II .
An Account of the Book entitled Commercium Epistolicum Collinii &amp; aliorum , De Analysi promota ; published by order of the Royal-Society , in relation to the Dispute between Mr. Leibnitz and Dr. Keill , about the Right of Invention of the Method of Fluxions , by some called the Differential Method .
SEveral Accounts having been published abroad of this Commercium , all of them very imperfect : It has been thought fit to publish the Account which follows .
This Commercium is composed of several ancient Letters and Papers , put together in order of Time , and either copied or translated into Latin from such Originals as are described in the Title of every Letter and Paper ; a numerous Committee of the Royal-Society being appointed to examine the Sincerity of the Originals , and compare therewith the Copies taken from them .
It relates to a general Method of resolving finite Equations into infinite ones , and applying these Equations , both finite and infinite , to the Solution of Problems by the Method of Fluxions and Moments .
We will first give an Account of that Part of the Method which consists in resolving finite Equations into infinite ones , and squaring curvilinear Figures thereby .
By Infinite Equations are meant such as involve a Series of Terms converging or approaching the Truth nearer and nearer in infinitum , so as at length to differ from the Truth less than by any given Quantity , and if continued in infinitum , to leave no Difference .
Dt .
Wallis in his Opus Arithmeticum published A. C. 1657 : Cap. 33 .
Prop. 68 .
reduced the Fraction A/ 1 R by perpetual Division into the Series A+ ARE + AR2 + AR3 + AR4 + &amp;c. Viscount Brounker squared the Hyperbola by this serieo 1/ 1 x 2+1/ 3 x 4+1/ 5 x 6+1/ 7 x 8+ &amp;c. that is by this , 1 1/ 2 +~ 1/ 4 + 1/ 5 1/ ~ + 1/ 7 1/ 8 + &amp;c. conjoining every two Terms into one , And the Quadrature was published in the Philosophical Transactions for April 1668 .
Mr. Mercator soon after published a Demonstration of this Quadrature by the Division of Dr. Wallis ; and soon after that Mr. James Gregory published a Geometrical Demonstration thereof .
And these Books were a few Months after sent by Mr. John Collins to Dr. Barrow at Cambridge , and by Dr. Barrow communicated to Mr. Newton ( now Sir Isaac Newton ) in June 1669 .
Whereupon Dr Barrow mutually sent to Mr. Collins a Tract of Mr. Newton 's entitled Analysis per aequationes numero terminorum infinitas .
And this is the first Piece published in the Commercium , and contains a general Method of doing in all Figures , what my Lord ~ and Mr. Mercator did in the Hyperbola alone .
Mr. Mercator lived above ten Years longer without proceeding further than to the single Quadrature of the Hyperbola .
The progress made by Mr. Newton shows that he wanted not Mr. Mercator 's Assistance .
However , for avoiding Disputes , he supposes that my Lord Brounker invented , and Mr. Mercator demonstrated , the Series for the Hyperbola some Years before they published it , and , by consequence , before he found his general Method .
The aforesaid Treatise of Analysis Mr. Newton , in his Letter to Mr. Oldenburgh , dated Octob. 24 .
1676 .
mentions in the following Manner .
Eo ipso tempore quo Mercatoris Logarithmotechnia prodiit , communicatum est per amicum D. Barrow ( tunc Matheseos Professorem Cantab ) cum D. Collinio Compendium quoddam harum Serierum , in quo significaveram Areas &amp; Longitudines Curvarum omnium , &amp; Solidorum superficies &amp; contenta ex datis rectis ; &amp; vice versa ex his datis rectas determinari posse : &amp; methodum indicatam illustraveram diversis seriebus .
Mr. Collins in the Years 1669 , 1670 , 1671 and 1672 gave notice of this Compendium to Mr James Gregory in Scotland , Mr. Bertet and Mr. Vernon then at Paris , Mr. Alphonsus Borelli in Italy , and Mr. Strode , Mr. Townsend , Mr. Oldenburgh , Mr. Dary and others in England , as appears by his Letters .
And Mr. Oldenburg in a Letter , dated Sept. 14 .
1669 .
and entered in the Letter-Book of the Royal-Society , gave notice of it to Mr. Francis Slusius at Liege , and cited several Sentences out of it .
And particularly Mr. Collins in a Letter to Mr. James Gregory dated November .
25 .
1669 .
spake thus of the Method contained in it .
Barrovius Provinciam suam public praelegendi remisit cuidam nomine Newtono Cantabrigiensi , cujus tanquam viri acutissimo ingenio praediti in praefatione Praelectionum Opticarum , meminit : quippe antequam ederetur Mercatoris Logarithmotechnia , eandem methodum adinvenerat , eamque ad om~ Curvas generaliter &amp; ad Circulum diversimode applicarat .
And in a Letter to Mr. David Gregory dated August 11 .
1676 .
he mentions it in this manner .
Paucos post menses quam editi sunt hi Libri [ viz. Mercatoris Logarithmotechnia &amp; Exercitationes Geometricae Gregorii ] missi sunt ad Barrovium Cantabrigiae .
Ille autem responsum dedit hanc infinitarum Serierum Doctrinam a Newtono biennium ante excogitatam fuisse quam ~ Mercatoris Logarithmotechnia &amp; generaliter omnibus figuris applicatam , simulque transmisit D. Newtoni opus manuscriptum .
The last of the said two Books came out towards the End of the Year 1668 , and Dr. Barrow sent the said Compendium to Mr. Collins in July following , as appears by three of Dr. Barrow 's Letters .
And in a Letter to Mr. Strode , dated July 26 .
1672 , Mr. Collins wrote thus of it .
Exemplar ejus [ Logarithmotechniae ] misi Barrovio Cantabrigiam , qui quasdam Newtoni chartas extemplo remisit : E quibus &amp; aliis quae prius ab authore cum Barrovio communicata fuerant , patet illam methodum a dicto Newtono aliquot annis antea ~ &amp; modo univerF f2 sali sali applicatam fuisse : Ita ut ejus ope , in quavis Figura Curvilinea proposita , quae una vel pluribus proprictatibus definitur , Quadratura vel Area dictae figurae , accurata si possibile sit , sin minus infinite vero propinqua , Evolutio vel longitudo ~ Curvae , Centrum gravitatis figurae , Solida ejus rotatione genita &amp; ~ ~ ; sine ulla radicum extraction obtineri queant .
Postquam intellexerat D. Gregorius hanc methodum a D. Mercatore in Logarithmotechnia ~~ &amp; Hyperbolae ~ adhibitam , quamque adauxerat ipse Gregorius jam universalem redditam esse , omnibusque figuris applicatam ; acri studio eandem acquisivit multumque in ea enodanda desudavit .
Uterque D. Newtonus &amp; Gregorius in animo ~ hanc methodum exornare : D. Gregorius autem D. Newtonum primum ejus inventorem anticipare haud integrum ducit .
And in another Letter written to Mr. Oldenburgh to be communicated to Mr Leibnitz , and dated June 14 1676 .
Mr. Collins adds : Hujus autem methodi ea est praestantia ut cum tam late pateat ad nullam haereat difficulatem .
Gregorium autem aliosque in ea fuisse opinione arbitror , ut quicquid uspiam antea de hac re innotuit , quasi dubia diluculi lux fuit si cum meridiana claritate conferatur .
This Tract was first printed by Mr William Jones , being found by him among the Papers and in the Hand-writing of Mr. John Collins , and collated with the Original which he afterwards borrowed of Mr. Newton .
It contains the above-mention 'd general Method of Analysis , teaching how to resolve finite Equations into infinite ones , and how by the method of Moments to apply Equations both finite and infinite to the Solution of all Problems It begins where Dr. Wallis left off , and founds the method of Quadratures upon three Rules .
Dr. Wallis published his Arithmetica infinitorum in the Year 1655 , and by the 59th Proposition of that Book , if the Abscissa of any curvilinear Figure be called x , and m and n be Numbers , and the Ordinates erected at right Angles be x m/ n , the Area of the Figure shall be n/ m+n x m+n/ n. And this is assumed by Mr. Newton as the first Rule upon which he founds his Quadrature of Curves .
Dr. Wallis demonstrated this Proposition by Steps in many particular Propositions , and then collected all the Propositions into One by a Table of the Cases .
Mr. Newton reduced all the Cases into One , by a Dignity with an indefinite Index , and at the End of his Compendium demonstrated it at once by his method of Moments , he being the first who introduced indefinite Indices of Dignities into the Operations of Analysis .
By the 108th Proposition of the said Arithmetica Infinitorum , and by several other Propositions which follow it ; if the Ordinate be composed of two or more Ordinates taken with their Signs + and - , the Area shall be composed of two or more Areas taken with their Signs + and respectively .
And this is assumed by Mr. Newton as the second Rule upon which he founds his Method of Quadratures .
And the third Rule is to reduce Fractions and Radicals , and the affected Roots of Equations into converging Series , when the Quadrature does not otherwise succeed ; and by the first and second Rules to square the Figures , whose Ordinates are the single Terms of the Series .
Mr Newton , in his Letter to Mr. Oldenburgh dated June 13 .
1676 .
and communicated to Mr Leibnitz , taught how to reduce any Dignity of any Binominal into a converging Series , and how by that Series to square the Curve , whose Ordinate is that Dignity .
And being desired by Mr. Leibnitz to explain the Original of this Theoreme , he replied in his Letter dated Octob. 24 .
1676 , that a little before the Plague ( which raged in London in the Year 1665 ) upon reading the Arithmetica Infinitorum of Dr. Wallis , and considering how to interpole the Series x , x 1/ 3 x3 , x 2/ 3 x3 + 1/ 5 x5 , x 3/ 5 x3+ 3/ 5 x5 1/ 7 x7 , &amp;c. he found the Area of a Circle to be x 1/ 2x3/ 3 1/ 8 x5/ 5 1/ 16x7/ 7 5/ 128 x9/ 9 &amp;c. And by pursuing the Method of InterpolatiG g3 on on he found the Theoreme abovemention 'd , and by means of this Theoreme he found the Reduction of Fractions and Surds into converging Series , by Division and Extraction of Roots ; and then proceeded to the Extraction of affected Roots .
And these Reductions are his third Rule .
When Mr. Newton had in this Compendium explained these three Rules , and illustrated them with various Examples , he laid down the Idea of deducing the Area from the Ordinate , by considering the Area as a Quantity , growing or increasing by continual Flux , in proportion to the Length of the Ordinate , supposing the Abscissa to increase uniformly in proportion to Time And from the Moments of Time he gave the Name of Moments to the momentaneous Increases , or infinitely small Parts of the Abscissa and Area , generated in Moments of Time .
The Moment of a Line he called a Point , in the Sense of Cavallerius , tho ' it be not a geometrical Point , but a Line infinitely short , and the Moment of an Area or Superficies he called a Line , in the Sense of Cavallerius , tho ' it be not a geometrical Line , but a Superficies infinitely narrow .
And when he considered the Ordinate as the Moment of the Area , he understood by it the Rectangles under the geometrical Ordinate and a Moment of the Abscissa , tho ' that Moment be not always expressed .
Sit AB D , saith he , ~ quaevis , &amp; AHKB rectangulum cujus latus AH vel KB est unitas .
Et cogita rectam DBK uniformiter ab AH motam areas ABD &amp; AK describere ; &amp; quod [ recta ] BK ( 1 ) sit momentum quo [ area ] AK ( x ) , &amp; [ recta ] BD ( y ) momentum quo [ area curvilinea ] ABD gradatim augetur ; &amp; quod ex momento BD perpetim dato possis , per praecedentes [ tres ] Regulas , aream ABD ipso descriptam investigate , sive cum area AK ( x ) momento 1 descripta confer .
This is his Idea of the Work in squaring of Curves , and how he applies this to other Problems , he expresses in the next Words .
Jam qua ratione , saith he , superficies ABD ex momento suo perD B A K H petim dato per praecedentes [ tres ] Regulas elicitur , eadem qualibet alia quantitas ex momento suo sic dato elicietur .
Exemplo res fiet clarior .
And after some Examples he adds his Method of Regression from the Area , Arc , or solid Content , to the Abscissa ; and shows how the same Method extends to Mechanical ~ , for determining their Ordinates , Tangents , Areas , Lengths , &amp;c. And that by assuming any Equation expressing the Relation between the Area and Abscissa of a Curve , you may find the Ordinate by this Method .
And this is the Foundation of the Method of Fluxions and Moments , which Mr. Newton in his Letter dated Octob. 24 , 1676 comprehended in this Sentence .
Data aequatione quotcunque fluentes quantitates involvente , invenire Fluxiones ; &amp; vice versa .
In this Compendium Mr. Newton represents the uniform Fluxion of Time , or of any Exponent of Time by an Unit ; the Moment of Time or of its Exponent by the Letter ~ ; the Fluxions of other Quantities by any other Symbols ; the Moments of those Quantities by the Rectangles under those Symbols and the Letter o ; and the Area of a Curve by the Ordinate enclosed in a Square , the Area being put for a Fluent and the Ordinate for its Fluxion .
When he is demonstrating anyProposition he uses the Letter o for a finite Moment of Time , or of its Exponent , or of any Quantity flowing uniformly , and performs the whole Calculation by the Geometry of the Ancients in finite Figures or Schemes without any Approximation : and so soon as the Calculation is at an End , and the Equation is reduced , he supposes that the Moment o decreases in infinitum and vanishes .
But when he is not demonstrating but only investigating a Proposition , for making Dispatch he supposes the Moment o to be infinitely little , and forbears to write it down , and uses all manner of Approximations which he conceives will produce no Error in the conclusion .
An Example of the first kind you have in the End of this Compendium , in demonstrating the first of the three Rules laid down in the Beginning of the Book .
Examples of the second kind you have in the same Compendium , in finding the Length of Curve Lines p. 15 .
and in finding the Ordinates , Areas and Lengths of Mechanical Curves p. 18 .
19 .
And he tells you , that by the same Method , Tangents may be drawn to mechanical Curves p. 19 .
And in his Letter of Decemb. 10 1672 .
he adds , that Problems about the Curvature of Curves Geometrical or Mechanical are resolved by the same Method .
Whence its manifest , that he had then extended the Method to the second and third Moments .
For when the Areas of Curves are considered as Fluents ( as is usual in this Analysis ) the Ordinates express the first Fluxions , the Tangents are given by the second Fluxions , and the Curvatures by the third , And even in this Analysis p. 16 .
where Mr. Newton saith , Momentum est superficies cum de solidis , &amp; Linea cum de superficiebus , &amp; Punctum cum de lineis agitur , it is all one as if he had said , that when Solids are considered as Fluents , their Moments are Superficies , and the Moments of those Moments ( or second Moments ) are Lines , and the Moments of those Moments ( or third Moments ) are Points , in the Sense of Cavallerius .
And in his Principia Philosophiae , where he frequently considers Lines as Fluents described by Points , whose Velocities increase or decrease , the Velocities are the first Fluxions , and their Increase the second .
And the Problem , Data aequatione fluentes quantitates involvente fluxiones invenire &amp; vice versa , extends to all the Fluxions , as is manifest by the Examples of the Solution thereof , published by Dr. Wallis Tom. 2 .
p 391 , 392 , 396 .
And in Lib. II .
Princip .
Prop. XIV .
he calls the second Difference the Difference of Moments .
Now that you may know what kind of Calculation Mr. Newton used in , or before the Year 1669 .
when he wrote this Compendium of his Analysis , I will here set down his Demonstration of the first Rule abovementioned .
Sit Sit Curvae alicujus AD~ Basis AB~ = x , perpendiculariter applicata BDHK = y , &amp; area ABD= z , ut prius .
Item D sit B~= o , BK= v , &amp; Rectangulum B~HK ( o v ) aequale spatio B~~ D. Est ergo A~=x+ o , &amp; A~~=z+o v , His praemissis , ex ~BA relatione inter x &amp; z ad arbitrium assumpta , quaero y ut sequitur .
Pro lubitu sumatur [ aequatio ] 2/ 3 x 3/ 2 = z , sive 4/ 9 x3 =z z. Tum x+o ( A ~ ) pro x , &amp; z+ov ( A ~ ~ ) pro z substitutis , prodibit 4/ 9 in x3 +3 x2 o+3x o2 + o3 = ( ex natura curvae ) z2 + +2 zov+ o2 v2 .
Et sublatis 4/ 9 x3 &amp; zz aequalibus , reliquisque per o divisis , restat 4/ 9 in 3 x2 +3xo+ o2 =2zv+o v2 .
Si jam supponamus B~ in infinitum diminui &amp; evanescere , sive o esse nihil , erunt v~y aequales , &amp; termini per o multiplicati evanescent ; ideoque restabit 4/ 9 x3xx=2z v , sive 2/ 3 xx ( = z y ) = 2/ 3 x3/ 2 y , sive x1/ 2 ( = x2/ x3/ 2 ) = y. Quare e contra , si x1/ 2 = y , erit 2/ 3 x3/ 2 = z. Vel generaliter , Si n/ m +nxaxm+ n/ n = z ; sive ponendo n a/ m +n = c , &amp; m+n= p , Si cx p/ n = z , sive cn xp = zn : Tum x+o pro x , &amp; z+ov sive ( quod perinde est ) z+oy pro z substitutis , prodit cn in xp +po xp-1 &amp;c. = zn +noy zn-1 &amp;c. reliquis nempe [ Serierum ] terminis , qui tandem evanescerent , omissis .
Jam sublatis cnxp &amp; zn aequalibus , reliquisque per o divisis , restat cn p xp-1 =ny zn-1 ( = ny zn/ z =ny cn xp/ c xp/ n ) sive dividendo per cnxp , erit p x-~ =n y/ c xp/ n sive pcx p-n/ n =n y ; vel restituendo n a/ m+n pro c &amp; m+n pro p , hoc est m pro p n , &amp; na pro p c , fiet a xm/ n=y .
Quare e contra , si axm/ n =y erit n/ m +naxm+ n/ n =z Q. E. D. By the same way of working the second Rule may be also demonstrated .
And if any Equation whatever be assumed expressing the Relation between the Abscissa and Area of a Curve , the Ordinate may be found in the same manner , as is mentioned in the next Words of the Analysis .
And if this Ordinate drawn into an Unit be put for the Area of a new Curve , the Ordinate of this new Curve may be found by the same Method : And so on perpetually .
And these Ordinates represent the first , second , third , fourth and following Fluxions of the first Area .
This was Mr. Newton 's Way of working in those Days , when he wrote this Compendium of his Analysis .
And the same Way of working he used in his Book of Quadratures , and still uses to this Day .
Among the Examples with which he illustrates the Method of Series and Moments set down in this Compendium , are these .
Let the Radius of a Circle be 1 , and the Arc z , and the Sine x , the Equations for finding the Arc whose Sine is given , and the Sine whose Arc is given , will be z=x+ 1/ 6x3 + 3/ 40x5 + 5/ 112x7 + 35/ 1152x9 + &amp;c. x=z 1/ 6z3 + 1/ 120z5 1/ 5040z7 + 1/ 362880z9 &amp;c. Mr. Collins gave Mr. Gregory notice of this Method in Autumn 1669 , and Mr. Gregory , by the Help of one of Mr. Newton 's Series , after a Year 's Study , found the Method in December 1670 ; and two Months after , in a Letter dated Feb. 15 .
1671 .
sent several Theorems , found thereby , to Mr. Collins , with leave to communicate them freely .
And Mr. Collins was very free in communicating what he had received both from Mr. Newton and from Mr. Gregory , as appears by his Letters printed in the Commercium .
Amongst the Series which Mr Gregory sent in the said Letter , were these two .
Let the Radius of a Circle be r , the Arc a , and the Tangent t , the Equations for finding the Arc whose Tangent is given , and the Tangent whose Arc is given , will be these .
a=t t3/ 3r2 + t5/ 5r4 t7/ 7r5 + t9/ 9r8 &amp;c. t=a+ a~/ 3r2 + ~/ 15r4 + 17a7/ 315r6 + 62a9/ 2835r8 + &amp;c. In this Year ( 1671 ) Mr. Leibnitz published two Tracts at London , the One dedicated to the Royal-Society , the Other dedicated to the Academy of Sciences at Paris ; and in the Dedication of the First he mentioned his Correspondence with Mr. Oldenburgh .
In February 167 2/ 3 meeting Dr. Pell at Mr. Boyle 's , he pretended to the differential Method of Mouton .
And notwithstanding that he was shown by Dr. Pell that it was Mouton 's Method , he persisted in maintaining it to be his own Invention , by reason that he had found it himself without knowing what Mouton had done before , and had much improved it .
When one of Mr. Newton 's Series was sent to Mr. Gregory , he tried to deduce it from his own Series combined together , as he mentions in his Letter dated December 19 .
1670 .
And by some such Method Mr Leibnitz , before he left London , seems to have found the Sum of a Series of Fractions decreasing in infinitum , whose Numerator is a given Number and Denominators are triangular or pyramidal or triangulo-triangular Numbers , &amp;c. See the Mystery !
From the Series 1/ 1 + 1/ 2 + 1/ 3 + + 1/ 4 + 1/ 5 + &amp;c. subduct all the Terms but the first ( viz 1/ 2 + 1/ 3 + 1/ 4 + 1/ 5 &amp; c ) and there will remain 1=1 1/ 2 + 1/ 2 1/ 3 + 1/ 3 1/ 4 + 1/ 4 1/ 5 + 1/ 5 &amp; c ) = 1/ 1 x2+ 1/ 2 x3+ 1/ 3 x4+ 1/ 4 x5+ &amp;c. And from this Series take all the Terms but the first , and there will remain 1/ 2 = 2/ 1 x2x3+ 2/ 2 x3x4+ 2/ 3 x4x5+ 2/ 4 x5x6+ &amp;c. And from the first Series take all the Terms but the two first , and there will remain 3/ 2 = 2/ 1 x3+ 2/ 2 x4+ 2/ 3 x5+ 2/ 4 x6+ &amp;c. In the End of February or beginning of March 1672/ 3 .
Mr. Leibnitz went from London to Paris , and continuing his Correspondence with Mr Oldenburg and Mr. Collin , wrote in July 1674 .
that he had a wonderful Theoreme , which gave the Area of a Circle or any Sector thereof exactly in a Series of rational Numbers ; and in October following , that he had found the Circumference of a Circle in a Series of very simple Numbers , and that by the same Method ( so he calls the said Theoreme ) any Arc whose Sine was given might be found in a like Series , though the Proportion to the whole Circumference be not known His Theoreme therefore was for finding any Sector or Arc whose Sine was given .
If the Proportion of the Arc to the whole Circumference was not known , the Theoreme or Method gave him only the Arc ; if it was known it gave him also the whole Circumference : and therefore it was the first of Mr. Newton 's two Theoremes above-mention 'd .
But the Demonstration of this Theoreme Mr Leibnitz wanted .
For in his Letter of May 12 .
1676 .
he desired Mr. Oldenburgh to procure the Demonstration from Mr Collins , meaning the Method by which Mr. Newton had invented it .
In a Letter composed by Mr. Collins and dated April 15 .
1675 .
Mr. Oldenburgh sent to Mr. Leibnitz Eight of Mr. Newton 's and Mr. Gregory 's Series , amongst which were Mr. Newton 's two Series above mentioned for finding the Arc whose Sine is given , and the Sine whose Arc is given ; and Mr. Gregory 's two Series above mentioned for finding the Arc whose Tangent is given , and the Tangent whose Arc is given .
And Mr. Leibnitz in his Answer , dated May 20 .
1675.acknowledged the Receipt of this Letter in these Words .
Literas tuas multa fruge Algebraica refertas accepi , pro quibus tibi &amp; doctissimo Collinio gratias ago .
Cum nunc praeter ordinarias curas Mechanicis imprimis negotiis distrahar , non potui examinare Series quas misistis ac cum meis comparare .
Ubi fecero perscribam tibi sententiam meam : nam aliquot jam anni sunt quod inveni meas via quadam sic satis singulari .
But But yet Mr. Leibnitz never took any further notice of his having received these Series , nor how his own differed from them , nor ever produced any other Series then those which he received from Mr Oldenburgh , or numeral Series deduced from them in particular Cases .
And what he did with Mr. Gregory 's Series for finding the Arc whose Tangent is given , he has told us in the Acta Eruditorum mensis Aprilis 1691 .
page .
178 .
Jam anno 1675 , saith he , compositum habebam opusculum Quadraturae Arithmeticae ab amicis ab illo tempore lectum , &amp;c. By a Theoreme for transmuting of Figures , like those of Dr. Barrow and Mr. Gregory , he had now found a Demonstration of this Series , and this was the Subject of his Opusculum .
But he still wanted a Demonstration of the rest : and meeting with a Pretence to ask for what he wanted , he wrote to Mr. Oldenburg the following Letter , dated at Paris May 12 .
1676 .
Cum Georgius Mohr Danus nobis attulerit communicatam sibi a Doctissimo Collinio vestro expressionem rationis inter arcum &amp; sinum per infinitas Series sequentes ; posito sinu x , arcu z , radio 1 , z=x+ 1/ 6x3 + 3/ 40x5 + 5/ 112x7 + 35/ 1152x9 + &amp;c. x=z 1/ 6z3 + 1/ 120z5 1/ 5040z7 + 1/ 362880z9 &amp;c. Haec , INQUA M , cum nobis attulerit ille , quae mihi valde ingeniosa videntur , &amp; posterior imprimis Series elegantiam quandam singularem habeat : ideo rem gratam mihi feceris , Vir clarissime , si demonstrationem transmiseris .
Habebis vicissim mea ab his longe diversa circa hanc rem meditata , de quibus jam aliquot abhinc annis ad te perscripsisse credo , demonstratione tamen non addita , quam nunc polio .
Oro ut Clarissimo Collinio multam a me salutem dicas : is facile tibi materiam suppeditabit satisfaciendi ~ meo .
Here , by the Word INQUA M , one would think that he had never seen these two Series before , and that his diversa circa hanc rem meditata were something else than one of the Series which he had received from Mr. Oldenburgh the Year before , and a Demonstration thereof which he was now polishing , to make the Present an acceptable Recompense for Mr. Newton 's Method .
Upon the Receipt of this Letter Mr. Oldenburg and Mr. Collins wrote pressingly to Mr. Newton , desiring that he himself would describe his own Method , to be communicated to Mr. Leibnitz .
Whereupon Mr. Newton wrote his Letter , dated June 13 .
1676 , describing therein the Method of Series , as he had done before in the Compendium above-mentioned ; but with this Difference : Here he described at large the Reduction of the Dignity of a Binomial into a Series , and only touched upon the Reduction by Division and Extraction of affected Roots : There he described at large the Reduction of Fractions and Radicals into Series by Division and Extraction of Roots , and only set down the two first Terms of the Series into which the Dignity of a Binomial might be reduced .
And among the Examples in this Letter , there were Series for finding the Number whose Logarithm is given , and for finding the Versed Sine whose Arc is given : This Letter was sent to Paris , June 26 .
1676 .
together with a MS .
drawn up by Mr. Collins , containing Extracts of Mr. James Gregory 's Letters .
For Mr. Gregory died near the End of the Year 1675 ; and Mr. Collins , at the Request of Mr Leibnitz and some other of the Academy of Sciences , drew up Extracts of his Letters , and the Collection is still extant in the Hand Writing of Mr. Collins with this Title ; Extracts of Mr. Gregory 's Letters , to be lent to Mr. Leibnitz to peruse , who is desired to return the same to you .
And that they were sent is affirmed by Mr. Collins in his Letter to Mr. David Gregory the Brother of the ~ , dated August 11 .
1676 .
and appears further by the Answers of Mr. ~ and Mr. Tschurnhause concerning them .
The Answer of Mr. Leibnitz directed to Mr Oldenburgh and dated August 27 .
1676 , begins thus ; Literae tuae die Julii 26 .
datae plura ac memorabiliora circa rem Analyticam continent quam 2 multa multa volumina spissa de his rebus edita .
Quare tibi pariter ac clarissimis viris Newtono ac Collinio gratias ago , qui nos participes tot meditationum egregiarum esse voluistis .
And towards the End of the Letter , after he had done with the Contents of Mr Newton 's Letter , he proceeds thus .
Ad alia tuarum Literarum venio quae doctissimus Collinius communicare gravatus non est .
Vellem adjecisset appropinquationis Gregorianae linearis demonstrationem .
Fuit enim his certe studiis promovendis aptissimus .
And the Answer of Mr. Tschurnhause , dated Sept. 1 .
1676 , after he had done with Mr. Newton 's Letter about Series , concludes thus .
Similia porro quae in hac re praestitit eximius ille Geometra Gregorius memoranda certe sunt .
Et quidem optime samae ipsius consulturi , qui ipsius relicta Manuscripta luci publicae ut exponantur operam navabunt .
In the first Part of this Letter , where Mr. Tschurnhause speaks of Mr. Newton 's Series , he saith that he looked over them cursorily , to see if he could find the Series of Mr. Leibnitz for squaring the Circle of Hyperbola .
If he had searched for it in the Extracts of Gregory 's Letters he might have found it in the Letter of Febr. 15 .
1671 .
abovementioned .
For the MS .
of those Extracts with that Letter therein is still extant in the Hand-Writing of Mr. Collins .
And tho ' Mr. Leibnitz had now received this Series twice from Mr. Oldenburgh , yet in his Letter of August.27 .
1676 .
he sent it back to him by way of Recompense for Mr. Newton 's Method , pretending that he had communicated it to his Friends at Paris three Years before or above ; that is , two Years before he received it in Mr. Oldenburgh 's Letter of April 15 1675 ; at which Time he did not know it to be his own , as appears by his Answer of May 20 1675 above-mentioned .
He might receive this Series at London , and communicate it to his Friends at Paris above three Years before he sent it back to Mr. Oldenburg : but it doth not appear that he had the Demonstration thereof so early .
When he found the Demonstration , then he composed it in his Opusculum , and communicated that also to his Friends ; and he himself has told us that this was in the Year 1675 .
However , it lies upon him to prove that he had this Series before he received it from Mr. Oldenburgh .
For in his Answer to Mr. Oldenburgh he did not know any of the Series then sent him to be his own ; and concealed from the Gentlemen at Paris his having received it from Mr. Oldenburgh with several other Series , and his having seen a Copy of the Letter in which Mr. Gregory had sent it to Mr. Collins in the Beginning of the Year 1671 .
In the same Letter of August 27 .
1676 , after Mr. Leibnitz had described his Quadrature of the Circle and Equilateral Hyperbola , he added : Vicissim ex seriebus regressuum pro Hyperbola hanc inveni .
Si sit numerus aliquis unitate minor 1 m , ejusque logarithmus Hyperbolicus 1 .
Erit m= 1/ 1-1~/ 1x2+13/ 1x2x3 -.14/ 1x2x~x4+ &amp;c. Si numerus sit major unitate , ut 1+n , tunc pro co inveniendo mihi etiam prodiit Regula quae in Newtoni Epistola expressa est : scilicet n= 1/ 1+12/ 1x2+13/ 1x~x3+14/ 1x2x3x4 + &amp;c. Quod regressum ex arcubus attinet , incideram ego direct in Regulam quae ex dato arcu sinum complementi exhibet .
Nempe sinus complementi =1 a2/ 1x2+a4/ 1x2x3x4 &amp;c. Sed postea quoque deprehendi ex ea illam nobis communicatam pro inveniendo sinu recto , qui est a/ 1 a3/ 1x~x3+a~/ 1x2x3x4x5 - &amp;c. posse demonstrari .
Thus Mr. Leibnitz put in his Claim for the Co-invention of these four Series , tho ' the Method of finding them was sent him at his own Request , and he did not yet understand it .
For in this same Letter of August 27 1676 .
he desired Mr. Newton to explain it further .
His Words are .
Sed desideraverim ut Clarissimus Newtonus nonnulla quoque amplius explicet ; ut originem Theorematis quod initio ponit : Item modum quo quantitates p , q , r , in suis Operationibus invenit : Ac denique quomodo in Methodo regressuum se gerat , ut cum ex Logarithmo quaerit Numerum .
Neque enim explicat quomodo id ex methodo sua derivetur .
He pretended to have found two Series for theNumber whose Logarithm was given , and yet in the same Letter desired sired Mr. Newton to explain to him the Method of finding those very two Series .
When Mr. Newton had received this Letter , he wrote back that all the said four Series had been communicated by him to Mr. Leibnitz ; the two first being one and the same Series in which the Letter ~ was put for the Logarithm with its Sign + or - ; and the third being the Excess of the Radius above the versed Sine , for which a Series had been sent to him .
Whereupon Mr. Leibnitz desisted from his Claim .
Mr. Newton also in the same Letter dated Octob. 24 .
1676 .
further explained his Methods of Regression , as Mr. Leibnitz had desired .
And Mr. Leibnitz in his Letter of June 21 .
1677 .
desired a further Explication : but soon after , upon reading Mr. Newton 's Letter a second time , wrote back July 12 .
1677 .
that he now understood what he wanted ; and found by his old Papers that he had formerly used one of Mr. Newton 's Methods of Regression , but in the Example which he had then by chance made use of , there being produced nothing elegant , he had , out of his usual Impatience , neglected to use it any further .
He had therefore several direct Series , and by consequence a Method of finding them , before he invented and forgot the inverse Method .
And if he had searched his old Papers diligently , he might have found this Method also there ; but having forgot his own Methods he wrote for Mr. Newton 's .
When Mr. Newton in his Letter dated June 13 .
1676 .
had explained his Method of Series , he added : Ex his videre est quantum fines Analyseos per hujusmodi infinitas aequationes ampliantur : quippe quae earum beneficio ad omnia pene dixerim problemata ( si numeralia Diophanti &amp; similia excipias ) sese extendit .
Non tamen omnino universalis evadit , nisi per ulteriores quasdam Methodos ~ Series infinitas .
Sunt enim quaedam Problemata in quibus non licet ad Series infinitas per Divisionem vel Extractionem radicum simplicium affectarumve pervenire .
Sed quomodo in istis casibus procedendum sit jam non vacat dicere ; ut neque alia quaedam tradere , quae cirea Reductionem infinitarum Serierum in finitas , ubi rei natura natura tulerit , excogitavi .
Nam parcius scribo , quod hae speculationes diu mihi fastidio esse caeperunt ; adeo ut ab ~ jam per quinque fere annos abstinuerim .
To this Mr. Leibnitz in his Letter of August 27 .
676 .
answered : Quod dicere videmini plerasque difficultates ( exceptis Problematibus Diophantaeis ) ad series Infinitas reduci ; id mihi non videtur .
Sunt enim multa usque adeo mira &amp; implexa ut neque ab aequationibus pendeant neque ex Quadraturis .
Qualia sunt ( ex multis aliis ) Problemata methodi Tangentium inversae .
And Mr. Newton in his Letter of Octob. 24 .
1676 , replied : Ubi dixi omnia pene Problemata solubilia existere ; volui de tis praesertim intelligi circa quae Mathematici se hactenus occuparunt vel saltem in quibus Ratiocinia Mathematica locum aliquem obtinere possunt .
Nam alia sane adeo perplexis conditionibus implicata excogitare liceat , ut non satis comprehendere valeamus : &amp; multo minus tantarum computationum ~ sustinere quod ista requirerent .
Attamen no nimium dixisse videar , inversa de Tangentibus Problemata sunt in potestate , aliaque illis difficiliora .
Ad quae solvenda usus sum duplici methodo , una concinniori , alterageneraliori .
Utramque visum est impraesentia literis transpositis consignare , no propter alios idem obtinentes , institutum in aliquibus mutare cogerer .
5a cc d ae 10 e ff h , &amp;c. id est , Una methodus consist it ~ extraction fluentis quantitatis ex aequatione simul involvente fluxionem ejus altera tantum in assumptione ~ pro quantitate qualibet incognita , ex qua caetera commode derivari possunt ; &amp; in collatione terminorum homologorum aequationis resultantis ad eruendos terminos assumptae seriei .
By Mr. Newton 's two Letters , its certain that he had then ( or rather above five Years before ) found out the Reduction of Problems to fluxional Equations and converging Series : and by the Answer of Mr. Leibnitz to the first of those Letters , its as certain that he had not then found out the Reduction of Problems either to differential Equations or to converging Series .
And the same is manifest also by what Mr. Leibnitz wrote in the Acta Eruditorum , Anno 1691 , concerning this Matter .
Jam anno 1675 , saith he , compositum habebam opusculum Quadraturae Arithmeticae ab amicis ab illo tempore lectum , sed quod , materia sub manibus crescente , limare ad Editionem non vacavit , postquam aliae occupationes supervenere ; praesertim cum nunc prolixius exponere vulgari more quae Analysis nostra paucis exhibet , non satis operae pretium videatur .
This Quadrature composed vulgari more he began to communicate at Paris in the Year 1675 .
The next Year he was polishing the Demonstration thereof , to send it to Mr. Oldenburgh in Recompense for Mr. Newton 's Method , as he wrote to him May 12 .
1676 ; and accordingly in his Letter of August 27 .
1676 .
he sent it composed and polished vulgari more .
The Winter following he returned into Germany , by England and Holland , to enter upon public Business , and had no longer any Leisure to fit it for the Press , nor thought it afterwards worth his while to explain those Things prolixly in the vulgar manner which his new Analysis exhibited in short .
He found out this new Analysis therefore after his Return into Germany , and by consequence not before the Year 1677 .
The same is further manifest by the following Consideration Dr. Barrow published his Method of Tangents in the Year 1670 .
Mr. Newton in his Letter dated December 10 .
1672 .
communicated his Method of Tangents to Mr. Collins , and added : Hoc est unum particular vel Corollarium potius Methodi generalis , quae extendit se citra molestum ullum calculum , non modo ad ducendum Tangentes ad quasvis Curvas sive Geometricas sive Mechanicas , vel quomodocunque rectas Lineas aliasve Curvas respicientes ; verum etiam ad resolvendum alia abstrusiora Problematum genera de Curvitatibus , Areis , Longitudinibus , Centris Gravitatis Curvarum , &amp;c. Neque ( quemadmodum Huddenii methodus de Maximis &amp; Minimis ) ad solas restringitur aequationes illas , quae quantitatibus surdis sunt immunes .
Hanc methodum intertexui alteri isti qua AEquationum Exegesin instituo , reducendo eas ad series infinitas .
Mr. Slusius sent his Method of Tangents to Mr. Oldenburgh Jan. 17 .
1672/ 3 , and the same was soon after published in the Transactions .
It proved to be the same with that of Mr Newton .
It was founded upon three Lemmas , the first of which was this , Differentia duarum dignitatum ejusdem gradus applicata ad differentiam laterum dat parts singulares gradus inferioris ex binomio laterum , ut y3 x3/ y x=yy +yx+x x , that is , in the Notation of Mr. Leibnitz d y3/ d y= =3y y. A Copy of Mr. Newton 's Letter of Decemb. 10 .
1672 was sent to Mr. Leibnitz by Mr Oldenburg amongst the Papers of Mr James Gregory , at the same time with Mr. Newton 's Letter of June 13 .
1676 .
And Mr. Newton having described in these two Letters that he had a very general Analysis , consisting partly of the Method of converging Series , partly of another Method , by which he applied those Series to the Solution of almost all Problems ( except perhaps some numeral ones like those of Diophantus ) and found the Tangents , Areas , Lengths , solid Contents , Centers of Gravity , and Curvities of Curves , and curvilinear Figures Geometrical or Mechanical , without sticking at Surds ; and that the Method of Tangents of Slusius was but a Branch or Corollary of this other Method : Mr. Leibnitz in his returning Home through Holland , was meditating upon the Improvement of the Method of slusius .
For in a Letter to Mr. Oldenburgh , dated from Amsterdam Nov~x 18/ 28 1676 , he wrote thus Methodus Tangentium a Slusio publicata nondum rei fastigium tenet .
Potest aliquid amplius praestari in eo genere quod maximi foret usus ad omnis generis Problemata : etiam ad meam ( sine extractionibus ) AEquationum ad series reductionem .
Nimirum posset brevis quaedam calculari circa Tangentes Tabula , eousque continuanda donec progressio Tabulae apparet ; ut eam scillcet quisque quousque libuerit sine calculo continuare possit .
This was the Improvement of the Method of Slusius into a general Method , which Mr. Leibnitz was then thinking upon , and by his Words , Potest aliquid amplius praestari in eo genere quod maximi foret usus ad omnis generis Problemata , it seems to be the only Improvement which he had then in his Mind for extending the Method to all sorts of Problems .
The Improvement by the differential Calculus was not yet in his Mind , but must be referred to the next Year .
Mr. Newton in his next Letter , dated Octob. 24 .
1676 , mentioned the Analysis communicated by Dr. Barrow to Mr. Collins in the Year 1669 , and also another Tract written in 1671 .
about converging Series , and about the other Method by which Tangents were drawn after the Method of Slusius , and Maxima and Minima were determined , and the Quadrature of Curves was made more easy , and this without sticking at Radicals , and by which Series were invented which brake off and gave the Quadrature of Curves in finite Equations when it might be .
And the Foundation of these Operations he comprehended in this Sentence expressed enigmatically as above .
Data aequatione fluentes quotcunque quantitates involvente fluxiones invenire , &amp; vice versa .
Which puts it past all Dispute that he had invented the Method of Fluxions before that time .
And if other things in that Letter be considered , it will appear that he had then brought it to great Perfection , and made it exceeding general ; the Propositi-a ons in his Book of Quadratures , and the Methods of converging Series and of drawing a Curve Line through any Number of given Points , being then known to him .
For when the Method of Fluxions proceeds not in finite Equations , he reduces the Equations into converging Series by the binomial Theoreme , and by the Extraction of Fluents out of Equations involving or not involving their Fluxions .
And when finite Equations are wanting , he deduces converging Series from the Conditions of the Problem , by assuming the Terms of the Series gradually , and determining them by those Conditions .
And when Fluents are to be derived from Fluxions , and the Law of the Fluxions is wanting , he finds that Law quam proxime , by drawing a Parabolick Line through any Number of given Points .
And by these Improvements Mr. Newton had in those Days made his Method of Fluxions much more universal than the Differential Method of Mr. Leibnitz is at present .
This Letter of Mr. Newton 's , dated Octob. 24 .
1676 , came to theHands of Mr. Leibnitz in the End of the Winter or Beginning of the Spring following ; and Mr. Leibnitz soon after , viz. in a Letter dated June 21 .
1677 , wrote back : Clarissiml Slusii methodum ~ nondum esse absolutam Celeberrimo Newtono assentior .
Et jam a multo tempore rem Tangentium generalius tractavi , scilicet per differentias Ordinatarum .
Hinc nominando , in posterum , die differentiam duarum proximarum y &amp;c. Here Mr. Leibnitz began first to propose his Differential Method , and there is not the least Evidence that he knew it before the Receipt of Mr. Newton 's last Letter .
He saith indeed , Jam a multo tempore rem Tangentium generalius tractavi , scilicet per differentias Ordinatarum : and so he affirmed in other Letters , that he had invented several converging Series direct and inverse before he had the Method of inventing them ; and had forgot an inverse Method of Series before he knew what use to make of it .
But no Man is a Witness in his own Cause .
A Judge would be very unjust , and act contrary to the Laws of all Nations , who should admit any Man to be a Witness in his own Cause .
And therefore it lies upon Mr. Leibnitz to prove that he found out this Method long before the Receipt of Mr. Newton 's Letters .
And if lie cannot prove this , the Question , Who was the first Inventor of the Method , is decided .
The Marquess De l ' Hospital ( a Person of very great Candour ) in the Preface to his Book De Analysi quantitatum infinite ` parvarum , published A. C. 1696 .
tells us , that a little after ` the Publication of the Method of Tangents of Des Cartes , ` Mr. ~ found also a Method , which Des Cartes himself ` at length allowed to be , for the most part , more simple than ` his own .
But it was not yet so simple as Mr. Barrow after ` wards made it , by considering more nearly the nature of Po ` lygons , which offers naturally to the Mind a little Triangle , ` composed of a Particle of the Curve lying between two Or ` dinates infinitely near one another , and of the Difference of ` these two Ordinates , and of that of the two correspondent ` Abscissa 's .
And this Triangle is like that which ought to be ` made by the Tangent , the Ordinate , and the Sub~tangent : ` so that by one simple Analogy , this last Method saves all ` the Calculation which was requisite either in the Method of ` Des Cartes , or in this same Method before .
Mr. Barrow ` stopped not here , he invented also a sort of Calculation proper ` for this Method .
But it was necessary in this as well as in ` that of Des Cartes , to take away Fractions and Radicals for ` making it useful .
Upon the Defect of this Calculus , that of ` the celebrated Mr. Leibnitz was introduced , and this learned ` Geometer began where Mr. Barrow and others left off .
This ` his Calculus led into Regions hitherto unknown , and there ` made Discoveries which astonished the most able Mathema ` ticians of Europe , ' &amp;c. Thus far the Marquess .
He had not seen Mr. Newton 's Analysis , nor his Letters of Decem .
10 .
1672 .
June 13 .
1676 , and Octob. 24 .
1676 : and so not knowing that Mr. Newton had done all this and signified it to Mr. Leibnitz , he reckoned that Mr. Leibnitz began where Mr. Barrow left off , and by teaching how to apply Mr. Barrow 's Method without sticking at Fractions and Surds , had enlarged the Method wonderfully .
And Mr. James Bernoulli , in the Acta Eruditorum of January 1691 page .
14 .
writes thus : Qui calculum Barrovianum ( quem in Lectionibus suis Geometricis adumbravit Auctor , cujusque Specimina sunt tota illa Propositionum inibi contentarum farrago , ) intellexerit , [ calculum ] alterum a Domino Leibnitio inventum , ignorare vix poterit ; utpote qui in priori illo fundatus est , &amp; nisi forte in Differentialium notatione &amp; operationis aliquo compendio ab eo non differt .
Now Dr. Barrow , in his Method of Tangents , draws two Ordinates indefinitely near to one another , and puts the Letter a for the Difference of the Ordinates , and the Letter e for the Difference of the Abscissa 's , and for drawing the Tangent gives these Three Rules 1 .
Inter computandum , saith he , omnes abjicio terminos in quibus ipsarum a vel c potestas habeatur , vel in quibus ipsae ducuntur in se .
Etenim isti termini nihil valebunt .
2 .
Post aequationem constitutam omnes abjicio terminos literis constantes quantitates notas seu determinatas significantibus , aut in quibus non habentur a vel e. Etenim illi termini semper ad unam aequationis partem adducti nihilum adaequabunt .
3 .
Pro a Ordinatam , &amp; pro e Subtangentem substituo .
Hinc demum Subtangentis quantitas dignoscetur .
Thus far Dr. Barrow .
And Mr. Leibnitz in his Letter of June 21 .
1677 above-mentioned , wherein he first began to propose his Differential Method , has followed this Method of Tangents exactly , excepting that he has changed the Letters a and e of Dr. Barrow into dx and die .
For in the Example which he there gives , he draws two parallel Lines and sets all the Terms below the under Line , in which dx and die are ( severally or jointly ) of more than one Dimension , and all the Terms above the upper Line , in which dx and die are wanting , and for the Reasons given by Dr. Barrow , makes all these Terms vanish .
And by the Terms in which dx and die are but of oneDimension , and which he sets between the twoLines , he determines the Proportion of the Subtangent to the Ordinate .
Well therefore did the Marquess de l ' Hospital observe that where Dr. Barrow left off Mr. Leibnitz began : for their Methods of Tangents are exactly the same .
But Mr. Leibnitz adds this Improvement of the Method , that the Conclusion of this Calculus is coincident with the Rule of Slusius , and shows how that Rule presently occurs to any one who understands this Method .
For Mr. Newton had represented in his Letters , that this Rule was a Corollary of his general Method .
And whereas Mr. Newton had said that his Method in drawing of Tangents , and determining Maxima and Minima , &amp;c. proceeded without sticking at Surds : Mr. Leibnitz in the next Place , shows how this Method of Tangents may be improved so as not to stick at Surds or Fractions , and then adds : Arbitror quae celare voluit Newtonus de Tangentibus ducendis ab his non abludere .
Quod addit , ex hoc eodem fundamento Quadraturas quoque reddi faciliores me in hac sententia confirmat ; nimirum semper figurae illae sunt quadrabiles quae sunt ad aequationem differentialem .
By which Words , compared with the preceding Calculation , its manifest that Mr. Leibnitz at this time understood that Mr. Newton had a Method which would do all these things , and had been examining whether Dr. Barrow 's Differential Method of Tangents might not be extended to the same Performances .
In November 1684 Mr. Leibnitz published the Elements of this Differential Method in the Acta Eruditorum , and illustrated it with Examples of drawing Tangents and determining Maxima and Minima , and then added .
Et haec quidem initia sunt Geometriae cujusdam multo sublimioris , ad difficillima &amp; pulcherrima quaeque etiam mistae Matheseos Problemata pertingentis , quae sine calculo differentiali AUTSIMILI non temere quisquam pari facilitate tractabit .
The Words AUTSIMILI plainly relate to Mr. Newton 's Method .
And the whole Sentence contains nothing more than what Mr. Newton had affirmed of his general Method in his Letters of 1672 and 1676 .
And in the Acta Eruditorum of June 1686 , page .
297 .
Mr. Leibnitz added : Malo autem dx &amp; similia adhibere quam literas pro illis , quia istud dx est modificatio quaedam ipsius x , &amp;c. He knew that in this Method he might have used Letters with Dr. Barrow , but chose rather to use the new Symbols dx and die , though there is nothing which can be done by these Symbols , but may be done by single Letters with more brevity .
The next Year Mr. Newton 's Principia Philosophiae came abroad , a Book full of such Problems as Mr. Leibnitz had called difficillima &amp; pulcherrima etiam mistae Matheseos problemata , quae sine calculo differentiali aut SIMILI non temere quisquam pari facilitate tractabit .
And the Marquess de L ' Hospital has represented this Book presque tout de ce calcul ; composed almost wholly of this Calculus .
And Mr. Leibnitz himself in a Letter to Mr. Newton , dated from Hannover , March 7/ 17 1693 and still extant in his own Hand-writing , and upon a late Occasion communicated to the Royal Society , acknowledged the same thing in these Words : Mirifice ampliaveras Geometriam tuis Seriebus , sed edito Principiorum opere ostendisti patere tibi etiam quae Analysi receptae non subsunt .
Conatus sum ego quoque , notis commodis adhibitis quae differentias &amp; summas exhibeant , Geometriam illam quam Transcendentem appello Analysi quodammodo subjicere , nec res male processit ; And again in his Answer to Mr. Fatio , printed in the ActaEruditorum of May 1700 .
page .203 .
lin.21 .
he acknowledged the same thing .
In the second Lemma of the second Book of these Principles , the Elements of this Calculus are demonstrated synthetically , and at theEnd of the Lemma there is a Scholium in these Words .
In Literis quae mihi cum Geometra peritissimo G. G. Leibnitio annis abhinc decem intercedebant , cum significarem me compotem esse methodi determinandi Maximas &amp; Minimas , ducendi Tangentes &amp; similia peragendi , quae in terminis surdis aeque ac in rationalibus procederet ; &amp; literis transpositis hanc sententiam involventibus [ Data aequatione quotcunque fluentes quantitates involvente , fluxiones invenire , &amp; vice versa ] eandem celarem : rescripsit Vir clarissimus se quoque in ejusmodi methodum incidisse , &amp; methodum suam communicavit a mea vix abludentem praeterquam in verborum &amp; notarum formulis .
Utriusque fundamentum continetur in hoc Lemmate .
In those Letters , and in another dated Decem .
10 .
1672 , a Copy of which , at that time , was sent to Mr. Leibnitz by Mr. Oldenburgh , as is mentioned above , Mr. Newton had so far explained his Method , that it was not difficult for Mr. Leibnitz , by the Help of Dr. Barrow 's Method of Tangents , to collect it from those Letters .
And its certain , by the Arguments above-mentioned , that he did not know it before the writing of those Letters .
Dr. Wallis had received Copies of Mr. Newton 's two Letters of June 13 .
and Octob. 24 .
1676 from Mr. Oldenburgh , and published several things out of them in his Algebra , printed in English 1683 , and in Latin 1693 ; and soon after had Intimation from Holland to print the Letters entire , because Mr. Newton 's Notions of Fluxions passed there with Applause by the Name of the Differential Method of Mr. Leibnitz .
And thereupon he took notice of this Matter in the Preface to the first Volume of his Works published A. C. 1695 .
And in a Letter to Mr. Leibnitz dated Decemb. 1 .
1696 , he gave the Account of it .
Cum Praefationis ( praefigendae ) postremum folium erat sub praelo , ejusque typos jam posuerant Typothetae ; me monuit amicus quidam ( harum rerum gnarus ) qui peregre fuerat , tum talem methodum in Belgio praedicari , tum illam cum Newtoni methodo Fluxionum quasi coincidere .
Quod fecit ut ( translatis typis jam positis ) id monitum interseruerim .
And in a Letter dated April 10 .
1695 , and lately communicated to the Royal-Society , he wrote thus about it .
I wish you would print the two large Letters of June and August [ he means June and October ] 1676 .
I had intimation from Holland , as desired there by your Friends , that somewhat of that kind were done ; because your Notions ( of Fluxions ) pass there with great Applause by the Name of Leibnitz 's Calculus Differentialis .
I had* this intimation when all but part of the Preface to this Volume was printed off ; so that I could only insert ( while the Press stayed ) that short Intimation thereof which you there find .
You are not so kind to your Reputation ( and that of the Nation ) as you might be , when you let things of worth lye by you so long , till others carry away * Extat haec Epistola in tertio volumine operum Wallisii .
the Reputation that is due to you .
I have endeavoured to do you justice in that Point , and am now sorry that I did not print those two Letters verbatim .
The short Intimation of this Matter , which Dr. Wallis inserted into the said Preface , was in these Words .
In secundo Volumine ( inter alia ) habetur Newtoni Methodus de Fluxionibus ( ut ille loqultur ) consimilis naturae cum Leibnitii ( ut hic loquitur ) Calculo Differentiali ( quod qui utramque methodum contulerit satis animadvertat , ut ut sub loquendi formulis diversis ) quam ego descripsi ( Algebrae cap. 91 .
&amp;c. praesertim cap. 95 ) ex binis Newtoni Literis , aut earum alteris , Junii 13 .
&amp; Octob. 24 .
1676 ad Oldenburgum datis , cum Leibnitio tum communicandis ( iisdem fere verbis , saltem leviter mutatis , quae in illis literis habentur , ) ubi METHODUMHANCLEIBNITIOE XP ONI T , tum ante DECEMANNOS nedum plures [ id est , anno 1666 vel 1665 ] ab ipso excogitatam .
Quod moneo , nequis causetur de hoc Calculo Differentiali nihil a nobis dictum esse .
Hereupon the Editors of the Acta Lipsiensia , the next Year in June , in the Style of Mr. Leibnitz , in giving an Account of these two first Volumes of Dr. Wallis , took notice of this Clause of the Doctor 's Preface , and complained , not of his saying that Mr. Newton in his two Letters above-mentioned explained to Mr Leibnitz the Method of Fluxions found by him Ten Years before or above ; but that while the Doctor mentioned the Differential Calculus , and said that he did it nequis causetur de calculo differentiali nihil ab ipso dictum fuisse , he did not tell the Reader that Mr. Leibnitz had this Calculus at that time when those Letters passed between him and Mr. Newton , by means of Mr. Oldenburgh .
And in several Letters which followed hereupon , between Mr. Leibnitz and Dr. Wallis , concerning this Matter , Mr. Leibnitz denied not that Mr. Newton had the Method Ten Years before the writing of those Letters , as Dr. Wallis had affirmed ; pretended not that he himself had the Method so early ; brought no Proof that he had it before the Year 1677 ; no other Proof besides the Concession of Mr. Newton that he had it so early ; affirmed not that he had it earlier ; commended Mr. Newton for his Candour in this Matter ; allowed that the Methods agreed in the main , and said that he therefore used to call them by the common Name of his Infinitesimal Analysis ; represented , that as the Methods of Vieta and Cartes were called by the common Name of Analysis Speciosa , and yet differed in some things ; so perhaps the Methods of Mr Newton and himself might differ in some things , and challenged to himself only those things wherein , as he conceived , they might differ , naming the Notation , the differential Equations and the Exponential Equations .
But in his Letter of June 21 .
1677 he reckoned differential Equations common to Mr. Newton and himself .
This was the State of the Dispute between Dr. Wallis and Mr Leibnitz at that time And Four years after , when Mr. Fatio suggested that Mr. Leibnitz , the second Inventor of this Calculus , might borrow something from Mr. Newton , the oldest Inventor by many Years : Mr. Leibnitz in his Answer , published in the Acta Eruditorum of May 1700 , allowed that Mr. Newton had found the Method apart , and did not deny that Mr. Newton was the oldest Inventor by many Years , nor asserted any thing more to himself , than that he also had found the Method apart , or without the Assistance of Mr. Newton , and pretended that when he first published it , he knew not that Mr. Newton had found any thing more of it than the Method of Tangents .
And in making this Defence he added : Quam [ methodum ] ante Dominum Newtonum &amp; Me nullus quod sciam Geometra babuit ; uti ante hunc maximi nominis Geometram NEMO specimine public dato se habere probavit , ante Dominos Bernoullios &amp; Me nullus communicavit .
Hitherto therefore Mr. Leibnitz did not pretend to be the first Inventor .
He did not begin to put in such a Claim till after the Death of Dr. Wallis , the last of the old Men who were acquainted with what had passed between the English and Mr. Leibnitz Forty Years ago .
The Doctor died in October A. C. 1703 , and Mr. Leibnitz began not to put in this new Claim before January 1705 .
Mr. Newton published his Treatise of Quadratures in the Year 1704 .
This Treatise was written long before , many things being cited out of it in his Letters of Octob. 24 .
and November .
8 .
1676 .
It relates to the Method of Fluxions , and that it might not be taken for a new Piece , Mr. Newton repeated what Dr. Wallis had published Nine Years before without being then contradicted , namely , that this Method was invented by Degrees in the Years 1665 and 1666 .
Hereupon the Editors of the Acta Lipsiensia in January 1705 .
in the Style of Mr. Leibnitz , in giving an Account of this Book , represented that Mr Leibnitz was the first Inventor of the Method , and that Mr. Newton had substituted Fluxions for Differences .
And this Accusation gave a Beginning to this present Controversy .
For Mr. Keill , in an Epistle published in the Philosophical Transactions for Sept. and Octob. 1708 , retorted the Accusation , saying : Fluxionum Arithmeticam sine omni dubio primus invenit D. Newtonus , ut cuilibet ejus Epistolas a Wallisio editas legenti facile const abit .
Eadem tamen Arithmetica postea mutatis nomine &amp; notationis modo a Domino Leibnitio in Actis Eruditorum edita est .
Before Mr. Newton saw what had been published in the Acta Leipsica , he expressed himself offended at the printing of this Paragraph of Mr. Keill 's Letter , least it should create a Controversy .
And Mr. Leibnitz , understanding it in a stronger Sense than Mr. Keill intended it , complained of it as a Calumny , in a Letter to Dr. Sloane dated March 4 .
1711 N. S. and moved that the Royal-Society would cause Mr. Keill to make a public Recantation .
Mr. Keill chose rather to explain and defend what he had written ; and Mr. Newton , upon being showed the Accusation in the Acta Lipsica , gave him leave to do so .
And Mr. Leibnitz in a second Letter to Dr. Sloane , dated Decem .
29 .
17 11 , instead of making good his Accusation sation , as he was bound to do that it might not be deemed a Calumny , insisted only upon his own Candour , as if it would be Injustice to question it ; and refused to tell how he came by the Method ; and said that the Acta Lipsica had given every Man his due , and that he had concealed the Invention above Nine Years , ( he should have said Seven Years ) that No body might pretend ( he means that Mr. Newton might not pretend ) to have been before him in it ; and called Mr. Keill a Novice unacquainted with things past , and one that acted without Authority from Mr. Newton , and a clamorous Man who deserved to be silenced , and desired that Mr. Newton himself would give his Opinion in the Matter .
He knew that Mr. Keill affirmed nothing more than what Dr. Wallis had published thirteen Years before , without being then contradicted .
He knew that Mr. Newton had given his Opinion in this matter in the Introduction to his Book of Quadratures , published before this Controversy began : but Dr. Wallis was dead ; the Mathematicians which remained in England were Novices ; Mr. Leibnitz may Question any Man 's Candour without Injustice , and Mr. Newton must now retract what he had published or not be quiet .
The Royal-Society therefore , having as much Authority over Mr. Leibnitz as over Mr. Keill , and being now twice pressed by Mr. Leibnitz to interpose , and seeing no reason to condemn or censure Mr. Keill without enquiring into the matter ; and that neither Mr. Newton nor Mr. Leibnitz ( the only Persons alive who knew and remembred any thing of what had passed in these matters Forty Years ago ) could be Witnesses for or against Mr. Keill ; appointed a numerous Committee to search old Letters and Papers , and report their Opinion upon what they found ; and ordered the Letters and Papers , with the Report of their Committee to be published .
And by these Letters and Papers it appeared to them , that Mr. Newton had the Method in or before the Year 1669 , and it did not appear to them that Mr. Leibnitz had it before the Year 1677 .
For making himself the first Inventor of the Differential Method , he has represented that Mr. Newton at first used the Letter o in the vulgar manner for the given Increment of x , which destroys the Advantages of the Differential Method ; but after the writing of his Principles , changed o into x , substituting x for dx .
It lies upon him to prove that Mr. Newton ever changed o into x , or used x for dx , or left off the Use of the Letter o. Mr. Newton used the Letter o in his Analysis written in or before the Years 1669 , and in his Book of Quadratures , and in his Principia Philosophiae , and still uses it in the very same Sense as at first .
In his Book of Quadratures he used it in conjunction with the Symbol x , and therefore did not use that Symbol in its Room .
These Symbols o and x are put for things of a different kind .
The one is a Moment , the other a Fluxion or Velocity as has been explained above .
When the Letter x is put for a Quantity which flows uniformly , the Symbol x is an Unit , and the Letter oa Moment , and xo and dx signify the same Moment .
Pricked Letters never signify Moments , unless when they are multiplied by the Moment o either expressed or understood to make them infinitely little , and then the Rectangles are put for Moments .
Mr. Newton doth not place his Method in Forms of Symbols , nor confine himself to any particular Sort of Symbols for Fluents and Fluxions .
Where he puts the Areas of Curves for Fluents , he frequently puts the Ordinates for Fluxions , and denotes the Fluxions by the Symbols of the Ordinates , as in his Analysis .
Where he puts Lines for Fluents , he puts any Symbols for the Velocities of the Points which describe the Lines , that is , for the first Fluxions ; and any other Symbols for the Increase of those Velocities , that is , for the second Fluxions , as is frequently done in his Principia Philosophiae .
And where he puts the Letters x , y , z for Fluents , he denotes their Fluxions , either by other Letters as p , q , r ; or by the same Letters in other Forms as X , Y , Z or x , y , z ; or by any Lines as D E , FG , ~H I , considered as their Exponents .
And this is evident by his Book of Quadratures , where he represents Fluxions by pricked Letters in the first Proposition , by Ordinates of Curves in the last Proposition , and by other Symbols , in explaining the Method and illustrating it with Examples , in the Introduction .
Mr. Leibnitz hath no Symbols of Fluxions in his Method , and therefore Mr. Newton 's Symbols of Fluxions are the oldest in the kind .
Mr. Leibnitz began to use the Symbols of Moments or Differences dx , die , dz in the Year 1677 .
Mr. Newton represented Moments by the Rectangles under the Fluxions and the Moment o , when he wrote his Analysis , which was at least Forty Six Years ago .
Mr. Leibnitz has used the Symbols sx , sy , sz for the Sums of Ordinates ever since the Year 1686 ; Mr. Newton represented the same thing in his Analysis , by inscribing the Ordinate in a Square or Rectangle .
All Mr. Newton 's Symbols are the oldest in their several Kinds by many Years .
And whereas it has been represented that the use of the Letter o is vulgar , and destroys the Advantages of the Differential Method : on the contrary , the Method of Fluxions , as used by Mr. Newton , has all the Advantages of ths Differential , and some others .
It is more elegant , because in his Calculus there is but one infinitely little Quantity represented by a Symbol , the Symbol o. We have no Ideas of infinitely little Quantities , and therefore Mr. Newton introduced Fluxions into his Method , that it might proceed by finite Quantities as much as possible .
It is more Natural and Geometrical , because founded upon the primae quantitatum nascentium rationes , which have a Being in Geometry , whilst Indivisibles , upon which the Differential Method is founded , have no Being either in Geometry or in Nature .
There are rationes primae quantitatum nascentium , but not quantitates primae nascentes .
Nature generates Quantities by continual Flux or Increase ; and the ancient Geometers admitted such a Generation of Areas and Solids , when they drew one Line into another by local Motion to generate an Area , and the Area into a Line by local Motion to generate a Solid .
But the summing up of Indivisibles to compose an Area or Solid was never yet admitted into Geometry .
Mr. Newton 's Method is also of greater Use and Certainty , being adapted either to the ready finding out of a Proposition by such Approximations as will create no Error in the Conclusion , or to the demonstrating it exactly : Mr Leibnitz 's is only for finding it out .
When the Work succeeds not in finite Equations Mr. Newton has recourse to converging Series , and thereby his Method becomes incomparably more universal than that of Mr. Leibnitz , which is confined to finite Equations : for he has no Share in the Method of infinite Series .
Some Years after the Method of Series was invented , Mr. Leibnitz invented a Proposition for transmuting curvilinear Figures into other curvilinear Figures of equal Areas , in order to square them by converging Series : but the Methods ofsquaring those other Figures by such Series were not his .
By the help of the new Analysis Mr. Newton found out most of the Propositions in his Principia Philosophiae : but because the Ancients for making things certain admitted nothing into Geometry before it was demonstrated synthetically , he demonstrated the Propositions synthetically , that the Systeme of the Heavensmight be founded upon good Geometry .
And this makes it now difficult for unskilful Men to see the Analysis by which those Propositions were found out .
It has been represented that Mr. Newton , in the Scholium at the End of his Book of Quadratures , has put the third , fourth , and fifth Terms of a converging Series respectively equal to the second , third , and fourth Differences of the first Term , and therefore did not then understand the Method of second , third , and fourth Differences .
But in the first Proposition of that Book he showed how to find the first , second , third and following Fluxions in infinitum ; and therefore when he wrote that Book , which was before the Year 1676 , he did understand the Method of all the Fluxions , and by con2 sequence sequence of all the Differences .
And if he did not understand it when he added that Scholium to the End of the Book , which was in the Year 1704 , it must have been because he had then forgot it .
And so the Question is only whether he had forgot the Method of second and third Differences before the Year 1704 .
In the Tenth Proposition of the second Book of his Principia Philosophiae , in describing some of the Uses of the Terms of a converging Series for solving of Problems , he tells us that if the first Term of the Series represents the Ordinate BC of any Curve Line AC G , and CBDI be a ParalleI logram infinitely narrow , whose Side C F GDI cuts the Curve in G and its Tangent CF in F , the second Term of the Series will represent the Line I F , and ABD the third Term the Line F G. Now the Line FG is but half the second Difference of the Ordinate : and therefore Mr. Newton when he wrote his Principia , put the third Term of the Series equal to half of the second Difference of the first Term , and by consequence had not then forgotten the Method of second Differences .
In writing that Book , he had frequent occasion to consider the Increase or Decrease of the Velocities with which Quantities are generated , and argues right about it .
That Increase or Decrease is the second Fluxion of the Quantity , and therefore he had not then forgotten the Method of second Fluxions .
In the Year 1692 , Mr. Newton , at the Request ofDr .
Wallis , sent to him a Copy of the first Proposition of the Book of Quadratures , with Examples thereof in first , second and third Fluxions : as you may see in the second Volume of the Doctor 's Works , page .
391 , 392 , 393 and 396 .
And therefore he had not then forgotten the Method of second Fluxions .
Nor is it likely , that in the Year 1704 : when he added the aforesaid Scholium to the End of the Book of Quadratures , he had forgotten not only the first Proposition of that Book , but also the last Proposition upon which that Scholium was written .
If the Word [ ut ] , which in that Scholium may have been accidentally omitted between the Words [ erit ] and [ ejus , ] be restored , that Scholium will agree with the two Propositions and with the rest of his Writings , and the Objection will vanish .
Thus much concerning the Nature and History of these Methods , it will not be amiss to make some Observations thereupon .
In the Commercium Epistolicum , mention is made of three Tracts written by Mr. Leibnitz , after a Copy of Mr. Newton 's Principia Philosophiae had been sent to Hannover for him , and after he had seen an Account of that Book published in the Acta Eruditorum for January and February 1689 .
And in those Tracts the principal Propositions of that Book are composed in a new manner , and claimed by Mr. Leibnitz as if he had found them himself before the publishing of the said Book .
But Mr. Leibnitz cannot be a Witness in his own Cause .
It lies upon him either to prove that he found them before Mr. Newton , or to quit his claim .
In the last of those three Tracts , the 20th Proposition ( which is the chief of Mr. Newton 's Propositions ) is made a Corollary of the 19thProposition , and the 19th Proposition has an erroneous Demonstration adapted to it .
It lies upon him either to satisfy the World that the Demonstration is not erroneous , or to acknowledge that he did not find that and the 20th Proposition thereby , but tried to adapt a Demonstration to Mr. Newton 's Proposition to make it his own .
For he represents in his 20th Proposition that he knew not how Mr. Newton came by it , and by consequence that he found it himself without the Assistance of Mr. Newton .
By the Errors in the 15th and 19th Proposition of the third Tract , Dr. Keill hath showed that when Mr. Leibnitz wrote these three Tracts , he did not well understand the Ways of working in second Differences .
And this is further manifest by the 10th , 11th , and 12th Propositions of this third Tract .
For these he lays down as the Foundation of his infinitesimal Analysis in arguing about centrifugal Forces , and proposes the first of them with relation to the Center of Curvity of the Orb , but uses this Proposition in the two next , with Relation to the Center of Circulation .
And by confounding these two Centers with one another in the fundamental Propositions upon which he grounds this Calculus , he erred in the Superstructure , and for want of Skill in second and third Differences , was not able to extricate himself from the Errors .
And this is further confirmed by the sixth Article of the second Tract .
For that Article is erroneous , and the Error arises from his not knowing how to argue well about second and third Differences .
When therefore he wrote those Tracts he was but a Learner , and this he ought in candour to acknowledge .
It seems therefore that as he learnt the Differential Method by means of Mr. Newton 's aforesaid three Letters compared with Dr. Barrow 's Method of Tangents ; so Ten Years after , when Mr. Newton 's Principia Philosophiae came abroad , he improved his Knowledge in these Matters , by trying to extend this Method to the Principal Propositions in that Book , and by this means composed the said three Tracts .
For the Propositions contained in them ( Errors and Trifles excepted ) are Mr. Newton 's ( or easy Corollaries from them ) being published by him in other Forms of Words before .
And yet Mr. Leibnitz published them as invented by himself long before they were published by Mr. Newton .
For in the End of the first Tract , he represents that he invented them all before Mr. Newton 's Principia Philosophiae came abroad , and some of them before he left Paris , that is before October 1676 .
And the second Tract he concludes with these Words : Multa ex his deduci possent praxi accommodata , sed nobis bis nunc fundamenta Geometrica jecisse suffecerit , in quibus maxima consistebat difficultas .
Et fortassis attente consideranti vias quasdam novas satis antea impeditas aperuisse videbimur .
Omnia autem respondent nostrae Analysi Infinitorum , hoc est calculo Summarum &amp; Differentiarum(cujus elementa quaedam in his Actis dedimus ) communibus quoad licuit verbis hic expresso .
He pretends here that the Fundamenta Geometrica in quibus maxima consistebat difficultas were first laid by himself in this very Tract , and that he himself had in this very Tract opened vias quasdam novas satis antea impeditas .
And yet Mr. Newton 's Principia Philosophiae came abroad almost two Years before , and gave occasion to the Writing of this Tract , and was written communibus quoad licuit verbis , and contains all these Principles and all these new Ways .
And Mr. Leibnitz , when he published that Tract , knew all this , and therefore ought then to have acknowledged that Mr. Newton was the first who laid the Fundamenta Geometrica in quibus maxima consistebat Difficultas , and opened the vias novas satis antea impeditas .
In his Answer to Mr. Fatio he acknowledged all this , saying Quam [ methodum ] ante Dominum Newtonum &amp; me nullus quod sciam Geometra habuit ; uti ante hunc maximi nominis Geometram , NEMOSPECIMINEPUBLICEDATO se habere PROBAVI T. And what he then acknowledged he ought in Candour and Honour to acknowledge still upon all Occasions .
Mr. Leibnitz in his Letter of May 28 .
1697 , wrote thus to Dr. Wallis .
Methodum Fluxionum profundissimi Newtoni cognatam esse methodo meae differentiali non tantum animadverti postquam opus ejus [ Principiorum scilicet ] &amp; tuum prodiit ; sed etiam professus sum in Actis Eruditorum , &amp; alias quoque monui .
Id enim candori meo convenire judicavi , non minus quam ipsius merito .
Itaque communi nomine designare soleo Analyseos infinitesimalis ; quae latius quam Tetragonistica patet .
Interim quemadmodum &amp; Vietaea &amp; Cartesiana methodus Analyseos speciosae nomine venit ; discrimina tamen nonnulla supersunt : ita fortasse &amp; Newtoniana &amp; Mea differunt in nonnullis .
Here also Mr. Leibnitz allows that when Mr Newton 's Principles of Philosophy came abroad , he understood thereby the Affinity that there was between the Methods , and therefore called them both by the common Name of the infinitesimal Method , and thought himself bound in candour to acknowledge this Affinity : and there is still the same Obligation upon him in point of Candour .
And besides this Acknowled meant , he here gives the Preference to Mr. Newton 's Method in Antiquity .
For he represents that as the vulgar Analysis in Species was invented by Vieta , and augmented by Cartes , which made some Differences between their Methods : so Mr. Newton 's Method and his own might differ in some things .
And then he goes on to enumerate the Differences by which he had improved Mr. Newton 's Method as we mentioned above .
And this Subordination of his Method to Mr. Newton 's , which he then acknowledged to Dr. Wallis , he ought still to acknowledge .
In enumerating the Differences or Improvements which he had added to Mr. Newton 's Method ; he names in the second Place Differential Equations : but the Letters which passed between them in the Year 1676 , do show that Mr. Newton had such Equations at that time , and Mr. Leibnitz had them not .
He names in the third Place Exponential Equations : but these Equations are owing to his Correspondence with the English .
Dr. Wallis , in the Interpolation of Series , considered Fract and Negative Indices of Dignities .
Mr. Newton introduced into his Analytical Computations , the Fract , Surd , Negative and Indefinitive Indices of Dignities ; and in his Letter of October 24 .
1676 , represented to Mr. Leibnitz that his Method extended to the Resolution of affected Equations involving Dignities whose Indices were Fract or Surd .
Mr. Leibnitz in his Answer dated June 21 .
1677 , mutually desired Mr. Newton to tell him what he thought of the Resolution of Equations invo ving Dignities whose Indices were undetermined , such as were these xy + yx = xy , xx + yy =x+y And these Equations he now calls Exponential , and represents to the World that he was the first Inventor thereof , and magnifies the Invention as a great Discovery .
But he has not yet made a public Acknowledgment of the Light which Mr. Newton gave him into it , nor produced any one Instance of the use that he has been able to make of it where the Indices of Dignities are Fluents .
And since he has not yet rejected it with his sual Impatience for want of such an Instance , we have reason to expect that he will at length explain its Usefulness to the World .
Mr. Newton in his Letter of October 24 .
1676 wrote that he had two Methods of resolving the Inverse Problems of Tangents , and such like difficult ones ; one of which consisted in assuming a Series for any unknown Quantity from which all the rest might conveniently be deduced , and in collating the homologous Terms of the resulting Equation , for determining the Terms of the assumed Series .
Mr. Leibnitz many Years after published this Method as his own , claiming to himself the first Invention thereof .
It remains that he either renounce his Claim publicly , or prove that he invented it before Mr. Newton wrote his said Letter .
It lies upon him also to make a public Acknowledgment of his Receipt of Mr. Oldenburgh 's Letter of April 15 .
1675 , wherein several converging Series for squaring of Curves , and particularly that of Mr. James Gregory for finding the Arc by the given Tangent , and thereby squaring the Circle , were communicated to him .
He acknowledged it privately in his Letter to Mr. Oldenburg dated May 20 .
1675 still extant in his own Hand~ writing , and by Mr Oldenburg left entered in the Letter-Book of the Royal-Society .
But he has not yet acknowledged it publicly , as he ought to have done when he published that Series as his own .
It lies upon him also to make a public Acknowledgment of his having received the Extracts of Mr. James Gregory 's Letters , which , at his own Request , were sent to him at Paris in June 1676 by Mr. Oldenburgh to peruse : amongst which was Mr. James Gregory 's Letter of Feb. 15 .
1671 , concerning that Series , and Mr. Newton 's Letter of December 10 .
1672 concerning the Method of Fluxions .
And whereas in his Letter of Decem .
28 .
1675 he wrote to Mr. Oldenburgh , that he had communicated that Series above two Years before to his Friends at Paris , and had written to him sometimes about it ; and in his Letter of May 12 .
1676 said to Mr. Oldenburgh that he had written to him about that Series some Years before ; and in his Letter to Mr. Oldenburgh dated Aug. 27 .
1676 , that he had communicated that Series to his Friends above three Years before ; that is , upon his first coming from London to Paris : He is desired to tell us how it came to pass , that when he received Mr. Oldenburgh 's Letter of Apr. 15 .
1675 he did not know that Series to be his own .
In his Lets of July 15 .
and Octob. 26 .
1674 , he tells us of but one Series for the circumference of a Circle , and saith that the Method which gave him this Series , gave him also a Series for any Arc whose Sine was given , tho ' the Proportion of the Arc to the whole Circumference be not known .
This Method therefore , by the given Sine of 30 Degrees , gave him a Series for the whole Circumference .
If he had also a Series for the whole Circumference deduced from the Tangent of 45 Degrees , he is desired to tell the World what Method he had in those Days , which could give him both those Series .
For the Method by the Transmutation of Figures will not do it .
He is desired also to tell us why in his said Letters he did not mention more Quadratures of the Circle than one .
And if in the Year 1674 he had the Demonstration of a Series for finding any Arc whose Sine is given , he is desired to tell the World what it was ; and why in his Letter of May 12 .
1676 he desired Mr. Oldenburgh to procure from Mr. Collins the Demonstration of Mr. Newton 's Series for doing the same thing ; and wherein his own Series differed from Mr. Newton 's .
For upon all these Considerations there is a Suspicion that Mr. Newton 's Series for finding the Arc whose Sine is given , was communicated to him in England ; and that in the Year 1673 he began to communicate it as his own to some of his Friends at Paris , and the next Year wrote of it as his own in his Letters to Mr. Oldenburgh , in order to get the Demonstration or Method of finding such Series .
But the Year following , when Mr. Oldenburgh sent him this Series and the Series of Mr. Gregory and Six other Series , he dropped his Pretence to this Series for want of a Demonstration , and took time to consider the Series sent him , and to compare them with his own , as if his Series were others different from those sent him .
And when he had found a Demonstration of Gregory 's Series by a Transmutation of Figures , he began to communicate it as his own to his Friends at Paris , as he represents in the Acta Eruditorum for April 1691 .
page .
178 , saying ; Jam Anno 1675 compositum habebam opusculum Quadraturae Arithmeticae ab Amicis ab illo tempore lectum , &amp;c. But the Letter by which he had received this Series form Mr. Oldenburgh he concealed from his Friends , and pretended to Mr. Oldenburgh that he had this Series a Year or two before the Receipt of that Letter .
And the next Year , upon receiving two of Mr. Newton 's Series again by one George Mohr , he wrote to Mr. Oldenburgh in such a manner as if he had never seen them before , and upon Pretence of their Novelty , desired Mr. Oldenburgh to procure from Mr. Collins Mr. Newton 's Method of finding them .
If Mr. Leibnitz thinks fit to obviate this Suspicion , he is in the first Place to prove that he had Mr. Gregory 's Series before he received it from Mr. Oldenburgh .
It lies upon him also to tell the World what was the Method by which the several Series of Regression for the Circle and Hyperbola , sent to him by Mr. Newton June 13 .
1676 , and claimed as his own by his Letter of August 27 .
following , were found by him before he received them from Mr. Newton .
And whereas Mr. Newton sent him , at his own Request , a Method of Regression , which upon the first reading he did not know to be his own , nor understood it ; but so soon as he understood it he claimed as his own , by pretending that he had found it long before , and had forgot it , as he perceived by his old Papers : it lies upon him , in point of Candor and Justice , either to prove that he was the first Inventor of this Method , or to renounce his Claim to it for preventing future Disputes .
Mr. Leibnitz in his Letter to Mr. Oldenburgh dated Feb. 3 .
167 2/ 3 claimed a Right to a certain Property of a Series of Numbers Natural , Triangular , Pyramidal , TrianguloTriangular , &amp;c. and to make it his own , represented that he wondred that Monsieur Pascal , in his Book entitled Triangulum Arithmeticum , should omit it .
That Book was published in the Year 1665 , and contains this Property of the Series ; and Mr. Leibnitz has not yet done him the Justice to acknowledge that he did not omit it .
It lies upon him therefore in Candor and Justice , to renounce his Claim to this Property , and acknowledge Mr. Paschal the first Inventor .
He is also to renounce all Right to the Differential Method of Mouton as second Inventor : for second Inventors have no Right .
The sole Right is in the first Inventor until another finds out the same thing apart .
In which case to take away the Right of the first Inventor , and divide it between him and that other , would be an Act of Injustice .
In his Letter to Dr. Sloane dated Decem .
29 .
1711 .
he has told us that his Friends know how he came by the Differential Method .
It lies upon him , in point of Candor , openly and plainly , and without further Hesitation , to satisfy the World how he came by it .
Mm2 In In the same Letter he has told us that he had this Method above Nine Years before he published it , and it follows from thence that he had it in the Year 1675 or before .
And yet its certain that he had it not when he wrote his Letter to Mr. Oldenburgh dated Aug. 27 .
1676 , wherein he affirmed that Problems of the Inverse Method of Tangents and many others , could not be reduced to infinite Series , nor to Equations or Quadratures .
It lies upon him therefore , in point of Candor , to tell us what he means by pretending to have found the Method before he had found it .
We have showed that Mr. Leibnitz in the End of the Year 1676 , in returning home from France through England and Holland , was meditating how to improve the Method of Slusius for Tangents , and extend it to all sorts of Problems , and for this end proposed the making of a general Table of Tangents ; and therefore had not yet found out the true Improvement .
But about half a Year after , when he was newly fallen upon the true Improvement , he wrote back ; Clariss .
Slusii Methodum Tangentium nondum esse absolutam Celeberrimo Newtono assentior .
Et jam AMULTOTE MP ORE rem Tangentium generalius tractavi , scilicet per differentias Ordinatarum .
Which is as much as to say that he had this Improvement long before those Days .
It lies upon him , in point of Candor , to make us understand that he pretended to this Antiquity of his Invention with some other Design than to rival and supplant Mr. Newton , and to make us believe that he had the Differential Method before Mr. Newton explained it to him by his Letters of June 13 .
and Octob. 24 .
1676 , and before Mr. Oldenburgh sent him a Copy of Mr. Newton 's Letter of Decem 10 .
1672 concerning it .
The Editors of the Acta Eruditorum in June 1696 , in giving an Account of the two first Volumes of the Mathematical Works of Dr. Wallis , wrote thus , in the Style of Mr. Leibnitz .
Caeterum ipse Newtonus , non minus Candore quam praeclaris in rem Mathematicam meritis insignis , public &amp; privatim agnovit Leibnitium , tum cum ( interveniente celeberrimo Viro Henrico Oldenburgo Bremensi , Societatis Regiae Anglicanae tunc Secretario ) inter ipsos ( ejusdem jam tum Societatis Socios ) Commercium intercederet , id est jam fere ante annos viginti &amp; amplius , Calculum suum differentialem , Seriesque infinitas , &amp; pro iis quoque Methodos generals habuisse ; quod Wallisius in Praefatione Operum , factae inter eos communicationis mentionem faciens , praeteriit , quoniam de eo fortasse non satis ipsi constabat .
Caeterum Differentiarum consideratio Leibnitiana , cujus mentionem facit Wallisius ( no quis scilicet , ut ipse ait , causeretur de Calculo Differentiali nihil ab ipso dictum fuisse ) meditationes aperuit , quae aliunde non aeque nascebantur , &amp;c. By the Words here cited out of the Preface to the two first Volumes of Dr. Wallis 's Works , it appears that Mr. Leibnitz had seen that Part of the Preface , where Mr. Newton is said to have explained to him ( in the Year 1676 ) the Method of Fluxions found by him Ten Years before or above .
Mr. Newton never allowed that Mr. Leibnitz had the Differential Method before the Year 1677 .
And Mr. Leibnitz himself in the Acta Eruditorum for April 1691 .
page .
178 .
acknowledged that he found it after he returned home from Paris to enter upon Business , that is , after the Year 1676 .
And as for his pretended general Method of infinite Series , it is so far from being general , that it is of little or no use .
I do not know that any other Use hath been made of it , than to colour over the Pretence of Mr. Leibnitz to the Series of Mr. Gregory for squaring the Circle .
Mr. Leibnitz , in his Answer to Mr. Fatio printed in the Acta Eruditorum for the Year 1700 .
page .
203 .
wrote thus .
Ipse [ Newtonus ] scit unus omnium optime , satisque indicavit public cum sua Mathematica Naturae Principia publicaret , Anno 1687 , nova quaedam inventa Geometrica , quae ipsi communia mecum suere , NEUTRUMLUCIABALTERO ACCEPT AE , sed meditationibus quemque suis debere , &amp; a me decennio ante [ i. e. anno 1677 ] exposita fuisse .
In the Book of Principles here referred unto , Mr. Newton did not acknowledge that Mr. Leibnitz found this Method without receiving Light into it from Mr. Newton 's Letters above-mentioned ; and Dr. Wallis had lately told him the contrary without being then confuted or contradicted .
And if Mr. Leibnitz had found the Method without the Assistance of Mr. Newton , yet second Inventors have no Right .
Mr. Leibnitz in his aforesaid Answer to Mr. Fatio , wrote further : Certe cum elementa Calculi mea edidi anno 1684 , no constabat quidem mihi aliud de inventis ejus [ sc .
Newtoni ] in hoc genere , quam quod ipse olim significaverat in literis , posse se Tangentes invenire non sublatis irrationalibus , quod Hugenius quoque se posse mihi significavit postea , etsi caeterorum ejus Calculi adhuc expers .
Sed majora multo consecutum Newtonum , viso demum libro Principiorum ejus , satis intellexi .
Here he again acknowledged that the Book of Principles gave him great Light into Mr. Newton 's Method : and yet he now denies that this Book contains any thing of that Method in it .
Here he pretended that before that Book came abroad he knew nothing more of Mr. Newton 's Inventions of this kind , than that he had a certain Method of Tangents .
and that by that Book he received the first Light into Mr. Newton 's Method of Fluxions : but in his Letter of June 21 .
1677 he acknowledged that Mr. Newton 's Method extended also to Quadratures of curvilinear Figures , and was like his own .
His Words are ; Arbitror quae celare voluit Newtonus de Tangentibus ducendis ab his non abludere .
Quod addit , ex hoc eodem fundamento Quadraturas quoque reddi faciliores me in sententia hac confirmat ; nimirum semper figurae illae sunt quadrabiles quae sunt ad aequationem differentialem .
Mr. Newton had in his three Letters above-mentioned ( copies of which Mr. Leibnitz had received from Mr. Oldenbergh ) represented his Method so general , as by the Help of Equations , finite and infinite , to determine Maxima and Minima , Tangents , Areas , solid Contents , Centers of Gravity , Lenghts and Curvities of curve Lines and curvilinear Figures , and this without taking away Radicals , and to extend to the like Problems in Curves usually called Mechanical , and to inverse Problems of Tangents and others more difficult , and to almost all Problems , except perhaps some Numeral ones like those of Diophantus .
And Mr. Leibnitz in his Letter of Aug. 27 1676 , represented that he could not believe that Mr. Newton 's Method was so general .
Mr. Newton in the First of his three Letters set down his Method of Tangents deduced from this general Method , and illustrated it with an Example , and said that this Method of Tangents was but a Branch or Corollary of his General Method , and that he took the Method of Tangents of Slusius to be of the same kind : and thereupon Mr. Leibnitz , in his Return from Paris through England and Holland into Germany , was considering how to improve the Method of Tangents of Slusius , and extend it to all sorts of Problems , as we showed above out of his Letters .
And in his third Letter Mr. Newton illustrated his Method with Theorems for Quadratures and Examples thereof .
And when he had made so large an Explanation of his Method , that Mr. Leibnitz had got Light into it , and had in his Letter of June 21 .
1677 explained how the Method which.he was fallen into answered to the Description which Mr. Newton had given of his Method , in drawing of Tangents giving the Method of Slusius , proceeding without taking away Fractions and Surds , and facilitating Quadratures ; for him to tell the Germans that in the Year 1684 , when he first published his Differential Method , he knew nothing more of Mr. Newton 's Invention , than that he had a certain Method of Tangents , is very extraordinary and wants an Explanation .
At that time he explained nothing more concerning his own Method , than how to draw Tangents and determine Maxima and Minima without taking away Fractions or Surds .
He certainly knew that Mr. Newton 's Method would do all this , and therefore ought in Candor to have acknowledged it .
After he had thus far explained his own Method , he added that what he had there laid down were the Principles of a much sublimer Geometry , reaching to the most difficult and valuable Problems , which were scarce to be resolved without the Differential Calculus , AUTSIMIL I , or another like it .
What he meant by the Words AUT SIMILI was impossible for the Germans to understand without an Interpreter .
He ought to have done Mr. Newton justice in plain intelligible Language , and told the Germans whose was the Methodus SIMILI S , and of what Extent and Antiquity it was , according to the Notices he had received from England ; and to have acknowledged that his own Method was not so ancient .
This would have prevented Disputes , and nothing less than this could fully deserve the Name of Candor and Justice .
But afterwards , in his Answer to Mr. Fatio , to tell the Germans that in the Year 1684 , when he first published the Elements of his Calculus , the knew nothing of a Methodus SIMILI S , nothing of any other Method than for drawing Tangents , was very strange and wants an Explanation .
It lies upon him also to satisfy the World why , in his Answer to Dr Wallis and Mr. Fatio , who had published that Mr. Newton was the oldest Inventor of that Method by many Years , he did not put in his Claim of being the oldest Inventor thereof , but staid till the old Mathematicians were dead , and then complained of the new Mathematicians as Novices ; attacked Mr. Newton himself , and declined to contend with any Body else , notwithstanding that Mr. Newton in his Letter of Octob. 24 .
1676 had told him , that for the sake of Quiet , he had Five Years before that time laid aside his Design of publishing what he had then written on this Subject , and has ever since industriously avoided all Disputes about Philosophical and Mathematical Subjects , and all Correspondence by Letters about those Matters , as tending to Disputes ; putes ; and for the same Reason has forborn to complain of Mr. Leibnitz , until it was showed him that he stood accused of Plagiary in the Acta Lipsiae , and that what Mr Keill had published was only in hisDefence from theGuilt of thatCrime .
It has been said the Royal-Society gave judgment against Mr. Leibnitz without hearing both Parties .
But this is a Mistake .
They have not yet given judgment in the Matter .
Mr. Leibnitz indeed desired the Royal-Society to condemn Mr. Keill without hearing both Parties ; and by the same sort of Justice they might have condemned Mr. Leibnitz without hearing both Parties ; for they have an equal Authority over them both .
And when Mr. Leibnitz declined to make good his Charge against Mr. Keill , the Royal-Society might in justice have censured him for not making it good .
But they only appointed a Committee to search out and examine such old Letters and Papers as were still extant about these Matters , and report their Opinion how the Matter stood according to those Letters and Papers .
They were not appointed to examine Mr. Leibnitz or Mr. Keill , but only to report what they found in the ancient Letters and Papers : and he that compares their Report therewith will find it just .
The Committee was numerous and skilful and composed of Gentlemen of several Nations , and the Society are satisfied in their Fidelity in examining the Hands and other Circumstances , and in printing what they found in the ancient Letters and Papers so examined , without adding , omitting or altering any thing in favour of either Party .
And the Letters and Papers are by order of the Royal-Society preserved , that they may be consulted and compared with the Commercium Epistolicum , whenever it shall be desired by Persons of Note .
And in the mean time I take the Liberty to acquaint him , that by taxing the Royal-Society with Injustice in giving Sentence against him without hearing both Parties , he has transgressed one of their Statutes which makes it Expulsion to defame The Philosophy which Mr. Newton in his Principles and Optiques has pursued is Experimental ; and it is not the Business of Experimental Philosophy to teach the Causes of things any further than they can be proved by Experiments .
We are not to fill this Philosophy with Opinions which cannot be proved by Phenomenon .
In this Philosophy Hypotheses have no place , unless as Conjectures or Questions proposed to be examined by Experiments .
For this Reason Mr. Newton in his Optiques distinguished those things which were made certain by Experiments from those things which remained uncertain , and which he therefore proposed in the End of his Optiques in the Form of Queries .
For this Reason , in the Preface to his Principles , when he had mentioned the Motions of the Planets , Comets , Moon and Sea as deduced in this Book from Gravity , he added : Uiinam caetera Naturae Phenomenon ex Principiis Mechanicis eodem argumentandi genere derivare liceret .
Nam multa me movent ut nonnihil suspicer ea omnia ex viribus quibusdam pendere posse , quibus corporum particulae per causas nondum cognitas vel in se mutuo impelluntur &amp; secundum figuras regulares cohaerent , vel ab invicem fugantur &amp; recedant : quibus viribus ignotis Philosophi hactenus Naturam frustra tentarunt .
And in the End of this Book in the second Edition , he said that for want of a sufficient Number of Experiments , he forbore to describe the Laws of the Actions of the Spirit or Agent by which this Attraction is performed .
And for the same Reason he is silent about the Cause of Gravity , there occurring no Experiments or Phenomenon by which he might prove what was the Cause thereof .
And this he hath abundantly declared in his Principles , near the Beginning thereof , in these Words ; Virium causas &amp; sedes Physicas jam non expendo .
And a little after : Voces Attractionis , Impulsus , vel Propensionis cujuscunque in centrum indifferenter &amp; pro se mutuo promiscue usurpo , has Vires non Physice sed Mathematice tantum considerando .
Unde caveat Lector no per hujusmodi voces cogitet me speciemvel modum actionis , causamve aut rationem physicam alicubi desinire , vel Centris ( quae sunt puncta Mathematica ) vires vere &amp; physice tribuere , si forte aut Centra trahere aut vises Centrorum esse dixero .
And in the End of his Opticks : Qua causa efficiente hae attractiones [ fc .
gravitas , visque magnetica &amp; electrica ] peragantur , hic non inquiro .
Quam ego Attractionem appello , fieri sane potest ut ea efficiatur impulsu vel al o aliquo modo nobis incognito .
Hanc vocem Attractionis ita hic accipi velim ut in universum solummodo vim aliquam significare intelligatur qua corpora ad se mutuo tendant , cuicunque demum causae attribuenda sit illa vis .
Nam ex Phaenomenis Naturae illud nos prius edoctos oportet quaenam corpora se invicem attrahant , &amp; quaenam sint leges &amp; proprietates istius attractionis , quam in id inquirere par sit quanam efficiente causa peragatur attractio .
And a little after he mentions the same Attractions as Forces which by Phenomenon appear to have a Being in Nature , tho ' their Causes be not yet known ; and distinguishes them from occult Qualities which are supposed to flow from the specific Forms of things .
And in the Scholium at the End of his Principles , after he had mentioned the Properties of Gravity , he added : Rationem vero harum Gravitatis proprietatum ex Phaenomenis nondum potui deducere , &amp; Hypotheses non fingo .
Quicquid enim ex Phaenomenis non deducitur Hypothesis vocanda est ; &amp; Hypotheses seu Metaphysicae seu Physicae , seu Qualitatum occultarum , seu Mechanicae , in Philosophia experimentali locum non habent .
satis est quod Gravitas revera existat &amp; agate secundum leges a nobis expositas , &amp; ad Corporum caelestium &amp; Maris nostri motus omnes sufficiat .
And after all this , one would wonder that Mr. Newton should be reflected upon for not explaining the Causes of Gravity and other Attractions by Hypotheses ; as if it were a Crime to content himself with Certainties and let Uncertainties alone .
And yet the Editors of the Acta Eruditorum , ( a ) have told the World that Mr. Newton denies that the cause of Gravity is Mechanical , and that if the Spirit or Agent by which Electrical Attraction is performed , be not the Ether or subtle Matter of Cartes , it is less valuable than anHypothesis , and perhaps may be the Hylarchic Principle of Dr. Henry Moor : and Mr. Leibnitz ( b ) hath accused him of making Gravity a natural or essential Property of Bodies , and an occult Quality and Miracle .
And by this sort of Railery they are persuading the Germans that Mr. Newton wants Judgment , and was not able to invent the Infinitesimal Method .
( a ) Anno 1714 , mense Martio , p. 141 .
142 .
( b ) In tractatu de Bonitate Dei &amp; in Epistolis ad D. Hartsoeker &amp; alibi .
It It must be allowed that these two Gentlemen differ very much in Philosophy .
The one proceeds upon the Evidence arising from Experiments and Phenomenon , and stops where such Evidence is wanting ; the other is taken up with Hypotheses , and propounds them , not to be examined by Experiments , but to be believed without Examination .
The one for want of Experiments to decide the Question , doth not affirm whether the Cause of Gravity be Mechanical or not Mechanical : the other that it is a perpetual Miracle if it be not Mechanical .
The one ( by way of Enquiry ) attributes it to the Power of the Creator that the least Particles of Matter are hard : the other attributes the Hardness of Matter to conspiring Motions , and calls it a perpetual Miracle if the Cause of this Hardness be other than Mechanical .
The one doth not affirm that animal Motion in Man is purely mechanical : the other teaches that it is purely mechanical , the Soul or Mind ( according to the Hypothesis of an Harmonia Praestabilita ) never acting upon the Body so as to alter or influence its Motions .
The one teaches that God ( the God in whom we live and move and have our Being ) is Omnipresent ; but not as a Soul of the World : the other that he is not the Soul of the World , by INTELLIGENTIA SUPRAMUNDAN A , an Intelligence above the Bounds of the World ; whence it seems to follow that he cannot do any thing within the Bounds of the World , unless by an incredible Miracle .
The one teaches that Philosophers are to argue from Phenomenon and Experiments to the Causes thereof , and thence to the Causes of those Causes , and so on till we come to the first CAuse : the other that all the Actions of the first Cause are Miracles , and all the Laws impressed on Nature by the Will of God are perpetual Miracles and occult Qualities , and therefore not to be considered in Philosophy .
But must the constant and universal Laws of Nature , if derived from the Power of God or the Action of a Cause not yet known to us , be called Miracles and occult Qualities , that is to say , Wonders and Absurdities ?
Must all the Arguments for a God taken from the Phenomenon of Nature be exploded by new hard Names ?
And must Experimental Philosophy be exploded as miraculous and absurd , because it asserts nothing more than can be proved by Experiments , and we cannot yet prove by Experiments that all the Phenomenon in Nature can be solved by mere Mechanical Causes ?
Certainly these things deserve to be better considered .

