IV .
Part of a Letter from Dr. William Musgrave , Fellow of the College of Physicians , and R. S. to Dr. Sloane , concerning the Cause of the Necessity of Breathing .
YOU know , how difficult it has been thought , to account for the principal Use of Respiration : Nothing is more evident , than that breathing is , from the very Moment of our Birth , perpetually necessary to Life ; yet nothing more in the Dark , than the true Cause and Reason ofthat Necessity .
Dr. Thruston asserts the chief Use of Respiration , to consist , in maintaining a due Motion of the Blood .
Officium illud [ Respirationis praecipuum ] Nos in eo maxim positum arbitramur , quod Sanguinis Motui inserviat , eumq ; tueatur .
page .
6 .
Edit .
Lond. 1670 .
And , to make out his Assertion , he urges ( among other Arguments of less note ) That this Opinion , easily explains , the Manner of Sudden Death , by Strangling ; by drowning ; and by violent Catarrhs ; supposing Death , and the Stagnation of the Blood in the Lungs , Right Ventricle of the Heart , &amp;c. to arise , in all these Cases , from the Stoppage of the Breath .
Etmuller embraces the same Opinion ; and , in Defence of it , alleges the same Argument : Indeed they both depend on it , as highly probable and convincing .
Tho ' , I think , the Opinion is very Rational ; I cannot say it appears such , from the Argument now produced ; which , upon Examination , will be found too liable and obnoxious to bear so great a Proportion of the Proof .
By Dr. Thruston 's own Concession , ( page .
173 .
) Men that are Hanged , may , with good Reason , be supposed to die , partly , from the mutual Commerce between the Head and Heart , being now intercepted .
The remarkable Lividness of their Faces , with the extraordinary Distention of the Jugulars , in their several Branches above the Ligature , argue , they die , in a great Measure , Apoplectical .
Now , whatever share the Interruption of this mutual Commerce has , in killing the Man ; so much the less Reason have we to impute his Death , and the Stagnation of Blood in his Lungs , &amp;c. to the Stoppage of his Breath .
Nor is the Second Case ( that of Sudden Death by Drowning ) without Exception : For here , the Water rushing , after an unusual Manner , into the Lungs , may be suspected so to affect them , as to occasion Death , tho ' not by stopping the Circulation .
And , as to Suffocation from a Catarrh , instances of this Kind , with Anatomical Observations on them , have not ( to me at least ) occurred , sufficient to prove , what was intended by this Argument .
Wherefore , that a Noble Proposition may not want Evidence , and that the Opinion , my Learned Countryman has so ingeniously defended , may for ever obtain , I pitched on the following Experiment as Luciferous , and , I hope it will appear decisive of the Matter .
I took a large , middle-aged , healthy Dog ; and , having freed the Trachea from the adjacent Parts , cut it off just beneath the Pomum Adami , and turned the loose End outward .
After some time allowed him to recover the present Concern ; with a Cork , got ready on purpose , I stopped up the Trachea , binding it close to the Stopple .
Some few , but violent Struggles succeeded ; in which the Sternum was raised , as in the deepest Inspiration ; and thus he died .
From the Stoppage of his Breath , to the last Motion I could discern in any Part of his Body , was , from a Watch , observed to be the Space of Two Minutes .
I then immediately threw open the Thorax ; where I saw the Blood Stagnating in the Lungs ; the Arteria Pulmonaris , the Right Ventricle of the Heart , with its appending Auricle , and the Two great Trunks of the Cava , distended with Blood , to a Degree excessive : The Vena Pulmonaris , Left Auricle and Ventricle of the Heart , in a Manner Empty ; not containing ( as near as I can guess ) more than One Spoonful of Blood .
This Experiment proves , That the Respiration promotes the Passage of the Blood thro ' the Lungs ; and that in Bodies full of vigorous Blood , it is , on this Account of perpetual Necessity .
This Acceleration of the Blood in that Passage , seems to be the principal use of Respiration ; no other is of such Consequence to Life , or stands in Competition with it .
Exon , May 9 .

