IV .
Some Observations concerning the Invention and Progress of Printing , to the Year 1465 .
Occasioned by by the Reverend Mr Ellis 's Letter , exhibited in Phil Trans. No 286 .
Page .
1416 .
WHat this Gentleman says about the Books Printed at Harlaem by Laurence Koster , agreeing so well with the account given by Theodore Schrevelius and others , leaves us little or no room to doubt ( whomustneedstakeit for granted that his Observation isaccurate , and theDates to be true ; ) whether the Honour of the Invention be due to this or the other Cities , whose Writers have so eagerlycontended for it ; since none of them have pretended to show any Book printed so soon as A. D. 1430 or 1432 , or near that time .
But the difficulty lies , either in showing why the Practice of ~ Art should be at a stand from A. D. 1432 .
to the noted Reviving of it at Mentz by John Fust and Peter Schoeffer , who ( as it has been vulgarly , but erroneously said ) did Print the first Printed Book there A. D. 1465 .
namely , Tully 's Offices : or else , in giving any tolerable account of the Progress of this Invention during an Interval of above 30 years .
Yyyyyyyy2 Box Boxhornius ( as I remember ) as well as Schrevelius and other Authors , do expressly say , ( and if they had not , it might well be imagined ) that Koster could not advance this Invention so far , as to Print so large a Work as the Speculum Salutis without gradual Improvements ; and that his first Essays were on loose and small leaves of Paper , before he attempted whole Books .
These being loose and single , are supposed to be all lost : but I once observed a loose leaf of Paper in Octavo , lying in an old MS .
Breviary in her Majesty 's Royal Library at St James 's , which I then thought ( and am still in the same opinion ) that it was one of Koster 's first Pieces ; done when he had attained to some Experience in the Art , and to get Money .
It is a little rude Wooden Cut , of the five Wounds of our Blessed Saviour , and the Instruments of his Passion , with a Latin Inscription at the bottom , to this purport , that Those who should say so many Ave Maria 's before it , should have so many thousand years of Pardon .
In this Cut or Print , the Ink which made it was Writing Ink , and it was all Black , without those other Colours with which Koster seems afterwards to have adorned his Books .
In the abovementioned Boxhornius 's Book de Origin Artis Typographicae , it is said , that Hadrianus Junius had a Book Printed by Koster , and like that kept in the Chest at Harlaem : Now amongst those Bequeathed to the Bodleyan Library at Oxford , by Mr Francis Junius ( who was a Kinsman of Hadrian 's ) there is a thin Book in a small Folio ( Numbred 31 .
) which may probably be the same ; and which Mr Foss , a learned and curious Danish Gentleman , did assure me was very like to that at Harlaem .
This contains the Sum of the History of the Old Testament , all represented in rude Wooden Cuts , colored with divers colors , without Shadows like to our Cards , ( which , with Sheet-Ballads , are remains of the old manner of Printing , ) and Stamped upon one Side only ; the white sides of two Leaves being pasted together ; the Black both in the Pictures and Inscriptions which show the meaning of them , being * Writing Ink , ( as the aforesaid Leaf ) inartificially spread upon the Wooden Block ; here thick , there thin ; spreading and yellowish ; the Letters extremely rude , and all together manifestly showing that the Art was yet in its Infancy .
The Stamping of this Book on one Side only , was not ( as some think ) because the Printer did not know how to dispose the Pages in such manner , as might be proper and easy forth Book-Binders use ; for it has its Signatures all along in Minuscule Letters , ( set in the middle of the Page , which is remarkable ; ) but because it was thought that the Paper would not bear a second Impression on the back side ; justas the Book-writers of those times ( when Paper began to be cheap , and to be made up into Books ) would yet have the first and last Leaf of each Quaternio , Senio , &amp;c. to be of Parchment for strength 's sake .
This Book ( as I remember ) is imperfect , and has no Date now appearing , and perhaps never had any ; neither has such another Book as this , which contains the History of St John and the Apocalypse , in such like wooden coloured Pictures and Inscriptions .
This is inscribed LAU D. E. 65 .
in the same Bodleyan Library , and has its Signatures also in Majuscule Letters ( as indeed I have observed Signatures in many MSS .
of different Ages , as high as 1000 years ago and upwards , expressed either by Letters or Numbers .
) This Book , tho Printed on one Side , and Pasted as the former ; is yet more elegant , and shows that the Art was much improved .
And here it may not be impertinent to observe , that in the same Library ( Arch. B. Bodl .
88 .
) is an ancient MSS with the same Figures and Inscriptions , tho the Habits of the Figures be different , those of the MS being of the older Fashion , and it is very * It is to be wished that Mr Ellis , when he had Koster 's Books in his Hands , had observed whether the Black Ink , was Printing Ink ~ not ; whether Koster 's Picture was ancient , and colonr 'd or not ; or if there were more in either of the Books ; whether the whole was Cut upon Wood , or Composed with Printing Letter ; whether there were Signatures for the Book-Binders , very likely that there is another Copy of this Book in the Emperors Library at Vienna ; for Lambecius , Comment .
de Biblioth .
Cas .
Lib. II .
Page .
772 .
reckons amongst those which he brought away from the Archi-ducal Library at Inspruck , a Book of which he gives this Account , Apocalypsis S. Joannis Apostoli &amp; Evangelistae Latino Germanica , chartacea in folio , una cum ~ ipsius , &amp; mullis siguris ligno incisis , quae propter vetustaetem suam spectatu sunt dignissimae , and in this Book at Oxford , besides the Printed Cuts , also a Commentary upon the Apocalypse in High-Dutch .
Besides these two most ancient Printed Books , Mr Bagford told me that in the Manuscript Library of Corpus Christi or Bennet College in Cambridge he saw a third , containing the History of our Saviour , Printed on one Side only of the Paper , with such like Wooden Cuts ; but yet more neatly than either of the former , which I had before shown him at Oxford .
And these three Books , being as is before said , Stamped but on one side of the Leaf ; the whole wrought or cut upon Wood ; not Set or Composed with Printing Letter ; and Printed with Writing Ink ; do sufficiently demonstrate that the Art was as yet in its Infancy : and may , tho they bear no Workmons Name , be very reasonably ascribed to Koster , not only because no body else lays claim to 'em , but because in divers Circumstances they agree with the History of the Man , and with what remains of his Workmanship .
If it be asked why Koster did not set his Name , and the Year to these Books , as well as to that at Harlaem , mentioned by Mr Ellis ?
It may be answered , that Schrevelius tell us that Koster bound Fust abovementioned , by Oath to secrecy , and not to betray the Art to any person whatsoever .
Wherein it is likely , that his design was not so much to let the World think , that he had a new way of multiplying the Copy of a Book much quicker than the quickest Penman ; but that he designed to Impose upon the World , by selling his Printed Books , for New-Written Copies , whereby the Book-Writer and Illuminator must ( as he might well pretend ) be so paid for their Work , as to maintain themselves and Families .
This Trick might be long undiscovered in and about Harlaem~ because there was no other Printing , whereby this might be condemned ; but at length , as Boxhornius and Schrevelius write , Fust ran away with all his Masters Tools and Materials , and in Process of time set up a Printers Shop at Mentz , being assisted by his Servant Peter Schoeffer ( a Young Man of a good Genius ) who afterwards Married his Daughter , and became his Partner in the Business .
The Story goes , that this John Fust went to Paris ( but whether before or after his settling at Mentz , I cannot tell : ) and that he there offered a great number of Printed Bibles to sale , as if they were Manuscripts .
But the French were not to be so caught .
They considered the number of these Books , and their exact conformity to one another throughout the whole , to a Line , a Word , a Letter , a Point , and that the best of BookWriters could not be thus exact , and therefore by Indicting him of Diabolical Magic ( or threating him with it ) they at once gave birth to the Story of Doctor Faustus , and caused him to discover theArt .
And I doubt not but about this time , very many Books were Printed and Sold for Manuscripts , I having seen divers such Books without Dates , which looked rather older than any I have seen with them .
I speak now of those that are Set or Composed of Letter , which with Printing-Ink of Lamp-Black and Oil , and the Printing-Press , is said to be the Improvement of Schoeffer ; above mentioned , tho Schrevelius with less reason ascribes the two former to his Countryman Koster .
When Fust and Schoeffer began first to W ork at Men z is uncertain , but the first mention I find of him , as a Printer at Mentz , is in Schrevelius , Harlem page .
272 .
where he says that this Fust ( or Faustus as he calls him ) published Alexandri Doctrinale cum Petri Hispani tractatibus A. D. 1442 .
but this and some other Books mentioned by Writers on this subject , are never said to be extant in any particular place , in order to be consulted upon occasion ; and therefore their Titles and Dales are not so much to be relied upon .
But another Date , which tho not so Old , is more Authentic , may be found in the above cited Book of Lambecius , Page .
989 .
where he says he brought away from Inspruck amongst other choice Volumes , and placed in the Imperial Library at Vienna , a Psalter Printed upon Parchment , with this Inscription at the end , Praesens Psalmorum codex venustate Capitalium decoratus , Rubricationibusq ; sufficienter distinctus , adinventione artificiosa imprimendi ac characterizandi , absque calami ulla exaratione sic effigiatus , &amp; ad eusebiam dei industry est consummatus per Johannem Fust , Civem Moguntinum , &amp; Petrum Schoffer de Gernszheim , anno Domini millesimo CCCCLVII .
in Vigilia Assumptionis .
From this time there are constant Remains of the Industry of these Men , and I can mention more Books Printed by them , than the Durandus ( in the Library of Basil in Switzerland ) Printed ( as a Gentleman who saw it , told me ) A. D. 1458 .
Joannes Joanuensis 's Catholicon ( in her Majesty 's and the Lord Bishop of Norwich 's Libraries , ) Printed 1460 .
The Latin Bible of 1462 , yet extant in the French Kings Library , and in divers Monasteries beyond the Seas , and perhaps in England .
The Tully 's Offices Printed both in 1465 and 1466 , ( if both these be not the same Edition , the last Sheet or Leaf being Composed afresh : ) and so on till Schoeffer worked for himself after the Death of Fust , and Schoeffer 's Posterity after him .
But I willingly forbear the Catalogue , in hopes that this , with that of the other old Printers throughout Europe , and especially of our English Workmen , with their Devices , the Effigies of most of them , and a multitude of uncommon Remarks relating to Writing , Printing , Parchment , Paper , Binding , &amp;c. will be communicated to the World , when Mr Bagford 's Papers shall be digested ; nor do I think it ingenuous or honest to prevent him in these his Labors , which have cost him so many Years Pains .
A word or two more I take leave to add , that upon the first discovery of the Art by Fust at Paris , or at his first Settle Settlement or public Profession of it at Mentz , it quickly spread over the best parts of Europe , ~ and was commonly used in other Countries before it was known in England ( not withstanding what some Writers do affirm to the contrary ; )the first Book that we pretend to have been Printed here , being Hierome ( or rather Rusinus ) on the Creed , Printed at Oxford , A. D. 1468 .
From these Places , and from Books , or parts of Books , where , or wherein such sorts of Letter was used , thePrinters do still call their Letter , Italick , Roman , English , &amp;c. Austin , Canon , Primer , Brevier , &amp;c. To prove this in some measure ( not to mention the Progress of Printing in other Countries ) I instance in Italy , and particularly Rome .
Here , not to insist on the large Catalogue of Printed Books described in an Epistle to Pope Xystus IV .
Published at the beginning of the V. Tome of the Bible printed with Lyra 's Commentaries at Rome , A. D. 1472 , and transcribed by Boxhornius ; Ishall only related the sum of what I meet with in Bernard Mountfaucon 's Diarium Italicum , Tom. 1 .
page 255 , 256 .
It is that Joannes Aleriensis , in a flattering Epistle to Pope Paul II .
( who was elected A. D. 1464 .
) congratulates him , because Printing was first used at Rome , under his Pontisicat .
Which if spoken of the very first practice of the Art at Rome , and not of an established Imprimery , seems to be false , because this learned Monk , in the same place , says he saw a Lactantius in the Musaeum ( or Study ) of Monsieur de la Thuilliere , which has these words at the End , Lactantii ~ani Institutiones cusae in venerabili Monasterio Sublacensi anno 1461 .
antepenultima Octobris .
Now unless a man will suppose Printing to be invented in this Monastery , he must believe it to be brought hither from Rome , which is but about 20 Miles distant from it .
And the same Author says , that Floravantes Martinellus in his Roma Sacra , affirms that Printing was practised at Rome in the Palace of the Maximi , A. D. 1455 , under Pope Nicolaus V. by Conrad Sweynheim and Arnold Pannartz , who were both Germans , and continued Printers there for many Years after .
Zzzzzzzz The The Custom of putting the Dates of Printed Books at the End of them , was taken up in Imitation of divers the middleaged and recenter Manuscripts ( for I never saw or heard of any ancient Manuscript in Capital Letters , either Geeek or Latin , which has a professed Date written in the first hand ; ) but here the Inspector ought to be cautious , lest he be led into an Error : For several Manuscripts at the End have a Date , which may be by some understood of the time when those individual Copies were written , whenas they only notisie the time when the Author finished his Work .
And some of these Dates , being printed from the Manuscripts , have deceived many curious men .
For Example , the first Edition of Lyndwood , Paulus a Sancta Maria , and others which I could name .
Besides , some Dates in ancient Printed Books , being not corrected , are false ; such as a Book printed in the beginning of the 16th Century , in the Library belonging to the Ashmolean Musaeum at Oxford~ which thus pretends to 400 or 500 years of Age .
A Julius Hyginus once showed to me by Mr Millington the Bookseller , printed at Paris ( as there put down ) An. Dom .
MCCCCXII .
instead of MCCCCCXII .
For the Printer is mentioned as then living in l ' Origin de l ' Imprimerie de Paris .
I have indeed a Book wherein , amongst other Tracts , is one of an old Print , at the end of which there seems to be such a Mistake , tho not so easily rectified as the former .
The words ae these , Explicit opusculum Enee Sylvii de duobus amantibus in Civitate Leydensi Anno Domini Millesimo CCCC quadragesimo tertio LEIE N. Now tho ' Leyden seems to be the place where it was printed , yet 1443 cannot be the time when ; for just before Sylvius says himself , Vale , ex Vienna quinto Nonas Julias Mo CCCC quadragesimo quarto .
Sylvius was elected Pope by the name of Pius I. A. D. 1458 , and died A. D. 1464 .
Now it may seem probable , that if this Tract was printed after his Election ( as suppose A. D. 1463 .
) or even after his Decease , his Papal Dignity might have been remembred ; If it be judged to have been printed before his Election , I know none that will allow of Printing at Leyden , ( or even in Lyons ) so very early .
One Objection may be urged against what is said of Koster 's or the old printed Books above-mentioned , being printed upon Paper about A. D. 1430 , or soon after .
For some Authors are of opinion , that Paper made of Linen Rags was first made at Basil , by some Greeks who fled out of their Country after the Saccage of Constantonople , A. D. 1452 .
in Imitation of the Cotton Paper , commonly used in the Levant .
But this can have no force , our Paper being much older : For I have a piece , the Writing upon which seems to be about 350 years old , and agrees very well with a Charter which I have seen of Thomas Beuchamp Earl of Warwick , bearing date A. D. 1358 .
and 32 Edw III .
In the Archives of the Library belonging to the RR .
Dean and Chapter of Canterbury , I saw an Inventory of the Goods of Henry Prior of Christs Church there , taken upon his Decease , ( as I remember ) the 20th year of K. Edward III .
and this is written upon Paper .
In the Cottonian Library , tho~ searching after other matters , I could not but observe several Writings upon our Paper , in the time of most of our Kings and Queens , as high as the 15th of K. Edward III .
and I doubt not but that there are others more ancient in the same place .
But in the East , the use of Cotton Paper is much more ancient , and I have in the Bodleyan Library , seen an Arabic Manuscript ( amongst those which the University bought of Dr Huntingdon ) written in the 427th of the year Hegira , i.e. A.D. 1049 , and others in the same place without Dates , seem older .
The Proximity of the subject , causes me here to take notice , that tho the Invention of the Rolling Press is commonly ascribed to Lipsius ; yet it seems older than his time , from a printed Book in the Bodleyan Library , placed LAVD .
D.138 .
This is a Missale secundum usum Ecclesiae Herbipolensis(i.e.Wurizburg in Germany .
) Rodolfus Arch Bishop of that Church sets forth in an Instrument at the beginning of the book , the reasons why he caused this Missal to be published , which InstruZ zzzzzzz~ meant meant bears date the 8th of November 1481.by which time he orders all theCopies to be finished by Jorius Ryser his Printer , who seems to have done so , since his Name , and this Year 1481 , is written at the end of the Book .
Instead of a Seal to this Instrument is an Engraven Print , being the Arms of the See supported by 2 Angels , and St Kilian ( its first Bishop and Protector)behind ; as also this Prelate 's own Arms with those of the See in another Escutcheon , and a very fine Mantling .
This is extremely well engraven for the time , and equals the performances of some of our best Workmen at present .
The evident marks of pressure by the Plate , with some touches of Ink at the Edges , the ~ of the Print , and other Circumstances concurring , I thought this must needs be wrought off at the Rolling-press .
But being unwilling to rely too far upon my own Judgment , I showed it to divers very knowing and curious Gentlemen , to several Printers , Engravers , and others working constantly at the Rolling Press , who all concurred ( tho at different times , one not knowing what another had said ) that it was not only excellently well engraven ( and this before Albert Durer 's time ) but that it was certainly pulled from the Rolling-Press , and could be done no other way .
And that this Print was not done after that time , appears from several Notes written here and there in the Book .
One of them specifies that William Kewsth , Vicar of St Bartholomew 's Church in Wurtzburg , bought this Book the same year , 1481 , paying 18 Florins for the Parchment , Printing , Rubrication , Illumination and Binding .
By another it appears , that he gave it to his Church for ever .
And by some others it appears that it remained there during the times of his several Successors , till the last Age , when , as I suppose , the Swedes , under Gustavus Adolphus , plundered the Church , and brought it out .

