II .
Part of a Letter , written to a Most Reverend Prelate , in answer to one written by his Grace , judging of the Age of MSS .
the Style of Learned Authors , Painters , Musicians , &amp;c. By Mr Humfrey Wanley .
London , July 11 .
1701 .
THe substance of what your Grace is pleased to say about Manuscripts and Copied Writings ( as I apprehend it ) is , That it is not only possible , but very easy , upon the perusal of a written Book , to pronounce in what Age or Century it was written , supposing a man to be tolerably well versed in Books of that Language or Country .
And that this judgment may be made , only by observing the Shape and Figure of the Letters of the Book , which ( as all other things ) have their fixed Periods for their Duration : as being formed this way in such a Century , and such a way in the next ; Time only ( which alters the outward state of other things ) working this Change in Letters also , of what Age , Language , or Country soever they be .
And then as to Original Compositions , your Grace is of Opinion , That the Style and Diction of any noted Author being well observed , it is very easy to discover such others of his Works as have gone abroad without his Name ; and also the very time when the Author Lived .
Tis evident , my Lord , that a man may judge of some MSS by the Hand ; and of the Genuine and Spurious Works of some Authors ; and of the time likewise , wherein they lived , by the style of them ; but whether this be so easy a Work , and that the Rules men generally go by in these cases , are always infallible Guides , is what ( I own ) I very much doubt of .
Ffffffffffff Su Suppose , my Lord , for instance , a man should bring to any Antiquary a good MS .
Copy of the Hebrew Bible , Pentateuch , or Psalter , written in a small common Letter , without Points , without fine Knots , and Flourishes , without Pictures , and great Letters , or any thing that should look like Pompous : Suppose that the Ink , Parchment , &amp;c. should carry a seeming face of Antiquity with them , and that a man should say his MS .
was 1000 , 1200 , or 1300 years old , when as really , it was written within a very few years : Could he from the Hand alone soon find out the Cheat ?
All the Hebrew MSS .
that I have as yet seen , are written either with Samaritan or Chaldee Letters .
As to the Samaritan , I own they bear a good resemblance one to another , and that they differ very much from those Samaritan Characters , which we find stamped upon divers truly Ancient and Genuine Coins .
But then there seems to be such a Resemblance ( as to the Character ) between those Coins struck in Ages far distant from one another , that it is hard ( from the Consideration of the Metal , its Fabric , Weight , from the Shapes of the Letters in the Inscription , &amp;c. ) to say which Coin was made in the time of David , or Solomon , and which no older than the time of the Machabees ; this being rather to be gathered from the Words and Meaning of their Inscriptions , than from the Figure of the Characters which Compose them .
The same may be said , in a great measure , of the old Greek , Punic , Roman , British and other Coins .
The Chaldee Character has indeed varied in tract of time , according to the different Fancies and Humours of men .
The Even plain Letter , I think , is the most Ancient .
This they altered into a more neat way of making it , as your Grace finds in R. Stephens Hebrew Bibles .
There is a third fashion , of waving the perpendicular strokes like Rays , as your Grace remembers in some of the Hebrew Coins exhibited in the Prolegomena to the Polyglott Bibles .
Then fourthly , there is a large fat Letter in the MS Rituals and Liturgies , besides the Rabbinical Letters of Italy and Germany , with their Offspring ; the Litterae Coronatae , and perhaps others that I never saw : ( Not to mention here the Jewish Custom of writing the Vulgar Language of the Country wherein they live , with Hebrew Letters .
) It seems a hard matter , my Lord , to trace the Original and Progress of all these ways of Writing , so , as upon the bare sight of a MS .
written in the Hebrew Language of Character , to say , by the shape of the Letters of this Book it appears to be so old : and it seems much more difficult to assign the particular Province or Country wherein each Hebrew Book was written , as for example , in Italy , France , Spain , Portugal , England , Holland , Germany , Poland , Barbary , Persia , India , in the several Provinces of Turkey , &amp;c. The same almost may be said of the Greek Manuscripts , in which Language there has been a great diversity of Writing , according to the different humours of the Scribes , the Fashion then in use , or the Manner of that particular Province , in which such a Book was written .
Nor is it easy ( tho one would be apt to take such Differences for so many Land-marks , ) to tell the Age of a Greek MS .
without the Date ; and I never yet saw such a Date so high as the year 6400 , according to the Greek Computation .
And it is still much harder , from any Remarks about the Character , Illumination , Ink , Parchment , Paper , Binding , &amp;c. to find out what * Country , Province , or Island , such a Greek Book should be written in , or what Country-man * If a man is born in one Country and writes a Book in another , keeping still to the Character and manner of Writing used in his own Country , I look upon it as the same thing as if he wrote it at home .
And therefore I look upon the Greek MSS .
which Angelus Borgecius wrote at Paris , as if they were written in Candy , where he was Born .
And so ( amongst many others ) to instance in a Latin MS , I look upon a Copy of Pope Gregory 's Pastoral Care , ( now remaining in the Bodleian Library ) as a noble Monument of our Saxon Ancestors : Tho St Willibald wrote it , perhaps , at Mount Cassinum in Italy , and afterwards ( as it is probable ) carried it with him into Germany , where it remained at Wurtzburg till that City was plundered by the Swedes about 70 years ago .
Ffffffffffff2 the the ~ Scribe shou 'd be .
Nay , and what does farther add to the Difficulty , is , that it is known that the shapes of the Majuscule Letters found in Greek MSS , have been retained for above 600 years together , with little Variation ; and also , that some MSS .
written with Minuscules and with Accents , are older than some others which want them .
And also , that the present Greek Copistes or Librarij have three or four different Hands commonly used by them , one being their own Common Hand , the others an Imitation of old MSS , which are more beautiful , but troublesome in writing , than their ordinary Running Hands : It being customary , as I have been told , when a man wants a Copy of such a Book to be written , for the Copiste to ask in what Hand it must be written ( for one Hand , itmay be , is more Costly than another ; ) and according as they agree , the Book is written .
And thus I have seen some very new Things written in the same Hand with Books which are certainly 400 years old .
~ Now this may in some measure be done by Latin MSS .
because there are greater plenty of them .
For even I , by exactly observing the nature of the Character , &amp;c. of these MSS .
whose Country I was sure of , have afterwards been enabled to say , that this Book looks as if it had been written in France , Italy , Spain , Germany , the Netherlands , England , Ireland , &amp;c. and , it may be , about such a time .
What Methods Learned Men have taken , in order to inform themselves of the different Ages of MSS , I know not , but my own has been this .
I have been careful to get all the Dates I could , wherein it was said that such an individual MS was written , at such a time , or by such a particular person ; every Book with a Date , being as a Standard whereby to know the Age of those Books of the same or a like Hand , and of those that are not very much older or newer .
Where Dates have been wanting in some Books , perhaps they have had some Succession of Emperors , Kings , Popes , Bishops , or other Officers ; and setting down the continuance of their Predecessors for so many years , months , and days , if there be only the naked Name of him who is the last in order , ( all other Circumstances concurring , ) I then judge the Book to have been written during the Life or Reign of such a person .
Especially if that Succession be afterwards continued by a more recent Hand , or that there be two such Successions , as of Kings and Bishops , and the last of each happen to be Contemporaries .
Other Observations I have made from Historical Notes and Ecclesiastical Tables , in some Books .
At other times I light upon some Authentic Charter or Original Writing , in the same Hand with such a Book as I have remembred to have formerly seen , but without any guess at the Age of it .
The Age of the Charter being known , that of the Book is then-known also : for I never entertained any Notion , or relied upon any Observation , but as I found it confirmed by the Suffrage of concurring Circumstances , and sufficient Authority .
But even in Dates , I have found that a man ought to be very Cautious ; for some have been altered by later Hands , for corrupt and base Ends .
Some are so worded , as when one thinks that the time they mention , is the time when the MS .
was finished by the Copiste , or Bookwriter ; it is meant only as to the time when the Author finished his Composition .
Other Books are Post-dated that they might be accounted New .
Of this last kind , is a Greek MS .
I saw in the University Library at Cambridge , which , as appears by a written Annotation therein , was bought such a year at Rome , for so much ; and yet the Date pretends that the Book was written at Rome in such a year , which happens to be two years after it was bought and paid for .
The Reason of these Post-Dates was , because , before Printing came up , a Book was by how much the Newer , by so much the more Valuable .
An old Book might be bought for an old Song , ( as we say ) but he that transcribed a fresh Copy must be paid for his pains .
And therefore , I have found in some Catalogues of the MSS .
formerly extant in our Abbey-Libraries , that when they said such a Book was Liber Vetus , they would often add , &amp; inutilis ; but Liber Novus was Nitidus , eleganter scriptus , tus , lectu facilis , &amp;c. which mean Opinion of the Ancient Copies , by the way , may have been the Occasion of the Loss of many a good Author .
The Librarii or Book-writers were from the time of the Romans a particular company of then , and their Business a Trade : But tho Book-writing was their profession , yet they afterwards had but a third part of the business .
Learning ( after the Erection of Monasteries , ) was chiefly in the hands of the Clergy ; and they were for the most part Regulars , and lived in Monasteries .
Amongst these were always many industrious men , who wrote continually new Copies of old Books , for their own use , or for the Monastery , or for both ; which seems to have swallowed up above half the business .
Then , if an extraordinary Book was to be written , for the standing , and more particular Use of the Church or Monastery , the Antiquarius must be sent for , to write it in large Characters , after the old manner , and such a Copy they knew would last for many Ages , without Renovation .
Between these two sorts of People , the Writing-Monks and Antiquarii ; the poor Librarij or common Scriptores ( who had Families to maintain ) could hardly earn their Bread .
This put them upon a quicker way of dispatch , that so they might underfell one another : And in order to this Dispatch , they would employ several persons , at one time , in writing the same Book , ( each person , except him who wrote the first Skin , beginning where his Fellow was to leave off : ) Or else , they would form the Letters smaller and leaner , and make use of more Jugations and Abbreviations than usually others did .
And this , my Lord , is the only account that I can give , for that Variety of Hands which in former Ages , being learned of , or borrowed from the Romans , was commonly used , and in fashion at the same time , and in the same Country , ( throughout these Western Parts of Europe , ) and for their growing less and less for one Age after another .
An Instance of this may be given from the Hands of England , which about the year of our Lord 730 was of three sorts .
I. The Roman Capitals , still retained , and kept up by the Antiquarij , in some Books and Charters .
II .
The more Set Saxon Letters ( which have a near affinity with the more Ancient Irish Characters , as being with them derived from the Roman , ) which were used as the Common Hand of the Age , by the Monks in their Books and some Charters of their Dictating and Writing .
III .
The Running Saxon Letters , fuller of Abbreviations , and something of kin to the Longbardic and Franco-Gallic , ( both which , with this third sort , were also of Roman Original , ) and was used by these Librarij in their Books and in the Charters ; as also by some Authors who wrote much , as Bed , &amp;c. There was another sort of Bookwriters still in use , namely , the Notarij , whose business it was to take Trials and Pleadings at Courts of Judicature ; to write as Amanuenses from the mouth of an Author ; and to take Homilies and Sermons at Church , from the Mouth of the Preacher .
These Notarij made use of Notae or Marks instead of Letters : But when , in Process of Time , Letters were usually written small and quick , and Abbreviations grew Common , the Notarij were turned off , unless they would write Books in Long Hand , as other Librarij did , and their Notae grew out of use ; and most of their Performances in Notes or Marks have been since destroyed .
Suppose then , my Lord , that a man had one Latin Book of each of the four sorts above-mentioned laid before him , written all at a time , and without any Date or Note of the Age : Would not he be ready to say that the three first were older than one another ?
As that that in Capitals was older than that in the Middling Hand ; and this again older than that in the Running and smaller Hand ?
and that such a Book written in the Notae being all full of marks , was not Latin , but of some other unknown known Language ?
But to come down later ; Suppose that a person should have some recenter Books or Charters laid before him in the Pipe , Text , Exehequer , Chancery , Court , and Common Hands , all written at the same time , would not he be apt to say , that one seemed to him to be older than another , and that they were the Hands of several Nations ?
If it be difficult for an Inquisitive Person to be a perfect Master in all the Successions of Hands , that have been used in his own Country , so far as he may be guided by the Monuments therein extant , ( and I never heard of any Man that was such a Master ) surely , it must be more difficult to pronounce the Age of those Books , from the Hand , which were written in other Countries , in an unknown Language .
And what may make a Man yet more liable to mistakes ( besides the want of Dates in the most Ancient Greek , Latin and other MSS ) was the Practice of many Writers , still to Use the very same Hand when in Years , as they learnt when they were Young ; like as many Ancient People , who do yet continue to write the Roman and Secretary Hands , which were more fashionable 50 or 60 years ago , than now .
I forbear to trouble your Grace with any more Words upon this head , on to make mention of the different ways of Writing in any other Language : because I find this Letter will prove larger than I intended .
I will therefore ( with your Grace 's leave ) touch upon the next Head in your Graces Learned Essay , showing the great Easiness of finding out an Author , and the Time he lived in , by his Style and Phrase .
I wish , my Lord , that it was as easy to discover the Villainous Authors of some Treasonable and Scandalous Libels , by their Style , as it has been to find out the Printers , by the Paper and Letter .
Could this be done , it might not be unuseful to the Government .
But People have learnt the knack of changing their Style , upon Occasion , so Artificially , as not to be discovered , but when they themselves are willing to be known .
Who would have thought that Erasmus wrote the Epistolae obscurorum Virorum ?
Or that some of the Nicer , nay , the most Eminent Modern Critics could have been imposed upon by their familiar and near Acquaintance , who trump 'd upon them their own recent Performances for invaluable fragments of the Ancients , whose other works these very Critics had lying before them ?
It has been a frequent Practice in all Ages for poor Scribblers to father their wretched Offspring upon Illustrious Persons : and the disparity between the Genuine works of the one , and the Spurious pieces of the other being evident enough , it has been easy to distinguish between the Gold and the Brass .
But , my Lord , I would humbly ask this Question , Is all that is even now by learned men ascribed to some Ancient Voluminous Greek and Latin Authors , undoubtedly theirs ?
May not there still some supposititious pieces lurk among them , which have the luck to be received , only because they have been more ingeniously counterfeited ?
Nay , may not the same person in the course of his Life , even alter and vary his Style and Phrase unwittingly , and without any design to do so ?
I think Mr Richardson somewhere in his Answer to Amyntor , upon occasion of the difference in point of Style between the Revelation of St John and his other Works , between the Prophecy of Jeremiah and his Lamentations , does tell us from Dr Cave , that the consideration of the Times when a man writes , or of the Persons to whom , or the Subjects about which , or the Temper of Body , or the Humour he is in when he writes , or the Care and Pains that he takes in Writing , may Occasion such Alterations in his Style , as that no certain Rule can be inferred from thence .
And if , my Lord , it was really possible to find out the Time when an Author lived , only by diligent Reading his Works , surely the World wou 'd have been long since Agreed as to the Time when Homer lived , though they Gggggggggggg could could not tell where he was born .
And I believe even in the List of Ecclesiastical Writers there are some , and those not of the least consideration , who ( notwithstanding their Works have been read over and over ) are still reckoned to be of uncertain Age .
As for Pictures , though I have much less Experience in them , than I had once in MSS .
yet I will not deny but that the Works of an hundred Masters ( besides those your Grace has been pleased to mention ) may be known by the Hands , tho they may be almost as different as their several Hands in Writing : But that one Painter ca n't Copy from another , so exactly , as that in tract of time it shall not be known which Picture is the Original , is what I dare not assert .
It has been frequently practised by Painters to borrow Pictures of those who are Lovers and Judges of such things , to Copy them , and to return their Copies for the Originals , without any discovery made by the discerning Owners .
And I believe it possible ( tho exceeding difficult ) for a great Master to Copy a Picture so , that when they both stand together , a good Judge shall not dare positively to say which is the Copy and which not : Nor he that drew the Original , dare to own , that he could imitate his own Handywork better than a Stranger has done .
There are a great many stories common among Painters , to this purpose .
And one wou 'd not think it much more difficult , for a Man to imitate a Drawing or Picture , than to counterfeit another Mans Hand-writing , which some People can do most exactly .
And others with Pen and Ink will Copy after any thing that is Printed so nicely , as that one would affirm their Writing to be printed off at the Press .
Your Grace 's Notions of discerning the Age as well as the Hand of the Painter , by his Picture , is very curious , and altogether new to me : And I doubt not but there is a great deal in it .
I only want the whole Works of some great Painter , with an Account of the time when he wrought each Piece , to fit me for the making the Experiment .
And why might not this Notion be advanced a little farther , and the Painter 's Complexion be known by his Pictures , as well as his Age ?
As supposing that the Sanguine do naturally run upon Pourtraits , Poetical Histories , Nudities , &amp;c. The Choleric upon Battel-pieces , Seafights , Fire-pieces by Land or Sea , Tempests , &amp;c. The Plegmatick upon the Still-life , Flower-pieces , Birds , Beasts , Fishes , &amp;c. and the Melancholic upon Landskips , Architecture , Pieces of Perspective , &amp;c. Not but that the different Genius of a Country , or the Desires of a good Customer , may oblige a Painter to work upon a subject , which he had no great Fancy for .
As to the difference in the works of Painters grown old , in respect of what they did when young , I doubt no certain Rules can be Established as to their Performances in that kind .
I know , my Lord , that Painters do generally live faster than other men , which may at length occasion a failure in their Sight and Memory , a trepidation in their Hands , &amp;c. And yet I never heard that Michael Angelo , Alb .
Durer , Titian , and others , painted worse at the latter end of their long lives , than they did before .
Nay , I hear that Signior Verrio , tho grown old , Paints now far better than ever , and is grown almost ashamed of some of his own Works which he Painted at Windsor-Castle in the time of K. Charles II .
There may be this in it , that Aged Persons having attained , thro long Practice , to a greater Experience , to a more Solid and Mature Judgment than they had when younger , are more Cautious of that which they let go out of their Hands ; and correct those flashy touches of their Pencil , and other superfluous Irregularities , which they and others were formerly very fond of .
As for the Flame and Motion of the Eyes in a Picture , or the Breath in its Mouth , I can say but little , having as yet Gggggggggggg~ never never had the happiness to see such Rarities , tho I have been admitted to the sight of some of the best Pieces of the most Celebrated Masters .
As to the Painters Painting a Living or Moving thing , so that one shall almost discern the Motion , and see the Bird Flying , the Horse or Hound Running , &amp;c. that is more easy , especially when assisted with the friendly and pregnant fancy of the Charmed Spectator .
In the Still life indeed , the Eye is quickly deceived , and tho there are , I believe , several Masters now living more Excellent at it than ever Zeuxis and Parrhasius were ; yet still , with all their Art , it is very difficult to impose upon a man so , as to make him believe it is not a Picture , but the very Life that he sees before him .
Musicians seem to be under the same Predicament with Painters , since they are observed to live Fast , as also the Poets .
It is by the Practice of many years that they attain to a just Knowledge and Mastery in their respective Arts ; and as their first Compositions are little and light , suitable to the Mercurial temper of heedless and inconstant Youth ; So , in time , this wears off , and as their Experience and Judgment increases , their Compositions grow more solid and sound .
A Young Man may make a better Minuet or Jigg , but the Elder a more sound Service or Anthem .
The Music of the former ( with other Accomplishments ) may go a great way towards the enticing a foolish Girl to Love ; but that of the latter Excites the Devotion , moves the Affections , and raises the Pastions of those truly Religious Souls , who take pleasure in singing praises to the Honour and Glory of his name , who lives for ever and ever .
If your Grace shall say , that the very best Painters , Musicians and Poets dyed young , or at least before they attained to an advanced Age , when they would have failed or grown dull , as others did : I must beg leave to say that Old Men are of two sorts , either those who are much affected with their Age and weakned , or those who are not .
If a Man be born of unsound Parents , or hath lived all along in an Air disagreeable to his Constitution , or has his Constitution always unhealthful , or has lived an intemperate or debauched Life , or has been crushed by any heavy Misfortunes , or always lived in Poverty or Discontent ; it is no wonder , if in spight of all this , he attains to old Age : but then he will probably lose the Clearness of his Head , the fixed Attention of his Mind , the Brightness of his Parts , which he might be formerly noted for .
If a Man has never had any of these disadvantages to wrestle with , but has all along been blessed with the Contrary : then , he being bred up to a profession , and always following it , his judgment therein still increases , and his Hand ( one would think ) should be more nimble and ready , and the Man a better Painter , Musician or Orator than ever : And why not a better Poet too ?
I say , with submission , my Lord , if Mr Dryden ( tho he was said to be unhealthy at last ) wou 'd have taken as much pains , or had been Allowed time to his Mind for revising his later Poems , as in some of-his former , they might have been as well , if not better accepted .
I do n't see that it is old Age that does a Man this diskindness , but rather , that'tis the Accidents that do too often attend it , which yet many are freed from to the very last .
Suppose then , my Lord , if Raphael or Vandike , or the late Mr H. Purcell , or Alessandro Stradella , should have continued their Practice of Painting and Music till they grew old , from the Accidents attending which , suppose them ( as a great many other People ) to be very free ; might we not then have justly expected from them , even greater Wonders than they had ever before performed ?
I wo n't say that an old General is fitter to be trusted than a young one ; or that the late Maresohat Schomberg at his death , was a better Soldier ( notwithstanding his Age ) than the Present Kings of Sweden and Poland : But rather , that the Study of Divinity , or of the Laws , do seem as nice and large as those of Painting and Music .
Now the old and sage Men of those Professions are every where most regarded , they are found to have the ripest Judgments , and they are deservedly employed in the most weighty Affairs appertaining to their Professions .
And it has been seen ( as was partly said before ) that some Painters and Musicians have not at all failed as they grew old , but kept that great Reputation to the last , which they had before acquired .
My Lord , upon the whole , it seems to me ( tho I know my Opinion is of no weight ) that there is a gradual and sensible alteration in the appearance of things , and especicially in the Scripture or Hand-writing of MSS .
Now these ought to be considered with respect to the particular places wherein they were written .
Every Country is supposed to have remaining in it , the greatest Variety and most considerable Monuments of its own Characters ; unless they are known to be carried away to other places .
And therefore , if any man be desirous of considering the Letters of any Language that has been confined to any one particular Region or Province ; it is but going thither , and it 's ten to one , but ( if he be diligent ) he may satisfy his Curiosity very well .
For Example , Suppose I should be willing to consider the Nature of the Irish Letters , their Original , Progress and Variations , with their Relation to the Roman , Franco &amp; AngloSaxon : this might be done by travelling Ireland principally , by taking a trip into the Scotch Highlands , and perhaps into the Isle of Man , and by consulting some English and other Libraries , whither some Irish MSS have been carried .
If I would consider the French , Italian , Spanish , or English Hands , each Country affords sufficient Helps .
But if a Man would consider the Letters of a Dead or Living Language , which spread far , and has been , or is used in several Countries : he ca n't be supposed a perfect Master in all the ways of writing that Language , till he has considered the whole State and Succession of its Letters in each of those Countries : Amongst those Languages I reckon the Hebrew , Arabic , Turkish , Armenian , Persian , Greek , Latin , Teutonic , Sclavonian , &amp;c. And tho Latin is common amongst us , and every body is pronouncing the Age of a Latin MS , yet I think they would do well to enquire where as well as when a Book was written .
And if they are certain that such a Latin Book was written in such a particular Country , or Province , it is then more easy , by considering the Succession of Letters used in that Province , or by comparing it with other Books written therein , to say how old it is .
For want of this consideration many Learned Persons have been almost always out in their Calculations , and have pronounced at Random .
If then , my Lord , this Method appears Rational , and even Necessary , in order to attain a sufficient Measure of this sort of Knowledge ; it follows , that it is no easy matter to assign the Age even of a Latin MS , no , not even in England , where yet I suppose there may be as great a Variety of Latin Hands , as in most other Countries .
As for Painting and Music , they are Arts that I have always had a great Love and Affection for .
I know very well that each Painters Hand and each Musicians Manner differs from another , but whether there is a gradual and remarkable Variation from themselves in the Course of their Lives , is what I never heard asserted .
This is certain , that they can change their way of Painting and Composing at pleasure ; and therefore , Mr H. Purcel 's Dulcibella is said not to be like his other Music ; and Mr Fuller the Painter could put one of this Pieces upon Sir Peter Lely for a most incomparable Picture of Mich. Angelo .
But then these Changes and Variations from their usual Manners are very seldom made .
And a man generally pursues and practices that which is most agreeable to his own Genius .
For this Reason , when a Painters Hand is fixed , his Manner is then limited , and so when a Curious Person comes into a Gallery , he knows that this Picture was done by Ryley , Kneller , Vandyke , Dobson , Tintoret , &amp;c. and that to be a Copy after Reubens , Georgeon , Salv .
Rosa , Han .
Caraccio , Pietro di Cortona , &amp;c. When he comes to an Opera , to a Consort , or to Church , not knowing before-hand what music is to be performed , yet he may soon discern that it was composed by Corelli , Baptist , Bassani , Charissimi , Blow , Purcell , &amp;c. And so upon Reading an Ancient Author , a sagacious and learned Person may find , that he writes according to the manner of such an Age , that the Style imitates such another , or that the Book , tho it bears such a Man 's Name , yet might , perhaps , be more truly ascribed to another , with whose Style it more exactly agrees : As for Example , that Piece of S. Cyril 's , published from the Escurial MS .
by Barthasar Corderius , is thought ( by reason of the Analogy in point of Style ) to be Origen 's : But then , whether all this can be always done , done easily and without Errors , is the doubt .
And it seems yet a greater difficulty , certainly to discover how old the Painter , Musician , Poet , Orator , or other Author was , when he finished any one piece of his Works , unless a man is plainly told so : This being a sort of Knowledge , that those who have been otherwise sufficiently experienced in their several Arts and Professions , have not as yet pretended to .

