II .
A Letter from Mr Samuel Dale to Mr Edward Lhwyd , Keeper of the Ashmolean Repository in Oxford , concerning Harwich Cliff , and the Fossil Shells there .
Braintree , Feb. 1703 .
SIR , THat I have been so long before I answered your kind Letters , I shall only offer one reason in excuse , which is my being desirous of making another Tour to Harwich , &amp;c. before I wrote , that I might accompany this with some Fossils , and make my observations more perfect : The account therefore you desire , take as follows .
Harwich Cliff is a sort of Promontory , which divides Orwel Haven from the AEstuarium contained between that and Walton Nase ; it is scituate on the Southern part of the Town , about a quarter of a mile distant or not so much , and contains many acres of Land .
The height of it from the Strand or Beach to the top , where its highest is 40 or 50 foot .
~ At the bottom of this Cliff , there is a Stratum of Clay about a foot thick , which is succeeded by another of Stone for a foot more ; in this Stratum of Stone are imbedded divers Shells ( though but thinly ) as well of the Turbinate as Bivalve kind , and also pieces of Wood and Sticks , as you may observe by the Fragments thereof , which I have sent you .
Over this are divers Strata of blueish Clay , of which you have also a Sample about the height of 20 foot or more ; this Clay hath Pyrites or Copperas Stones sticking in it , but no Shells that I could observe .
Above this are likewise divers Strata , which reach to within about two foot of the Surface , some of which are only of fine Sand , other small Stones and Gravel mixed with fragments of Shells , of which I likewise sent you a specimen , and in others small Pebbles are mixed ; and it is in some of these last mentioned Strata , that the Fossil Shells are imbedded , which lye promiscuously together , I mean the Bivalve or Turbinate ; neither do the Strata 's with the Shells observe any order in their lying , being sometimes higher and sometimes lower in the Cliff ; and sometimes 2 or 3 one above another with other Strata 's of Sand , Fragments and Gravel between .
Above all these is a covering of common Sandy Earth , which is about 2 foot thick , in which , in some places are Veins of a Species of Osteocolla , tho more tender than Osteocolla Officinarum , which is brought from Germany : This I have adventured to call Osteocolla Anglicana , it doth incrust about small Strings like the Fibres of the Roots of Trees it 's of divers magnitudes , and sends forth Branches here and there , but is so tender , as not to be gotten out of the Earth in any large pieces .
Whether like the German it appears above the Earth , I never could discover .
Before this Cliff , the Shore , as far as the ebbing of the Sea would permit my observation , was rudely paved with Stones , divers of which are veined with that sort of Body , which by Helmont and other later Naturalists , is called Ludus Paracelsi : Of these Stones the Inhabitants have a tradition that they are formed by the Clay , which tumbling down from the Cliff , and being washed by the flowing of the Sea , are in a short time converted into Stone ; and the ingenious Mr Silas Tailor in his Manuscript Collections of Harwich and Dovercourt , ( a Copy of which I have ) thus writes concerning it .
The Washing of these Cliffs discovers a blueish Clay , which tumbling down upon the Shore , altho washed by the Sea at High-water , within a short Nnnnnnnnn time time turns into Stone : There they may be seen , some that are new fallen as soft as the Clay in the Cliff , and others that have lain there longer crusted over and hard , but if opened or broke .
the Clay still soft in the middle ; others that have lain longest petrisied to the very heart , and with these the Walls of the Town are for the most part built , and the Streets generally are pitched .
How far this is matter of fact I will not determine , my stay at Harwich being always too short for me to make observations so critical as this phenomenon doth deserve ; and altho I must at the same time own that many of the Stones are washed out from the Stratum at the bottom of the Cliff , yet I have sometimes been inclined to Mr Tayler 's opinion , because he lived long upon the Spot , being Store-keeper of the Kings Building yard for many years , and by his Collections , &amp;c. seems to be a person of Probity and Learning : and also because divers of the said Stones have cracks or chops in them , as Clay and Earth will have by being exposed to the Sun ; and there is yet [ Anno 1702 .
] lying upon that Shore a Stone , in which a large pile ( perhaps of Oak ) such as was formerly made use of there to preserve the Cliff from the injuries of the Sea , doth evidently appear to be imbedded ; which can owe its situation to no other Original , than by being pressed into the superficies of the Clay while soft , and petrifying with it , which being square , takes off an objection which some might make had it been round , of its being lodged there in the general Deluge .
I am not insensible that this manner of Petrification is not only different from the common methods Nature uses in that operation , but also thwarts the opinions of divers Learned and Ingenious men , and it was strenuously opposed by the Reverend Mr John Morton of Oxendon in Northamptonshire ; when we , together with Mr John Luffkin , an Apothecary of Colchester , were upon the place ; the substance of which discourse he wrote down , and afterwards at my request sent me , together with his thoughts of Petrifications , which perhaps will not be unacceptable to you , and therefore I shall transcribe it from his Letter , dated August 4th , 1699 .
At Harwich , under the Cliff , upon the Sea-shore , there is a Stratum of a Clayie-Stone , which is covered here and there with ragged Stones of a closer texture , which was formerly ( I conjecture ) another entire Stratum , but is broken thus by the Tearing of the Waves .
The Clayie-Stone Stratum , Mr Dale and Mr Luffkin my Companions were of opinion had been formerly a softer substance , but was daily petrisied by the Sea WaterHaving argued a little about it , when turning to the Cliff , I found a Stratum there , of the very same sort of Clayie-Stone with that upon the Shore ; yet the Sea water very seldom comes up hither , unless by Storms and at Spring tides .
I broke a little piece off , and showed it to you , and then you was convinced ( I think ) it was not hardned or petrified by the Sea water , but in its natural state .
And I have often , I assure you , met with just such sort of Stone in many of our Stone-pits here , in Inland Countries .
It appears to me , that the Water should have rather foftned than hardned the Stone upon the Shore , tho by washing away the looser Clayie matter and other Earthy stuff , that is sometimes left upon it at the ebb , it might seem to be a sort of Petrification , and occasion this mistake .
As to Petrifactions : I 've only observed these three sorts .
Ist , A Stony Incrustation upon Sticks and any thing that lies in the way , in the Petrifying Springs ; the Earth in those Waters is usually intermixt with particles of Stone , that trickle down into it with the Water , and are there detained .
Of this first sort you have doubtless many instances in Essex , and I think there is one at Harwich Cliff ; tho this in my opinion is not so properly called a Petrifaction .
2dly , The second sort is that which is performed by the Permeation or incinnation of the finer sorts of Stony Particles , as it is in the case of some of our Petrifying waters , ( I believe ) particularly that at Knaresborough sometimes ; the Stony particles Nnnnnnnnn2 how however of the Knaresborough Spring are very fine .
And many of the Fossil-shells have undergone the same fate .
3dly , The third , which indeed is a Petrification , properly so called , is often met with on the sides of Caves and Grotto 's , as at Pooly-hole in the Peak , and in the Fissures , and Clests of Mines and Quarries .
Of this kind are the several sorts of Fluors , the Lap .
Stillatitii , Stalagmitae , &amp;c. that we meet with in the Fissures , and Hiatus 's of the Earth .
These are continually growing ( as they vulgarly say ) that is , are receiving an additional increase of real and solid Stone , as is observed in many Caves in the Peak , &amp;c. This I take to be performed in such a manner as the Incrustations are , viz. the particles of Stone are brought along with the Water as their Vehicle , and are deposited at length upon the sides of the Cave or Fissure , ( this is matter of fact , that there is always a watery Stream , and usually Water a trickling down upon the sides of those Caves : ) but here , the particles of stone are extremely minute and fine , and do thereby naturally concrete and join together very close ; whereas in our Incrustations the particles of Stone being grosser , the Stone is rough , and course , and friable .
And this I leave to your Judgment if it be not a more reasonable Hypothesis , than that of Dr Plot in page .
33 of his History of Oxsordshire , viz. That the very body of the Water is turned into Stone as it drops down from the Rocks .
I know not indeed of any other sorts of Petrification than these I have already mentioned .
As to that Hypothesis of the Transmutation of a Stratum , e. g. of Chalk to Clay , of Coal to common Stone , or the like , I must confess I never met with any thing in Nature which would countenance it , that is , such a Transmutation in the Bowels of the Earth .
Nor is there any thing thing that proves it , that ever I have met with in any Natural Observations .
Only some will guess and fancy such a thing , but for making it out , I am sure I am no more able to do it , than to make the Philosophers Stone , whatever they are .
Thus I have freely given you my thoughts of these things A late Author is of opinion , that this Bed of Stones was the Foundation of the Loamy Cliff , where the Cliff has been washed away or cut : And that they are the Production of a Vitrioline juice in conjunction with the Loam ; as the common Copperas Stones are by the same Juice in a Gravel , and that the latter were only to be found where the Cliff was gravelly , and not where the Loam is .
How far these Stones are the effect of a Vitrioline Juice , I will not determine , but this I can affirm , that I have now by me some of the Pyrites or common Copperas Stones , which I did pick out of the Clayie Stratum of this Cliff , in which they may be frequently met with , as mentioned in its description .
Nor do I remember at any time to have observed these Stones to be invested with either Gypsum or Trichitis , as the same Author affirms , but with the aforesaid Ludus Paracelsi , and some other sorts of Lap .
Stalagmitae frequently .
How those Shells or Marine Bodies came to be here posited , is a Subject , which hath employed the Heads and Pens of divers learned and ingenious men , and your self being engaged in the controversy , I shall not pretend to say any thing thereof , lest I should be thought like Phormio to treat of the Art of War before Hannibal , only crave leave to make some remarks on the positive assertion of the aforesaid Author , concerning the imbedding of these Fossil Shells in this Cliff , and the alteration of the Channel , viz. That this Bed of Shells , which covers the Cliff , was carried thither at the making of the Harbour or clearing of it .
For the Harbour or Channel there is artificial and of no old date , the Current having been formerly on the other side of Languard Fort , which then stood in Essex .
Against the first part of which , altho many reasons might be given to prove the contrary , I shall only trouble you with the following , and as our Author begs the Question , How else could the Shells lye a top of this Cliff ?
So I shall also ask him , why the same Strata of Sand , and Fragments of Shells , with the same Fossils imbedded , are to be found at Walton Ness on the other side of the AEstuarium , which is 5 or 6 miles broad from Harwich , as likewise at Bawdfey Cliff in Suffolk , which is 8 or 9 miles distant , and in other Cliffs on that Shore , where I have met with them .
A second Question may here be asked How it comes to pass that none of those Buccina Heterostropha , ( whereof such plenty of their Exuviae are in all the Cliffs hereabouts ) are not now to be found in this Channel , nor the adjacent Seas ?
( where I have divers times been a fishing ) for I cannot think the clearing this Harbour could have destroyed all that species of Shell-Fish , whereof there was then such plenty ; and therefore some other Original must be allow 'd them , than what this Author has assigned .
Nor can I allow the Harbour here to be Artisicial ; because so great a work as this is , viz. the making a Channel 2 miles wide , as it is in this place , would not have been without some Record thereof in History , and besides , the Earth , &amp;c. which must arise by this work , must consequently have made a much greater Hill than the Cliff ever was ; and another doubt will from hence arise , why the Workmen should bring all the Earth , &amp;c. to this side the Channel , and not lay some thereof on the other , as it 's plain they did not .
The ground on which Landguard Fort stands , as far as Walton Coleness , which is about 3 miles , is only a Sandy Level or Beach , which I believe hath in time subsided there , as may be observed at the mouths of other great Rivers .
And as to the Argument which our Author brings ' of Landguard Fort being accounted to stand in Essex , to confirm his Hypothesis of the change of this Channel , it will be of no force with any one which doth but observe , that not only parts of Parishes , but likewise of Counties , are often divided from those Parishes and Counties to which they belong , and included in others , of which I could give you many instances , e. g. a part of Kent is on the Essex side the Thames ; and in Oxfordshire the Parishes of Shilton doth belong to Berkshire , Daylesford to Warwickshire , Compton to Gloucestershire , and Stratton Audley to Buckinghamshire , altho all included in the other : And there is a Farm which doth belong to this Parish of Braintree , that is separated from it at least 2 miles , and many others might be given , but let these suffice .
And to me a probable reason of this Forts being accounted in Essex , is , the Sands here subsiding , made at first , I suppose , an Insula , which being nearest to Essex was accounted of that County ; or 2dly , the Island so made belonging to none but the Crown , it was at the pleasure of the Kings Officers to call it of which County they pleased .
Nor was it the Gentleman in Cambden 's ignorance ( whatever this .
Author saith ) that made him mention these Stones for Petrifactions made by the Sea , for Mr Tailor in his aforesaid Collections did not omit the tradition the Inhabitants of this Town have about the alteration of the Mouth of this Haven , which I will transcribe in his own words .
It 's generally believed that Stoure did formerly in a straighter current ( than now it doth ) discharge it self into the Sea about Hoasley-bay , under the High-land of Walton-Colness and Felix-Stow in the County of Suffolk , betwixt whom and Landguard Fort are ( as they are reputed ) certain remains of the old Channel , which the neighbouring Inhabitants still call Fleets , retaining at this day the tradition of the course of the Water , and the entrance into this Haven to have heretofore been by and through them .
And I am of opinion that this Tradition is matter of fact , having before hinted to you what mutations the Mouths of great Rivers daily undergo by the lodgment of Sands , &amp;c. which may be assigned as a better reason for this alteration than that of our Author , i. e. that it was Artificial ; and the yearly washing of the Cliff on the Harwich side , doth likewise add to its probability ; it being a constant observation , that where the Sea gains eth on one side it loses on the other .
And that this level was so made I am confirmed by the modern removal of the Fort , more towards the point , more Sands , I conjecture , being added after the old Fort was built : This alteration is taken notice of by the aforesaid Mr Tailor in these words .
And altho several now living pretend to the remembrance of the building it ; [ Landguard Fort ] yet we find there was an ancienter Fort thereabouts , and called by the same name [ Anno 1553 .
] which was not far distant from this modern one , a little North of it , where are yet to be seen two Faces and Flankers of a Bastion , the rest of it being eaten away by the Sea , but in its place hath left upon the Shore a long row of Sand Banks .
The Spring mentioned by the Ingenious Mr Edmund Gibson in his English Edition of Cambden , from the aforesaid Manuscript of Mr Silas Tailor , is a very small inconsiderable thing ; nor could I observe that it did petrifie or incrustate either pieces of Wood or Sticks , but I have a piece , which I broke off from a large Pile upon that Shore , which was petrified so far as it was driven into the Earth , and the Sea Water came ; and do suspect there yet remains some others of the same .
And of this sort I believe , is that large piece sent from hence , which Mr Tailor mentions to be reserved in the Repository of the Royal Society .
I have already taken notice , that the Fossil Shells are imbedded in a loose Stratum of Sand , Gravel , &amp;c. which may serve to demonstrate that their Matrix is not a Clay bed upon the top of the Cliff ; as likewise for another Argument to evince that they could not be there scattered by Crows , Gulls , and other Sea Fowls , as well as that some of them are likewise bedded in Stone at the bottom of the Cliff ; and altho some few of them may be met with upon the top of the Cliff , yet it 's only where the Earth has been broken by digging of Ditches , &amp;c. And now I think it time to close this Letter , left I should quite tire your patience with its length ; and shall only add a Catalogue of the Fossils by me found at this Cliff ; after I have subscribed my self , Sir , Your obliged humble Servant , S. Dale .
1 .
Buccinum fossile heterostrophum rostratum laevem maximum Listeri referens .
2 .
Buccinum fossile rostratum maximum Listeri referens .
3 .
Buccinum fossile minus ventricosum mucrone obtuso .
4 .
Buccinum fossile tenue minus ponderosum , striatum &amp; undatum 5 .
Buccinum fossile tenue confragosum .
6 .
Buccinum fossile strijs prominulis marginalibus insignitum .
7 .
Buccino-turben fossile reticulatum minus .
8 .
Buccino-turben fossile Sulcatum .
9 .
Buccino-turben fossile rostratum .
10 .
Buccino-turben maximum rostratum fossile Spiris intus Strijs elatis insignitis .
11 .
Cochlea fossilis maxima umbilicata quinque Spirarum .
12 .
Cochlea fossilis umbilicata mucrone obtuso .
13 .
Nerita parva fossilis .
14 .
Turbo fossilis Spiris duabus Strijs eminentibus insignitis 15 .
Pecten minor fossilis unica aurita .
16 .
Auricularia maxima .
17 .
Pectunculus fossilis fere circinatus Strijs tenuibus , valvis per ginglymon connexis .
Ooooooooo 18 .
Pectun 18 .
Pectunculus fossilis crassus rostro acuto Strijs majoribus .
19 .
Pectunculus fossilis fascijs transversis undautibus noratis .
20 .
Pectunculus vulgaris fossilis .
21 .
Pectunculus fossilis Strijs majoribus &amp; elatioribus .
22 .
Pectunculus maximus fossilis Listerianum maximum referens .
23 .
Pectunculites maximus Strijs latis .
24 .
Concha parva fossilis fascijs transversis insignis .
25 .
Concha longa fossilis fasciata .
26 .
Conchites laevis maxima .
27 .
Conchites parva fasciata .
28 .
Trigonella minor sive vulgatior Anglica Lithoph .

