A short Discourse concerning Concoction : Read at a Meeting of the Royal Society , May 1699 , by Clopton Havers , M. D. Fellow of the Royal Society .
THE Manner in which the Digestion of the Aliment is performed , is a thing not very easy to be understood and explained .
However , it has not escaped the Conjectures of some Philosophical Men , who having curiously observed the Phenomenon of Nature , and enquired into their Causes , have , amongst other things , endeavoured to account for this .
But their Sentiments about it have been various , and the Hypothesis , by which they have studied to explain it , very different .
Some have thought the Concoction of the Food to be a kind of Elixation ; and that the grosser and more solid Parts being as it were boiled in the Liquid by the Heat of the Stomach , and the Parts adjacent to it , as the Liver , Spleen , and Omentum , are by a long and continued Elixation first rendered more tender , and then colliquated , and dissolved into minuter Particles , so as to mix more equally with the fluid , and with that to make one Pulpament , or chylous Mass .
And Hippocrates , tho ' he does not plainly call it an Elixation , yet seems to attribute the Concoction of the Food to the Heat of the Stomach , as the Cause of it : Sect. 4 .
Libro de salubri victus ratione .
So where he takes Notice of the voiding of such Faeces as appear to be like the Food that has been eaten , he adds , Constat enim , sane ventriculum , ciborum copiam , ut concoguat , calefacere non posse .
And there are other Passages in the same Book , from which we may conclude , that he supM m pos 'd pos 'd the Heat of the Stomach to be the great Cause of the Digestion of the Food .
There are others that make the Stomach it self to be the great Instrument of Digestion , but in a different manner : And they suppose it to be performed by an Attrition , as if the Stomach , by those repeated Motions , which are the necessary Effects of Respiration , when it is distended by the Aliment , did both rub or grind off some minuter Particles from the grosser Parts , and by continually agitating the Mass of Food , make those Parts , which are not contiguous to the Stomach , strike one against another , and break one another in pieces , until they are all attenuated .
It is evident enough , that the sides of the Stomach do in Expiration press upon the Contenta , so as to oblige , at least some Parts of them , every time the Muscles of the Abdomen are contracted , to move and shift their Places .
So in Inspiration , when the Diaphragme and Liver press upon the upper Part of the Stomach , the Aliment must be moved again .
So that by these reciprocal Motions , that part of the Food , which is contiguous to the Stomach , and moves in a Line parallel to it , must rub against it : And all the other Parts being moved by such a Compression , as gives them a different Tendency , it is certain they must be continually striking one against another .
And for Bread , and such Things as are made of Flower , that will be softened and dissolved with any common Liquid , that Agitation of the Stomach , which moves them in Respiration , might seem sufficient to break and dissolve them , when they are sufficiently moistened with a Fluid .
Yet this cannot be thought enough to break and digest Flesh-meat , Fruits , or any other thing that will not be softned and dissolved in Water , or some such Liquid .
But altho ' this Motion of the Aliment , caused by Respiration , does not actually digest it , yet it has a great and necessary Use in Concoction , and makes all the grosser Parts , as they are attenuated , mix equally with the Fluid .
Some think that the Bilious Juice ~ others , that the Spirits , are chiefly concerned in this Affair .
Galen , in his Book de Naturalibus Facultatibus , makes it to be the Effect , not of one , but of several Causes ; as , a Pituitous Juice in the Stomach , the Bile , &amp;c. which appears from what he has said , and the Translator thus rendered : ` ` Verum quanto ii ( cibi ) qui mansi sunt , iis , qui inhaeserunt , magis sunt alterati ; tanto ctiam his magis ii , qui devorati sunt .
Siquidem incomparabilis erit horum alterationis excessus , si &amp; quae in ventre est Pituita , &amp; Bilis , &amp; Spiritus , &amp; Calor , &amp; tota Ventris substantia , aestimentur .
Some there are that will have the Food to be dissolved by a Menstruum , which is supplied from the Glands of the Stomach , or some other way : But those that do so far agree in the General , as to think Concoction is performed by a Dissolvent , do differ in their Notions of the Nature of the Menstruum : For there are some that suppose it to be an Acid , which does erode the grosser Parts of the Food , and dissolves them in the same manner as Vinegar , Spirit of Vitriol , or any such-like Acid , will dissolve even so solid a Body as Iron .
And it cannot be denied , but that Oil of Vitriol will dissolve Fleshmeat , and reduce it to a Pulp : But it is not to be supposed that the Fibres of the Stomach can admit any such strong and corroding Acid , without something to correct it , but it must be injured in its Tone , and labour under great and extraordinary Pains .
Neither does such a Menstruum , tho ' it will digest some things , seem capable of dissolving so great a Variety of Things as we eat , especially when a great many of them are of a contrary Nature .
Some will have the Menstruum to be a nitro aereous Spirit , that is , quick , and very penetrating , and included in its proper Vehicle ; which , being in its own Nature apt to penetrate the Mass of the Aliment , does diffuse it self through the Whole , and breaking the Vinculum of the more solid Parts , does dissolve their Compages .
By others , it is thought to be some Saline Juice in the Stomach , by which the Parts of the Aliment are divided and dissolved , and those which are fit for Nourishment , are volatiliz 'd .
Lastly , There are some others who reject the Opinions I have already mentioned , and suppose the Digestion of the Food to be performed by the Benefit of a Ferment , which , when it is mixed with the Aliment , excites in the Mass an intestine Motion , and the different and contrary Motions or Tendency of the Parts making some kind of Collision , gradually break off Particles from the Grosser , and more solid Parts , till they are so attenuated as to be apt to mix more equally with the Fluid , and with them to make one soft or chylous Substance .
But yet there is not amongst them an universal Consent , either about the Nature of this Ferment , or the manner how it is supplied .
For first , some think it to be the Remains of the Food that was last digested ; which , having lain some time in the Stomach , after the rest is carried down into the Intestines , contracts an Acid , or some other Quality , and is so altered as to partake of the Nature of a Leaven .
And this Leaven being a Part of the Food , which has been already digested , is so soft and liquid as to be capable of mixing with the Aliment , which is next taken into the Stomach , and being agitated with it by the repeated Pressures of the Diaphragme , Liver , and Abdominal Muscles upon the Stomach in Respiration , does diffuse it self through the whole Mass , and being mixed with it , like Leaven , or Yest added to new Wort , &amp;c. puts it into a State of Fermentation , and by this Fermentation , or the Expansion of the Ferment , and the more tenuious Parts , which are first put into Motion by it , those which are more solid , and with which they are intermix 'd , are rent , and divided , and so attenuated , as to become a soft and pulpous Matter .
And altho ' the greatest part of the Food , that is thus broken and concocted , is by the Contraction of the Fibres of the Stomach pressed into the Duodenum , yet they do not contract themselves so as to force out all the Aliment , but leave between the Rugae or Folds , on the inside of the Stomach , a sufficient Quantity to be a Leaven to the next Meal ; and so from time to time .
Some have a Notion , That this Ferment , or Principle of Fermentation , is in the Aliment it self ; which being a Congeries of Matter , consisting of various Parts of a different Nature , is no sooner enclosed in the Stomach , and digested in the Heat of that , and the adjacent Parts , but the more spirituous and subtle Particles are put into motion both from that Warmth , and the Difference of their Natures , and enter upon a Fermentation .
And so by their intestine Commotion , and the Violence they offer to those Parts which oppose the Tendency of any of them , they break and dissolve what is more solid .
Again : Some suppose , that this Ferment is supplied from the Glands of the Stomach .
And Lastly , Others , and perhaps with much better Reason , contend for the Saliva , and make that to be the Ferment , which serves principally for the Digestion of the Food ; which in Mastication being mixed with our Aliment , is with that carried down into the Stomach , where the Parts of it being put into Motion by a kindly and agreeable Heat , they do ferment with , and exagitate first those Parts of the Food which are most apt to ferment with it , and then both conspire to break and dissolve the grosser and more stubborn Parts .
And Galen , in the Book I have before-mentioned , plainly allows that the Saliva is concerned in the Business of Concoction , tho ' he supposes the Alteration , which is produced by this Juice , to be made in the Mouth , as appears from these Words : Quae ( alteratio ) in ore agitur mutat quidem id ( nutrimentum ) in alteram speciem manifest , non tamen ad perfectionem transmut at Qui mansi sunt Cibi primum quidem hac Pituit a ( oris ) imbuuntur , &amp; cum ea miscentur Itaque majorem mutationem consecuti sunt , quam ii , qui in vacuis dentium intervallis fuere impacti .
Now I have given this short Account of the various Opinions of some Ingenious Men , concerning the Manner how Concoction is performed ; I come now to propose my own Hypothesis , by which I shall endeavour to explain it .
In order to the more easy and effectual Digestion of the Food , Nature has appointed some Parts for the breaking our Aliment , and reducing whatever is gross into smaller Parts , before it is put upon Digestion : Others to supply the Ferment , by which it is to be dissolved and concocted , and which , before it comes to be included in the Stomach , does moisten , and make it more soft , that it may more easily be penetrated and broken by those Parts which serve to divide every Morsel into smaller Pieces , and prevents the Inconvenience and Trouble which would arise from the Nourishment sticking about or between them , when it is dry or viscous .
For the breaking of that part of our Food , which is not liquid , Nature has furnished us with Teeth , and those of two sorts : For some are ordained to divide and break off smaller Morsels from a larger Mass ; others are made for the grinding those Morsels into much smaller parts .
The Teeth , which serve to break off Pieces of a convenient Magnitude from a larger Mass , are of two sorts accommodated to the Nature of the Substance which we eat .
These are the Incisores , and the Dentes Canini .
If the Substance , which we have to eat , be not hard , but more easily penetrated and divided , then the Incisores are capable of making an Impression upon it , and fixed firmly enough in the Jaws to break off that Part which they take hold of .
But if it be more solid , and not easily penetrated , nor any Piece without Difficulty to be separated from that Body , whereof it is a Part , then we apply the Dentes Canini , or Eye-Teeth to it , which are not spread , nor have such an edge as the Incisores , but are sharp and pointed like an Awl , and so do more readily penetrate a Substance that is hard , and which the Incisores can scarcely make any Impression upon .
And as the Parts of a more solid Body are commonly with more Difficulty separated , and there must be a greater Stress put upon those Teeth which pull it into pieces ; so these Teeth are much more firmly fixed in the Jaws then the Incisores , tho ' they have but one single Root .
Besides , the position of all these Teeth is accommodated to their use , as being planted opposite to the Aperture of the Mouth , so that they may be conveniently applied to the Substance which we have to eat , before it is broken , and when it is too large to be admitted within the Mouth .
The Teeth which do by a Compression and Attrition reduce the little Morsels to smaller parts , are from the manner in which they break the Aliment , called Dentes Molares , because they do , like so many little Mill-stones , grind the Food between them .
And that they might be rendered fit for this purpose , they are made broad at that Extremity , which stands out of the Gums , by which means they retain some Quantity of the Food between them every time the lower Jaw is pulled up and forced against the Maxilla superior .
And as they are broad , so they are formed with Inequalities and Protuberances , and by the motion of the lower Jaw , from one side towards the other , they grind what they have between them into pieces .
The Position of these Teeth too is as convenient as that of the Incisores , and the Dentes Canini : For being designed to break those pieces of our solid Food , which are taken into the Mouth , and these pieces , when they are compressed , and moved by the Dentes Molares , being apt to fly out of the Mouth , if there were no Contrivance to prevent it , they are placed beyond the Aperture of the Mouth , and opposite to the Cheeks , which keep the Food within that Cavity , and not only so , but press it in between the Dentes Molares on one side , as the Tongue does on the other , until they have sufficiently broken and divided it .
At the same time , whilst the Dentes Molares are breaking the Food , there flows into the Mouth a salival Juice which mixes with it , and not only serves to moisten it , and to render it more apt and easy to be divided , but seems to be the Ferment , by the Benefit of which the Food is dissolved and digested .
And therefore it is intimately mixed with it by the Teeth agitating or stirring them together in mastication .
This Liquor , which we commonly call the Saliva , or Spittle , seems to be a Composition made of two several Juices , very different in their Nature .
And therefore the several Parts of it are separated by their proper Glands , and Nature has planted no fewer than four pair about the Mouth , which supply the Juices that make the Saliva ; to wit , the Parotides , and the Glandulae Nuckianae , the Glandulae Maxillares internae , and Sublinguales .
guales .
Whereas if the Saliva were but one more simple Liquor , a less Number of Glands might have been sufficient .
At least there appears no Reason why one of every Pair should disembogue it self into the Mouth so very near to the Orifice , by which a Gland of some other Pair throws in its Juice ; and they are not rather all planted at more equal Distances from one another , so to flow in upon every part of the Aliment at the same time .
Not that I suppose , as there are four pair of salivatory Glands , so there are four sorts of Juices supplied from them , to make the Saliva ; but , as I hinted before , that there are only two different Juices , that constitute it .
And these are not only sufficient , but more proper to excite and secure that Fermentation , which is necessary to Concoction .
For we find that most of those Fermentations , which arise upon Mixtures made for Experiments , are produced from the Mixture of two things , and it is not so easy to find out three or four such Liquors of a different nature , as will , upon the Mixtion of them all , produce a Fermentation , and from the Omission of any one of them discover no Discord or Disposition to ferment .
Besides , it is certain that two do better secure the End , which Nature designs .
For , if there were three or four different Juices , of which the Saliva naturally consists , these must all have their proper Qualities preserved to them , or else the Fermentation , which should arise between them , will not necessarily follow upon their Mixture ; and it is certain , that there would be more Danger , that one of three or four should be deprived of its natural Quality , than one of two .
What Nature these two Juices are of , I do not pretend positively to determine ; but so far as I have been able to make my Conjectures about it from Experiments , I do think one of them to be an acid Juice ; the other an oleaginous Liquor , something like Oil of Turpentine .
For amongst the many Experiments I have made , there was no one that gave me so much Satisfaction as that which I made with Oil of Turpentine and Oil of Vitriol , tho ' I tried several other things , that will produce a Fermentation upon their Mixture .
And it was for this Reason that I made the Experiment with Oil of Turpentine , and the other Oil .
I took a piece of raw Flesh , and having cut it into pieces , but much larger than what our more solid Food is reduced to by due Mastication , I mixed some Crums of Bread with it , then I poured in the Oil of Turpentine to them , and upon that the Oil of Vitriol , and having shook them together , I digested them about four Hours in Balneo Mariae , and then shaking them again in the Glass , I found the Meat dissolved , and they all became a thickish Pulp .
I could not but take notice , that Oil of Camphire ( tho ' it does not otherwise seem much different in its Nature from Oil of Turpentine ) and Oil of Vitriol , which upon Mixture will produce an effervescence as well as the Oil of Turpentine and Oil of Vitriol , yet did not touch the Meat , upon which I poured them , so as in the least to dissolve them .
I cannot deny but that an Acid , and a Solution of Salt of Tartar , did dissolve some part of the Flesh-meat , which I mixed them with , but yet neither so soon nor so perfectly as the two forementioned Oils .
And I do the rather think one of those Juices , which constitute the Saliva , to be of the Nature of Oil of Turpentine , than of a fixed Salt , because it will correct and temper even Oil of Vitriol , so as to render it more tolerable to the Fibres of the Stomach .
Not that I suppose the acid part of the Saliva to come near to the Acidity of Oil of Vitriol .
For tho ' , when they are mixed , they will make a Liquor that may not be injurious to the Stomach , yet the acid Juice , if it were so corrosive as Oil of Vitriol , would certainly be injurious and painful to the salivatory Ducts , which convey it to the Mouth before it is mixed with the oleaginous Liquor .
But I only say it is an Acid , and in some degree approaches to the Nature of that Oil .
And Nature , which can much better adapt several Causes for the Production of such an Effect than Art , may attain her End by a more temperate Acid .
Tho ' at the same time we may be able to make some probable and true Conjectures about the Nature of those Causes from Experiments .
It being most reasonable to suppose , that there are but two sorts of Juices , of a different Quality , that make the Saliva , I do conceive , that four of the eight salivatory Glands , or two pair of the four , do supply one of these Juices , and the other four Glands the other .
And this seems to be a very good Reason , why they are so planted , and the Orifice of their Ducts so ordered , that the Juice , which is supplied by one Gland , is discharged into the Mouth , very near to the Orifice , by which the Juice of a different Nature is transmitted from another , so that they must necessarily meet and mix together .
Thus the Glandulae Nuckianae , and the Parotides , throw in two different Juices by Orifices , which open into the Mouth very near to one another ; and the Glandulae Maxillares internae , and Sublinguales , do below supply the same kind of Juices by Orifices , that open so near to one another as to secure the Mixture of the two different Juices .
These Glands , I say , do between them afford two diverse sorts of Liquors , of such a Nature as are apt to ferment upon their first Mixture , but perhaps more considerably when they come to be digested by the Heat of the Stomach .
So that the Colluctation , or Fermentation , which attenuates and concocts the Food in the Stomach , does not ordinarily arise between the Aliment and the Saliva , but between the several Parts of the Saliva it self .
And indeed , if the Saliva did not consist of two Juices , whose Nature is in such a manner different , as to render them apt to ferment upon their Mixture , it would be very hard to conceive how it should so readily and indifferently serve for the Digestion of all Eatables ; how it should ferment with , and dissolve so great a Variety of things , not only of a different , but of a contrary Nature ; how it should ferment with Acids as well as Alkalies , digest things that are cold as well as hot or temperate ; some things that are salt , others that are insipid , bitter , and sweet , mucilaginous , oily , &amp;c. But if we suppose , that the Fermentation , which serves for the Digestion of the Food , arises from a peculiar Difference in the nature of two Juices , which constitute the Saliva , it will be easy to give a rational Account of our Concoction of innumerable things of a different Nature .
And this seems to be as effectual , and a more certain way to attenuate and dissolve the grosser Parts of our Food , than if the Fermentation were made only between the Saliva and the Aliment : Besides , the Saliva seems to discover a Fermentation upon the Mixture of its constituent Juices , even at those times when we do not actually eat ; for it is always attended with Bubbles , and a Froth , when it has not been at all agitated in the Mouth , and many of those Bubbles will remain for some considerable time after we have spit it out .
Nature therefore having appointed the Saliva for the Digestion of the Food , has taken care that it shall be thrown in upon the Aliment on every side .
Thus the Glandulae Nuckianae , and the Parotides , supply their Juices to that part of the Food , which lies on the outside of the Gums , between the Cheeks and the Teeth , and the Glandulae Maxillares internae , and Sublinguales , do bestow their Liquor upon the Meat , which is within the Teeth and Gums .
Neither has she had a Regard only to that Supply , which is due to all the Parts of our Food , but likewise to the Mixture of the two different Juices of the Saliva , which is necessary to its Fermentation .
And therefore , as I have already observed , the Orifices of the Ducts , which belong to one sort of Glands , are placed near the Aperture of a Duct , which conveys a Juice from one of the other Glands .
So the Ducts of the Glandulae Nuckianae , and the Ductus Stenoniani , do on each side open into the Mouth , near one another ; and the salivatory Ducts of the Glandulae Sublinguales , and the Maxillares internae , tho ' they have distinct Orifices , empty themselves under the same Papillae ; and the Juices , which are supplied by them , meet there , and flow into the Mouth together .
The several Parts of the Saliva being discharged into the Mouth in such a manner as to meet and begin a Fermentation , the Saliva does , partly as it is agitated with the Food by the Teeth , and some other Parts of the Mouth , partly by its own Fluidity insinuate it self into , and mixes with the Food , and not only moistens and softens it , but excites the Fermentation , which is to dissolve it .
And when the Aliment is thus mixed with the Saliva , which serves to ferment the whole Mass , it is then to be conveyed into the Stomach , that great digestive Vessel of the Body , where the Fermentation is not only continued but improved .
The Nourishment being conveyed into the Cavity of the Stomach , is there kept for some time in a digestive Heat , all which time it is under a Fermentation produced by the different Parts or Juices of the Saliva , which are mixed with it ; which Fermentation does first agitate the more tenuious or subtle parts of the Food , and puts them into motion , and so with the Fermentation of its own , and those Alimentary Parts , which it first communicates a motion to , improved by the Heat of the Stomach , the Saliva must necessarily act upon the grosser Parts .
For the intestine Motion , which is excited in the Mass , does not give the Particles , which are fermented , the same Tendency , but what is so various and confused , that they must inevitably strike not only one against another , but against those , which are more gross , so as to attenuate them , sometimes by a Collision , which strikes off smaller Particles from the larger Parts ; sometimes by a Compression , when the Particles , which are in motion happen to strike directly against any grosser Part , on every side of it ; sometimes by a kind of Explosion .
For without doubt the Saliva , which is fluid , insinuates it self into the Interstices of the more crass Parts of the Aliment , and whatever is agitated and expanded in those Interstices , requiring a larger space for the Freedom of its Motion , and offering a Violence to every thing , that opposes its Tendency , will , like Gun-powder included in a Shell , force its way out , and tear to pieces that Matter , which does endeavour to confine it .
Thus the grosser Parts are broken and divided , until they are at last so far attenuated as to mix more equally with the Fluid , and with them to make one Pulp or chylous Mass .
And altho ' I do not apprehend how the Stomach should by its reciprocal Motions in Inspiration , and Expiration , be able to break and attenuate any Matter , that will not be softened and dissolved by agitation in a Liquid , yet it is certain that these Motions , caused by the Diaphragme and Abdominal Muscles in Respiration , do make those Parts , which are broken off , as they are dissolved , mix intimately with the more liquid , as the Meat which I digested with Oil of Turpentine , and Oil of Vitriol , did by agitation mix more equally with the Oils , and became a Pulpament .
As the Juices , which constitute the Saliva , do ferment upon their Mixture , so it is probable that from their Mixture and Fermentation there results such a Tertium quid as is apt to ferment with the Bile .
And therefore , when the Aliment has been under the Fermentation , excited by the Saliva , a sufficient time , it is then thrown into the Duodenum , where it meets with the bilious Juice , which flows into that Intestine from the Liver , from which a new Fermentation seems to begin ; and the Commotion of the Parts of the Aliment being still continued , does carry on the Business of Digestion until the Food is perfectly concocted .
Tho ' it is probable , that this new Fermentation serves not only for the more perfect Digestion of the Food , but likewise for the Separation of the Chyle from the feculent Parts .
Neither do I by a random Guess , and an ungrounded Conjecture , suppose that from the Mixture and Fermentation of the two Juices , which constitute the Saliva , there results a Matter , which is apt to ferment with the Bile .
But to me the Notion seemed to be confirmed by an Experiment that I made .
For considering with my self that the Bile is generally allow 'd to have much of a saponary nature , I made a Solution of Soap in fair Water , and mixed it with the Oils of Turpentine and Vitriol first put together , and from their Mixture I observed a very easy and gentle Fermentation , which continued for a considerable time .

