A Letter of Dr. John Wallis to Samuel Pepys Esquire , relating to some supposed Imperfections in an Organ .
Mr. Harris an Organ-maker ( whom I rind , by the little discourse I had with him , to be very well skilled in his profession ) was lately with me , as by direction from you , to ask my opinion about perfecting an Organ , in a point wherein he thinks it yet Imperfect .
It is an honour you please to put upon me , to think my opinion considerable in a thing wherein I am so little acquainted as that of an Organ .
I do not pretend to be perfectly acquainted with the Structure of an Organ , its several Parts , and the Incidens thereunto ; Having never had Occasion and Opportunity to inform my self particularly therein .
And , for the same reason , many of the Words , Phrases , Forms of Speech , and Terms of Art , which are familiar to Organists and Organ-makers , are not so to me .
Which therefore I shall wave ; ( For till we perfectly understand one anothers Language , it is not easy to speak intelligibly ; ) and apply my self directly to what is particularly proposed .
This ( I take it ) is evident ; That each Pipe in the Organ is intended to express a distinct Sound at such a Pitch ; That is , in such a determinate Degree of Gravity or Acuteness ; or ( as it is now called ) Flatness or Sharpness .
And the Relative or Comparative Consideration of Two ( or more ) such Sounds or Degrees of Flatness and Sharpness , is the ground of ( what we call ) Concord and Discord ; that is , a Soft , or Harsh , coincidence .
Now , concerning this , there were amongst the Ancient Greeks , Two ( the most considerable ) Sects of Musicians : the Aristoxenians , and the Pythagorians .
They both agreed thus far ; That Dia-tessaron and Dia-pente , do together make-up Dia-pason ; that is ( as we now speak ) a Fourth and fifth do together make an Eighth or Octave : And , the Difference of those two ( of a Fourth and Fifth ) they agreed to call a Tone ; which we now call a Whole note .
Such is that , ( in our present Music , ) of La Mi , ( or as it was wont to be called , Re Mi .
) For La fa sol la , or Mi fa sol la , is a perfect Fourth : And La fa sol la mi , or La mi fa sol la , is a perfect Fifth : The Difference of which , is La mi .
Which is , what the Greeks call , the Diazeuctick Tone ; which doth Dis-join two Fourths ( on each side of it ; ) and , being added to either of them , doth make a Fifth .
Which was , in their Music , that from Mes to Paramese ; that is in our Music , from A to B : supposing Mi to stand in B fa b mi , which is accounted its Natural position .
Now , in order to this , Aristoxenus and his Followers , did take , that of a Fourth , as a Known Interval , by the judgement of the Ear ; and , that of a Fifth , likewise ; And consequently , that of an octave , as the Aggregate of both ; and that of a Tone , as the Difference of those Two .
And this of a Tone ( as a known Interval ) they took as a common Measure , by which they did estimate other Intervals .
And accordingly they accounted a Fourth to contain Two Tones and an half ; a Fifth to contain Three Tones and an half ; and consequently an Eighth to contain Six Tones , or Five Tones and two Half-tones .
And it is very near the matter , though not exexactly so .
And at this rate we commonly speak at this day ; supposing an Octave to consist of Twelve Hemitones , or Half-notes .
( Meaning thereby , somewhat near so many half-notes : ) But , when we would speak more Nicely , we do not take those supposed Half-notes to be exactly Equal , or each of them just the Half of a Full-note , such as is that of La-mi .
Pythagoras and those who follow him , not taking the Ear alone to be a competent Judge in a case so nice ; chose to distinguish these , not by Intervals , but by Proportions .
And accordingly they accounted that of an Octave , to be , when the degree of Gravity or Acuteness of the one Sound to that of the other , is Double , or as 2 to 1 ; that of a Fifth , when it is Sesqui-alter , or as 3 to 2 ; that of a Fourth when Sesqui-tertian , or as 4 to 3 .
Accounting That , the Sweetest proportion , which is expressed in the Smallest Numbers ; and therefore ( next to the Unisone ) that of an Octave , 2 to 1 ; then that of a Fifth , 3 to 2 ; and then that of a Fourth , 4 to 3 .
And thus , that of a Fourth and Fifth , do together make an Eighth ; For 4/ 3 ~ 3/ 2 = 4/ 2 = 2/ 1 = 2 .
That is , four thirds of three halves , is the same as four halves , that is Two .
Or ( in other words to the same sense ) the proportion of 4 to 3 , compounded with that of 3 to 2 , is the same with that of 4 to 2 , or 2 to 1 .
And , consequently , the Difference of those Two , which is that of a Tone or Full-Note , is that of 9 to 8 .
For 4/ 3 ) 3/ 2 ( 9/ 8 ; that is , three halves divided by four thirds , is nine eights ; or , if out of the proportion of 3 to 2 , we take that of 4 to 3 ; the Result is that of 9 to 8 .
Now , according to this Computation , it is manifest , That an Octave is somewhat less than Six Full-notes .
For ( as was first demonstrated by Euclide , and since by others ) the Proportion of 9 to 8 , being six times compounded , is somewhat more than that of 2 to 1 .
For 98 ~ 98 ~ 98 ~ 98 ~ 98 ~ 98 = 531441/ 262144 , is more than 524288/ 262144 = 2/ 1 .
This being the Case ; they allowed ( indisputably ) to that of the Dia-zeuctick Tone ( La mi , ) the full proportion of 9 to 8 ; as a thing not to be altered ; being the Difference of Dia-pente and Dia-tessaron , or the Fifth and Fourth .
All the Difficulty , was , How the remaining Fourth ( Mi fa sol la ) should de divided into three parts , so as to answer ( pretty near ) the Aristoxenians Two Tones and an Half ; and might , altogether , make up the proportion of 4 to 3 ; which is that of a Fourth or Dia-tessaron .
Many attempts were made to this purpose : And , according to those , they gave Names to the different Genera or Kinds of Music , ( the Diatonick , Chromatick , and Enarmonick Kinds , ) with the several Species , or lesser Distinctions under those Generals .
All which to enumerate , would be too large , and not necessary to our business .
The first was that of Euclide ( which did most generally obtain for many ages : ) Which allows to Fa sol , and to Sol la , the full proportion of 9 to 8 ; And therefore to Fa sol la ( which we call the greater Third , ) that of 81 to 64 .
( For 98 ~ 98 = 81/ 64 .
) And , consequently , to that of Mi fa ( which is the Remainder to a Fourth ) that of 256 to 243 .
For 81/ 64 ) 3/ 4 ( 256/ 243 ; that is , if out of the proportion of 4 to 3 , we take that of 81 to 64 , the Result is that of 256 to 243 .
To this they gave the name of Limma ( ~ ) that is , the Remainder ( to wit , over and above Two Tones .
) But , in common discourse ( when we do not pretend to speak nicely , nor intend to be so understood ) it is usual to call it an Hemitone or Half-Note ( as being very near it ) and , the other , two Whole-Notes .
And this is what Ptolemy calls Diatonum Ditonum , ( of the diatonick kind with Two full Tones .
) Against this , it is objected ( as not the most convenient Division , ) that the Numbers of 81 to 64 , are too great for that of a Ditone or Greater Third : Which is not Harsh to the Ear ; but is rather Sweeter than that of a single Tone , who 's proportion is 9 to 8 .
And in that of 256 to 243 , the Numbers are yet much greater .
Whereas there are many proportions ( as 5/ 4 , 6/ 5 , 7/ 6 , 8/ 7 , ) in smaller numbers than that of 9 to 8 ; of which , in this division , there is no notice taken .
To rectify this , there is another Division thought more convenient ; which is Ptolemy 's Diatonum Intensum ( of the Diatonick Kind , more Intense or Acute than that other. .
) Which , instead of Two Full tones for Fa sol la ; assigns ( what we now call ) a Greater and a Lesser Tone ; ( which , by the more nice Musicians of this and the last Age , seems to be more embraced ; ) Assigning to Fa sol , that of 9 to 8 ( which they call the Greater Tone : ) and to Sol la , that of 10 to 9 , ( which they call the Lesser Tone : ) And therefore to Fa la ( the Ditone or Greater Third ) that of 5 to 4 .
( For 10/ 9 ~ 9/ 8 = 10/ 8 = 5/ 4 .
) And consequently , to Mifa ( which is remaining of the Fourth ) that of 16 to 15 .
For 5/ 4 ) 4/ 3 ( 16/ 15 .
That is ; if out of that of 4 to 3 , we take that of 5 to 4 , there remains that of 16 to 15 .
Many other ways there are ( with which I shall not trouble you at present ) of dividing the Fourth or Dia-tessaron , or the proportion of 4 to 3 , into three parts , answering to what ( in a looser way of Expression ) we call an Half-note , and two Wholenotes .
But this of 16/ 15 ~ 9/ 8 ~ 10/ 9 = 4/ 3 , is that which is now received as the most proper .
To which therefore I shall apply my discourse .
Where 16/ 15 is ( what we call)the Hemitone or Half-note , in Mifa ; 9/ 8 that of the Greater-Tone , in Fa sol ; and 10/ 9 the Lesser-Tone , in Solla .
Only with this addition ; That each of those Tones , is ( upon occasion ) by Flats and Sharps ( as we now speak ) divided into two Hemitones or Half-notes : Which answers to what by the Greeks was called Mutatio quoad Modos ( the change of Mood ; ) and what is now done by removing Mi to another Key .
Namely ~=~=~~ 17/ 16 .
; and 10/ 9 = 20/ 18 = 20/ 19 ~ 19/ 18 .
Thus , by the help of Flats and Sharps ( dividing each Whole-note , be it the Greater or the Lesser , into two Half-notes , or what we call so , ) the whole Octave is divided into Twelve Parts of Intervals ( contained between Thirteen Pipes ) which are commonly called Hemitones or Half-notes .
Not , that each is precisely Half a Note , but somewhat near it , and so called .
And I say , by Flats and Sharps ; For sometime the one , sometime the other , is used .
As , for instance , a Flat in D , or a Sharp in C , do either of them denote a Middling Sound ( tho ' not precisely in the Midst ) between C and D ; Sharper than C , and Flatter than D Accordingly ; supposing Mi to stand in B fa b mi ( which is accounted its Natural seat ) the Sounds of each Pipe are to bear these proportions to each other , viz. BC#D# OF #G#a#b mi fa # sol # la fa # sol # la # mi 16/ 15 18/ 17 17/ 16 20/ 19 19/ 18 16/ 15 18/ 17 17/ 16 20/ 19 19/ 18 18/ 17 17/ 16 98 10/ 9 98 10/ 9 98 4/ 3 4/ 3 3/ 2 2/ 1 And so in each Octave successively following .
And if the Pipes in each Octave be fitted to sounds in these proportions of Gravity &amp; Acuteness ; it will be supposed ( according to this Hypothesis ) to be perfectly proportioned .
But , instead of these successive proportions for each Hemitone ; it is found necessary ( if I do not mistake the practise ) so to order the 13 Pipes ( containing 12 Intervals which they call Hemitones ) as that their Sounds ( as to Gravity &amp; Acuteness ) be in Continual Proportion , ( each to its next following , in one and the same Proportion ; ) which , all together , shall complete that of an Octave or Dia-pason , as 2 to 1 .
Whereby it comes to pass , that each Pipe doth not express its proper Sound , but very near it , yet somewhat varying from it , Which they call Bearing .
Which is somewhat of Imperfection in this Noble Instrument , the Top of all .
it .
It may be asked , Why may not the Pipes be so ordered , as to have their Sounds in just Proportion , as well as thus Bearing ?
I answer , It might very well be so , if all Music were Composed to the same Key , or ( as the Greeks call it ) the same Mode .
As , for instance , if , in all Compositions , Mi were always placed in B fa b mi .
For then the Pipes might be ordered in such proportions as I have now designed .
But Musical Compositions are made in great variety of Modes , or with great diversity in the Pitch .
Mi is not always placed in B fa b mi ; but sometimes in E la mi ; sometimes in A la mi re , &amp;c. And ( in sum ) there is none of these 12 or 13 Pipes but may be made the Seat of Mi .
And if they were exactly fitted to any one of these cases , they would be quite out of order for all the rest .
As , for instance ; If Mi be removed from B fa b mi ( by a Flat in B ) to E la mi : Instead of the Proportions but now designed , they must be thus ordered ; B#C#D# OF #G#ab fa # sol # la # mi fa # sol # la fa 18/ 17 17/ 16 20/ 19 19/ 18 18/ 17 17/ 16 16/ 15 18/ 17 17/ 16 20/ 19 19/ 18 16/ 15 Where it is manifest , that the removal of mi doth quite disorder the whole series of Proportions .
And the same would again happen , if mi be removed from E to A ( by another Flat in E. ) And again if removed from A to D. And so perpetually .
But the Hemitones being made all Equal ; they do indifferently answer all the positions of Mi ( though not exactly to any : ) Yet nearer to some than to others .
Whence it is , that the same Tune sounds better at one Key than at another .
It is asked , Whether this may not be remedied ; by interposing more Pipes ; and thereby dividing a Note , not only ( as now ) into Half-notes , but into Quarter-notes or Halfquarter-notes , &amp;c. I answer ; It may be thus remedied in part ; ( that is , the Imperfection might thus be somewhat Less , and the Sounds somewhat nearer to the just Proportions : ) but it can never be exactly true , so long as their Sounds ( be they never so many ) be in continual proportion ; that is , each to the next subsequent in the same Proportion .
For it hath been long since Demonstrated , that there is no such thing as a just Hemitone practicable in Music , ( and the like for the division of a Tone into any number of Equal parts ; three , four , or more .
) For , supposing the Proportion of a Tone or Full-note , to be 9/ 8 ( or , as 9 to 8 ; ) that of the Half-note must be as ~9 to ~8 ( as the Square-root of 9 to the Square-root of 8 ; that is , as 3 to ~8 , or 3 to 2~2 , ) which are Incommensurable quantities .
And that of a Quarter-note , as ~qq 9 to ~qq 8 , ( as the Biquadrate root of 9 , to the Biquadrate root of 8 , ) which is yet more Incommensurate .
And the like for any other number of Equal parts .
Which will therefore never fall-in with the Proportions of Number to Number .
So that this can never be perfectly adjusted for all Keys ( without somewhat of Bearing ) by multiplying of Pipes ; unless we would for every Key ( or every different Seat of Mi ) have a different Set of Pipes , of which this or that is to be used , according as ( in the Composition ) Mi is supposed to stand in this or that Seat .
Which vast number of Pipes ( for every Octave ) would vastly increase the Charge .
And ( when all is done ) make the whole impracticable .
These are my present thoughts , of the Question proposed to me , and upon these grounds .
You will please to excuse me for the trouble I give you of so long a Letter .
I thought it necessary , to give a little intimation of the Ancient Greek Music compared with what is now in practise ; which is more the same than most men are aware of : though the Language be very different .
But I was not to be large in it .
Those who desire to know more of it ; may see my thoughts more at large , in that Appendix which I have added at the end of my Edition of Ptolemy 's Harmonicks in Greek and Latin .
The two Eminent Sects amongst them , the Aristoxenian and the Pythagorian , differ much at the same rate as doth the Language of our ordinary practical Musicians , and that of those who treat of it in a more Speculative way .
Our Practical Musicians talk of Notes and Half-notes , just as the Aristoxenians did ; as if the Whole Notes were all Equal ; and the Half-notes likewise each the just Half of a Whole Note .
And thus it is necessary to suppose in the Pipes of an Organ ; which have each their determinate Sound and not to be corrected , in their little Inequalities , as the Voice may be by the guidance of the Ear .
But Pythagoras , and those who follow him found ( by the Ear ) that this Equality of Intervals would not exactly answer the Musical Appearances , in Concords and Discords : just as our Organists and Organ-makers be now aware ; that their Pipes at equal Intervals do not give the just desired Harmony , without somewhat of Bearing , that is , of some little variation from the just Sound .
The Pythagorians , to help this , changed the notion of Equal Intervals into that of due Proportions .
And this is followed by Zarline , Keppler , Cartes , and others who treat of Speculative Music in this and the last Age .
And though they speak of Notes and Half-notes ( in a more gross way ) much as others do , yet declare themselves to be understood more nicely .
And though our present Gam-ut take no notice of this little diversity ; yet , in Vocal Music , the Ear directs the Voice to a more just proportion .
And , in String Music , it may in like manner be helped by straining and slackening the Strings , or moving the Frets .
But , in Wind Music , the Pipes are not capable of such correction ; and therefore we must be content with some little irregularity therein ; that so they may tolerably answer ( though not exactly ) the different Compositions according to the different placing of Mi in the Gam-ut .
Now the Design of Mr. Harris seems to be this ; either ( by multiplying intermediate Pipes ) to bring the Organ to a just Perfection : Or else ( if that cannot be done ) to rest content with the little Imperfection that is ; which though , by more Pipes , it may be somewhat abated , yet cannot be perfectly remedied .
And in this I think we must acquiesce .
I am SIR Yours to serve you Oxford June 27 .
1698 .

