IX .
Account of aBOO K. Marcelli Malpighii Philosophi &amp; Medici Bononiensis e Regia Soc. Lond. Opera Posthuma Fig. aeneis illustrata quibus praefixa est ejusdem Vita a seipso Scripta Lond. impensis A. &amp; J. Churchill , ad insigne nigricygni in Vico dicto Pater-noster-row , 1697 , in Fol. THis Posthumous Work of Malpighius , was delivered when he found himself draw near the fatal Period of his Life , with orders to send to the Royal Society after his Death , by whose care it was published , being the last Remains of the Illustrious Malpighi , giving an account of his whole Studies , and some remarkable passages of his Life .
The Work begins with his Life , which is Dedicated to the Royal Society ; where he tells us , that Anno 1645 .
having finished his Gramatical Studies , he began to apply himself to the Peripatetic Philosophy , Anno 1649 .
He fell upon the study of Physic at the Persuasion of his Master Franciscus Natalis , his Father , Mother , and Grand-mother being then dead , and began with Anatomy , Anno 1653 .
He was honoured with the Laurel , as Doctor of Philosophy and Physic , to which and Anatomy he dedicated himself under the Famous Dr. Massarias , who died Anno 1655 .
Anno 1656 he was made Public Reader at Bononia , and Professor of Physic at Pisa , when he began to leave off the disputative , and apply himself to a more Experimental Method , and wrote some Dialogues against the Peripateticks and GaM mmm lenists lenists , which soon after perished , his House being casually burnt down .
About this time he fell acquainted with Magalotti , Chimentelli , Borelli , and other Learned Men .
While he stayed at Pisa , the Academy del Cimento was Instituted by the Grand Duke about this time .
Leaving Pisa , he returned to Bononia as a more healthy place in the Year 1660 , and with Dr. Fracassatus dedicated himself to Anatomy , when he discovered a new Structure of the Lungs ; about which he had several Disputes with the Learned of that time , as Dr. Ent , Thruston , Swammerdam , Willis , Borelli , Paulus Minus , &amp;c. which he relates at large , and in inserts their Letters to him about it , with his Answers .
Anno 1671 .
He wrote to Mr. Oldenburgh , R. S. Secr. concerning the structure of the Lungs , and the carneous Fibres of the Spleen and Testicles .
Anno 1662 he was made Profesfor of Physic in the Academy at Messina : He relates the Subject of his first Lecture there .
Retiring sometimes into the Country to a Friends House about the Year 1663 , he made his discoveries of the Structure of Plants , and Published his Observations de Ductibus adiposis , de Cerebro , &amp; Lingua , without any Name .
He proceeds to give an account of several other discoveries he made in Anatomy relating to the Brain , Organs of the Sense , of Touching , &amp;c. Then he tells us several Disputes he had with some Young Physicians that were strenuous asserters of the Galenick Principles and opposed all new Discoveries , such as Avellinus , Valuesius and Liparus , who published a Treatise under the Title of Galenistarum triumphus Neotericorum Medicorum insanias funditus eradicans , &amp;c. to which our Author wrote an Answer under the name of D. Placidus de Papadopulis one of his Scholars which is put out in this work in Latin , at which time he coninacted a Friendship with D. Joannes Baptista Caputius , a Learned Physician .
Next his Treatise of the Structure of the Viscera was Printed : Concerning which he gives an account of some Disputes with several Persons , and confirms his own Sentiments and Discoveries , and proceeds to the structure and use of the Spleen , mentioning several Letters he received from Steno , Gaspar Bartholine , &amp;c. thereupon : As likewise concerning the Polypus in the Heart .
At the end of the Year 1666 , he was invited by the Senate of Messina to return to the Public Academy , which he did the beginning of the next Year , and prosecuted his former Studies and Discoveries : where treating of the Bones , he gives an account of a Petrified Scull and other Bones .
After which he gives a large Description of the Teeth of which he also adds the Figures to explain himself the better .
He then tells of several other Learned Men he grew into Familiarity with , particularly Schenckius , who amongst other things told him of a Woman that had the Hydrophobia from a bite of her Epileptick Daughter .
In October 1667 he received a Letter from Mr Oldenburgh , inviting him to a Correspondence , at whose Solicitation he Wrote his History of the Silke-Worm in the Year 1668 , and sent it to the Royal Society , and the next Year was Elected a Member of the same , and had his Diploma sent him , Dated Mart .
4 .
1669 .
Next follows a Letter of his to Dr. Sylvester Bonfiliolus with several Additions to his History of the Silk Worm , which he here confirms by some farther Additions , and gives an account of some Disputes he had with Swammerdam thereon , and gives several Figures of the Parts not before Printed ; and proceeds to Answer the Objections of Bonanni , concerning the plurality of the Hearts of Silk-Worms .
In the Year 1671 , he began his Anatomy of Plants , Printed at London by the Royal Society .
Concerning which , he relates a Dispute he had with Signr .
Triumphetti chiefly about the Seminal Plant : and adds some farther Observations made in the Year 1687 , upon the Seeds of Cataputia Major with their Figures .
His next Dispute was with Borelli concerning the use of the Seminal Leaves , and here also he gives several Curious Figures , with his Observations on the Seeds of Laurel , made Anno 1682 , with other Observations on Dates , and their Figures .
Other Disputes he had with Father Bonanni , concerning Galls and other excrescencies of Plants .
He then gives a short recapitulation of his observations of the Chick in the Egg , and the Generation of Animals , which he sent to the Royal Society about Anno 1672 , and tells , that in the following Years he applied himself to the dissection of several Animals , the first he gives us an account of is an Eagle , the Parts whereof he describes very nicely , he adds an observation of an Eagles Heart that died of a Palpitation of the Heart ; in the right Ventricle whereof , he found a large Polypus , as likewise several Tubercles upon the Heart , Lungs , and Ribs .
He proceeds to observations on the several Worms found in Animals .
Of a flying Glow-worm of two kinds the cause of whose light , he says , proceeds from a certain shining Juice contained in the lower part of it , and is forced out in little Bubbles at two holes at the Tail .
Of all these he gives the Figures .
In the next place he gives an account of a Letter he sent to Dr. Jacobus Sponius , Anno 1681 , Printed in the Bibliotheca Anatomica , containing several matters , Viz .
Of the generation of the Horns of Animals ; of a new Vessel discovered in the Uterus of a Cow , reaching from the Cornua to the Meatus tus Urinarius where it has an open Ductus ; and of the manner of the impregnation of the Eggs in Women : and here he adds an account of a Superfaetation observed in 1689 ; as also , of imperfect conceptions , in one of which it is observable that it wanted the Head and Legs , but had the Heart with the Aorta and Cava , the rudiments of the Lungs , &amp;c. visible .
After some other Observations about Vesicles in the Uterus of Women , he describes at monstrous Hen Egg , containing four Eggs in one , with their Yolks , Whites , and Secundines : This our Author parralels with an observation of a monstruous Limon , and proceeds to give an account of the cause of these Productions or Superfaetations , from several successive conceptions in the Uterus , and compares this to the formation of a sort of Stone that seems to contain , or be made up of several others included in it .
Our Author in the next place treats of the motion of the Blood which he observed in Frogs to move from the extreme parts of the Body , and capillary Veins into larger and larger Vessels till it came to the Heart , he likewise finds , that the motion is sometimes inverted and sometimes stands still , which is supplied by the frequent Anastomoses of the Vessels ; nor does it keep the same pace in all the Veins , moving much slower in those that are winding than in strait ones .
There are several other curious Observations of the Blood and its Circulations .
Next follow several Observations upon the Hairs of Animals , which are Plants Sui Generis have a bulbous Root and Vegetate , here he inserts an account of an Hair Ball found in the Womb of a Woman , and another under the Skin of an Ox. Hence he comes to treat of the Hairs , Feathers , and Quills of Birds , which he does with his usual accuracy , and ends with his Observations ons the Claws , Nails , and Hoofs of Creatures , their Structure , Use and Growth .
Then he says that in the Year 1688 , receiving a Letter from R. Waller Esq ; Secretary of the Royal Society , requesting him to resume his Studies .
He sent them his Epistle of the Glands , which was then Published : about which time Dr. Nuck wrote a Treatise of the Glands , advancing a different sentiment from our Author which he here endeavours to refute .
In the Year 1689 , Dr. Paulus Minus set forth several Conclusions or Public Theses against the Doctrines and Opinions advanced by our Author which he here sets down .
The next Year came forth a nameless Book , Entitled De Recentiorum Medicorum studio Dissertatio Epistolaris ad amicum , wherein Anatomical and Microscopial Observations are condemned as useless , and the Empiric Practise of Physic asserted .
This Epistle with an Answer to it by our Author is also published in this work .
Lastly , He tells us that Jo. Baptista Triumphetti in a public Speech in the Physic Garden at Rome , Ridiculed his Anatomy of Plants , Animals , &amp;c. as useless Curiosities , more fit for mere Philosophers , and to divert ingenious Gentlemen , than for Physicians to trouble themselves withal .
Anno 1691 , He was sent for to Rome by Pope Innocent the XII .
to be his Physician , where the 29th of November 1694 this Great Man died of an Apoplexy in the Quirinal .
This Postumous Work of Signr .
Malpighi , besides his Life , &amp;c. wrote as was said by himself , contains some other Tractates which he desired should be published , and first a Treatise by Signr .
Joannes Alphonsus Borellus which is here printed in Italian and Latin , concerning the disputes of Signr .
Firichius and Faba English Men , and the Great Duke of Tuscanies Anatomists .
The Dispute is concerning the Optic Nerve of the Sword-fish or Tunny , whether Malpighi was the first that observed it to be a large nervous Membrane , &amp;c. or whether Bartholomeus Eustachius an Italian Anatomist of the last Age was the first discoverer thereof .
Now tho ' it be granted that Eustachius might observe something thereof aceidentally , yet not having prosecuted it , nor he thinks named the Animal in which it is , he affirms Malpighi to be the first Inventor thereof , for several Reasons which he alleges ; showing , that any thing may be said to be new , tho ' possibly it might have been known in formertimes , if the memory of it is wholly perished , which he shows to be the present case in relation to Malpighi .
The Second is a Treatise under the Name of Dr. Placidus Papadopolis Messanensis , being in answer to a Book Entitled , Triumphus Galenistarum contra Philosophos ac Medicos recentes in humano corpore nonnullarum partium ac operationum , ignotarum antiquis Medicinae Professoribus , this is a Defence of Malpighi , in which he answers each conclusion or Member of the Book wherein Physic is asserted to be already perfect , and needs not any additions or new discoveries to be made by Anatomy or Experiments , it being sufficient to study the Old Authors and follow their steps , the contrary to which is demonstrated in this defence from the concessions and practice of Hippocrates , Galen , &amp;c. themselves .
Next they proceed to several Particulars ; as whether the Heart be the Origin of heat , which in this Tract is denied , and shown to be no hotter than other of the Viscera .
The next Question is , whether the Lungs or Liver are principal actors in Sanguification , the reasons for the Liver are first set down out of the Triumph .
Galenist , and then answered in this Treatise , where he also shows , that it is chiefly made in the Lungs from several Anatomical mical and other Observations , then he comes to the Four Nutritious Humours , Blood , Choler , Spittle and Melancholy , which the Opponent proving out of Hippocrates , our Author shows that Hippocrates is not in this matter consistent with himself ; sometimes constituting but two , sometimes more Humours ; he likewise Answers the Authority of Galen ; as also his other Reasons from the Four Seasons of the Year , &amp;c. After which he brings a Citation out of Willis de Ferment .
Whereupon he enlarges chiefly upon the motions of matter that are observable in Animals , and thence explicates the cause of Fevers , and so proceeds to the examination of several other Diseases disputed of between the Galenists and Moderns , the Opponent calls Novatores , and first whether blood-letting be necessary in Apoplexys ; our Author affirming it to be so , the other having asserted the contrary .
Secondly , Concerning the Pleurisie , whether it be seated in the Lungs or Pleura : the former is defended by our Author , the rest of the Treatise relates to the Method of curing Diseases especially Fevers , whether by Purging , Vomiting , and Sweating or by Blood-letting , the later being chiefly approved by our Author , showing the danger of a Looseness in an illness from the Histories of Hippocrates concerning Epidemic Fevers .
This Treatise being mostly Polemick ought to be read it self , it not being so easy to make an extract thereof without being too large .
The next Treatise Printed in this work is , De recentiorum Medicorum studio Dissertatio Epistolaris ad Amicum , this Tract is mentioned by our Author in his Life , where he gives some account of it himself : The design of the Writer thereof is to show , that a more subtle and curious Anatomy of the Parts , the Anatomy of Plants , and Comparative Anatomy are little or not at all serviceable to the more solid Practice of Physic .
The first he endeavours to prove from the Authority of Galen , Celsus , Helmont , &amp;c. then he says , that no new use of most of the Parts having been discovered by this nice over curious Anatomy ; it is of necessity , of no value ; says , that the Urine was separated by the Kidnies , before they were discovered to be furnished with Glands and Tubuli , &amp;c. And where any new use is ascribed to them , they have rather overthrown the old Opinions , than Established new Truths , which he instances in the Pancreas and Spleen .
Secondly , As to the Diseases of the Parts , no new or better way of Cure has been found out .
Thirdly , it is not needful to know them otherwise a Diseased Spleen or Pancre as , would never be Cured , because their use is not yet known , the contrary of which is daily found by Experience , those parts being as Curable as others .
This he extends also to the Brain , Lungs and Diaphragm Parts , tho ' subtly Dissected , yet not better known as to their Use or Cure , which he instances in some Diseases , Remedies for which have been found out by Chance , not from the Knowledge of the Parts .
He then takes Comparative Anatomy in Hand , which he says can signify nothing to the advancing Physic .
Animals are so different from each other in all their Parts , that nothing of use for Man can from them be discovered , tho ' he allows Zootomy to be necessary for the completing of Natural History , but signifies nothing to the Physician , whose business is to Cure , not be Curious .
Lastly , He comes to Dendranatome , which he also affirms unnecessary in Physic ; all the Discoveries of the parts of Plants , being like Tantalus 's Gardens , delusive Vanities , the virtues of Plants not being the better discernible from their Minute parts , being Microscopically viewed .
The Cause of the Stinging of the Nettle not being better known , tho ' its Asperities are discovered .
In fine , he recommends Experience , Observation , and the like , as more likely to discover the Quantity and Quality of Remedies , with their Use and most fit times of Application , than these supposed Inventions and curious Speculations .
To this Epistle Snr .
Malpighi subjoins a large and very particular Answer , having first inserted in this Work an extraordinary Case of a young Lady , afflicted with a Complication of Diseases , proceeding chiefly from Melancholy , all which she bore with an Heroic Fortitude , that she could hardly be said to be unhappy , tho labouring under loss of Appetite , frequent Vomitings of undigested Food ; Palpitations of the Heart , with great gnawing Pains ; Hysteric Fits , Faintings , &amp;c. with a Swelling in the Abdomen , like an Aneurism , all which reduced the Patient to a Skeleton , as she then was , when the Account was given of her .
Here follows Snr .
Malpighi 's Reply to the Epistle De Recentiorum Medicorum Studio , &amp;c. where in the first place he observes from Hippocrates , that Men condemn that as superfluous , which they are deficient in themselves ; and complaining of the hard usage he has met with from the ill-nature of some Men , he comes to answer the Treatise it self ( having first given some account of the Author , who was at first an AnatomyReader , and teacher of the Rational Practice of Physic ) and observes , that the Author omits many things of great weight , that the Modern Practisers of Physic carefully regard , and insists only upon the three particulars mentioned in the Letter , as if they were their whole Care and Study , viz. the more curious Anatomy , Dendranatome and Comparative Anatomy , whereas the very Titles of Books Printed , shows on the contrary their application to Chemistry , Mechanicks , Generation of Animals , to find out the seats of Diseases , with their Causes , &amp;c. which the Author of the Epistle could not be ignorant of , whence he concludes , it was designedly levelled at himself and his Studies , which were chiefly of those three Subjects .
Then he shows , that the Ancient as well as Modern Physicians applied themselves diligently to Anatomy , and Galen himself to that of Plants , as likewise Cesalpinas and Mizaldus , and hints at the use and necessity of Microscopes , to discover the Minute Operations of Nature ; The whole Answer to this Epistle being pretty large , and this Extract of the Work already extended too far , I shall only touch upon some few of the principal Heads , and Conclude .
First he shows , that but few in respect of the great Number of Practitioners apply themselves to those three Anatomies ; and they that have so done , have not so wholly Studied that , as to neglect other parts of Medicinal Learning , and tho ' it should be granted , these three things did conduce but little to the more solid Medicine , yet still they render the Physician more Complete .
And here , by the way , he determines what may be a Solidior Medicina Practica , which he will not allow to be only Empirical , as the Author of the Epistle contends ; but a truly Rational Method , which he shows was the more Ancient , and the Empiric but an Heresre from it ; this is founded upon a true Anatomical Knowledge of the several parts of the Body , by the means of Philosophy and Mechanicks ; whence we proceed , a priori to Physiology , Pathology , and lastly , the Art of Medicine .
Here he gives some Instances of the use of Mechanical Experiments , to Explicate Vision , Pulsation of the Arteries , Respiration , Coction or Digestion , &amp;c. and tho ' we cannot know the way that the Soul actuates the Body , by the Brain and Nerves , yet we may discover the Engines it makes use of to perform its Operations , whence the Physician may come to the Knowledge of rectifying the Engine , and fitting it for the Souls use .
In the next place he shows the weakness of the Empiric ; and that even by the Concessions of his Opponent , it is fain to be beholden to the former for what it has of solid , for casual and fortuitous Remedies ought to be Examined by reason as well as Experience .
Coming closer to the Argument he proves , that the more Curious subtle Anatomy , is not useless to the Cure of Diseases , answering his Citations from the Authority of Galen , who was himself as Curious as he could , not being furnished with Microscopes and other helps of later Invention : As to the necessity of the more curious Anatomy , he instances in the Discoveries that have been thereby made in the use of the Parts and their Diseases , viz. of the Spleen , Lungs , and Glands , under the Tongue , Palate and Trachea , Glandulous Structure of the Pleura , and Peritoneum .
Proceeding farther he shows , that neither the Methodists nor Chimists ever despised Anatomy ; and then sets down the different uses ascribed by the Ancients and Moderns to several parts of the Body , viz. the Kidneys , Liver and Gall ; and thence shows , contrary to the Opposers Assertion , how they differ , and affirms , that the Moderns have in many things reformed the ancient Practise , instancing in some Diseases of the Kidnies , &amp;c. After this he shows , from the Authors of the Biblioth .
Anat .
some new Discoveries that have been made , as the Structure and use of the Heart , with the Circulation of the Blood , Motion of the Arteries , use of the Veins , the Lymphaticks , the Lacteal Veins , Structure of the Liver , and Motion of the Gall , Structure and use of the Pancreas , of the Spleen , of the Parotides , of the Glands of the Palate and Trachea , of the Brain , of the Kidnies , of the Papillae , of the Tongue for the Taste , and of the Skin for the Touch , of the Glands , of the Ventricle , of the Conglobated Glands , of the ways of Sweat and Transpiration , of the Eggs in Viviparous Animals , of the Tracheae in Insects , Plants , and imperfect Animals , of Respiration in all living Creatures , with the Structure of the Lungs and Muscles , &amp;c. And then shows the Ancients were not more Successful in Curing Diseases than the Moderns , whose Method is at least more rational and safe , and less vexatious to the Patient .
He instances in some , and then shows how several Diseases are better Cured now than formerly , and ends his Reply to the first of the Objectors three things , with answering his Citation out of Hippocrates against Anatomy .
Coming to Treat of the Second , viz. Comparative Anatomy , which he shows to have been recommended by the Lord Bacon , as necessary , not only to the completing Natural History , but likely also to discover the use of the Parts in Man ; wherefore several Members of the Royal Society set upon it , and were followed by the Learned of France and Germany .
This Zootomy he shows to be serviceable to Physic ; those Parts that are not so discoverable in one Animal , being more evident in another ; and tho ' possibly they may differ something in the Figuration , yet they are Analogically reducible to the same Machine : Of this he gives several Instances in the Sturcture of the Lungs , Brain , Eyes , the use of the Gall , Circulation of the Blood , &amp;c. which are more visible in one Animal than another ; and then answers the Objection from the great variety of Animals , which tho ' indeed numerous , yet may be reduced to severals Heads , all these under one Genus , having much the same Figuration of Parts , for the same uses , as the Wings of Birds for Flying : And the variety of the internal Parts depends upon the Quality of the Nourishment or Nature of the place where they live , or other Circumstances : Instancing in some , he says , the Oeconomy is nevertheless much the same ; next he answers his Citations out of Hippocrates and concludes this second part with answering the Opponents Dilemma , which is this , Zootomy is either for completing natural History , and then belongs to the Philosopher , or for the better Attainment of the Cure of Diseases : but since by it no new Medicines are found out , neither can it be useful to the Physician any way .
After the Answer to this , he shows , that the Moderns have not been wanting in their Observations and Experiments on the Humors of the Body , and inserts his own upon the Blood : and so comes to handle the last part , concernDendranatome , which our Author confesses was not prosecuted by himself or others , upon the Account of the Practice of Physic , or thereby to find out new Remedies : But for the Cultivation of that part of Natural Knowledge , which before was but little known .
And shows , that Galen and others did the same : Then he defends his Compairing some of the Parts of Plants with those of Animals , tho ' others might have extended this too far , as Montalbanus Mizaldus , &amp;c. proves in the next place , the Discoveries that have been made in the Structure of Plants by Microscopes , and to what purpose ; and adds that Dendranatome may , tho ' more remotely , advance even the Practice of Physic , by the Discovery of the Oeconomy of Plants , as from the Generation of Galls ; he Explicates the Cause of Pustles and Tubercles rising up in Animals .
After this he shows the Disquisition of the Nature of Salts ( objected against by the Opponent ) to be no useless Study , instancing how it serves to discover the Nature of the Blood .
Coming to Treat of the Seminal Leaves , he shows their use , then he answers the Quotations out of Galen and others , against these Curiosities ; he shows him to be mistaken in his Story of Gnidius the Architect , from the Authority of Strabo and Pliny , wonders the Opponent should mention Passion , or any Intemperance in the Moderns ; professing that he can find little of that kind in their Works , which are wrote with the greatest Modesty , as he Instances in Galileo , Redi , Boyle , Willis , &amp;c. nor are the Titles now ~ on Learned Men , so extravagant as those of the past Age , in which the Attribute of Divine was frequent , even to Poets , as to Petrarch , &amp;c. He adds , that whatever the Opponent may fancy of the short Life of the Fame of new Discoveries , says , Anatomy had its Original from the Sacrifices of the Jews and Gentiles , was Cultivated by Hippocrates and Democritus , augmented by Erasistratus , but chiefly by Erophilus , who ~ Condemned Persons alive , which getting him the hatred of the People , Dead as well as Living were Dissections forbidden .
It was at this time practised in AEgypt , where Galen was Instructed therein ; after that it was Received , tho ' not Increased , by the Arabians , was revived in Italy , in the 13th Age , by Mundinus , and advanced by Vesalius Columbus , &amp;c. till in this last Age it is come to that Height and Perfection we now admire ; so that as since from the first beginning it has never been wholly neglected , but still gone on Increasing ; so we have no reason to apprehend it will by Future Ages be so slighted , as to be thrown by as a useless Speculation , as the Opponent predicts ; whose Discourse ending with Seneca 's advice to Lucillius , against useless Learning , our Author thor Examines the Passage in Seneca , and says , that Seneca advised against Sophistical and Cavelling contentious Disputes , as of no advantage to make Men better , and therefore useless , which cannot be said of the things Condemned by the Author of the Epistle , which are neither liable to Sophistry nor Cavillations .
Lastly , as to the Date of the Epistle ; Our Author shows it to be false , for whereas he Dates it Gottingae idibus Sept. 1687 .
it ought to have been much later , for it was not Published till the beginning of 1689 .
after the Conclusions disputed the 13th of January , and public Anatomy by D. Paulus Minus , Ap. 12 .
In the Conclusion of this Posthumous Work , is Reprinted our Authors Epistle of the Structure of the Conglobated Glands , first Published Anno 1689 .
and of which there is an Account already given in these Transactions .
LONDO N : Printed for Sam .
Smith , and Benj .
Wallford Printers to the Royal Society , at the Princes Arms in St. Paul 's ChurchYard .
1697 .

