ; this rough raised Work serves for the bruising and grinding the Animal 's Food , the tough Grains of Rize , Leaves , Fruits and the Boughs of Trees ; and is made of so extreme an hard Texture , that it resembles large knotted Threads of white Glass , laid on and closely fastned to the dark Superficies of the Tooth : and answers that glassy Surface wherewith Nature has armed the Outside of the Teeth of most Animals , to prevent their wearing from the constant Attrition in Chewing of their Foods .
c. c. c. c. c. is that part of the Tooth which rises above the Gumms , and continues even now distinguished from the rest of the Bone , by having its Colour of a different Shade .
d. d. d. d. d. d. d. are many strong Tangs or Roots , seemingly united altogether , by which the Tooth received its Sense and Nourishment , and tho ' it was so large and ponderous , by these it kept firmly fixed into the Jaw .
For the Mechanism Nature shows it self to have followed in framing the Teeth of this Animal , is no more than this : whereas in other Creatures , she has divided that bony Substance wherewith they chew their Food , each having its peculiar Roots to secure its Articulation in the Jawbone : she has in this of so great Bulk ( As Pliny the Naturalist stiles it Terrestrium maximum Elephas , ) for the greater Strength , Stabiliment , and Duration of it 's Teeth , and the better to provide for a complete Attrition of the Aliment , in order to perfect the Digestion so thoroughly , as to sustain the Life of the Animal for two or three hundred Years , ( as it is a common received Opinion in the East ) She has , I say , contrived to make the Substance of the Teeth in their Roots below , and in their upper per parts above the Gumms , closely unite together ; and coalescing thus , form a few large massy Teeth instead of many small ones .
As for instance , in Man 's Body , that is of so much a less Size , the Number of the Teeth , ( when the whole Set is complete ) reckons to thirty two , whereas in the large Elephant , the Teeth of both the Jaws amount in all but to Eight , besides it 's two great Tusks , which rather serve as Horns for its defence than Teeth to prepare it 's Food , and therefore I think not so very properly called Teeth .
Figure the 2d .
E. E. is the smaller Grinding Tooth of the under Jaw on the same side : it 's Surface covered over with the same white indented Work , as before describe d for grinding of the Food .
f. f. f. are three large Roots that kept it firmly fixed in the Jaw Bone .
This smaller Tooth weighed full six Ounces .
Figure the 3d G. G. is the large Grinder of the under Jaw on the left side , much of the Size and Shape and Weight with it 's fellow Tooth described Figure the 1 st. It shows its Roots and all its parts , with the rough protuberant white Work on its upper Surface made after the same Contrivance , and formed after the same strong Model as the former .
And truly if one considers it , it is plain that were not the Teeth of this Creature made of so large a Size , and withal of so massy and firm a Substance , 'twere absolutely impossible they could resist the Force , and bear all that Pressure wherewith those vast Muscles exert themselves , that move the lower Jaw in Mastication in this so strong an Animal .
Figure the 4th .
H. H. is the smaller Grinding Tooth of the under Jaw on the same side ; it is less complete than the small Tooth described before in Figure 2d or some of the Root is wanting , and part of its outward grinding Surface is broke off at k. k. so that it weighs somewhat less ; yet what remains exactly shows the same kind of Work and Shape of the other Tooth , that answered it on the right Side .
These Four Teeth here described , fully complete the Set of the Teeth , wherewith Nature has furnished the lower Jaw of the Elephant ; and are answered by just as many more , formed after the same manner in the upper Jaw , as Dr. Moulins informs us , who dissected the Elephant that was burnt here at Dublin in 1681 .
In it 's Anatomy p. 40 .
speaking of the Teeth he assures , there were besides the Tusks only four Teeth in each Jaw , two in every side : and that these eight Teeth were all Molares , so that he had no Incisores .
But notwithstanding this , perhaps it will be said , we may not hastily conclude from hence , that our Great Teeth dug up in Ireland must certainly have been the Four Grinders of an Elephant , since they might as well belong to some other large kind of Terrestrial or Marine Animal .
As for the Hint of their being human or gigantic , it is so groundless a Thought , and so contradictory to comparative Anatomy and all Natural History , it does not deserve our Consideration .
To obviate this , I shall take notice first in general , that the differing Kinds of living Creatures , wherewith Nature has stocked the World , are not more distinguished by the Make of any part of their Bodies from one another than by the various Shape and Disposition of their Teeth : and hence it is , we shall not find any two distinct Classes of Animals that do exactly agree in the same Make and Ranging of their Teeth .
But yet to be more particular , and make this Point so plain , I hope , as that it may admit of no Controversy , I shall here set down at length , as I find them .
the Words of two late Authors , that purposely have described the Teeth of the Elephant .
The first I shall mention is Mr. Patrick Blair , who has published a Treatise he calls Osteographia Elephantina , or a Description of the Bones and other Parts of an Elephant , that died and was dissected near Dundee in Scotland , anno 1706 .
in the London Philosophical Transactions for April , May , June , July , August and September , 1710 .
Numb. 3 .
6 .
and 327 .
Here giving us a Description of the Teeth of this Animal page .
110 .
he says , Dr. Moulins well observes that they are all Molares , being two Inches broad in that part of them wherewith they grind , and six Inches and a half long on the Right Side , and five Inches and a half on the Left : Their Surface , tho ' flat , is yet very unequal , for they have alternately placed , running from the Bight to the Left Side , an Hollowness and then an Eminence ; and this Eminence ~ surrounded by a rough protuberant Border .
There are Nine of these Hollownesses and as many Eminences , undulated as they paint Sea Waves , It is remarkable how very exactly all this agrees with our Figures ; it is true those Hollownesses and Eminences which he mentions to be Nine , do not so nicely hit with the Number of those in our Teeth : but this Difference proceeds from hence , that he-describes here the Grinders of the upper , whereas ours are the Teeth of the lower Jaw ; tho ' such a Distinction as this , I am apt to think , may very well arise even in those of the same Jaw , in various Animals , from some peculiar Disposition in one from another , nay and perhaps in the same Animal , at differing times , according as it happens to be older or younger , but this by the bye .
A little farther page .
114 .
and 115 .
where he gives an Account of those of the under Jaw , he says .
The hind Tooth of the Right Side is four Inches , and that on the Left five : the one half of their Surface , where they begin gin to appear above the Gumms , is semicircular , with the forementioned Ridges and Sulci running transversly , four on the Right Side and five on the Left , the other half ( or Tooth I suppose he means ) has five of these Eminences where it grinds on the Right , and four on the Left : each of the four Teeth is six Inches long , and has six or seven of the forementioned Eminences and as many Depressions : these Teeth are the most firm , solid and weighty Bones of any Animal yet known .
So much from Mr. Blair .
The other Author I shall produce for the further Illustration of this Matter , is the laborious and accurate Naturalist Mr. Ray , who , in his Synopsis Animalium Quadrupedum , when he comes to give us the Description of the Elephant , has the following Words .
Os pro mole Belluae parvum , quatuor in utraque maxilla Dentibus molaribus seu Dentium molarium Massis instructum ; si quidem plurimi Dentes in Os solidum &amp; durum ita infixi sunt , ut cum eo &amp; inter se unum &amp; continuum Corpus efficiant .
Dentes hi lineas parallelas undulatas octo vel novem in superficie massae efficiunt ; suntque reliquo osse candidiores : Massae integrae , Dentium singularium modo , per Gomphosin maxillis inseruntur .
Incisoribus omnino caret .
Thus Mr. Ray in very proper and expressive Terms describes the Teeth of this Animal : and truly if your Grace will but compare Mr. Blair 's Words with his , and the Particulars of both Accounts with the Description and Figures we have before given of the Teeth dug up in Ireland , and observe how they all agree exactly , even so as one may say they tally together , I think it will amount to nothing less than Demonstration , and that all our Ideas have been taken from one and the same Natural Object ; and as they , so we , must certainly have described no other Teeth but those of the Elephant .
But then perhaps it will be asked what is become of all the rest of the Teeth that were in the upper Jaw , which being as firm and solid Bones as those that are here preserved , might for the same reason have still remained entire .
But since we find it otherwise , it is obvious to imagine a probable Conjecture how this might come about .
From what Mr. Nevil mentions in his Letter , it is plain that the Bed where all these Bones were found , must once have been the outward Surface of the Earth , the Green-Sod , producing Rushes , Fern and Nuts : and when the heavy Beast first fell dead upon this Spot , the Scull , with all the Bones and Teeth of the upper Jaw , being the highest Parts of the Animal , might likely fall in such a Posture , as to be exposed some while above the Earth ; tho ' those of the under Jaw first coming to the Ground , might make themselves a Bed , and being covered with the Mould remain preserved , whilst the upper Teeth , and most of the other Bones , lying exposed to the Injuries of the Air and Weather , before they got a Covering , might rot and quickly moulder all away .
But tho ' this be allowed , yet still a greater Difficulty remains unsolv 'd ; how this large Body 'd Animal , a Native of the remote warm Climates of the World , should be deposited in this wild Northern Island , ( where Greeks or Romans never had a footing ) so many Miles from Sea , and distant from those Places of the Isle where People might most probably resort .
And still to make the Difficulty yet greater , we must consider , not only from the dark black Colour of the Teeth , contracted by their lying long under Ground , and the remarkable Alteration wrought on their bony Substance , which ( by the mineral Streams and Exhalations it has imbibed whilst it was in the Earth ) is now become more solid , hard , and ponderous , than it was naturally at first , ( nay in some Parts we find it plainly petrified ) but also from the perishing of all the other Bones of the Animal 's Body , and from the considerable Depth of Earth that covered those that were found : we must conclude , I say , from hence , that they have lain in this Place for many Centuries : I wo n't say with Mr. Nevil ever since the Flood , because I ca n't suppose that the slight Texture of vegetable Substances , Nuts and the Seeds of Rushes , could possibly have been preserved so long : But this , at least , may safely be affirmed , that these Remains must be Cotemporaries with some of the remote Ages of the World ; which carries us so far back into the earliest Times , that we can ne'er imagine the rude Inhabitants of Ireland , or any of their neighbouring Countries , were Masters of so much Art , in those Days of Ignorance and Darkness , as to make Carriages by Sea strong and capable or of Curiosity and Politeness enough , to transport a Beast of this large Size from those far distant Countries where it was bred ; which they that now attempt do find a Work of vast Care , Trouble and Expense , even in this Age wherein Navigation is brought to such perfection .
These Considerations , my Lord , grounded on other Instances of the like kind , make me inclined to think this Elephant we are speaking of , might not be brought hither by any Care or Industry of Man : but the Surface of this Terraqueous Globe might , in the earliest Ages of the World , after the Deluge , but before all Records of our oldest Histories , differ widely from its present Geography , as to the Distribution of the Ocean and Dry-land , its Islands , Continents and Shores , so as to allow this Beast , and others of its Kind , for ought I know , that may by some such Accident hereafter be luckily discovered , a free and open Passage into this Country from the Continent .
For otherwise , how can we ever explain that that other vast large stately Animal the Moose-Deer , little inferior to the Elephant it self , could have been brought to Ireland , ( where elsewhere I have shown it formerly was common ) from distant North America , even long before that Quarter ter of the World was known , and is the only Region I can hear , where this great Beast is found at present .
And can we well Imagine that Foxes , Otters , Badgers , Tigers , Wolves , with Linxes and such ravenous Animals as we have been told , have lately been discovered by the great Snows that fell this present Winter in the Island of Sardinia and other Places , should ever be imported ( being useless noxious Beasts of Prey ) by the Industry of Man , to propagate in Islands , that they might destroy Men 's Food and Flocks , and make their Lives not only uneasy but unsafe ?
Nay how can we suppose that Birds of shortest Flight , the various Sorts of poisonous Serpents , and of offensive Creeping Vermin , with all the various Tribes of smaller Insects , could possibly be found in Islands , unless they had been stocked with those Inhabitants when the Intercourse between them and the Continent was free and open .
But in whatever manner this Elephant ( to return to our Subject ) might first have made its way for Ireland ; this is beyond dispute , that the Bones of Elephants have been discovered deep under Ground , in other Places as well as this Kingdom : and those too out of the way , far distant from the Native Countries of this Animal .
For not many Years ago , in a Hill near Erfurt , a Town of the Upper Saxony in Germany , several Parts of the Skeleton of an Elephant were Dug up : on which Occasion Wilhelmus Ernestus Tentzelius Historiographer to the Duke of Saxony,.writ a Letter to the very learned Antonio Magliabechi , Library Keeper to the great Duke of Florence : This Treatise is published , but I have not been so lucky as to procure a Sight of it , and know no more but just the Title-page Wilhelmi Ernesti Tentzelii Historiographi Ducalis Saxoniae Epistola , de Sceleto Elephantino Tonnae nuper effosso , ad Antonium Magliabechium , Magni Ducis Hetruriae Bibliothecarium .
And I am well persuaded , by the best Construction I can make of those imperfect and obscure Accounts , we have in Evert Isbrand Iddes curious Travels from Muscovy to China over Land ; Chap. the 6th , ( which he confesses he only gathered from the barbarous Ostiacks Inhabitants of that Country ) concerning the vast Teeth and Bones and Limbs of mammuths-as he calls them , frequently found ( and diligently sought after to make profit of them ) in the Hills , and Banks of several Rivers in Siberia , the Keta , Jenize , Trugan , Montgamsea and Lena ; that they are nothing else but the Remains and Skeletons of Elephants buried there , and accidentally discovered by the Earth 's opening , and falling down on the sudden Thaws , after severe long Frosts .
Bu of this , please to consult the Author , whose Words are too prolix to be inserted here .
But to bring this Matter still nearer home to our selves , Mr. Cambden in his Britannia is of opinion , that those great monstrous Teeth and Bones , which he takes notice to have been at several times dug up in many parts of Great Britain , must have been the Remains of Elephants ; but then he thinks , they must be of those that Dion Cassius the Historian tells us , the Roman Emperor Claudius brought over , when he made his Expedition into that Island .
But that this truly is so , I own is but Surmise as yet , and has not been so fairly proved by him or any other , as that we can rely upon it with satisfaction .
What Mr. William Somner the learned Antiquary has published in his Discourse of Chartham News is more remarkable ; ( this is reprinted lately in the Philosophical Transactions for July 1701 .
No. 272 .
) where he informs us , that in the Year 1668 in the Village of Chartham near Canterbury in England , digging within 12 Rods of a River , they found a Parcels of strange monstrous Bones , some whole , some broken , together with four Teeth perfect and sound , each weighing something above half a Pound , and some of them almost most as big as a Man 's Fist .
They are all Cheek-Teeth or Grinders ; the Earth in which they lay being like a Sea Earth , or Fulling Earth with not a Stone in it .
It is observable how this Account in many of it 's Circumstances , agrees with that of Mr Nevil in his Letter to your Grace : as that the Teeth were all Grinders , Four in number , found with other large broken Bones near a Brook , and in a Claiey Earth , without a Stone : but then the weight and Magnitude of our largest Teeth so far surpass those that were found in England , that these did not come up to a fifth Part of those , which shows they could not be the Teeth of the same Animal .
I must confess the Author does not so much as suspect they were Elephant 's Teeth , but on the contrary is of opinion that they belonged to another Species , the Hippopotamus or River-Horse , a Beast that 's yet a greater Stranger in these Parts of the World , than the Elephant it self ; and therefore it 's Passage hither can never be accounted for , but by some such like Supposition as we have made .
However Mr. John Luffkins in his Letter , wherein he designs to have reference to that Discourse ; and which is inserted in the Philosophical Transactions for Sept. 1701 .
No. 274 differs in his Judgments from Mr. Somners about these Teeth , which he thinks must have been Elephant 's Teeth ; as he is positive those large Bones he describes in the same Letter , and found near Harwich in Essex , certainly must have been .
Not having seen , much less examined , any of the Bones or Teeth concerned in this Controversy ; either those that were found in Kent , or those in Essex ; I cannot well take upon me to determine any thing in this matter ; tho ' those dug up at Chartham , as I understand , may still be perused by the Curious among the Natural Rarities of the Royal Society in their Repository at London .
But this at present I can safely say , that if the Figures of the Teeth given us by Mr. Somner , and represented in the Plate of the foremention 'd Transaction No. 272 .
be genuine and well expressed ( as I have no reason to doubt , as coming from one so skilful and so accurate ) they no way seem to agree either in Shape or Make , or in that particular and Characteristic Work on the grinding Superficies , with the Teeth of the Elephant ; or with the Description and Figures we have given , which I am sure are both correct and natural .
I should now , my Lord , make some Apology for detaining your Grace so long upon what may seem so light and trivial a Subject , a Piece of mere Curiosity : but I am so vain as to hope , whatever others may fancy , it may not appear so inconsiderable altogether to your Lordship 's more discerning Judgment .
For I am inclined to think , ( even from these Imperfect Hints ) that if we had more correct Histories and Observations of this kind , made in distant Countries , and skilfully registered , with all their instructive Circumstances , they might lead us into great and momentous Truths relating to the Deluge ; to the wise Methods of Providence , in replenishing all Regions of the World with Animal Beings soon after the Flood ; and to the Knowledge of several important Changes that may have happened on the Surface of this our Terraqueous Globe : Inquiries that are truly worthy the utmost Application of the most learned Divine and the most sagacious Philosopher .
But I shall stop here , and only beg leave to subscribe my self , with the utmost Respect .
My LOR D , Your Graces most devoted faithful and humble Servant .
T. MOLYNEU X. This Letter of Mr. Nevile with Dr. Molineux 's curious Draughts of the Teeth , and his learned Remarks upon them , having been produced and read before the Royal Society , they ordered that what Teeth they had of like sort should be looked out and laid before them ; to which Sir Hans Sloane was pleased to furnish a yet greater Variety , out of his incomparable Collection of Natural Rarities .
And to obviate all Doubts , there being at this time in Westminster the entire Skull of a large Elephant with the Teeth in it , That was likewise ordered to be viewed and compared with the Figures : which done , it appeared that the Teeth in question could be no other than those of an Elephant .
By this Enquiry we were likewise satisfied , that the Number of Teeth sound , being but four , was no Objection : it appearing that the Number of Molares in this Animals is not certain .
Pliny Lib. XI .
Cap , 37 .
says expressly Dentes Elephanto intus ad mandendum quatuor , praeter eos qui prominent .
And in the Remains of that mighty Elephant described by Tenzelius .
Phil. Trans. No. 236 .
there were no more than four Teeth found .
In that at Westminster there are Six , viz. One in each lower Jaw , and Two in each of the Upper , whereof the in~ ner Tooth is about three times as long as the other , and both together longer than those of the under Jaw by about an Inch ; the upper small Teeth being much worn by grinding .
These we have thought fit to represent by Fig. 5 .
showing the rough grinding Surface of the left under Tooth , being considerably Concave ; and by Fig. 6 .
the same Roughness on the upper Teeth is shown , having a Convexity tallying with the Concavity of the under , which is a Circumstance not observed by any of those that have described them .
And altho , by the Observation of Mr. Du Verney , Dr. Moulins , and Mr. Blaire , who dissected three different Elephants , it appear that each of them had eight Molares : yet from them it is also evident that in the division of them Nature observes no Rule , For Dr. Moulins found the two Teeth in each of the upper Jaws of that dissected dissected , to be divided ded after a different manner ; so that the inner Tooth on the one side , and the outer on the other , was bigger than its adjoining Fellow , yet not so as to be very unequal : and Mr. Du Verney and Mr. Blaire had on both sides the much greater Tooth outwards : whereas the Westminster-Skull , on the contrary , has only a small one outwards , and the much greater Grinder within .
All which considered , we may with Assurance conclude , that this Elephant found in Ireland had but four Teeth in his Head when he died ; and that the two Greater were those of the upper Jaws , and the other two those of the Under .
Again , by the Size of the grinding Part , we may conclude these to be the Teeth of a very young and small Elephant ; since they are not much above half the Length of those that are to be seen at Westminster , which belonged to a Beast of not more than between 10 and 11 Foot high ; nor much above one Third of the Length of a fossile Elephant 's Grinder in the Royal Society 's Repository , the which is here represented by Fig. 7 .
( all the Figures being drawn to the Scale of half their true Dimensions ) .
Hence it is not to be marvelled that the Bones of so young an Animal , having not acquired their Firmity , as being in a growing State , should be dissolved by long lying in the Earth , as also the Roots of the Teeth .
On this Occasion , perhaps it may not be amiss to quote a Passage out of Matthew Paris his History , who assures us , that in his Time Louis IX .
( afterwards St. Louis ) King of France , made a Present of an Elephant to his Cotemporary Henry III .
of England ; and that in the Year 1255 , after the English had been fourscore ~ Masters of Ireland .
Of this says Matthew , Nec credimus quod unquam aliquis Elephas visus est in Anglia praeter illum .

