A Letter of Dr Wallis to Dr Sloan , concerning the Quadrature of the Parts of the Lunula of Hippocrates Chius , performed by Mr John , Perks ; with the further Improvements of the same , by Dr David Gregory , and Mr John Caswell .
SIR , THE Squaring a certain Lunula by Hippocrates Chius long since , hath been known ( as to the whole Lunula ) for many Ages .
But ( as to the Parts of it , and the Appurtenances thereunto , ) New Discoveries have been lately made , which ( I think ) had not been considered by any before this present Age .
I received ( in November 1699 .
) from Mr. John Perks ( Master of an Hospital at Old-Swynford in Worcester-shire , founded by Mr , Thomas Foley ) a brief account of his Squariug the Portions of Hippocrates 's Lunula ; with which ( I presume ) you will not be displeased .
For the better understanding of which ; I shall premise as known.(because long since demonstrated , ) That , If on AB ( the KB ~ D AC Chord of ADB , the Quadrantal Arc of a Greater Circle , who 's Center is C , ) be described , as on a Diameter , a Semi-circle ABE ; This Semi-circle , will be Equal to that Quadrant .
( Because the Squares of their Diameters , are as 2 to 1 ; And , in such proportion are their respective Circles ; and therefore a Quarter of the one , equal to Half the other .
) And , consequently ; If , from each of these , we substract the common Segment ABD ; the Remaining Lunula ADBE ( on the one side ) will be Equal to the Remaining Triangle ( on the other side ) ABC ( Or , to ABK , supposing AB bisected in K ; that is , to half the Square CK , inscribed in the Lesser Circle .
) Which is commonly called , The Squaring of Hippocrates 's Lunula ; That is , the Finding a Rectilinear Figure ( which may be easily reduced to a Square ) equal to that Lunula .
This being premised ; The Point in hand , is , the Squaring a given Portion of such Lunula : suppose ADE , cutt-off by a Straight Line CDE , drawn from the Center C. Which Mr Perks ( not knowing that the like had been before attempted by any other ) doth perform after this manner ; viz. Drawing the Straight Lines EA , and EB ( cutting the Arc EB in G , ) and , on AG , a perpendicular OF , ( which will therefore pass to the Center C , because Bisecting AG at Right-angles ; ) The Right-lined Triangle AFE , is equal to ADE , the proposed Portion of the Lunula .
His Demonstration is to this purpose : viz. ADB being a Quadrantal Arc ; the Angle AGB will be Three Halves of a Right Angle ; ( and its Conjunct Angle EGA , Half a Right Angle .
) And that Angle ( being External to the TrianB G E D F AC gle AGE , ) is Equal to the Two Opposite Internals GEA + EAG .
Whereof GEA ( because an Angle in the Semicircle AEB ) , is a Right Angle ; and therefore EAG is Half a Right Angle , ( as are also FEG , and FEA .
) And the Three Triangles AFE , GFE , and GEA , each of them Half a Square .
And AG to AE , as ~2 to 1 ( proportional to the Respective Radii of the Two Circles .
) And the Like Segments ADG , AE , in their Respective Circles ( as the Squares of their Respective Radii ) as 2 to 1 .
And therefore the Semi-segment AFD , equal to the Segment AE .
And consequently ( one taking from the Triangle as much as the other adds to it ) the Portion of the Lanula ADE , equal to the Triangle AFE .
Which was to be Demonstrated .
( I take the liberty ( both in this and the things that follow ) to vary somewhat from the Authors Words , ( but to the same sense , and without any disadvantage to Them , ) so as to Design the same Respective Points ( in all the Figures ) by the same Letters .
Which makes it somewhat Shorter ( without Repeating the same Construction anew for every Figure ; ) and prevents the Confusion which might arise to the Fancy , if the same Respective Points , in several Figures , were designed by different Letters ; and the same Letters , in the different Figures , design different Points .
) If the Point E chance to be in K ( the middle of the Arc AEB ) there will be no Intersection at G ( the Points G , B being then coincident , but without any disturbance to the Demonstration : ) If it happen beyond it , toward B ; then G will be on the other side ; and what is here said of EGB , must be accommodated to EGA : which things are so obvious , as not to need any long discourse .
The whole proceeds upon the same general notion with that of squariug the whole Lunula .
( and some other Curve-lined Figures ; ) that , if as much be added to the one side , as is taken from the other , the Equality remains .
And the stress of the Demonstration , is , to prove the segments ADG and AE , to be Like Segments ; and therefore Proportional to their Respective Circles ; the Whole of one , equal to Half the other .
The Ground of the whole Process is plainly this , The Angle ACE , being an Angle at the Center of the Greater Circle , but at the Circumference of the Lesser , the line CDE ( as it passes from CA to CB ) doth , in the same proportion , divide the Quadrantal Arc ADB , and the Semicircular AEB : whence all the rest doth naturally follow .
And this is Applicable to other Lunula 's ( beside that of Hippocrates ) if ( by altering the Angle at F , or otherwise , ) we take-in such a Portion of the common Segment ABD on the one side ( instead of AE cut-off on the other side ) as the Proportion of the two Circles requires .
I showed this Quadrature of Mr. Perks to Dr. David Gregory ( our learned Professor of Astronomy at Oxford , ) who gives his Opinion about it ( with his Improvement of it ) in a Letter of his to me ; which I shall give you in his own words , Reverend Sir , The Quadrature of the Parts of the Lunula of Hippocrates Chius , by Mr. Perks ( which you showed me ) is very Elegant .
I remember , the like was done , some years since , by Monsieur Tchirnhause ; who assigns , as equal to the same Portion , not the same Triangle with that of Mr. Perks , but another Equivalent thereunto , ( as I shall show by and by .
) We have his Theorem , in the Acta Lipsiae , for the Month of September , 1687 .
But , without any Demonstration .
But , both the One and the Other , seem not to have considered this affair in its full extent .
For , if you complete the Two Circles , whose Arcs contain the Lunula of Hippocrates ; the same is true , as well of the Points in the other Semi-circle ACB , as of those in the Semi-circle AEB ; and , for the same Reasons .
As appears in the Scheme annexed , wherein I have marked the Points in the Semi-circle ACB , ( cor``respondent to those of Mr. Perks in AEB , ) with the correspon``dent small Letters of the Roman and Greek Alphabets .
If Mr. Perks had made his construction universal ; by ma``king both EA and EB , meet with the Greater Circle , ( which he might have done by protracting these Lines and the Greater Circle 'till they meet ; ) he might have found that the Portions of the Spaces A~ CM , BHCN , ( supposing MCN parallel to AB ) are Quadrable as well as those of Hippocrates 's Lunula : And that EA~ being a straight Line , the Portion AED of Hip``pocrates 's Lunula , is to A ~~ ( the Correspondent of A~C M ) in the Duplicate Proportion of C~ to A ~ .
For ER~ ( at R the Center of the Lesser Circle ) is , in this case , a Right Angle .
Moreover ; If you take any Point ~ in the Semi-circle ACB , and proceed according to Mr. Perk 's construction Universalized as above-said ; you will find , on the one side , the Trilineum A~~ ( contained by the Arcs A ~ , A ~ , and the straight line ~~ ) equal to the Rectilineal Triangle A ~ .
And , on the other side , the Trilineum contained by the Arc B~ ( the Complement of ~A to the Semi-circumference , ) and the Arc Bd ( the Complement of A~ to the Fourth part of the Circumference , )and the straight line ~ d , ( that is , the Trilineum BHCd diminished by the Se``gment E G D F A~LRB ~ ~H ~ ~ MCN f d ~ gment C ~ ; ) to be equal to the Rectilineal Triangle B~ f. And , that those two spaces A~ ~ , and the Difference of BHCd from the Segment C~ ( parts of the Lunula ~ ACB g~ A ) taken together , are equal to the Triangle ACB ; as well as the two Spaces AED and BED , parts of the Lunula of Hippocrates .
So that , upon the whole , it appears , that the Two Circles ( containing the Lunula of Hippocrates ) being completed ; this Lunula AEBGA , and the other ACB g~ A , make up one System , and are Conjugate Figures .
For , ( drawing a straight line CDE , or C~ ~ , or C~ d , at pleasure through C the Center of the Greater Circle , and cutting those two Circles , ) the Space contained within two Arcs of these two Circles and part of the said straight line , ( as AED , or A~ ~ , or BH~ d , ) is equal to the Rectilineal Triangle AEF , or A~ ~ , or B~ f , respectively .
And it so happens , that , if this line going out from C , be on the same side of the Diameter MN with the Lunula of Hippocrates ; the foresaid Space ( which receives a perfect Quadrature ) is solitary ; ( such as are the Parts of Hippocrates 's Lunula ; and of the two Spaces A~ CM , BHCN ; which therefore are Parts of the Lunula more nearly relating to one another .
) But if that Line going out from C , be on the other side of MN ; then the Space which is equal to the Rectilineal Triangle , is , the Difference of two Mixtilineal Figures , ( the one a Trilineum , the other a Segment of the Lesser Circle , ) as is abovesaid ; neither of which can be squared severally .
All these particulars are plain from Mr. Perks 's Demonstration ; which , with a little variation ( such as is usual in the different Cases of the same Theoreme ) is applicable to all of them : though perhaps he was not aware of it .
In the Dimension of the Parts of Hippocrates 's Lunula , it might perhaps be expected , that the Triangle assigned equal to a Portion of the Lunula , should be Part of the Triangle to which that whole Lunula is wont to be assigned equal ; ( that is , that the Triangle assigned equal to the Portion ADE , should be the respective part of ACB which is equal to the whole Lunula ; ) which in that of Mr. Perks is not .
But , in that of Mr. Tschirnhause ( above mentioned ) it is so , which is to this purpose .
If from any Point E , in the circumference of the Lesser Circle , we let fall on AB , a Perpendicular cutting it in L , and draw the line CL ; the Triangle CAL , is equal to the Portion of the Lunula AED .
( And , consequently , the Triangle CBL , equal to the Portion BED .
) Which ( because Mr Tschirnhause hath not at all done it ) I shall briefly Demonstrate , so as the Demonstration may reach the Portions of the Conjugate Space ACB g~ A. For the Triangles ACB , AEF , are like Triangles , each being the half of a Square : And therefore , by 19 el .
6 , the Triangle ACB is to the Triangle AEF in the duplicate proportion of BA to AE , that is , by 8 , el .
6 , as BA is to AL .
But , by 1 .
el .
6 , the Triangle ACB is to the Triangle ACL as BA is to AL .
Therefore , by 9 .
el .
5 , the Triangles ACL and AEF are equal .
But the Triangle AEF is ( by Mr Perks ) proved equal to the Portion tion AED .
And therefore the said Portion AED is also equal to the Triangle ACL .
I am , Sir , Your &amp;c. D. Gregory .
Mr Caswell had a sight of this Quadrature of Mr Perks ( before Dr Gregorie or I had seen it ; ) And had given a Specimen of its being capable of further Improvement .
But , without having Leisure , or giving himself the Trouble , of pursuing it through all its Appendages .
I would ( with his leave ) have here inserted that Specimen : But he chose rather to decline it ; saying , He thought it needless , because Dr Gregorie had , since , done the like more fully .
The Result of it , is to this purpose ; On the Center B , he draws by A , a Third Circle ; which forms another Lunula , than that of Hippocrates : And he doth ( very dextrously ) Square the Portions of this Lunula .
And doth thereby let us in , to a New System , which may be pursued in like manner as Dr Gregorie hath done that of Hippocrates .
After these learned Disquisitions , on so trite a Subject ; it will not be needful for me to say much .
I shall but briefly Compare the Two Quadratures of Mr Tschirnhause and Mr Perks , ( wherein they Agree or Differ with each other .
) And then show , How , by either of them , to Divide the Lunula in any Given Proportion .
Monsieur Tschirnhause ; Letting fall , from E ( on AB ) a Perpendicular EL , determines the Triangle ALC equal to the Portion ADE .
Which being admitted ; We may thus Divide the Lunula in any Given Proportion .
If we divide AB , at L , in such Given ProportiB on ; CL will , in the same proporE tion ( because of the Common AltiD tude ) divide the Triangle ACB ( which is equal to the Whole Lunula .
) And LE ( erected at Right .
L Angles on ALB ) will determine the Point E ; from whence if we AC draw , to C , the Straight line EC , this will , at DE , divide the Lunula in the same Proportion .
Mr Perks ; On EDC , drawing the Perpendicular AF , determines the Semi-quadrate AFE , equal to the proposed Portion tion ADE .
Which Semi-quadrate , is a Like Figure , and a like situate to AE , as is ACB to AB .
And therefore ( because like Figures are in the Duplicate Proportion of their respective Sides ) If we so inscribe AE , as that the Square of AE be to the Square of AB , in such Given Proportion , the Lunula will at DE , be so divided as is required .
B E D F AC And this will hold ( if duly applied , according as the different Cases may require ) though E be taken ( in the Continuation of the Semi-circle ) beyond B. For ( still ) Like Figures , will be in Duplicate Proportion of their Respective Sides ; and CE = CD ~ DE .
And the same is yet improveable much further .
I forbear to Apply this to the several Parts of the whole Systeme , considered by Dr Gregorie , ( Or to that of Mr Caswell , ) that I be not too Tedious .
Much less shall I give my self the trouble to consider the Solids to be made by the Conversion of it , or of its parts , about a given Axis , ( as MN , or AB , or AC , or BC , &amp;c. ) with their Surfaces and Centers of Gravity ; as I have done elsewhere for the Cycloid : But such as are at Leisure ( and think it worth the while , ) may do it by such like Methodes as I have made use of for the Cycloide , I am SIR , Yours to serve you , JOHN WALLIS .
Post-script .
In the Transactions for the Month of August last past ; Numb. 255 .
A Letter of mine , is very faultyly Printed .
I desire that the Errata may be thus Corrected .
Page .
280 .
l. 24 .
ut ait .
p. 281.l .
15 .
differentias infinitesimas .
p. 282 .
l. 12 .
( ut antea ) rerum Novitas .
l. 14 .
Messis .
l. 15 .
Et quidem .
l. 16 .
Atque hinc .
l. 17 .
natura .
l. 22 .
Academia .
l. 25 .
reapse .
l. 33 .
misi .
p. 283 .
l. 5 .
desperatum .
l. 11 .
Sueci .
l. 17 .
itinere .
l. 25 .
adornat .
l. 33 .
Caeno .
p. 284 .
l. 1 .
sita .
l. 13 .
redeundo ) sensim .
l. 17 .
motibus .
l. 19 .
penitius .
l. 22 .
materiae .
l. 23 .
perpendiculum erectos ) ad .
l. 24 .
longo tractu .
l. 25 .
prae se .
l. 29 .
Multaque .
l. 30 .
annos .
l 31 .
deprompta ) mihi videntur huc .
l. 32 .
alio .
l. 34 .
caenosum , turbidum .
l.35 .
Isthmo .
l. ult .
The Words P. S. Aug. 29 .
1699 .
should have stood at lin. 20 .
Numb. 257 .
p. 346 .
l. 11 .
the Solar Tropical year .
p. 349 .
l. 2 .
suggested by .
p. 351 .
l. 34 .
stands thus .

