Philos : Transact : no. 271 .
Fig : 3 .
R F a Fig : 2 .
Ia a LLMR C MID C LL G CCB Ea ~ HFA QRT E ASV CKR ~ ~ A A Fig : 1 .
A F E B aB E CC a AA D I E I CC B C H K N M R F a a G ~ A Scale of Inches N M AOFMLA L L R R II .
The Humane Allantois fully discovered and the Reasons assigned why it has not hitherto been found out , even by those who believed its Existence .
With an Answer to their Objections , who deny it still .
By Rich Hale , M. D. of Trinity College in Oxford .
Communicated to the R. S. by Edward Tyson .
M. D. NO point in Anatomy has been , and still is , more controverted by the greatest Masters of it , than the Existence , Shape , &amp;c. of a Humane Allantois .
I shall therefore give a true and exact account of it , as it appeared in two subjects , still by me .
One of which I observed several years ago , and the other ( Fig. Ist .
) in March , 1698/ 9 .
But before I do this , it may be convenient to show , that no Anatomist had hitherto made an entire discovery of this Membrane ; and to take notice of the difficulties that have hindred such a discovery , even by those who believed the Existence of it ; and afterwards answer the objections of those who still deny it .
Most of the Ancients indeed allow a Humane Allantois , not from their experience of it , but because they took it for granted , that Men and other Animals were alike , in the Viscera , Membranes , Vessels , &amp;c. Hence Hippocrates says , that Twins lie in Sinus 's , and that the Uterus has Cornua .
Galen describes the Navel-string to consist of four Vessels , besides the Urachus , and the Allantois to be like a Pudding reaching from one Cornu of the Uterus to the other .
In short , notwithstanding the Ancients might sometimes dissect Humane Bodies , and although ( a ) Herophilus and Erasistratus did open live Men and Women , yet it ca n't be found what great use was made of those Rrrrr op(a)Celsus .
opportunities : For the accounts the Ancients have left of many parts , particularly of the Urachus and Allantois , ( as to its Name , Figure , Site , &amp;c. ) agree only to their appearance in Brutes .
I shall say nothing of the Allantois in Brutes , since it is granted by most Anatomists , to be in these Animals , and sufficiently described by Dr Needham .
This excellent Anatomist also first discovered part of the Allantois in Humane subjects , but neither he , nor any other , has taken the right method of finding it entire , and it is no wonder they could not truly describe what they never saw .
( b ) Dr Needham says , that after the Amnios is cleared , and left fixed to the Umbilical Rope , you may divide by the fingers , or knife , the remaining part of the Involucra into two Membranes .
The exterior he truly calls the Chorion , the interior he takes to be the Allantois .
But by these ways of separation , you will presently tear the Allantois , and be able to discern only some small pieces of it .
Besides , the Allantois is at first sight , so like the Amnios , that ( c ) many who suppose the Amnios double , and that its Coats are easily separable , have taken these pieces of the Allantois , for broken parts of one of the Coats of the Amnios .
Whereas having first found the Hole whence the Urine came forth ( if the Allantois with not too much torn ) you may blow up the Allantois with a Pipe to its full dimensions , and then see its true Shape , the Fundus , the Crevix , the insertion there of the Urachus , its relation to the other Membranes , &amp;c. Be the Allantois never so much torn , yet this way you may easily separate many Inches of it , from the Chorion , and Amnios .
Which easy separation demonstrates a distinction of Membranes , since no double Membrane can be divided by the breath alone .
Indeed Hoboken and ( d ) Diemerbroaeck make it a very easy thing to separate the Allantois from the other Membranes , only by the fingers ; but it is plain from their de(b ) cap. 3d 7th .
( c)Diemer li .
1 .
cap. 31 .
Horn .
parag .
69 .
( d ) Li .
Ist descriptions that they never saw one entire .
Amongst other mistakes ( e ) Diemerbroeck says that the Urine of a Faetus lies between the Urinary Membrane and the Chorion ; as though not contained in a distinct Bladder , but in a Cavity made partly from the Chorion , partly from the Urinary Membrane .
( e)de Mul .
Org .
cap. 15 .
I confess De ( e ) Graaf tells us , that by blowing with a Pipe into a Hole made through the Chorion , all the Membranes of the Secundines will appear distinct .
He has also delineated an Allantois , with the other Membranes , &amp;c. as he says he found them .
Yet this ( f ) Fig. must have been drawn from his own fancy , and not from any preparation , for these reasons .
Ist , Because , by this way of separation , you can only part the Allantois from the Chorion , but never see its true dimensions , nor any appearance of a Bladder ; for a Bladder , as the Allantois is , can be showed only by blowing into its Cavity , or by finding it full .
Yet in this Fig. no sign can be observed , where it was blown up , and tied , De Graaf also speaking of making a Hole only in the Chorion .
Nor can this Allantois be supposed full of Urine , because it is not of the Shape of a full All antois , and our Author himself calls it only the inflated part of the Allantois .
However , I ca n't conceive how the Allantois could remain partly filled with Air ( any more than it might with Urine ) so long as till this Fig. was drawn , unless some Hole was tied up , whence the Urine came forth , and the Air was blown in .
2dly , Because in this Fig. the Umbilical Rope seems to run through both Amnios , and the Allantois , to its insertion on the Placenta .
Whereas the Allantois is no where perforated by the Umbilical Rope , nor does it any where pass through the Amnios , but only runs under it , at the place of its insertion on the Placenta .
If the Navel-string could be allowed to enter the Amnios at ( g ) I , and to pass under it to the Placenta , why should it not appear ( which it does not ) under the Amnios , as well as the Rrrrr2 thin ( f)cap .
15 .
Tab. 22d .
( g ) Tab. 22d De thin substance of the Allantois ?
Again , according to-De Graaf 's position of the Secundines , ( which is the reverse of Fig. Ist , where the Navel-string lies under the Allantois ) nothing could hinder a plain view of the place where the Navel-string is set on to the Placenta .
This will be easily apprehended , by supposing the part H in my ISt Fig. to lie uppermost , the Fundus G and Navel-strings being turned over ; for then the Strings will run over the Allantois , as in De Graaf 's Cut , and its insertion appear plain on the Placenta , which yet ca n't be discovered in his ( g ) Fig. I am sure the whole is irregular , and I take it to be fictitious .
As for the Urinary ( g ) Membrane G it seems to be the Allantois of a Colt ( where ( h ) Needham says , ` the Umbilical Rope runs through the Urinary Membrane ) not less absurdly added to the Secundines of a Humane Faetus than the Secundines of a Whelp are to a like Faetus by Vesalius .
( h ) vid .
B. Tab. 2d .
Lastly , It is most evident that De Graaf knew nothing of the true Shape of this Membrane , and that he had never seen one entire , because ( i ) he consents to ( i ) Needham 's description of it as true , which yet is false in several particulars .
For Ist , the Urinary Membrane does not cover the whole Faetus ( as he affirms ) but only that part of it , which respects the Chorion , and does not lie on the Placenta ; for the Allantois can be extended at farthest but to the edges of the Placenta , where the Amnios and Chorion are so closely joined by Fibres , that no Membrane can come between them .
Wherefore 2dly , the the Allantois is not every where fastned to the Chorion , And consequently 3dly , the Allantois ca n't be of the same Shape that the other Membranes are of , nor be like the Allantois of a Colt , which contains the Faetus in the Amnios ; all which nevertheless ( k ) Needham asserts .
In short , Dr Needham had seen only pieces of the Urinary Membrane , but never an entire one , and so could only guess at the Shape , &amp;c. of it , from what he had observed ( h ) vid .
B. Tab. 2d .
( i)De Gra .
ca .
15 .
( i ) cap. 3d de format ~ .
served in Mares , and Glanduliferous Animals .
He might have made a better guess at the figure , site , &amp;c. of a Humane Allantois from that of a Whelp , which does not every where encompass the Faetus , as he observes .
Bidloe in most of his Figures of the Secundines , letters some Vestigia of the Urinary Membrane , but in any of these Figures , you only see broken pieces of one , so confusedly placed , that no Idea of its Bigness , Shape , or Situation can be formed from them .
I must confess that oftentimes the Membranes of the Secundines are so torn , that no Art can exhibit an entire Allantois .
However , among the many Secundines that have come under the hands of Anatomists , several no doubt must have been entire enough for a fuller discovery than they have made , had it not been by their ways of proceeding ( viz. by knife , fingers , or blowing under the Chorion ) impossible to discover any thing plain , or satisfactory , even in the fairest subjects .
I come now to answer the objections of those who still deny an Urinary Membrane to a Humane Faetus .
The difficulty of finding this Membrane is by no means an argument against the existence of it : But a Woman that dies big with Child is so fair a subject for the discovery of threeMembranes , that I wonder(l)Parey having such an opportunity could find but two , if he was so careful as he says he was .
The accurate Dr Tyson observed three Membranes some years ago , in a like subject .
After the Chorion was divided , and laid aside , he saw two Bladders , containing Liquors of different colours , which he pressing one towards the other , did not mix , but remained distinct .
This observation fully satisfied that great Anatomist , to as the existence of an Allantois ; and its figure , texture , site , &amp;c. might also have been discovered by him , had not the less curious Spectators been impatient to pass on to other parts of the Dissection .
Some ( l ) Lib. 3d Some deny a Urinary Membrane to a Humane Faetus , because they suppose the Urachus to be impervious , and that therefore there would be no passage for the Urine , consequently no need of an Allantois .
( m ) Needham indeed says that he could never find any sign of a Cavity in the Urachus , yet is of opinion , that by blowing from the Bladder , the Air might be forced through a Humane Urachus , as easily as he has often done it through that of a Whelp .
I do n't understand why Dr Needham , and ( n ) others should insist so much upon an apparent Cavity in the Urachus , or expect that air should necessarily pass through it upon blowing , and think that otherwise it cannot be fit for the assigned Office ; since many Bodies , as Membranes , &amp;c. will not admit Air , &amp;c. yet let Water pass freely through them .
It will not seem strange , that Water should pass through the substance of the Urachus , if we consider that the Cavity of the Urachus to the Navel is open , as appears by Inflation , or Injections , ( to say nothing of those who are mentioned to have made Water by the ( o ) Navel ) and that the rest of the Urachus is pervious , tho ' not plainly hollow , ( the Urine rather soaking gently , than running through its more strait Tubes ) may be gathered from hence .
Ist , That the substance of the Urachus , ( as well as the Cavity of the Allantois ) is always found turgid with a Liquor , that in colour , taste and smell , seems Urinous .
2dly , That since the Mucous Coat of the Intestines is demonstrated to be vascular by Mr Leeuwenhoeck , therefore the Mucous substance of the Urachus may also be Vascular .
3dly , That Urine may as easily ouze through these Mucous Vessels , as other fluids run through Vascular Cartilages , and Bones , &amp;c. or the Chyle into Lacteals , whose Orifices as ( p ) Leeuwenhoeck observes , will scarce admit of Particles so big as the 1000000000 part of a grain of sand ) the great Cavity of the Intestines being open at the same time ; or as easily as grosser parts of the Semen pass the Tubes ( m ) cap. 3d cap. 4th cap. 7th .
( n ) Parey Lib. 3d .
cap. 34 .
Maurieau Lib. 2d cap. 4th ( o ) Fern. .
Lib. 6 .
cap 13 .
Senn .
Lib. Prac .
3d part 8.sect .
2d cap. 10 .
Lauren .
Lib. 8th Quest .
17 ( p ) Vol.2d Epist .
68 .
Tubes of the Testicles , whose Cavities are not more perceptable .
I am sure the Urine is more assisted in its motion by the Detrusor Urinae , &amp;c. than any of these Fluids can be by the Heart , or other Muscles .
( q ) Others will not admit of an Urinary Membrane , they thinking it would be useless , because they imagine , that when the Bladder is full , the Urine must be dis charged at its Cervix , and not at its Fundus by the Urachus .
But in answer to this , the Urine can never pass through the Cervix , and Urethra , unless the Abdominal Muscles contract , because we never void Urine naturally , but by the help of these Muscles , nothing less being able to force open the Sphincter Vesicae .
Now it being more than probable that these Muscles never act before Respiration , no Urine can pass through the Sphincter , before the Child breathes .
No reason can be given why the Abdominal Muscles of a Faetus , should voluntarily contract , since neither the Quantity nor Quality of the ( r ) Urine can excite to such an action .
For when the Bladder is too full of Urine , it will ouze through the lax spongy substance of the Urachus , being gently pressed by the Detrusor alone .
There would arise many inconveniences from the voluntary contraction of the Abdominal Muscles of a Faetus , as voiding Faeces as well as Urine , into the Amnios , which would be more prejudicial than ( s ) Sweat &amp;c. Yet if we should suppose the Abdominal Muscles of a Faetus to act , the Urine will however pass where it can most easily i.e. through the Urachus , which is partly open , and altogether of such a Texture , as in no wise can hinder the passing of the Urine , much less be able to resist a considerable force , as the ( t ) Sphincter Vesicae can .
Besides , the Urachus is not only thus qualified , for the admission of Urine , but when the Mother lies down , it is almost upon a Level with the Urethra , and what has once passed the Urachus , cannot return by reason of the Length , Situation , and peculiar Structure of it .
Lastly , the ( q ) Barth Lib. 1.cap 36 .
&amp; 37 .
Riolan .
Lib.6.cap .
3 &amp; 4 .
Parey Lib. 3d cap. 34 .
( r ) Barth .
Lib.1.cap 37 .
Need .
cap. 3 .
page .
81 .
( s ) Harv .
de Humor page .
547 .
( t ) Gal.de usu .
part the ( v ) Pudendi Clausura sometimes happening in both Sexes , demostrates that then at least , the Urine ca n't pass through the Urethra .
( w ) Dioni not finding any Allantois , nor an Urachus plainly pervious , thinks there is no need of either , on another account .
For he supposes that the Blood , which serves for the Nutrition of the Faetus , is depurated from all Excrement .
But I cannot apprehend , what should make this portion of the Blood and Chyle freer from Excrement , than the rest of the Massa Sanguinea .
There is indeed no portion of it , which does not contain parts unfit for Assimilation and Nutrition .
Our Author would have been convinced of this error , had he ever opened Abortions of five Months old or upwards , their Bladders being always full of Urine , and some Faeces constantly in the Intestines .
It is difficult to determine when this separation of Urine first begins , but I am apt to think it much sooner than is generally supposed .
Fig. the 3d is the Allantois of a very small Abortion , which I have still by me .
Since all the parts are perfectly formed before Impergnation , not very long after Impregnation they may begin to perform their Offices .
No doubt they begin as soon as there is occasion for any separation , and a separation of Urine is necessary , when the Faetus is first nourished by the Umbilical Arteries .
( v ) Senn .
Prac .
Lib. 4 .
part 1 .
sect. 1.cap .
1 .
cap. 3 .
Mauric .
Lib. 2.cap .
3 .
( w ) page .
145 .
The Existence of an Allantois is denied by ( x ) some who grant an Urachus , but will have it convey the Urine to between the Amnios and Chorion .
( y ) ~Diemerbroeck 's opinion is somewhat like this , only he would have the Urine lodged between the Urinary Membrane and the Chorion .
These men do n't consider that the Urine in this case would get into the Amnios , as well as the Succus Nutritius of the Chorion , whether imbibed from the Uterus by the Chorion , or separated by its Glands .
Such a Succus Nutritius of the Chorion is granted by the ( z ) Maintainers of the fore-cited opinions , as well ( x ) Aquapend .
Lib. 1 .
cap. 7 .
Fallop .
( y ) Lib. 1 .
cap. 31 .
( z ) Harv .
deHum .
&amp; membra .
Needh .
cap. 2 .
3 .
cap 7 .
Barth .
Lib. 1.cap 36 .
G raaf de mul .
org .
well as by those who deny an Allantois altogether , or ( a ) suppose it to have a different Figure , &amp;c. from what Diemerbroeck assigns it .
The Transudation ( or Filtration through the Membranes ) of this Succus seems most likely in Mares and Sows ; for in a ( b ) Mare , the Chorion is not joined to the Uterus , till she is half gone , and in a ( c ) Sow it does not adhere to the Uterus till near the end of her going with young .
But it is most evident that the Urine of a Humane Faetus is not contained between the Chorion and Amnios , nor between the Chorion and Allan tois , from the close connexion of these Coats to one another ; also from the observation of Midwives , who often find a Bladder of Water ( they call it a By-Water ) offering it self before the Child , whereas the Humour of the Amnios is little , and of the Chorion much less , and of another Colour , &amp;c. at the time of Birth .
This ByWater is taken notice of , as an argument for an Allantois by Mr Cowper , to whose assistance we owe that the Figures belonging to these Papers appear correct .
( a ) Needh .
Graaf .
( b ) Harv .
de Membran .
( c ) Need .
cap. 2 .
cap. 3 .
and 7 .
Graaf de mul .
org .
cap. 15 .
The great ( d ) Harvey will not allow an Allantois even to Brutes , and fancies the Allantois and the Chorion to be the same Membrane , that has two names , the first from its shape , the other from its office , or number of Vessels .
Yet it is plain from Galen and all the Ancients , that they meant two distinct Membranes by the Allantois and Chorion .
Dr Harvey thinks that a Faetus does not void Urine , but that the Bladder contains it , till the time of .
Birth .
What was offered against Dioni 's Opinion may serve for an answer to this also .
Because it was impossible for this diligent Anatomist not sometimes to observe an Urinary Bladder , he has thought of ways to explain such Phenomenon without granting an Allantois .
In ( e ) Sheep and Does he had seen as it were a certain Process between the Umbilical Arteries full of Urine .
This Process is no doubt the Allantois , though ( f ) Bartholinus calls it the Urachus .
Again , he thinks what is called by others an Sssss Allan .
( d ) Harv .
de memb .
&amp; humor .
( e ) Harv .
de memb .
&amp; humor .
( f ) Lib ~ .
Allantois ( if it is not the Chorion ) is some Coat accidentally formed from a Reduplication of the Membranes : because ( since every Membrane is double ) Nature may upon a straight , lodge the Urine between a Duplicature .
Yet he does not tell us how his Duplicature is to be filled , he allowing no Urachus .
But , in short , this Urinary Bladder , can be no Duplicature of the other Membranes , since in all Animals it differs from them , as to Figure , Texture , and in having an Urachus , which no other Membrane has .
And since every Animal that has a Bladder , must have a like necessity for a Receptacle of Urine till born , since also the Urachus is ever alike inserted in the same Species of Animals , and the Urinary Bladder constantly the same , as to Shape , Texture , Situation , &amp;c. the Urachus and Allantois with its ( g ) By-Water can be no accidental or preternatural things .
( g ) ~ de Hum. All the material Objections , and Difficulties about an Humane Allantois being thus cleared , I shall now consider what has been , or may be , offered against these Figures in particular , when I have first given the Explication of them .
And I think there is no need of any other account thereof , since it is not my design to give an entire History of the Secundines , &amp;c. or repeat what can be found in other Anatomists ; but only to relate what I have discovered of an Humane Allantois , Amnios , &amp;c. which is altogether new , or different from the Observations of others .
Fig. I. Represents the Secundines of Twins , to show the Allantois , and its Relation to the other Membranes , &amp;c. after the parts were prepared and dried .
AAAA Part of the Chorion expanded .
BBBa Line , expressing the edges of the Placenta .
CCC the Amnios , which is united to D. : the Allantois , at EEE the Line of Union .
F the Cervix of the Allantois .
Ga Hole at the Fundus of the Allantois , whence the Urine came forth , and where the Allantois was blown up .
H Part of that half of the Allantois , which lies under the Line of Union , and immediately covered the Faetus 's , unless it is supposed that the Amnios is continued under the Allantois .
II Two Stiles or Probes thrust under the Amnios .
They support the Allantois , and keep open the Aperture **** of the Amnios , whence the Twins came forth .
K Part of the Placenta , with some Blood-Vessels injected .
LLLL the Arteries of the Navel-string filled with Red Wax .
MM The Umbilical Veins filled with Green Wax .
Na Communicant Artery , by means of which all the Arteries of both Navel-strings were filled at once , and the Veins were filled by one Injection in like manner .
Oa Pin that keeps out the Amnios , where from the edge of the Placenta it runs partly to the Line of Union , or Adhaesion , and partly over the Placenta .
P Part of the Chorion at the edge of the Placenta , where it runs under the Amnios on the Placenta .
Qa Pin that by a thread helps to pull open the Aperture of the Amnios .
RRR the Urachus , lying between the Arteries .
aaaa Fibres or Vessels which fasten the Allantois to the Chorion .
Fig. II .
Exhibits a side-view of the same Preparation , that the Insertion of the Urachus , &amp;c. may be better seen .
N. B. That A and all the same Letters in these three Figures denote the same Parts in every one .
S shows the Course of the Urachus R at F in pricked lines .
T part of the Amnios raised from the edge of the Placenta , to discover the Placenta K and V. V that part of the Allantois which is below the Line of Union , near its neck F. Fig. III .
Shows an entire Allantois of a very small Abortion .
N. B. This Allantois was easily separated from the other Membranes between which it lay ; and the Amnios remained an entire Bladder or Membrane under the Allantois .
Now some to whom I have communicated these Figures Object , that what is called the Line of Union can be on real thing .
As to this I do n't know whether the Allantois of Twins may not require such a conjunction to sustain , and keep steady a greater quantity ofUrine:nor can I resolve whether the Allantois of Twins(like that of a~ single Faetus in Fig. 3 .
) may not be distinct , and separable from the Amnios , but was not discovered by me to be so , through want of skill or care .
However , the reasons why such a Line was figured are these .
1 .
Although I used more force , with equal care , to separate the Allantois from the Amnios in this place than in any other ( where nevertheless the separation was very easy ) yet I cou 'd n't divide these Membranes farther than that Line .
2 .
This Line seeming so regular as to divide the Allantois into two equal parts , I could not take it to be the effect of Chance , or my Separation .
3 .
The Part H below the Line EE was alike in Transparency to that part of the Allantois D above it .
Whereas had the Amnios been still joined to the Allantois ( as these Objectors suppose ) the Allantois below this Line must have appeared thicker than that part above it , since the Amnios alone is much thicker than the Allantois .
It is easy indeed to conceive the Amnios running an entire Bladder , or Membrane , under the Allantois , and perhaps it may be so : but I think it disingenuous to conceal what I did observe , or to make out by fancy , what I cou 'd n't discover in fact .
Others have thought this Allantois to be an Amnios of one of the Twins belonging to these Secundines .
This Objection , though it may seem plausible , yet is of no force .
For 1st , this Allantois is much finer to the touch , and also much more transparent , than the other Amnios ; which still remains stiff , whilst the much thinner Allantois sinks upon the least blast of Air , notwithstanding the stiles II which assist it .
2dly , This Allantois had two visible Urachus 's , and it is of an Oviform Figure , somewhat like the common Cuts of a Mans Bladder ( for a true Cut of a Humane Bladder I never yet saw , for it ought to be made much bigger ( as it really is ) at its Crevix , &amp;c. ) Also this Allantois no where touches the Placenta , unless at the Neck F. But on the contrary , the Amnios is of the same irregular Figure , as the Position , Motion , &amp;c. of the Faetus require .
Likewise , it covers the whole internal surface of the Placenta .
3dly , They who make this Objection must suppose some Hole in this Bladder , and in the Amnios , through which one Umbilical Rope may pass from the Placenta to the Faetus .
But such a Foramen would be preternatural , because the Navel-string only runs from the Placenta to the Faetus , under a Coat taken from the Amnios , and lies with the Faetus in the Cavity of the Amnios , that is no where perforated , 4thly , The Hole at the Fundus G was scarcely wide enough to receive the end of a mans finger , whereas the Twins did not want six weeks of their full time .
Since therefore a Faetus of near eight months could not possibly pass this Orifice , this Bladder could not be an Amnios .
Nothing in these Secundines is preternatural , only some things were not before observed .
Hitherto Anatomists have not allowed Twins to lye in a common Amnios nios , bur supposed each Faetus to have a distinct Amnios .
The reason of this Opinion might be , that some denying any Urinary Membrane , called every Membrane they found ( except the Chorion ) an Amnios , and these finding two Membranes in the Secundines of Twins , supposed them to be two Amnios 's .
That others granting an Allantois , but not distinctly discovering it , but only two Membranes , also imagined them to be two Amnios 's .
Both of these taking that for an Amnios , which might really be an Allantois .
But since one Chorion , and one ( h ) Placenta ( the ( i ) Placenta , and ( i ) Chorion being ever of the same number ) generally serve Twins ( nay , sometimes three Faetus 's ) why should it seem strange , that one Amnios ( at least sometimes ) and one Allantois should serve the like number ?
( b ) Mauriceau Lib. 2 .
cap. 4 .
Need.cap .
2 .
Barth .
Lib.1 cap. 36 .
Diemerb .
Lib. 1 .
cap. 30 .
( i)DiemerLib .
1 .
cap. I am not ignorant that ( k ) Mauriceau , and ( l ) Diemerbroeck think there is an absolute necessary for every Faetus to lie in a distinct Amnios , and that otherwise Twins in the same Membrane would grow together , and make a Monster .
( m ) Aquapendens further says , that all Ova ~Gemellifica produce some other sort of Monster .
Yet it is most certain that Ova Gemellifica do exclude two perfect Chicken , however not both alive .
( n ) The Great Harvey indeed thinks it possible , that such an Ovum may produce a Monstrous Chick , if its Vitelli are contained in the same Membrane , &amp;c. yet does not positively say it must be so .
For my part I ca n't see any more reason why Twins in one Amnios should grow together , than that the Hands or Heels of the same Faetus should grow to its own Body .
How can the Humors that lubricate a single Faetus , and help it to move , join two together ?
since the Humours as the same , and the parts of the same Faetus as tender as those of Twins are , and lye as close to one an other , as Twins do .
It is very observable , that among all the Monsters we read of , there are very few , which seem to be made of two entire Bodies joined together , and that most 31 .
Graaf cap. 15 .
( k ) Maur .
Lib. 2 .
cap. 3 .
and 4 .
( l ) Diem .
Lib. 1 .
cap. 31 .
( m ) page .
19 .
( n ) Exercit .
24 .
de most of these upon ( o ) Dissection were found to have but one Heart , one Liver , &amp;c. whence it is most plain , that these Monsters ( and no doubt all others ) were originally Monsters in the Ova , before Impregnation , and not so from want of an the Amnios .
Yet ( p ) Diemerbroeck does not a little boast of having first ( as he thinks ) found the reason why Twins must lie in distict Amnios 's .
But since the matter of fact(sometimes at least as in these Secundines , where there was only one Amnios , and two regular Faetus ) is not true , his argument for a necessity of two Amnios 's for two Faetus 's , will never prove valid , even where Twins , and two Amnios 's are found .
Indeed any part may be made to grow to any part , as we see in the cure of Hair lips , &amp;c. but then the Fibres must be first broke , before there can be any Union .
Now I ca n't conceive what should naturally break the Fibres of the Twins in the Uterus .
But although it is evident from what has been said , that Twins may lie distinct in the same Amnios , yet there must be as many Urachus 's , as Faetus 's .
In these Secundines I saw two running over the Placenta , to the Neck of the Allantois , which I communicated to some Physicians , before the parts began to grow dry .
The Urachus passes under the Amnios as the other Umbilical Vessels do , and runs from that part where the Umbilical Rope is set on to the Placenta , straight to the Cervix F. S describes the course of that Urachus marked R at F in the 2d Fig. The other Urachus lay about a quarter of an Inch laterally beyond that marked R in the same Figure .
I mean by two Urachus 's , two long roundish Bodies , of a depressed Figure , they seemed as big as a common Knitting Needle , and were of a darker substance than the Placenta on which they lay .
They appeared in every respect like that part of the Navelstring , which is allowed by all Anatomists to be the Urachus , and in like manner shrunk in two or three days , from a Mucous substance to a mere Membrane .
These ( o ) Parey Lib. 25 .
cap. 2 .
( p ) Diem .
Lib. 1 .
cap. These two are the only entire .
Urinary Membranes that I have prepared .
Yet in the many Secundines that have come to my hands , I have ever found three distinct Membranes easily separable .
Perhaps some less curious Persons may think such discoveries as these of no use .
But these may consider that hence we can better explain some Phenomenon , as voiding Urine by the Navel , and the Breaking of Waters from Women half gone with Child , and tell the consequences of such accidents ; as also better account for those Waters , and Bladders Midwifes meet with , and direct them in their doubtful Operations , &amp;c. It is something likewise to have cleared Points thus long controverted by the greatest Anatomists , &amp;c.

