III .
A Letter from Dr. William Musgrave to Dr. Sloane , being an Argument for the more frequent use of Laryngotomy , urged from a remarkable Cure in Chirurgery ; performed by Mr. John Keen of Roch in Cornwal .
SIR , IT cannot pass your Observation , that the erroneous Opinions , and unhappy Prejudices ; entertained by Mankind , in matters of Physic ; have occasioned great Calamities , and been of Pernicious Consequence to them .
It was no small number of Men , that some years since , lost their Lives , from an Aversion to the JesuitsBark : depriving themselves of the Use and Advantage of that excellent Drug , from a Reason merely nominal .
The like unaccountable Humour obtained a long time against the use of Opiates , and a Temperate Regimen in the Small Pox ; by which single Method , the famous Dr. Sydenham has in all probability already preserved more of his Countrymen , than in the last ten years fell by the Sword , in Ireland and Flanders .
Of such destructive Consequence are Errors of this kind , when they become Fashionable and Established ; and of such Public Advantage is it to hinder their Growth , and taking Root in the ~ Men .
We are still Labouring under many Prejudices of this Nature ; some quite excluding , others rarely admitting , even in the utmost extremity , most advantageous Methods of Physic .
I will at present mention only one ; that is Laryngotomy , and set forth the groundless less Exceptions , and needless Fears , commonly expressed against this safe and useful Operation .
Laryngotomy is highly to be valued , for that in the greatest extremity , when a Man is in most imminent danger of Suffocation , and to all appearance within very few minutes of his last , by opening a new Passage for Breath ; it gives speedy and certain Relief , and this when all other Methods fail : and without any considerable Injury from the Instrument .
The Patient , in a Minute or two , is brought from the struggles of Death ; to a state of Complacency , Ease and Security .
In the large Field of Practical Physic ; perhaps there is not any one Method that works so great a Change , for the better , in so short a time .
But however Beneficial this Operation is , in itself , we find it seldom practised ; very seldom in Comparison to the occasions for it .
That Gap which appears on the cutting a Throat , ( the divided Parts being then drawn to their other more fixed ends ; ) together with the great Flux of Blood , when the Jugulars , and Carotid Arteries are also wounded ; create in most Men a dread of this butcherly Operation ; and make those , especially who are unacquainted with Anatomy , suspect all Wounds of the Trachea , as mortal ; and oppose Laryngotomy under all the most urgent Circumstances .
This Prejudice is still of worse Consequence , for that Squinzies may be , as they often have been , Epidemical ; ( instances of which we have in Panarol , Wier , Hippocrates , &amp;c. ) in which Case this Operation becomes of more frequent necessity ; and greater numbers of Men must perish for not admitting it : In order to wipe off this Prejudice , ( as far as Argument will go in this Matter ; ) it may be affirmed , that Laryngotomy is in great danger of Suffocation , allowable , and the Wound curable : for that , ( to argue a fortiori ) when the Trachea has been Cut through , the Parts have been joined together , and the Wound cured .
Indeed , the Encyclopaedia Chirurgica ( Lib. 2 .
cap. 4 ) has these words , Quae ( vulnera ~ .
Asperae Arteriae ) ut plurimum periculo sunt plenissima ; praesertim si vasa Jugularia simul sint discissa , aut ipsa Arteria integre per transver sum dissecta ; quae nulla Art denuo connectetur , sed Machinae humanae totalem assert destructionem .
But , in opposition to this Voluminous Authority , I beg leave to present you , with the following Observation , sent me by an Ingenious Surgeon , Mr. John Kean of Cornwal , who performed the Cure .
You have it under his own Hand .
Nicholas Hobb , of St. ~ in Cornwal , aged Sixty three or thereabout , was ~ time in March 1696 .
at a distance from any House set on by Ruffians , who first by a Blow on the Occiput knocked him to the Ground ; then transected the Trachea somewhat beneath the Pomum Adami , together with several of the adjacent Muscles , and some large Blood-Vessels ; from which he lost a very great quantity of Blood , seen afterwards lying on the Ground .
The Ruffians having Robbed him , and thinking him either dead , or past all recovery , left him .
After some time the Wounded Man recovers so much Sense and Strength as to thrust his Neckcloth into the large and gaping Wound , and by degrees to craul Home to his own House , not far from the Scene of this Tragedy .
In In this lamentable condition I was sent for , and after examination of the Wound , and considering the great Flux of Blood , I was not more surprised at any thing than that the Patient was then alive .
There seemed to be no manner of hopes , not the least prospect of Recovery : however , in order to an attempt , I endeavoured to suppress the Hemorrhage , and to join the divided parts .
Lipothymies came frequently upon the Patient , especially upon every little motion of his Body , and gave great interruptions to the Methods of Chirurgery , and lessened our hopes of a Cure .
His frequent Lipothymies were after some time succeeded by Convulsions , and then indeed I thought his Thread of Life very near an end .
Another great difficulty arose from the parts of the ~ being now at a vast distance from each other .
The lower part being every turn of Inspiration sunk deep into the Neck as low as the Claviculae , and just appeared upon every Expiration .
To surmount these Difficulties , and particularly to secure fast hold of the lower part of the ~ , I ordered a lusty strong Fellow , then present , to hold the Legs of the Patient over his Shoulders , and by this means raise them , together with the Abdomen , above the Thorax , Collum , &amp;c. in which Posture the divided parts came so near to each other , that with strong waxen Thread I sewed together several of them : but as to the Divisions of the Trachea , I secured them together by passing large Needles deep into the Flesh on each side , and twisting strong waxen Thread about them as in labio fisso .
Over all , for ~ security , I applied a Restrictive ( ~ pulv restring .
Clowes ) covering the greatest part of the Neck with a ~ , Ex ~ cum albumine ovor .
advising the Patient to lie as quiet as he could .
The Patient now begins again to Speak , and as well as the Cough , ~ of Breath , and his weakness would allow , softly , and with a low Voice gives an account of the occasion as above .
An Arteriac was then made up for him ( to smooth the Trachea , and promote Expectoration ) e Troch .
Pectoral .
Batean .
( in aq .
Stephan ~ .
Solut .
) ~ .
Sir .
Tussilag .
~ Balsamic , ~ pulv .
Anis .
Glycyr .
ana ~ .
Balsam .
Sulphur .
terebinth .
~ .
Peruv .
gut .
vj .
cum mellis opt .
despumat .
q. s. fiat Linctus per Bacillum Glycyr .
saepins ad libend .
From the use of which his Cough abated , and he discharged by Expectoration much Grumous Blood and other Matter .
As to the Convulsions and Lipothymies , I applied to his Nostrils Spir .
C.C. Succin .
&amp;c. and Embrocated the back part of his Neck with a Liniment , ex ol .
Lil .
Alb .
~ .
Tereb .
Succin .
ana ~ .
N. M. ~ .
Ung .
Nervin .
~ .
Mis .
And then took leave , and upon my return the next day found the Convulsions had left him ; nor had he from that time any return of them , or of the Syncope .
But on the fourth day the Stitches were torn open , the Wound appeared large enough to admit a middle fiz 'd Hand : a great part of the Oesophagus appeared in view much inflamed and scratched by the Instrument .
The Epyglottis did not as usual , cover the Rima of the Larynx , so that I could easily see up into the Mouth , part of the Annular Cartilage was cut obliquely , and hung only by a little Fibre to the upper part of the Larynx , &amp;c. Indeed I met with frequent Ruptures , the wax Thread and Needles often fretting through the Flesh they held , and was by them put back in my Cure ; but I as often repeated the said Stitches in manner and method as before-mentioned .
About the tenth Day the larger Blood-Vessels appeared conglutinated and covered with new Flesh ; the Gula of good Aspect , the Inflammation of that and all the Neighbouring parts gone .
I now dressed with Liniment Arcei .
On the Eleventh the symptomatic Fever was in a manner gone , and the Wound under the circumstances of good digestion .
In the mean time the Diet when he could swallow was of Mutton-Broth , Ale-Meat , Poacht-Eggs .
The Cough continuing a long time very severe , was at length overcome by duly adhereing to the Linctus aforesaid , with repeated Boles of Balsam .
Lucatel .
Cons .
Rosar .
Rub .
hora somni , with a Draught of a Pectoral Decoction , used also instead of common Drink To mitigate the violence of it , and procure him Sleep , the following Haustus was frequently used , and never failed our expectation .
~ Ol .
Amygdal .
Dul .
Rec .
Express ~ .
Sir .
de Mecon : ~ Laud .
Lond. ( Aq .
Steph .
~ .
Solut .
) gr. ij .
fiat haustus hora somni sumendus .
About the Eleventh and Twelfth Days we plainly discovered little Portions of new Flesh arising not only from the Carneous Membrane incumbent on the Gullet , but also out of the Substance of the Cartilages themselves , both on the upper and lower parts of the divided Trachea .
The external containing parts of the Neck began now to unite by Incarnation ; new Flesh arising and apparently lessening the dimensions of the Wound every time there was a Laceration of the Stitches , insomuch that two Needles were now sufficient , whereas I used in the beginning not less than six .
And those Carneous Portions both of the Trachea and Exterior parts , gradually joining and intermixing , became one solid Cicatrix from each end of the Wound almost to the middle of the Wind-Pipe , where the Air continued in some degree to have an Exit .
About the Fifteenth Day I removed several pieces of Bones which had contracted a Caries in the Cartilage ( which in this old Man as in many others was grown Osseous ) and were thrust out by the New Flesh .
He now Swallows with little trouble , Eats sufficiently , and nourishes in Proportion .
The Aperture about the Twenty sixth Day was almost closed up , and in Four or Five Days more the sides of the Wound were perfectly joined and Cicatriz 'd , the Trachea performing its part in Respiration as at other times without any considerable inconvenience .
He speaks indifferent well , but is forc't to take care in swallowing , the Rimula not being exactly shut as before the Wound , which makes Liquor of any sort more apt to fall into the Canal , and so cause a Cough , Hoarsness , &amp;c. He does not Swallow dry Meats as well as formerly , but in all other respects is as well as ever .
This Cure was in this manner performed by me John Keen , of Roch in Cornwal , in the Year 1696 .
as above .
This signal History affords Matter for much Observation ; but the only use I shall at present make of it , is , that if , in a Person of this Age , ( above Sixty ; ) if in a Wound whereby the Trachea was Cut through , and several of the Cartilages beaten together ; the divided parts of the Trachea may be made to unite and grow together , ( as in the present Case ; ) certainly then Laryngotomy ; which is a much less dangerous Wound indeed , but little in Comparison to it : in violent Squinzies , in danger of Suffocation , from Causes of a like nature with them ; may safely , and ought to be put in Practise .
The Disadvantage is a slight .
Wound easily cured ; the Advantage nothing less than the Life of a Man .
Exon , Dec.28 .
1699 .

