VII .
An Account of a very large Eel , lately caught at Maldon in Essex ; with some Considerations about the Generation of Eels , by Mr. Dale .
TO meet with Accounts and Descriptions of very large Congers or Sea-Eales , is not a thing rare or uncommon , among the Writers of Natural History , and , among the rest , the Learned and most Ingenious Mr. John Ray , my very good Friend and Neighbour , in his Ichthyographia , page .
11 .
describes it to be a very large Fish , in these Words , Piscis est longissimus , quatuor vel quinque Cubitorum longitudinem non raro attingens , &amp; femoris humani crassitiem aequans .
Consonant to which , Aldrovandus Lib. de Pisc .
P. 134 .
saith , Saepe in quatuor aut quinque Cubitorum longitudinem excrescit ; and for Weight , Salvianus writes , Non majores se vidisse quam triginta librarum : Near to which Weight , Mr. Daniel , an Apothecary of Colchester , lately told me of one ( if I mis-remember not ) that amounted to 27 or 28 Pounds .
But if we may believe what Eudoxus writes , some are of a prodigious Magnitude ; for he in his Book De Terrae Motu apud Athenium , Lib. 6 .
saith , Congros multos in Sicyone capi quos Homo vix ferat , horumque aliquos etiam esse plaustrales seu plaustri magnitudine .
And Strabo , Lib. 3 .
Geog .
affirms , in exterioribus locis augentur supra minarum octoginta : whose Authorities I shall not contradict , altho ' neither by the Observations of the Worthy Mr. Ray , nor any other Modern Author , can I find any to acquire near that Bigness .
Yet to find very large Eels , notwithstanding what is said both by Pliny and Solinus , of those found in the Gauges Thirty Foot long , is that which is rare and seldom ( in England at least wise ) to be found , and therefore having lately met with Relations of Two very large Eels cought upon the Coast of Essex , I thought the Communication thereof to the Curious , would not be altogether unacceptable .
These both had all the Characterizing Notes of the Eel , and wanted those Barbles which the Eel sometimes hath not , but the Conger is never without .
The First was taken somewhere about Cricksea , and for its rarity was made a present of to a Noble Peer of this Realm : Its Length from Tip of the Nose to Tail 's End , was Five Foot Eight Inches , and In Circumference it was Two and Twenty Inches ; but as for the Weight , no Persons could inform me what it was , tho ' perhaps it might not exceed Twenty Pound , of which Aldrovandus saith , that in Italy they come up to , but never exceed it .
And for Length it agrees with those mentioned by Rondeletius to be sometimes caught in the Lake of Latera , which were Three or four Cubits long .
But those were far exceeded by one lately caught in Maldon Channel , about a Mile below the Town , the length of which was Seven Foot , the Circumference Seven and Twenty Inches , the Weight Six and Thirty Pounds , and out of its Belly was taken Five Pounds of Fat , its Skin was Black , and being stuft , is still preserved at Maldon , for the Inspection of the Curious .
This Fish was supposed to have been brought down thither by the Great Floods at the breaking of the last Frost , because of a Hurt it had on its Back , which the Fisherman which caught it told me , he did conjecture it might be from some Mill it must pass through .
Had it been my good Fortune to have had the Knowledge of this monstrous Eel soon enough , I would have gone over to Maldon , to have seen it opened , it being a fit Subject in which to have examined the Parts of Generation , so much controverted , not only by the Ancient , but also by Modern Authors , and thereby been in some measure capacitated to have satisfied my self concerning that no less controverted Point , the Manner of their Generation .
Many there are , that with Aristotle , will have the Generation of Eels to be Spontaneous or Equivocal , and will not allow them the Distinction of Sex ; the Difficulty how Eels should come to be in any Pool , Pond , Mote or Ditch , in which never any were put , they are not able to surmount , and therefore have vainly imagined them either to be produced from Mud , or from a peculiar Sort of Dew , falling in May or June , upon the Blades of the Grass , whereof~ Turfs being cut , and the Grassy Sides being together , and then laid on the warmest Side of a well promising Pool or Pond , the Sun 's Heat will thence hatch them ; of which Original Myllius , in his Treatise de Origin Antmalium , lib. 10 .
and Morhofius de Metallorum transmutatione , p. 38 , 39 .
seem so well satisfied , that they give the Process of this Affair , as practised by the Dutch , successfully to stock their Fish-ponds with that sort of Fish .
That the Generation of any Animal cannot be Equivocal or Spontaneous , but from Animal Parents , hath been so well , by many undeniable Arguments asserted , and by multiplied Experiments confirmed , by those famous and celebrated Virtuosi , Malpighius , Redi , Swammerdam , Leewenhoeck , Mr. Ray , and others , in their several learned and ingenious Tracts and Observations on that Subject , that I think there is no room left in the least to doubt but that Eels have the same Original .
And if we may credit what the ingenious Dr. Plot , in his Natural History of Staffordshire , p. 243 .
writes , concerning the Night Travels of Eels observed near Bilson in that Country , by Mr. Mosely , the Way of their stocking Ponds , &amp;c. may not be altogether so improbable neither , as at first it may be thought to be , if we but consider how long they will live out of Water , and though I cannot with Pliny , in his Natural History , Lib. 9 .
Cap. 21 .
allow the time to be Six Days , yet I am sure it may be long enough , to travel over a few short Meadows , or from one Ditch or Pond to another , which may be performed in much less time than that of one Night ; and if we may believe what Gesner in his Book of Fishes , lib. 4 .
cap. de Auguilla , quotes from Albertus , of a Parcel of Eels , which in a very cold Winter , Anno 1125 .
not only left their NaP tural tural Element , but were found in a dry Meadow , bedded together in a Hay-stack , the thing will seem more probable , to which let me add the Form and Shape of their Bodies , which by its undulate or Serpentine Motion is adapted to travel in arido : Neither are Eels the only Fish , which by Authors are affirmed to live in Sicco , but the Exocetus also mentioned by Rondeletius , with others so considerable for their Number , that Theophrastus Eresius wrote a Book of them , which was afterwards Commented upon by Aurelius Severinus , in a Book entitled De Piscibus in sicco viventibus , Printed at Naples , Anno 1655 .
Not to mention the Cerian and Paphlagonian Fishes , affirmed by Aristotle to wander up and down on the dry Sands , and then return back to Sea again , the like is also asserted of those of the River Cherati , in Judaea , by Geo. Pictorius .
All which , Rondeletius thinks Eels , as well as the aforesaid Fishes , perform by the Rima of their Gills , being narrow and thereby capacitated to oppose the free , and too sudden Appulses of the Air .
Neither doth the Controversy here terminate , for even among those learned Persons which oppose an Equivocal or Spontaneous Generation , the Dispute is , Whether Eels have distinct Sex , or are Hermophradites .
By some a distinct Sex is allowed them , for Mr. Allen , in his Account of the Generation of Eels , Published in the Philosophical Transactions , Numb. 231 .
affirms the Parts distinguishing the Sex to be discoverable , and in this Rondeletius is positive , when he affirms , Anguillas mutuo corporum complexu coeuntes se vidisse neque putare se partibus ad gignendum necessariis prorsus destitutas esse , inferiore enim ventris part , &amp; Vulva in Faeminis &amp; semen in Maribus reperitur : sed pinguidine multa circumfusa hae parts non apparent : And from hence , I mean from the parts of Generation being hid in Fat , might arise that mistake in Aristotle , which did occasion him so positively to affirm , Anguillam neque marem esse neque faeminam .
And though it cannot but be granted , that that ingenious Inspector of Nature , Mr. Lewenhoek , hath , by the Help of his Glasses ( which are very good ones ) made many curious Discoveries in Animals and their Parts of Generation , yet never ( to use his own Words ) had he found a Male Eel that he could call so ; for all those that he did Diffect , as in his Letter Published in the Philosophical Transactions , Numb. 221 .
he declares were provided with an Uterus , from whence he doth conjecture Eels to be Hermaphrodites , and besides the Uterus to be provided with Masculine Seed .
Another great Controversy about the Generation of Eels is , whether they are Oviparous or Viviparous , and many ingenious Persons I find there are , which cannot consent to an Equivocal or Spontaneous Generation , but strenuously oppose the same , yet firmly believe them to be Oviparous , whose Sentiments are contrary to the Observations of Walter Chartwynd , Esq ; who in the Month of May , found them to be Viviparous , by cutting open the red Fundaments of the Females , from whence the Young Eels would issue forth alive : And although Mr. Allen affirms them to be certainly Viviparous yet his Observations concerning the Place of their Conception , I cannot conceive to be consonant to that Care and Industry of Nature , in providing convenient Receptacles for preserving the Faetus , neither is it agreeable to Reason , to believe , that when Nature hath provided a Uterus in all Animals , not only the VivipaP 2 rous , rous , and such as only cherish the Embryo in Utero , but in the Oviparous also , and Insects , the Eel and Xiphia or Sword-Fish , mentioned by Bartholinus Cent. 2 .
H. 16 .
Anno 1654 .
should be the only Animals without it , much less that the Guts , appointed by Nature for the Secretion of Nourishment , and the Expulsion of the Faeces , and are always in Motion , should be the Place of Generation in any Animal ; though we may allow Eels not to feed Gross in the Winter .
On the contrary , that the Eel hath an Uterus , is asserted by Mr. Leewenhoeck , who never found them without ; which perhaps is that part which Mr. Allen names a slender Gland , transversly lying near the Bowel .
Besides , Nature having in all Animals , Oviparous , as well as Viviparous hitherto dissected , provided not only an Uterus , but also Tubes ( first observed by Fallopius ) for the conveying the Ovum from the Ovaria to the Uterus .
Another great Difficulty and Objection that lies against Mr. Allen 's Observations , and in which indeed he seems to contradict himself , is this , whereas he saith that in one Eel he found Eggs , and those on the out side of the Intestine ; but in the other , Six Young ones , each fastened to a small Placenta , and those within the great Intestine , called , the Strait Bowel , which adjoins immediately to the Pylorus : How and by what Passages those Eggs came into the Intestine , to be formed and invigorated , unless we may suppose they do , like the Embryo 's of some sorts of Insects , which for the Convenience of Food , eat their own Way into their Heterogeneous , or assumed Matrices .
These Objections I have proposed to be considered only that I might excite that Ingenious Person to perfect his Discoveries , and by ocular Demonstrations to convince the Curious of the Truth and Certainty of his Observations , and finally to terminate this long continued Controversy , concerning the Generation of Eels , and after what manner their Coitus must be performed ; the Parts of Generation in the Male , being by him affirmed , to be affixt to the Extremity of the Kidney , and the Embrios in the Female , ( as is before observed ) found in that Bowel which adjoins to the Pylorus .

