II .
A Letter of Dr Wallis to Dr Tyson , concerning Mens feeding on Flesh .
Oxford , Feb. 3 .
1 699/ 700 SIR , THough I have not had the opportunity of Acquaintance with you , I desire you will give me leave to suggest to you a Question or two in your Profession , relating to Comparative Anatomy .
You may perhaps censure me , as an Interloper in your Faculty : But while I was ( at Cambridge ) but a young Student in Philosophy , I looked upon the Medicinae pars Physica , as a piece of Natural Philosophy ; and did accordingly apply my self to it , ( though without any design of practising the Pharmaceutick , ) and to Anatomy in particular .
And Dr Glisson ( who was then our Public Professor of Physic , and under whom I kept , as they call it , a Physic Act ) hath since told me , that I was the First of all his Sons , that did ( in a public Disputation ) maintain Dr Harvey 's Circulation of the Blood , in the year 1641 , ( when it was but a New Doctrine ) being then able to trace it through the Arteries and Veins of the whole Body , better than now I can , ( having since forgotten much of the particularities thereof , upon my diverting to other Studies .
) Which I hope you will admit as an Excuse for my Interloping .
Now , I remember to have read ( about fifty years ago ) in one of Gassendus 's Printed Epistles , ( printed among some previous pieces of his , before the body of of his Works was published , ) a suggestion of his , which he seems to espouse as his own opinion , ) as if he thought it not ( originally ) Natural for Man to feed on Flesh ; though by long usage ( at least ever since the Flood ) we have been accustomed to it , and it is now familiar to us ; but rather , on Plants , Roots , Fruits , Grain , &amp;c. And I take it to be the Opinion of many Divines , that before the Flood , Men did not use to feed on Flesh , because of what we have in Gen. 9 .
3 .
where God says to Noah , ( after the Flood , ) Every moving thing that lives , shall be meat for you , even as the green Herb have I given you all things : Compared with Gen. 1 .
29 .
where God says to Adam , I have given you every Herb bearing Seed , and every Tree in the which is the fruit of a Tree yielding seed , to you it shall be for Meat ; but without any intimation of his feeding on the Flesh of Animals , which seems to be an insinuation to that purpose , and is commonly taken so to be .
Yet , I confess , I have some doubt therein remaining , seeing that we find , very early , that Abel was a Keeper of Sheep , as well as Cain a Tiller of the Ground , both Employments seeming equally in order to their Food and Sustenance .
And their first Cloathings , were the Skins of Animals .
It may perhaps be thought , that these Animals were Slain for Sacrifice , and the Sheep fed only for that purpose , but even their Sacrifices seem to have been offered but as a Portion ( or First-fruits ) of things appointed forFood ; and that asCain was not toSacrifice the whole fruit of his Tillage , so neither was Abel , the whole product of his Sheep , but the best thereof ( the Firstlings of hisFlocks , and the fat thereof)and reserving the rest for his own use .
And it cannot seem likely , that God would give to Noah after the flood , a greater Dominion over other Animals , than had been given to Adam , in Paradise before the fall .
And I should then consider this permission to Noah , not as contra-dictinct from that to Adam , ( as of what is now permitted , which before were not ; ) but rather as Introductive of the Prohibition which presently follows , to wit , Though he might eat Flesh , even as the green Herb , ( so far as it might be wholesome food : ) yet , not with the Blood thereof ; that is , not Raw flesh ; not carnem crudum , or carnem cum cruore .
I add also , that the same Rule is given to other Animals , Gen. 1 .
30 .
as is to man , at ver .
29 .
I have given them every green herb for meat : Yet there are , we know , many Carnivorous Animals , without any further Permission that we know of .
But ( without disputing it as a point in Divinity , Whether men , before the Flood , did or might feed on Flesh , supposing it to be wholesome nourishment ; ) I shall consider it ( with Gassendus ) as a Question in Natural Philosophy , whether it be proper Food for Man .
The consideration insisted upon by Gassendus , is from the structure of the Teeth , ( and , as I remember this only ) that our Teeth are mostly either Incisores , or Molitores ; not such as ( in Carnivorous Animals ) are proper to tear Flesh , except only 4 , which are called Canini : As if Nature had rather furnished our Teeth , for Cutting Herbs , Roots , &amp;c. and for bruifing Grain , Nuts , and other hard Fruits , than for Tearing Flesh , as Carnivorous Animals do , with their Claws , and sharp Teeth .
And , even when we feed on Flesh , it is not without a preparative Coction , by boiling , roasting , baking , &amp;c. And , even so , we forbid it to persons in a Fever , or other like distempers , as of too hard digestion .
And Children ( before their Palats are vitiated by custom ) are more fond of Fruits than of Flesh-meat .
And their breeding Worms is wont to be imputed to their too early feeding on Flesh .
This ingenious Conjecture of Gassendus , did presently suggest to me another speculation , which seems not less considerable .
There is in Swine , Sheep , Oxen , and , I think , in most Quadrupeds that feed on Herbs or Plants , a long Colon , with aCaecum at the upper end of it , or somewhat equivolent , which conveys the Food , by a long and large progress , from the Stomach downwards , in order to a slower passage , and longer stay in the Intestines : But in Dogs , of several kinds , and I suppose , in Foxes , Wolves , and divers other Animals which are Carnivorous , such Colon is wanting ; and , instead thereof , a more short and slender gut , and quicker passage through the Intestines .
That which I would propose hereupon is , that you would please to consider , as your leisure and opportunity permit , whether it do generally hold , or how far forth , that Animals which are not Carnivorous , have such Colon , or somewhat eqvivalent ; and , that those which are Carnivorous have it not .
For if so , it seems to be a great Indication , that Nature , which may be reasonably presumed to adapt the Intestines to the different sorts of aliments that are to pass through them , doth accordingly inform us , to what Animals Flesh is proper aliment , and to what it is not ; and that from thence we may judge more solidly , than from the structure of the Teeth only , whether or no Flesh were designed as proper food for Man .
Now it is well known , that in Man , and , I presume , in the Ape , Monkey , Baboon , &amp;c. such Colon is very remarkable ; and the like in your ingenious and accurate dissection of your Homo Sylvestris , which may therefore be thence conjectured , not to belong naturally to the Carnivorous Tribes , if that rule hold .
It is true , that the Caecum in Man is very small , and seems to be of little or no use : But in a Faetus , it is in proportion much larger than in persons adult .
And it 's possible , that our Customary change of Diet , as we grow up , from what originally would be more natural , may occasion its shrinking into this contracted posture .
But I add this also , that Man 's being endued with Reason , doth supply the want of many things , which , to other Animals may be needful .
Man is not covered with such quantity of Hair or Feathers all over his Body , which to other Animals serve for Cloaths ; but can , by his use of Reason , supply himself with Cloaths suitable to every Climate , and different Seasons .
He is not furnished with Claws , Hoofs , Horns , &amp;c. which serve for Arms to other Animals , but can , by the use of his Reason , supply himself himself with Weapons , and other Instruments for different occasions , to much better advantage .
And , in the present case , though raw Flesh be not proper , as it is to some other Animals , he can by Preparative Coctions , and other Expedients , render it more agreeable .
Nor is he wholly destitute of Dentes Canini ; but is indeed furnished with all sorts of Teeth , for all sorts of wholesome Food .
I take the Sheep , the Goat , the Swine , the Ox , the Horse , the Ass , the Camel , the Elephant , the Hart , the Hare , the Rabbit , the Mouse , &amp;c. not to be carnivorous ; but the Dog , the Wolf , the Fox , the Cat , the Lion , the Leopard , the Tiger , &amp;c. to be naturally carnivorous , which of all these have , or have not the Colon , or what other distinctive mark may be observed between these different Tribes of Animals , I think may deserve a serious consideration .
I submit the whole to your Enquiry , who have more opportunity , by your Experience and Conversation , to judge of it , than I can pretend to have .
There is another Point , which ( if I have not already trespassed too far ) I had thoughts of proposing to you , about the structure of the Ear .
But I shall omit that at present ( that I be not at once too tedious ) and beg your pardon for having trespassed so far .
Resting Yours to serve you , The Answer of Dr Tyson to the foregoing Letter of Dr Wallis , concerning Man 's feeding on Flesh .
London , Jan. 16 .
~ .
SIR , BEfore I return you my Answer to your obliging Letter , I must beg Pardon that I have deferred it so long : And do assure you , it was not for want of a just Respect and Esteem ( which all the Learned World deservedly have had for so long a time of your great worth ) that occasioned this Delay : But other affairs , which it were needless to trouble you with .
I do now give you my hearty Thanks for the honour you have done me therein : And our whole Faculty is no less obliged to you , for your so early defending so momentous a Doctrine , as that of the Circulation of the Blood , which , for some time afterwards was so warmly opposed , both by our own Countrymen and Foreigners .
I doubt not , had you continued these Studies , the force of so great a Genius would have made as great discoveries , as that you then defended ; and since have done in the Mathematicks , whereby you would have demonstrated many important truths in our Faculty , which now are received only as mere conjectures .
The Argument you propose , from the Conformation of the Intestines , why Man should not be Carnivorous , seems far more Rational than that which Gassendus urges , from the structure of the Teeth .
Though it must be owned , there is nothing he hath omitted , that could have been said on that subject , to favour it .
I shall beg leave to give you my thoughts freely on this occasion : sion : And , if in my Answer some things may seem ~ , or not exactly adapted to the question in hand ; if otherwise they may not be unuseful , I hope they will not be unacceptable to you .
But , before I come more particularly to consider your Hypothesis , give me leave to remark , That , had Man been designed by Nature not to have been a Carnivorous Animal , no doubt there would have been observed , in some part of the World , Men which did not at all feed upon Flesh .
But since no History ( as I know of ) furnishes us with such an instance , I cannot but think what hath been done universally by the whole Species , must be Natural to them .
What the Pythagoreans did , in Abstaining from Flesh , was upon the notion of a ~ , or Transmigration of Souls , a mistake in their Philosophy , and not a Law of Nature .
And , though in some Countries Men feed more freely on Flesh , in others more sparingly , this is owing to their own choice , from the Advantage they find thereby .
Nature having given Mankind Reason , he can , or ought to elect what food he finds most agreeable to him , in the Climate he lives in ; and is not determined to any one sort , but has liberty to all .
And it is as probable , that the Ante-diluvial World had so likewise .
Wherefore I shall wholly acquiesce in your determination of this point , and am fully satisfied with the Reasons you give for it .
We shall therefore now , as you direct , consider it as a Question in Natural Philosophy ; Whether from the Observation of the structure of the Parts in Man , we can find reason to think Nature did , or did not , assign him to be Carnivorous .
For I am of Gassendus his opinion , Licet ex conformatione Partium Corporis Humani , conjecturas desumere ad Functiones mere Naturales .
For , all the Knowledge we have of the Uses of the Parts in Animal Bodies , is by observing Nature 's wonderful contrivance in the formation of them ; who most wisely adapts them to the Uses they are designed for .
Not because they are casually so and so formed , are they necessarily put to such and such uses : But therefore they are so contrived , that they may perform such Offices in the Oeconomy of Animal Bodies , as Nature intended them for .
Longe proinde facessat illa Empedoclis , Epicuri , aliorumque Opinio , sc .
Membra Animalium non esse facta propter Usum ; sed , Membris ita casu factis , &amp; coalescentibus , ipsorum usum Accomodatione Experientiaq ; varia adinventum , saith the same Gassendus .
And there are several remarkable Instances I have given in my late Treatise of the Homo Sylvestris , that sufficiently confutes such Unphilosophical Atheists .
I come therefore now more closely to our Business .
Since you have so fairly represented Gassendus his Opinion and Argument from the structure of the Teeth , why Man should not be designed by Nature to be Carnivorous ; and have likewise sufficiently , I think , answered his Reasons ; I shall wholly pass that over at present : And shall only consider the Observation you have made of the different Formation of the Intestines in Carnivorous Animals , from those that are to be met with in such as do not feed upon Flesh , but other food .
And indeed this seems to me to be of far greater weight and to carry more strength in it , than any thing I have met with before .
And all the Instances you give are very True .
We shall therefore first of all observe , That the Ductus Alimentalis ( for so I call the Gula , the Stomach , and Intestines ; all which make but one continued Canalis or Ductus ; ) This Ductus , I say , is properly the true Characteristic of an Animal , or Proprium quarto modo .
For there is no Animal but hath such a Ductus ; and whatsoever hath such a Ductus , may properly enough be ranged under the Classis of Animals .
Plants receive their Nourishment by numerous Fibres of their Roots , but have no Common Receptacle for the Digesting the Food received , or Vent for carrying off the Recrements : But in all , even the lowest degree of Animal Life , we may observe a Stomach and Intestines ; even where we cannot perceive the least Formation of any Organ of the Senses , unless that common one of Tactus ; as in an Oyster .
Where also we may observe a sensible Muscular Motion , or Contraction ; though it would be difficult to assign what Part should be reckoned the Brain , or Medulla Spinalis , from whence the Nerves arise that give it so strong a motion .
Now this Ductus being so Principal a Part in an Animal , and its Use being for the Receiving and Digesting the Food , and Destributing the Chyle ; it is reasonable to suppose , that , according to the difference of the Food , the structure of the Organ should be also Different ; or , where the Organ was the same , there the Use was the same too , for the Receiving , Digesting and Destributing the same sort of Food .
Man therefore having these Parts formed , not like Carnivorous Animals , as you well observe ; but more resembling those that live on Herbs , Roots , Fruits , &amp;c. it may seem reasonable to conclude , that Nature never designed him to live on Flesh ; But , that the Wantonness of his Appetite , and a debraved custom , had inured him to it .
For , as Gassendus remarks in the same Epistle I have so often quoted , S viz. Epist .
Jo. Bapt .
Helmont .
operum Tom. 6 .
page .
19 .
Custom may make that seem Natural to us , which Nature never intended .
As he instances in a Lamb that was bred on Ship-board , which refused the green Pasture of the Fields , for the Diet it was formerly used to .
And I have often seen here in London ( and it being a thing so unusual , I take leave to mention it ) a Horse , that , with a great deal of pleasure , would eat Oysters , scranching them , shell and all , between his Teeth , and swallowing them ; And this he took to by accident , being left at a Tavern door , where stood a Tub of Oysters : And since hath frequently done it , whenever they were offered him .
Now Gassendus observes , that Children ( from whom he thinks we may better take the Instincts of Nature , than from our Appetites when depraved by Custom ) are much fonder of Fruit than of any Flesh that is offered them ; and therefore he supposes it more Natural to them .
The Instance you give , wherein the structure of the Intestines ofCarnivorous Animals is different from that inMen , is , that the former want a Colon ; whereas in Men there is a very large one , which is not to be observed but in such Animals as live upon Fruits , Roots , Herbs , &amp;c. What therefore you propose to me , is to consider , Whether it does generally hold ( or how far forth ) that Animals that are not Carnivorous have such a Colon , ( or somewhat equivalent ) and those that are Carnivorous have it not .
I shall begin with those Animals that are Carnivorous , and have no Colon , or large Caecum .
For though they may have the Appendicula Vermiformis ( as some Anatomists call it ) yet if that is not extended or filled with the faeces , which the other Guts contain , I think it not properly to be esteemed as a distinct Gut , or to come into that number , since here it does not perform the office of a Gut , in containing the Food or Excrement .
So , in a Man , in Dogs , and other Animals , when it is thus contracted , I exclude it out of the number of the Intestines , though by use and custom ( but I see no reason for it ) it is commonly reckoned one of the Intestina crassa .
Animals therefore that have no Colon , or large Caecum , though some of them have this Appendicula Vermiformis , and are Carnivorous , I reckon .
1 .
The Dog-kind ; under which , beside their own species , may be included the Fox , the Wolf , the Coati Mondi , the Badger , the Otter , &amp;c. 2 .
The Vermin-kind ; as the Weasel , the Fitchet , the Polecat , the Martin , &amp;c. Both these kinds have a Bone in the Penis ; have no Colon or Caecum ; some have the Appendicula Vermiformis ; and all are Carnivorous .
3 .
The Cat-kind ; to which may be reduced , besides their own Species , the Lyon , the Tiger , the Leopard , the Lynx , the Catamountain , &amp;c. Tis true , the French Memoirs for the History of Animals , tells us , that a Lyon has a Colon 18 inches long , and an Appendicula Vermiformis 3 inches ; and that in a Lyoness the Colon was two foot , and the Caecum two inches long .
Now I question whether we may properly call this a Colon or no : For tho the Gut about this place may be more extended than in others , yet not having those Ligaments whereby the Gut is corrugated into Cells , as in a Humane Body , I think strictly it does not deserve that name .
So in a Cat , the Intestine , at the place of the Colon , is larger , but , for the same reason , shall not call it a Colon .
And though a Cat has a small Projection of the Gut , which may be called a Caecum , because it contains faeces ; yet , since it is so very short , we will not insist on it .
4 .
A Boar hath no Colon or Caecum .
5 .
A Mole , which feeds on Worms and Insects , has no Colon or Caecum .
In the next place we will consider those Animals that are not Carnivorous , but live upon Herbs , Fruits , Roots , &amp;c. all which have a Colon , or Caecum or both ; For , as to your Query , I think it much the same , whether they have either one of these only , or both ; provided that the Capacity of the Gut there , be large and extended , and do contain faeces .
I will ennumerate first those Animals that have both a Colon and a Caecum or at least a Colon .
As 1 .
The Horse-kind ; in which may be included the Ass , the Mule , &amp;c. which have a large Colon and Caecum .
Gggggg2 2 .
The 2 .
The Elephant hath a great Colon and Caecum .
3 .
The Dromedary and Camel , a long Colon .
4 .
The Swine-kind , whose Species is numerous , have a large Caecum and Colon .
5 .
The Guiny-pig , a Colon and Caecum .
6 .
The Castor , or Beaver , has a large cellulated Colon and Caecum .
7 .
The Hare-kind , has a large Colon and Caecum .
The Caecum in the Rabbit is very long , and in the middle , a cochlear valve .
8 .
The Ape and Monkey-kind , have a cellulated Colon , and short Caecum .
Now there are several Animals that have a large Caecum and no Colon , and these too are not carnivorous , but live upon Grass , Fruits , Roots , &amp;c. as 1 .
The Neat-kind , as the Ox , the Barbary Cow , &amp;c. 2 .
The Sheep-kind , which is numerous .
3 .
The Stag-kind , to which may be referred , the Elk , the Rain-deer , the Stag of Canada , &amp;c. 4 .
The Goat-kind .
5 .
The Gazella or Antelope .
6 .
The Squirrel-kind .
7 .
The Rat-kind .
By all which Lists , you may plainly perceive , what good grounds you have for forming your notion ; since there are so many Animals that are carnivorous , that have no Colon or Caecum at all ; and , on the other hand , how vast a number are there that are not carnivorous , that have either a Colon or Caecum , or both .
But notwithstanding all this , we may be mistaken in the Conclusion we may be apt to draw from hence : and may as well argue , that because the Neat-kind , the Stag-kind , the Goat-kind , and the Sheep-kind , that live on Herbage , have four stomachs , therefore those that have not four stomachs , were not designed by Nature to be Graminivorous .
Now the Horse-kind , the Hare-kind , &amp;c. have but one stomach , and yet their Food is Grass .
And the case is here the more remarkable , because the stomach is a part more principally concerned in digesting the Food .
The Intestines are for separating the Chyle and carrying off the Faeces .
Yet we observe even in Animals , that live on the same sort of Food , that their stomachs are very different .
One would therefore be more apt to think , that for digesting the variety of Food , and what is of a different nature , that the Organ that is to perform it , should be different too .
Yet we find that the stomachs of Animals that live upon Flesh , of others that live upon Fruits , and others that live upon Grass , &amp;c. to be much alike ; that 'twould be difficult to assign any difference between them .
If therefore we cannot make a conclusion from the structure of the stomach , what food is most natural to an Animal , much less one would think from the Colon or the Caecum ; those parts of the Ductus Alimentalis that are remote from the stomach ; and being so , seem rather as a Cloaca , for the reception of the Faeces , than otherwife , of any great concern in digesting the food , or distributing the chyle .
It would be infinite should I expatiate upon Natures great Variety , in the formation of the structure of this Ductus Alimentalis in different Animals ; and even where we may observe much the same sort of food , yet we do not always find the same structure , though her Intendment be the same , in digesting the Food , distributing the Chyle , and ejecting the Faeces in all of them .
But herein she shows her great Wisdom , in attaining the same end , different ways .
Had chance any concern herein , we should not observe that constant regularity in the same species , nor variety in different , where the action is so much the same .
But here perhaps you will say , I begin to Interlope ; I shall therefore now draw toward a conclusion .
Since Since Man therefore hath all manner of Teeth , fit for preparation of all sorts of Food , before it be conveyed to the Stomach ; I should rather think , that Nature did intend he should live upon all ; or at least is so Bountiful as not to deny him any , or stint him to one sort only .
So in like manner , since the Organ here in Man , is fitly adapted for Digesting all sorts of Food , I should rather incline to conclude , that therefore Nature intended all sorts for him : Which God Almighty assures us he did , in the Text you have quoted , Gen. 9 .
v. 3 .
Every moving thing that lives shall be meat for you , even as the green Herb have I given you all things .
But perhaps you may expect I should give you some Instances in Brutes , where it doth not hold , that all Carnivorous Animals have no Colon or Caecum , though , as to Man , the case may be different .
Now the Carigueya or Opossum ( Whose Andtome I have given in Philosoph. Trans. No. 239 ) had a long Colon , though not cellulated , and a large Caecum , that received all the Faeces as they pass down ; Yet this Animal feeds on Poultry and Birds .
And I have , a Male Opossum now by .
me , that feeds on nothing but Flesh .
On the other hand , the Hedge-hog or Urchin , that hath no Colon or Caecum , and therefore , by your rule , should be Carnivorous , feeds on Roots , Fruits , Herbs , &amp;c. and not on Flesh .
Hogs likewise , that have both a Colon and Caecum , will feed upon Flesh greedily enough , when they can meet with it ; though their ordinary Food be of another kind .
And a Rat and Mouse , that have a large Caecum , but no Colon , feed upon Bacon , as well as Bread and Cheese .
But , if what AElian tells us ( Hist. ~ de Animal .
lib. 17 .
cap. 45 .
) can be relied upon , you have an instance in the Neat-kind also .
For he assures us , ~~ ~ .
So likewise in the same Book , cap. 25 .
he mentions Horses and Sheep that fed upon Fish .
But these stories , suppose , he hath taken up from the Indian Historians ; whose Credit I have sufficiently examined in my Discourse concerning the Pygmies of the Ancients ; and shall therefore lay no stress upon them .
Your Observation therefore as to Brutes , though it may hold for the most part true , yet it is not Universal .
And , as all other Rules , may have some Exception .
I am , Sir , with the greatest Respect , Your most Obedient Humble Servant , Edward Tyson .
A second Letter of Dr Wallis to Dr Tyson , on the same subject .
Oxford , Jan. 23 .
1701 .
SIR , I Received ( some days ago ) your Obliging Letter , ( in Answer to mine about ~ , or Feeding on Flesh ; ) and Read it with great Content .
I should ( with more earnestness ) beg your pardon , for having given you the trouble of so Elaborate and Judicious a Discourse , if I did not think I have served the Public therein ; and that it may give as ample satisfaction to the Learned World ( if you will permit it to be published ) as it hath done to me .
I am not fond of advancing a New Hypothesis , contrary to the common sense of mankind .
I did but suggest , to your consideration , a matter of Fact ; without being Positive , what Conclusion to infer from it .
And I should not have ventured so far , if Gassendus had not first broke the Ice ; upon a Notion not much more considerable than that of mine .
Wherein you have furnished .
nished me with a great number of Instances , beyond those few I could suggest , or could expect from any other hand .
Upon the whole matter , I think your sentiments to be much the same with mine .
I am inclined to think , That all Nations ( as well before as since the Deluge ) have used to feed on Flesh .
Which is a strong Presumption ( as you well observe ) that to feed on Flesh ( duly prepared ) is not wholly Unnatural for Mankind .
On the other hand ; I believe you think ( as I do ) that Raw Flesh is not a Natural Food for our Bodies .
I do not know that any Nation have ( of choice ) used to feed on Raw Flesh ; unless in cases of Extremity , or when they have not the Convenience of Preparing it by previous Coction , or some what equivalent .
( For I put a great difference between Raw Flesh ( which is the common Food of what we call Carnivorous Animals , ) and Flesh duly prepared for our Food .
) If any there be that ( of choice ) feed on Raw Flesh , I look upon it as a Case Anomalous ; like that of the Lamb mentioned by Gassendus ; and the Horse ( you mention ) that Eats Oysters .
I may add , the Rat eating Bacon , for want of other Food , ( which yet is not quite void of Coction ; ) and the Swine sometimes eating Poultry .
Which latter , I do not take to be purely Natural ; but rather the effect of an Appetite Depraved by Custom ; because much of the Hog-wash we give to Swine , arises from the Coction of Flesh for our own use ; which doth inure the Swine ( a Voracious Animal ) to the Taste of Flesh , and makes it familiar to them .
But Flesh , duly prepared for our Food , I look upon as a thing very different from Raw Flesh , and which may be proper Food for Man ; if ( and so far as ) it agrees with our Health : ( which caution is to be observed , as to other Food , as well as Flesh .
) And this I refer to the care of the Physician and the Apothecary , rather than the Cook and the Confectioner : fectioner : For these do oft comply with the Wantonness of the Palate , rather than the Health of the Body .
I leave it to you to consider , from what Reason , and for what Use , the passage of Flesh through the Ductus Alimentalis , should ( ordinarily ) be more Quick , and that of Herbs more Slow ; ( For that seems to be the cause , the Colon making the Way Longer , and the Passage Slower ; ) and , in what Degree it is so .
I say Ordinarily ; because , in case of Catharticks ( or what is equivalent ) the speed is quickened .
And , again ; When as Nature seems to have ( originally ) designed , in Man , a large Caecum , as in some other Animals , ( and which , if I mistake not , is , in the Faetus , larger , in proportion to the rest of the Intestines , than in persons Adult , ) How it comes to pass that it is~ now of little or no use ; but shrinks up into an Appendicula Vermiformis ; Whether or no this may partly proceed from our Feeding so much on Flesh~ ; which will not admit so great a Remora , as a large Caecum may occasion in other Animals .
I conclude , with hearty Thanks for your great Pains ; And am , SIR , Your very humble Servant , John Wallis .
Hhhhhh III .
Part

