X. An Account of a Book , Entitled , Joh. Conradi Beckeri , Phil. &amp; Med. D. Tractus Alsfeld .
Medici Ordin .
Paradoxum Medico-Legale de submersorum Morte sine pota Aqua , aliquot Cadaverum sectionibus detectum , &amp; e principiis mechanicis illustratum .
Cui adjicitur Dodecas Observationum circumstantiis curaq ; rarissimarum .
Giessae-Hassorum .
A. MDCCIV .
THis Author having made several Experiments about Drowning , and being dissatisfied with the various Opinions that were held concerning it , was induced to write this present Treatise , in which he relates these following Cases , as Matters of Fact .
Having catch 'd a Cat , ( says he ) and designing to make some sport with her , I took a Board with a hole in the middle , and putting the Tail through , I fastned her very well to it , then put her afloat into the River , and by a String held the Board from being carried down by the rapidity of the Stream ; afterwards I sent in a well mettled Cur after her , who made very pleasant sport ; but the Dog being tired with worrying of the Cat , was sucked into a Whirlpit , sunk down , and never came up again alive .
By the help of a Boat , after an hours search for him , we found him , and then carried him home to Diffect him .
The Abdomen appeared to be a little extended , as did likewise the Stomach and Intestines in a small measure ; but that which was the greatest cause of our wonder , there was no Water found in either of them .
The Lungs were ~ wise extended .
but in no greater a degree than the ~ or Intestines , and looked exactly as those do in Dogs that are hanged .
We made an Incision into the Trachaea , whereupon they sank down immediately .
This at first made a great noise , the Physicians were amazed at it , and , in short , every one much wondred how a Dog could be drowned without Water .
This our Author tells us was the first occasion of his dissenting from the Ancients in Cases of Drowning .
The next Observation he gives us , is of a Countryman , who having been missing for some weeks , was afterwards found drowned in a very shallow place .
The Body being cleaned from Mud , some Livid Spots appeared externally , tho we could not perceive any violence had been used : Then we proceeded to open the Abdomen and Thorax ; in the Abdomen the Intestines appeared to be full , after we had tied up the Gula and Duodenum , that we might more easily judge of the Contents of the Stomach , we took it out , and by the weight of it judged there must needs be a very considerable quantity of Water in it ; neither were we mistaken in the quantity , but upon cutting into it , it appeared to be the Liquor he had been too freely drinking of ; we thought there might be much about the same quantity in the Lungs , by reason of their great extension ; but it happened we were out in our guessing , for no sooner did we cut into the Trachaea , but the Wind rushed out , and the Lungs sunk down that very moment .
Now had I perceived that any violence had been used , I should certainly have concluded that the Person had been killed , and after he was dead was thrown into the River ; but we understood by some present with us , who told us , that they saw the Deceased at a Fair very much in drink ( which was the last time that ever he was seen alive ) and fancied , that in passing over that River ( which he could not avoid ) in his way home , he unfortunately fell in ; and indeed the contents of his Stomach proved what they said to be true .
This Observation did not only throw down the Hypothesis of the Ancients , but made me believe that were ~ in the wrong .
who denied any person to be suffocated under Water , without they find a quantity in the Lungs or Stomach ; it appeared as certain as could be , that this person went into the Water alive , and yet there was no Water found either in the ~ or Substance of the Lungs .
The Liquor he had been too freely drinking of an hour or two before he dyed showed itself plainly in the Stomach and Intestines .
The next Subject the Author tells us of , was a Woman who unfortunately fell into a Well ; after the Body was taken out there appeared several large Contusions , there were two upon each Arm , about the breadth of two Fingers , but longer , which looked as if they had been made with a Stick ; the Blood was extravasated between the Os Bregmatis and Panniculus Carnosus on the Left Side .
There were two Fissures on the Os Frontis , and one on each Orbit of the Eye .
Under the Pia Matter of the Left Side we found some black Grumous Blood ; the Stomach and Intestines were distended , which upon Incision sunk down ; the Lungs were cut into in several places , but not the least drop of Water was found in them .
Now if this Woman did tumble into the Water alive , it 's plain she dyed for want of Respiration ; but if the Fall occasioned her Death , it proves those to be mistaken , who think that Water can get into the Passages after Death .
A man after 5 days search was found standing upright in the bottom of a Fish-pond ; he was carefully taken out and viewed , and not the least mark of any violence appeared .
I my self , with the assistance of a Surgeon , opened the Thorax and Abdomen ; the Intestines were very much distended , and contained in them a whitish Liquor like Chyle : The Stomach was so swelled as induced the Spectators to think it was full of Water ; we tied up both the Orifices , and took it out , that we might more easily measure the Contents : It was so very light , that none but those that handled it could ever have imagined it ; afterwards wards we opened it , and a great blast of Wind rushing out , it sunk down again immediately ; neither was there any more than six ounces of a whitish Liquor in it .
The Lungs were so distended with Wind as to fill up the whole Cavity of the Thorax ; we pricked , and cut into them , but not a drop of Water came from them The Man had the Character of a~ honest harmless Fellow , and therefore could not well be suspected of being murdered , and the posture of his standing made every one conclude that it was the darkness of the Night that occasioned his losing his Way and Life at the same time .
And as we have all the reason in the World to believe that this person was stifled alive under Water , so we may see how fallacious that standing Rule of the Ancients is , who allowed no person to be drowned , without considerable quantities of Water , both in the Lungs , Stomach and Intestines .
After the Author hath given us these Experiments , he proceeds to answer the Objection that was made , of persons recovering by being set upon their Heads ; and afterwards to show why it happens , that in drowned persons the Water is seldom found either in the Lungs or Stomach .
For which we refer you to the Book itself , containing besides twelve uncommon Observations of different Cases .
Printed by Sam .
Smith and Benj .
Walford , Printers to the Royal Society , at the Princes Arms in St Paul 's Churchyard , 1706 .

