III .
An Explanation of the Rule for the finding of Easter .
In a Letter from the Reverend Mr J. Jackman to Dr Hans Sloane , S. R. S. HAving met with several Explanations of the Rule for Easter in our Common-Prayer-Book , and two published among the Transactions of the Royal Society , but none right and sufficient ; and having undoubtedly collected the true sense of the same , by comparing the said Rule and the Table for Easter in the Common Prayer-Book together , I have been persuaded to communicate it to you , in order to be inserted ( if you think fit ) in the next Philosophical Transactions , as here follows .
The Rule is thus worded , viz. Easter-day is always the first Sunday after the first full Moon , which happens next after the one and twentieth day of March .
And if the full Moon happens upon a Sunday , Easter-day is the Sunday after .
For the right understanding of which it is sufficient to observe , 1 .
That the full Moon meant is the 14th day of the Moon , according to the Calendar in the CommonPrayer-Book ( which may be called the Church-Kalendar ) counting that day of the Month for the first of the Moon , which hath the Golden Number of the Year collateral to it in the first column of the said Calendar .
And 2 .
That these words [ next after Mar. 21 .
] are meant inclusively , as if it had been said [ next after the commencement of Mar. 21 .
] so that if the full Moon happens on Mar. 21 .
the same must be the Paschal Now , in order to prove these Observations are both right , and sufficient for the understanding of the Rule , I shall only suppose ( what all Men of Sense and Candour will , and all Maintainers of Rule must , allow ) That if they are necessary and sufficient to reconcile the Rule with the authentic Table to find Easter ( from which Practice never varies ) then are they right and sufficient .
Which being premised , 1 .
I prove that the first Observation is necessary to that end : Because , if the Pascal full Moon be any day before or after the 14th of the Moon by the Church-Kalendar , then the Rule and the Table will clash .
For 1 .
If it be any day before , then as often as the said 14th of the Paschal Moon is a Sunday , that very day , at latest , must be Easter-day by the Rule , as being a Sunday after the full Moon therein meant : Whereas by the Table and Practice it is not till the Sunday after that .
Thus Sunday , Apr. 1 .
this year ( 1705 .
) was the 14th day of the Moon by the Church~Kalendar , and therefore must have been Easter-day ( or after ) by the Rule , if the full Moon therein meant had been any day before the said 14th of the Moon , whereas Easter-day was April 8 .
by the Table , and accordingly observed .
And this obliges us not to understand the true full Moon by the full Moon in the Rule , because that happens about four days before the 14th of the Moon by the Church-Kalendar .
~ .
If the full Moon meant in the Rule be any day after the 14th of the Paschal Moon by the Church-Kalendar , then as often as the said 14th happens to be Saturday , and consequently the full Moon meant in the Rule to be the Sunday following at soonest ( that being the very next day ) that Sunday cannot be Easter-day by the Rule ; whereas by the Table and Practice it is .
Thus Saturday , April 4 .
1702 .
was the 14th day of the Moon by the Church-Khalendar ; and therefore if the full Moon meant in the rule were any day after that , it must have been on Sunday April 5 .
at ~ , consequently April 12 at soonest must have been Easter-day by the Rule ; whereas April 5 .
was Easter-day by the Table and Practick : And this evinces the mistake of those , who make the 15th day of the Moon to be the Full in the sense of the Rule ; as Dr Wallis , Philos. Trans. 240 .
Mr Wright , in his Postscript to his Short View of Mr Whiston 's Chronology .
&amp;c. and the Introductio ad Chronologiam ( Reprinted at Ox ford , A. D. 1704 .
) p 37 .
2 .
I prove the second Observation necessary to the same end ; because a full Moon in the sense of the Rule , ( viz. the 14th day of a Moon by the Church-Kalendar ) often happens on March 21 .
and in that case the Sunday following is always Easter day by the Table and Practice ; whereas it must be a month after by the Rule , unless we understand these words , [ next after March 21 .
] as I explain them .
And this will be the case next year ( 1706 .
) nor doth the proof of this point need the supposition of the foregoing , ( tho ' that may now be fairly supposed , as being already proved : ) for , count you the full Moon how you will , March 22 .
can never be Easter-day by the Rule , unless March 21 .
may be the Paschal full Moon by the same ; and yet March 22 .
is Easter-day by the Table and Practice , as often as the Golden Number is 16 , and the Dominical Letter D. I am aware that this 2d Observation may seem to many forced and unnatural ; and that , perhaps , might induce some to count the 15th day of the Moon for the Full in the Rule , and Mr Thornton , Philos. Trans. 297 , to substitute March 20 .
in Leap-years for March 21 .
neither of which Hypotheses , however , do any service , all things considered .
The former indeed would vacate my second Observation , ( March 21 .
never being the 15th day of the Moon by the Church-Kalendar ) but then it would make the Rule notoriously irreconcilable with the Table and Practice , as hath been already seen .
And , as to Mr Thornton 's Hypothesis , 1 .
The only colour for it ( viz. That at the time of the Council of Nice the Vernal Equinox was March 20 .
in Leap-years , and not March 21 .
as in Common years ) is , for any thing that I know , more likely to be false than true , and doth by no Bbbbbbbbbbbbb means means follow from the Intercalation .
2 .
If this Colour were true , it were too great a nicety to have been probably regarded by the Church .
3 .
This Hypothesis puts more force upon the words of the Rule than mine .
And , lastly , If it were admitted , it would solve the difficulty only in Leapyears , and my second Observation would still remain ne~ , because the case happens as well in Common as in leap-years ; whereof we have an Example in the next year ( 1706 .
) Nor will my second Observation be much boggled at by those that know and consider the inclusive way of reckoning used by the Romans , and from them derived to all the Latin Churches , and particularly that of England ; ~ it is as proper to say [ next after March 21 .
] with the meaning I contend for , as to say , Tertio ( ante ) Calendas , Nonas vel Idus in the sense of the Roman Calendar , or , as to say ( as our Church doth a little after this Rule for Easter ) that Ascension-day is forty days after Easter , intending Easterday itself to be one of those forty .
And it is observable in this very Rule , that , after it had been said , that Easter day is always the first Sunday after the full Moon , &amp;c. it is added , that if the full Moon happens on a Sunday , Easter-day is the Sunday after ; which had been a gross Tautology , if by the first Sunday after the full Moon might not be understood the day of the full Moon itself , when happening to beSunday .
And if the Sunday of the full Moon may be signified by the first Sunday after the full Moon , then the full Moon of March 21 .
may be signified by the full Moon next after March 21 .
3 .
I prove that my two Observations are sufficient to reconcile the Rule and the Table ; because I my self have drawn up a Table to find Easter for ever by the Rule understood according to those Observations , and in the plain and obvious sense in all other respects , and , upon comparing , have found it to agree in every particular with the Table for the same purpose in the Common Prayer Book ; and any body else may make the same trial : which method , if others had taken to examine their Explications of the Rule by , they must have discovered their mistakes .
Stonel eigh-house , Oct. 13 .
1705 .
III .
Part

