II .
An Extract of two Letters , from Dr. John Wallis , ( Professor of Geometry in Oxford .
) The One to his Grace the Lord Arch-Bishop of Canterbury .
The Other to the Lord Bishop of Worcester .
Concerning the Alteration ( suggested ) of the Julian account for the Gregorian .
FOR The most Reverend Father in God , Thomas Lord Arch-Bishop of Canterbury , his Grace at Lambeth .
Oxford June 13 .
1699 .
May it please your Grace , AS to what your Grace mentions ( in the close of your Letter which I had the honour to receive ) about altering the Annual Stile .
I am at a loss what to say .
That there is , in our Ecclesiastical Computation of the Paschal Tables , somewhat of Disorder , is not to be denied .
But I am very doubtful , that , if we go to alter that , it will be attended with greater Mischief , than the present Inconvenience .
It is dangerous removing the Old Land-marks .
~~~ ~ ~ .
A thing ( of moment ) when once settled ( though with some Inconvenience ) should not be rashly altered .
Such changes may have a further prospect than Men at first sight are aware of , and may be attended with those Evils which are not presently apprehended .
In the business of Geography ; upon removing the FirstMeridian ( upon some plausible pretence ) from where Ptolomy had placed it ( though a thing at first purely arbitrary ) it is now come to pass , that we have ( in a manner ) no First-Meridian , at all ; that is , none Fixed ; but every New Map-maker places his FirstMeridian where he pleases : which hath brought a great Confusion in Geography .
And , as to the point in question , the Disorder in the Paschal Tables was a thing noted , and complained of for three or four hundred years , before Pope Gregory did ( unhappily ) attempt the Correction of the Calendar .
But it was , all that time , thought adviseable , rather to suffer that Inconvenience , than , by correcting it , to run the hazard of a greater Mischief .
And it had been much better , if it had so continued to this Day , rather than Pope Gregory ( upon his own single Authority ) should take upon him to impose a Law on all the Churches , Kingdoms and States of Christendom , to alter both their Ecclesiastical and Civil year , for a worse form , than what before we had .
Or if merely upon account of the Paschal Tables ( for he made no other pretence ) it were thought necessary to make a Change ; he might have corrected the Paschal Tables ( or given us New Paschal Tables instead of those of Dionysius , ) withont altering the Civil year .
Which hath introduced the confusion ( which we now complain of ) of the Old and New Stile .
And which now can never be remedied ; unless all Nations should , at once , agree upon one ; which is not to be supposed .
I say , at once ; for if some sooner and some later do alter their Stile , the Confusion ( in History ) will yet be greater than now it is .
It is true , that upon pretence of the Popes ( usurped ) Supremacy in Spirituals ( and in Temporals also in order to Spirituals ) most Popish Countries ( but I think , not all ) have submitted their Civil year ( as well as their Ecclesiastical ) to the single Authority of the Pope 's Bull .
But your Grace knows very well , that the Church of England had ( long before this pretended Correction ) Renounced the Pope 's Supremacy ; and ( that being supposed ) there is no pretence for the Pope of Rome 's imposing a Law on the Church and Kingdom of England , to change our Ecclesiastical and Civil year ; more than , in Us , for that in Rome .
And , upon this account , the Church and Kingdom of England , did at first not admit of that change , and have hitherto retained our Old Constitution of the Julian year ; notwithstanding the Pope 's ( pretended ) Supremacy ; and I see not why we should now admit it , after having so long renounced it .
And really , though it may not yet appear and be owned above board ; and , those who now press for an alteration , be not aware of it , and be far from any Popish design , I cannot but think there is , at bottom , a latent Popish interest , which ( under other specious pretences ) sets it on foot ; in order to obtain ( in practise ) a kind of tacit submission to the Pope 's Supremacy , or owning his Authority .
And though they be so wise as to say nothing of it at present ( for the Bait is designed to Hide the hook till the Fish be caught , ) they will please themselves to have gained de facto , what in words we disclaim .
For there is nothing but the Pop 's Bull , which should induce the Change of the ( Civil ) Julian year ( which is much better ) for the New Gregorian .
For the Equinox going backward , ( for 10 or 11 Minutes each year , ) is very inconsiderable , and which in Celestial Computations , is easily rectified ; as are many other inequalities of much greater concernment .
And I think it was never pretended that the Civil year must needs agree ( exactly to a minute ) with the Celestial .
And , if never so much affected , is impossible to be had : For the Solar year , and the Sidereal year , differ more from each other , than the Julian from either , which is a midlde betwixt them .
And the Seat of Easter ( which only concerns the Ecclesiastical not the Civil year ) may easily be rectified , if need be , without affecting the Civil year at all .
Or , if not rectified ; the Celebration of Easter a Week or Month sooner or later , doth not influence at all our solemn Commemoration of Christ 's Resurrection .
And it is agreedby most ( if not all ) Chronologers , that as to the Year of our Lord , the Annus Vulgaris is not the Annus verus ( though it be not agreed how much it differs : ) But it would be a horrible Confusion in History , if we should now go about to alter the Vulgar Account .
All the pretence that I can understand for altering our Stile , is only , that in so doing we should agree with some of our Neighbours with whom we now differ : But it will then be as true , that we shall differ from others with whom we do now agree .
We should agree with France , but differ from Scotland ( which , as to us , is more considerable ) and with all others who yet follow the old Stile .
If it be said , that they , in time , may come so to do by our Example .
This would but make the Confusion yet the greater .
For then we must be obliged , not only to know what places do use the new Stile ; but , from what time they began so to do , if we would understand their Dates .
And , if we should , by a new Law alter our Stile in England ; this would not comprise Scotland : And we cannot promise our selves that they would presently comply also .
For ( according to the present Constitution of that Church ) they are not so pliable to comply with the Modes of Rome as some in England are .
And the business of Easter ( which has the sole pretence of the first alteration ) would , to them , signify nothing : Who ( according to their Constitution ) observe no Easter at all , but do rather declare against it .
And when all is done , there will still be a necessity of keeping up the distinction of old Stile and new Stile ( which Pope Gregory 's pretended Correction hath made necessary ; ) and with that distinction things may be now as well adjusted , as if we should now change our Stile .
I forbear to discourse at large ( that I be not too tedious ) how much a better Constitution the Julian Year is , and more advisable , than the new Gregorian .
Which is a thing so notorious , that no Astronomer , ( who understands the Methods of Astronomical calculations ) though a Papist , can be ignorant of ; however they may please to dissemble it .
Insomuch that ( in their Astronomical Calculations ) they are fain sirst to adjust their Calculations to the Julian Year , and thence transfer them to their New Gregorian .
And consequently how unreasonable it is for us to exchange our better Julian Year for one that is so much worse .
It would be much more reasonable ( save that they will never be induced to part with ought , which may favour their Usurpation , how absurd soever , ) that the Papists should quit their new Gregorian , and return to their old Julian Year .
But I forbear to enlarge on this , ( and many other things which might be alleged ; ) and hum bly beg your Graces Pardon for having already given you the trouble of too long a Letter .
And am , My Lord , Your Graces very humble and obedient Servant John Wallis .
APOS T-S CRIPT To be added to a former Letter to the Lord Archbishop of Canterbury .
Post script , Aug. 31 .
1699 .
OF what Mr. Lock hath done in this matter , I know nothing but from your Graces Letter of Aug. 27 .
1699.It seems he advises , that , for Eleven Leap-years , we should omit the Intercalation of Febr. 29 .
and thenceforth go on with the Gregorian Account : The last of which 11 Leap-years should be 1744 .
But , if we begin in the Change ( as it is suggested ] at the Year 1700 .
the last of those Eleven Leap-years must be 1740 .
not This Expedient is the same that was ( during our Civil-wars ) suggestedly those then at Oxford in the Year 1645 .
viz. That , from thence forward , we should omit ten such Intercalations .
Against which there seems to me this great Obje ction .
In the time of Julius and Augustus Caesar , there was a Year which was called Annus confusionis : Upon the settling , unsettling , and resettling the Julian Year .
( Of which Kepler gives an Account , with the Mischiefs of it , in his Tabulae Rudolphinae , with the Title Typus Anni confusionis .
) And the like in the Year 1582 .
when Pope Gregory did at once strike out Ten Days of that Year .
But , if this Advice should take place ; we should now , instead of one Annus confusionis , have a Confusion for Four and Forty Years together , wherein we should agree neither with the Old nor with the New Account .
But be sometimes 10 Days , sometimes 9 Days , sometimes 8 Days , ( and so forth ) later than the One , and sooner than the other account .
And a Foreigner would not be able to judge of an English Date , without knowing in which of these Years , we vary 10 , 9 , or 8 Days ( and so forth ) from either of these Accounts .
And this , for 44 Years together .
Which seems to me a much greater Confusion , then if ( as in 1582 ) we should ( once for all ) cast out 11 Days .
But I cannot think it advisable to do either .
FOR The Right Reverend Father in God William Lord Bishop of Worcester at Whitehall .
Oxford June 30 .
1699 .
May it please your Lordship , IN a late Letter which I had the honour to receive from my Lotd Archbishop 's Grace of Canterbury , His Grace was pleased to intimate , as a thing now under Consideration , about changing the Stile of our Civil Year .
It may perhaps be presumption in me to interpose my thoughts with your Lordship in a Business of that Nature .
But I must needs think it a~ point to touch upon : and which , if we attempt it , may be attended with greater Mischiefs , than we may at first be aware of .
I adventured to say somewhat to that purpose in a Letter to his Grace : But more may be said .
That the difference of Stiles doth create some Consusion in History is not to be denied .
( And it is very unhappy that Pope Gregory XIII .
did in the last Century attempt it .
) But it is now unavoidable and cannot be remedied .
For it is not England only , that uses the Julian Year .
But all the Three Kingdoms of England , Scotland , and Ireland ; and all our Foreign Plantations , which are not a few ; and the two Kingdoms of Denmark and Sweden ; the Protestant Cantons of Switzerland ; and Four of the Seven united Provinces ; and how many more of the Protestants in Germany I cannot presently say .
And if we should now change our Stile in compliance with some of our Popish Neighbours from whom we differ ; we should then vary from the Protestants with whom we now agree .
And particularly from Scotland , ( with whom we are more concerned to agree than with France .
) For we are not to presume that they will presently change at the same time with us .
It is happy that they did comply with us in the late Revolution ; ( to be under the same King with us : ) We cannot presume they will be so fond of Compliance in all the Modes of Rome : ~ As is very evident in their not admitting Episcopacy , nor the Observation of Easter ; ( which latter was the only pretence of first introducing the Gregorian Year .
) So that there will still be as great necessity of SV .
and SN .
( Old Stile and New Stile ) as now there is , ( without which we shall be at a loss , in History to judge distinctly of Dates ; and , with it , we are now as easy as if we change .
) If it be said , that other Protestants may , in time , be induced to follow our Example : Perhaps some may ( not all : ) But this would but make the confusion yet greater : For thenceforth , we must be obliged ( if we would be at a certainty in History ) not only to know what Countries do use this or that Stile ; but , from what time they began so to do .
It would be much more advisable ( if the Papists would be as compliant as they would have us to be ) for the Papists to return to their Old Julian Year , than for us to embrace their New Gregorian .
And , it might much easier be effected ; For , if the Pope could be persuaded to grant a Bull to that purpose ; all the Papists would , at once , be as much obliged so to do , as by Pope Gregory 's Bull to vary from it .
If it be said ; there is no hopes of that ; Then the Argument stands : If the Pope will not leave his pretended Supremacy , then we must admit it .
That the Julian Year is , in it self , a better form , and more advisable , than the New Gregorian , is undeniable ; and , all Aftronomers , even Papists themselves ( if not otherwise Bigoted in favour of the Pope 's Supremacy , and the Infallibility of the Roman Church ) cannot but know it : Insomuch , that in many cases they are fain ( or find it advisable ) first to Adjust their Calculations to the Julian Year , and thence transfer them to the Gregorian .
And there is no Inducement for our changing our Better Year , for a Worse , but only in compliance with the Pope 's pretended Supremacy , not only over all Churches and Kingdoms , but even the Celestial Motions , ( as Pope Gregory , in his Bull , doth wisely pretend .
) Now it is well known , that , long before Pope Gregory 's Bull , England had renounced the Pope 's Supremacy ( and are therefore unconcerned in that Bull ; ) and I see no reason why ( after so long a Disclaimer ) we should be now fond to readmit it .
But what greater Evidence ( of owning that Authority ) can ( in practice ) be expected , than obeying their Commands , in things ( otherwise ) unadvisable ~ Hoc Ithacus velit , &amp; magno mercentur Atridae .
And no doubt but the hand of Joab is in the matter , though perhaps we do not see it .
As to our selves ; this cannot be done , without altering the Act of Uniformity , and altering the CommonPrayer Book ; ( For , at least , all the Calendar must be new framed : ) And your Lordship knows how warm some were a while since , against touching that in the least , ( or so much as considering ( on the King 's Commission for that purpose , ) whether ought in it might be changed for the better .
If yet your Lordship think it necessary , that the Seat of Easter should be rectified ; that may easily be done , without altering the Civil Year : For if , in the Rule for Easter , instead of saying next after the One and Twentieth of March , you say , next after the Vernal Equinox ; the work is done .
( And we might be excused the trouble of Paschal Tables ; and the intricate Perplexities of the Gregorian Epacts .
) For then every Almanac will tell you , when it is Equinox , and when it is Full Moon , for the present year , ( without disturbing the Civil Account .
) And this Pope Gregory might as well have done , without troubling the Account of Christendom .
But , if he would needs disturb the Civil Year ; He should have rectified it ( not to the time of the Nicene Council , but ) to the time of our Saviour 's Birth .
For our Epoch is not from the Nicene Council , but from the Birth of Christ .
We do not say , Anno Niceni Concilii ; but Anno Domini .
And most certain it is , that , at our Saviour 's Birth , the Vernal Equinox , was not on the One and Twentieth of March , ( as this New Account would suppose , ) but nearer to the Five and Twentieth .
It is alleged as an Argument , why Now to change , because the difference , which this Year is but Ten Days , will next Year be Eleven Days .
But , My Lord , we must be very weak Disputants , to be caught by such a Fallacy , ( which is barely begging the Question .
) The Point in Question , is not why Now ; but why at all .
It is not We that have departed from them ; but They from Us .
The Julian Year was their Year , as well as Ours , till the year 1582 .
when a Fancy took Pope Gregory to Exchange a Better year for a Worse , and disturb the Christian World .
And then the Argument ( if it signify any thing ) stands thus : The farther they be gone astray ; the more reason there is that we should follow them .
I should rather argue , The more Reason there is why They should return ( to that from whence they went astray .
) We are as we were , ( and as They were till that time .
) And the reason why we did not then change , remains still good why we should not make that change , at all .
If this Point had been started in our late King James 's time ; I desire your Lordship to consider , with what Face it would have looked .
And , if the Mask be taken off , the Face is still the same .
I find , it was started in the time of our Civil Wars ( about the year 1644 ) by those about the King , when Oxford was the King 's Head-Quarters ; but the project did not then succeed , by reason that the King 's Party ( in that contest ) were not revalent .
And your Lordship knows very well ; how much it was to the prejudice of the King 's Cause , that those on the other side would suppose him to be too much influenced by Popish Councils ; of which this was a great Instance .
And no doubt they will be as ready to push it forward , ( upon any the least pretence ) whenever they find us soft enough to receive the impression .
Not perhaps under the names of Julian and Gregorian , ( for the word Gregorian speaks too plain , ) but ( under the softer terms ) of Old and New Stile .
Otherwise , so much weight would not be laid upon so slight a pretence .
For the Addition of Old Stile or New Stile will certainly determine the difference of Eleven Days in the next Century , as of Ten in this , if nothing else were in the wind .
We have been too often caught in such Snares .
I forbear to say more ( though more might be said ) that I may not too much presume on your Lordship 's Leisure .
But am , My Lord , Your Lordship 's very humble Servant , John Wallis .

