A Question in Music lately proposed to Dr. Wallis , concerning the Division of the Monochord , or Section of the Musical Canon : With his Answer to it .
Question .
TAKE a String of any Musical Instrument , and divide the same into two equal Parts , and stop the String there ; it shall be an Eighth , which consists of twelve Semi-tones .
Hence it appears , that the Frets are nearer to one another toward the Bridge , and wider toward the Nut Head of a Viol .
And that they decrease or proceed in a Geometrical Proportion .
Quaere , How is it possible , from the foresaid Hypothesis , to divide the other 11 Semi tones , in their due Proportion , and to demonstrate the same .
And whether the other Distances assigned by Simpson in his Compendium of Music ( and Chapter of Greater and lesser Semi-tones ) are demonstrable from the said Hypothesis .
Answer .
March ~ .
169 7/ 8 .
WHAT Method is used by Simson ( in the Book mentioned ) to divide a String or Chord , I know not : Nor have I the Book at Hand to consult .
That a String open ( or at its full Length ) will sound ( what we call)an Octave ( or Diapason ) to that of the same String stopped in the Middle ( or at half its Length ) is very true .
And hence it is that we commonly assign , to an Octave , the Duple Proportion ( or that of 2 to 1 : ) because such is the Proportion of Lengths ( taken in the same String ) which give those Sounds .
And ( upon a like Account ) we assign to a Fifth ( or Diapente ) the Sesqui-alter Proportion ( or that of 3 to 2 : ) And , to a Fourth ( or Dia tesseron ) the Sesquitertian ( or that of 4 to 3 : ) And to a Tone ( which is the Difference of a Fourth and Fifth ) The Sesqui-octave ( or that of 9 to 8 : ) Because Lengths ( taken in the same String ) in these Proportions , do give such Sounds .
And ( universally ) whatever Proportion of Lengths ( taken in the same String , equally stretched ) do give such and such sounds ; such Proportions ( of Gravity ) weassign to the Sounds so given .
But when an Eighth(or Octave)is said(in common Speech ) to consist of 12 Hemi-tones , or 6 Tones ; this is not to be understood according to the utmost Rigour of Mathematical Exactness , ( of such 6 Tones , as what they call the Diazeuctick Tone , or that of la mi , which is the Difference of a Fourth and Fifth ; ) but , ' as exact enough for common Use .
For Six such Tones ( that is , the Proportion of 9 to 8 Six Times repeated ) is somewhat more than that of an Octave ( or the Proportion of 2 to 1 : ) And , consequently , such an Hemi-tone , is somewhat more than the Twelfth Part of an Eighth , or Octave , or Dia-pason .
But the Difference is so little , that the Ear can hardly distinguish it : And therefore ( in common Speech ) it is usual so to speak .
And , accordingly , when when we are directed to take the Lengths ( for what are called the 12 Hemi-tones ) in Geometrical Proportion : it is to be understood ( not , to be so in the utmost Strictness , but ) to be accurate enough for common Use ; for placing the Frets on the Neck of a Viol , or other Musical Instrument ; wherein a greater Exactness is thought not necessary .
And this is very convenient , because ( thus ) the Change of the Key ( upon altering the Seat of mi ) gives no new Trouble , for this doth indifferently serve any Key ; and the Difference is so small , as not to offend the Ear .
But those who choose to treat of it with more exactness , go this way to work .
Presupposing the Proportion for an Octave ( or Dia-pason ) to be that of 2 to 1 ; they divide this into Two Proportions ; not just equal ( for that would fall upon surd Numbers , as of ~2 to 1 ; ) but near-equal ( so as to be expressed in small Numbers .
) In order to which , instead of taking 2 to 1 , they take ( the double of these Numbers ) 4 to 2 ; ( which is the same Proportion as before ; ) and interpose the middle Number 3 .
And , of these Three Numbers , 4 , 3 , 2 , that of 4 to 3 , is the Proportion for a Fourth ( or Dia-tesseron .
) And that of 3 to 2 , the Proportion for a Fifth ( or Dia-pente .
) And these Two put together , make up that of an Octave ( or Diapason , ) that of 4 to 2 , ( or 2 to 1 .
) And the Difference of those Two , that of a Tone or 9 to 8 .
As will plainly appear in the ordinary Method of Multiplying and Dividing Fractions .
That is , 4/ 3X3/ ~=4/ 2=2/ 1 .
And 4/ 3 ) 3/ 2 ( 9/ 8 Thus , in the common Scale ( or Gam-ut ) taking an Octave , in these Notes , la , fa sol la , mi , fa sol la ; suppose , from E to e , ( placing mi , in b fa ~ mi ; which is called the Natural Scale ; ) the Lengths for the Extremes la la , an Octave , are as 2 to 1 , or 12 to 6 .
Those for la la ( in la fa sol la ) or mi la ( in mi fa sol la ) a Fourth , as 4 to 3 , or 12 to 9 , or 8 to 6 .
Those for la mi ( in la fa sol la mi ) or la la ( in la mi fa solla ) a Fifth , as 3 to 2 , or 12 to 8 , or 9 to 6 .
Those for la mi , the Diazeuctick-Tone ( or difference of a Fourth and Fifth , ) as 9 to 8 .
So have we for those Four Notes la la mi la , their Proportionate Length in the Numbers 12 98 6 .
Then ~ ~8 46e 1a 9d Sol 15 10 5c fa 16 8b mi 18 869a 1a 9g Sol 15 10 F fa Then , if we proceed in like manner , to divide a Fifth ( or Dia-pente ) la fa sol la mi , or la mi fa sol la , or the Proportion of 3 to 2 , into near-equals , ( taking double Numbers in the same Proportion , 6 4 ; and interposing the middle Number 5 ; ) of these Three Numbers , 65 4 ; that of 6 to 5 , is the Proportion of a lesser Third ( called a Tri hemitone , or Tone and half , ) as la fa ( in la mi fa .
) And that of 5 to 4 , is the Proportion of the Greater Third ( commonly called a Ditone , or Two Tones , )as fa la ( in fa sol la ) which Two put together , make a Fifth , as 3 to 2 ; That is 6/ 5X5/ 4=6/ 4=3/ 2.And their difference is as 25 to 24 : That is ~~ ( ~ So have we for these 3 Notes la fa la , their proportionate Lengths in Numbers , as 65 4 .
In like manner , if we divide a Ditone ( or Greater Third ) as fa la ( in fa sol la ) whose Proportion is as 5 to 4 ( or 10 to 8 ) into Two near-equals ( by help of a middle Number 9 ; ) then have we ( in these Three Numbers 10 9 8 ) that of 10 to 9 , for ( what they call ) the Lesser Tone : And that of 9 to 8 , for ( what they call ) the Greater Tone .
But , whether fa sol shall be made the Lesser ( as 10 to 9 ) and sol la the Greater , as 9 to 8 ; ) or , This the Lesser ( as 10 to 9 ) and That the Greater ( as 9 to 8 ) or sometime This and sometime That , as there is occasion , ( to avoid what they call a Schism ; ) is somewhat indifferent : For , either way , the Compound will be , as 5 to 4 ; and the Difference ( which they call a Comma ) as 81 to 80 .
That is , ~X 10/ 9 = 10/ 9 X~=~= ~ .
And 10/ 9 ) ~~ ~ .
Lastly , ~ from that of the Tri-hemitone ( or Lesser Third ) la mi fa ; whose Proportion is as 6 to 5 ; we take that of the Tone la mi ( which is the Difference of a Fourth and Fifth ) as 9 to 8 ; There remains for the Hemi-tone mi fa ( or la fa ) that of 16 to 15 .
That is 9/ 8 ) ~ ( 48/ 45=16/ 15 .
Or , the Tri-hemitone ( or Lesser Third ) whose Proportion is as 6 to 5 ; may be divided into Three Near equals , ( by taking Triple Numbers , in the same Proportion , 18 15 ; and interposing the Two Intermediates , 17 16 ; ) which will therefore be as 18 to 17 , and as 17 to 16 , and as 16 to 15 ; That is , ~X~X~=~=6/ 5 .
Where also the Greater Tone , who 's Proportion is as 9 to 8 , or 18 to 16 , is divided into its Two Near-equals ( commonly called Hemi-tones , ) that of 18 to 17 , and that of 17 to 16 : That is , ~X~=~=~ .
And And the Lesser Tone , that of 10 to 9 , or 20 to 18 , may be in like manner divided into that of 20 to 19 , and that of 19 to 18 : That is , 20/ 19X19/ 18 = 20/ 18 = 10/ 9 .
Which Divisions of the Greater and Lesser Tone , answer to what is wont to be designed by Flats and Sharps .
So that ( by this Computation , ) of these Eight Notes , la , fa sol la , mi , fa sol la ; their Proportions stand thus ; that of la fa ( or mi fa ) is as 16 to 15 .
That of fa sol as 10 to 9 , and that of sol la as 9 to 8 : ( or else that of fa sol as 9 to 8 , and that of sol la as 10 to 9 , ) That of la mi as 9 to 8 .
And if either of the Tones ( Greater or Lesser ) chance to be divided ( by Flats or Sharps ) into ( whatthey call ) Hemi-tones , their Proportions are to be such as is already mentioned .
There may be a like Division of a Fourth ( or Dia-teslaron ) into Two Near equals : And of some others of these , into Three Near-equals .
Which might be of use for ( what they were wont to call ) the Chromatick and Enarmonick Music .
But those Sorts of Music , having been long since laid aside , there is now no need of these Divisions , as to the Music now

