Some Additional Remarks on the Extracting the Stone of the Bladder out of those of the Female Sex .
By Thomas Molyneux , M. D. S. R. S. ABout Six Years since , a Paper of mine was read before our Philosophical Society here in Dublin , and after published in the Philosophical Transactions , Numb. 202 .
Wherein I gave an Account of a Stone of an extraordinary bignels , spontaneously voided through the Uthera , by a Woman here in Dublin : And as a Corollary or Deduction from this History , I there proposed the Extraction of the Stone , by the gradual Dilatation of the Urethra , or Neck of the Bladder , without any manner of Section .
as the most safe and easy Way , and of most general use , for the freeing those of the Female Sex from the Stone in the Bladder .
I then alleged two Instances of Fact , to prove not only the Reasonableness , but the real Success of this Practise ; and I have been since still more confirmed in that Opinion by several other successful Operations I have seen of the like kind : but more particularly , by one lately performed in this Town on a Girl , between Eleven and Twelve Years Old , one Sarah Jones , that for Six Years past , has been severely afflicted with all the painful and unusual Symptoms of the Stone , but on the 16th of October , was happily relieved , by only dilating gently , the Neck of the Bladder , and then extracting a Stone of a very considerable bulk , without making any Incision at all .
The whole Operation was performed in Six or Seven Minutes , and was the more remarkable on the Account of the extraordinary large Size of the Stone , whose Shape and Bigness is exactly represented in the annexed Figure , Vid. Tab. Fig. 1 .
I did omit taking the Weight of it , nor was it truly any great neglect , since I think it no very material Circumstance for our Information in in such Cases , to know exactly what a Stone Weighs ; for the greater or less Gravity of these Bodies , depend not on their outward Dimensions , so much as on their internal Parts accidentally cohering more or less compactly together , as they are formed in the Bladder , and as if no importance in the Operation of extracting them : the Difficulty or Easiness of which , as well as the Danger and Success , more immediately depend , on the Magnitude and Shape of the Stone , rather than on its Gravity ; so that if we have a right Idea of those , it is altogether sufficient to our Purpose .
By the Size of this we have here figured , it appears to have been so big , that it may seem almost incredible a Solid of that Bulk , should be forced through the Urethra of so small and so Young a Child , withont any manner of Section : and that the Child should recover so as to be perfectly well , without the least ill Accident succeeding the Operation .
But we may gather hence , of what vast Extention this Urinary Passage , though Naturally strait , is capable ; and how much still wider it may be dilated , where it is proportionably larger , I mean of those of this Sex of Riper Years , or grown up to Womens Estate ; who may yet more easily and safely be relieved after this same manner , even of Stones of a much larger Size than this we here speak of .
The French , a Nation certainly very subject.to the Stone in the Bladder , and whose Chirurgeons therefore , must of necessity be very conversant with this Disease , and expert in the Operations requisite for the Cure of it , have , I see , lately established this sort of Practice ; tho ' I must needs own I did not know so much , till I had perused a very useful Book of Chirurgery , Published but this last Year , 1696 .
at Paris , in 8vo .
by Monsieur de la Vauguion ; Entitled , Traite Complete des Operations de Chirurgie : where I find in his Thirteenth Chapter , that treats of the Stone in the Bladder , and describes the way of Extracting it out of Women ; he has these Words : On dilate l'Uretre avec le Dilatateur sans rien couper , &amp; 'lon tire la pierre avec un crochet ou bien avec de Tenettes .
And a little after ; L'Uretre de Femmes se dilate extraordinairement , ainsi il arrive rarement qu'on soit oblige de leur fair un Incision .
These Quotations may show , how that right Reasoning , together with due Experience , have not only suggested , but likewise approved and settled this way of Extracting the Stone out of the Bladder of Women without Section .
When I was a Stranger to this Practice , I did only then propose it to be well considered of by the Judicious ; but now that it proves so successful , I cannot but recommend it to the skilful Surgeon , as an Operation fit for general use in these Cases , being both safe and easily Practicable , and also of great benefit and Relief to no less than the Moiety of Mankind , when ever they are afficted with this painful Disease .
And to say truly , if Women in this case would but timely seek for help , they might with far less Danger and Pain be relieved of this torturing and lasting Evil , than they are delivered of a common Natural Birth .
I say timely seek for Help ; that is , before the Stone is grown to so large a Magnitude , as not to admit this sort of Operation ; of which there may be some Instances , though I believe , as the attempting the Cure of such will be very dangerous , so likewise they will be very rarely met with ; for Experience Justifies what I have elsewhere observed , ( Numb. 202 .
of the Philosophical Transactions ) that Women are not capable by Nature of breeding Stones in their Bladders of so big a Size as Men frequently do ; which is most apparent from those many Histories of stupendious large Stones ( I mean them of the greatest Magnitude ) Registred by both George and John Schenkius , Hildanus , Greonevelt , the Philosophical Transactions , and other Authors ; all which that have hitherto occurred to me , have been only found in Men : Whereas the largest I have heard of bred in a Womans Bladder , was not one fifth Part of what has been produced of this kind in a Man 's .
In the Philosophical Transactions , Numb. 222 .
there is inserted an Account of the largest Stone I have yet heard of bred in a Man 's Bladder : That mentioned by Mr. Wood the Surgeon , Numb. 209 .
of the same Transactions .
taken out of a Woman , and as he thought , of a Prodigious Size , does not amount to near a Fifth Part of this : However , that is extraordinary in Mr. Wood 's Relation , that though it was extracted by Section , and the Membranous part of the Bladder , as he says , cut in the Operation , yet the Patient recovered and became perfectly well .
But these , and such like surprising Cures , I take to be erratic or Anomalous , if I may so call them ; because they happen seldom , and when they do , seem to be contrary to the settled Rules of Physic ; and therefore can little avail in guiding a Man 's Practice , according to the Saying , Quae Rara sunt , not sunt Artis : And notwithstanding several such rare Cases , daily Experience will vouch for the Authority of that Aphorism of Hippocrates , ~~ ~ , cui Secta est vesica lethale est , as not being founded on a sew Examples or a Notion , but what commonly holds true , or as Hippocrates often expresses it , ~~~ ~ , for the most part , which is a sufficient , and indeed the only Principle on which we may constitute a standing Rule in Physic ; for as the Judicious Celsus has truly observed in his Preface to his Book de Re Medica , Vix ulla Perpetua praecepta Medicinalis , Ars recipit .
Fig:8 8 7 9 6 5 4 3 ~ 5 ~ 8 C ~~CC ~~ CBA

