III .
An Account of a Child Born alive without a Brain , and the Observables in it on Dissection , by Dr. Charles Preston .
SIR , IN obedience to your Commands , and judging it will not be unacceptable , I have Collected the best Account ( in so far as I can remember ) of that extraordinary Birth , mentioned in the fourth Journal of the Progres de la Medicine , for the Month of April , 1695 .
of which I had the fortune to be a Witness , and also the opportunity of examining more particularly : But in the first place , I think it not amiss to relate the Story as it is given in by Monsieur Le Duc , sworn Surgeon of Paris , famous for his Practice in Midwifery ; and I hereafter shall proceed to give a farther History of the thing , with all the Circumstances about it , and show wherein they are in a Mistake .
April 3d .
1695 .
I was called to a Woman aged about 28 Years , ~ Months and a half gone in her third Child , she was Feverish , and raved a little ; on Examination , I found the ~ uteri Internum dilated about the largeness of a Crown ; she complained of Pains in those Parts : This , joined with that of a Fall from a Stair about eight days before , determined me to assist Nature , which seemed ready to Relieve herself of that Burden ; I caused to be given her some Aliment , to prepare her for a Work in which she stood in need of force , and one Hour after I delivered her happily of a Male Child , that lived half an Hour , and received Baptism ; this Child was big and strong , and all the Parts of the Body well proportioned , as they ought to be naturally , except the Head , the hinder Part whereof was flat , as if it had been taken off with the Stroke of some Weapon , even to the Os Sphaenoides ; there was neither Brain , Cerebellum , nor Medulla oblongata ; the Cavity which ought to contain these was very superficial ; I found in their place , a black and livid Substance , covered with a Membrane , which may be the Dura and Pia Matter joined together ; this Substance had coloured the Os petrosum and other Bones of a deep red Colour , I thrust a Stilet or Probe into the Cavity of the Vertebres , where ought to be placed the Medulla Spinalis , but found no opposition ; for in effect , it was filled with a red stinking Liquor , contained in the Membranes of the Medulla Spinalis ; the Visage of this Child was a little deform , because of the want of the Cranium , which might have been communicated to the Bones as yet tender , that sustained the Skin of the Face .
The great Motion of the Eyes of this Child , during the time it lived , gave me the Curiosity to search the Cause ; I was assisted by a skilful Anatomist , who was surprised with me , to find nothing in the place of Muscles cles and Nerves , but Skins and Filaments very small , and not capable of Contraction , mixed in a~ Humor , so that this great Motion might rather proceed from the Motion of the Palpebrae .
There has passed under my Hands three Subjects like unto this , all Males , and who lived some time .
Having given you the Story as it is related by Monsieur Le Duc , I shall proceed to give you the farther Account .
Being Lodged with Monsieur Le Duc , for the Benefit of Accouch-mens , this extraordinary Birth happened , and finding it a very singular and rare case , I proposed the sending for Monsieur Du Linier , Operator to Mr. ~ Verny , to have it dissected , which accordingly was performed .
First , we examined the External Parts , and found all well proportioned , except , that it wanted the Cranium , Cerebrum , and Cerebellum ; the Visage was a little deform , it had Eyes and Ears like a Monkey , and all over the Body was more hairy then ordinary .
2 .
We examined what there was in place of the Brain , but could discover nothing but a Substance like congealed Blood , covered with a Membrane .
We searched also for the Optic Nerves , but all we found in their place was some small Filaments .
3 .
We thrust a Probe into the Canal of the Vertebres , to see whether there were any Medulla Spinalis , and finding small resistance , they concluded there was none : We went on to discover the Vessels of Communication , and some other things , curious in Anatomy ; but I shall pass them over , as not relating to our present purpose .
This Examen not being satisfactory to me , and several Difficulties occurring , not only as to the Motion of the Parts , but as to the Circulation of the Blood ; which according to the Modern Opinions , depends upon the Influx of theAnimal Spirits into the Nerves that were separated in the Brain , I carried the Subject to Monsieur Du Verny , Professor of Anatomy in theRoyalGarden atParis , to have it more carefully examined ; who willingly complied with my desire : And first he searched ~ the Optic Nerves , but theybeing ruined by theabove-mentionedPersons , he could not saywhetherthey had been there or not .
2 .
He traced the ~ and ninth pairs of Nerves and 'Intercostal .
3 .
Having cut up the Canal of the Vertebres , discovered the Medulla Spinalis all along the Cavity , and traced all the vertebral Nerves proceeding therefrom ; as also the ~ Nerve considerable enough : It is true , the Medulla Spinalis was not here of that ~ as in adult Persons ; but one could with some pains observe all the four Tunicks , and the two Substances as in the Brain , to wit , the Cortical or Glandulous Substance , and the Fibrous or White , but with this difference , that the Brown Substance is exterior in the Brain , but interior in the Medulla Spinalis , for it is as it were a third Brain contained in the Canal of the Vertebres so framed for its defence ; for there are Meninges as in the Brain , Sin 's and Cavities which may pass for Ventricles : In a word , one can say all of it that they can of the Brain , and more , for it appears more sensible and necessary for the Life , for you can take the Brain or Cerebellum from an Animal , and yet the Animal shall live sometime thereafter ; but a Wound or Compression of the Medulla Spinalis will cause sudden Death .
And the Generation , or Filtration , and Distribution of Animal Spirits , is performed the same way as in the Brain : And Monsieur ~ Verny has observed , that all the Subjects of this nature , that he has had occasion to dissect , never one of them was found wanting the Medulla Spinalis ; so that from what is above observed , ed , I take for a sufficient Demonstration .
It was not wanting in this Subject , being so necessary for the Life of Animals , and without which it is impossible toconceive how they can subsist ; ~ is confirmed by several Anatomical Experiments ; and in particular , by one of Monsieur Du Verny , in the Year 1673 .
when he took the Brain and Cerebellum from a Pigeon , and in place thereof , filled the Cranium with Flax , notwithstanding which it lived some time , searched for Aliment , did the ordinary Functions of Life , and had the use of Sense ; and Monsieur Chirac , Professor of Anatomy at Montpelier , by several Experiments he has made upon Dogs , has clearly proved , an Animal may live some time wanting the Brain , andeven sometimes the Cerebellum ; as you 'll see by the following Experiments .
The first was upon a Dog , from whom he had taken the Brain , yet he lived some time , but when the Cerebellum was taken out he died immediately : but he has observed , that by blowing into the Lungs , the Animal has lived an Hour altho ' wanting the Cerebellum .
The second Experiment was upon a Dog , from whom he took half of the Cerebellum , but he died immediately .
The third upon a Dog , from whom he took half of the Brain , after he continued to have the Motion of all the Parts , and could walk about ; then he took all the Brain from the same Dog , he had yet Sense and Respiration .
A fourth Experiment upon a Dog , by introducing a pair of Scisars betwixt the first Vertebre and the Os Occipitis , to separate the Medulla Oblongata from the Medulla Spina~ lis , the Animal had died immediately , but by blowing into the Lungs , the Motion of the Heart continued , and the Animal could move its Body .
The fifth Experiment upon a Dog , from whom he took the Cerebellum , but he lived Twenty four Hours , and his Heart beat well .
All these Experiments let you see an Animal may live some time , tho imperfectly wanting the Brain , and even the Cerebellum , but there is no Experiment where ever they lived wanting all ; therefore I humbly conceive , the Medulla Spinalis was not here wanting , for it has supplied the defectof theBrain and Cerebellum , and the Animal Spirits have been separated and distributed for continuing the Circulation of the Blood : For it is to be considered , that altho ' the Intercostal Nerve and eighth pair have their Origin in the Medulla Oblongata , yet after their entry into the Cavity of the Breast , they are united with Branches from almost all the vertebral Nerves , and with them make up several Plexus 's , and from those Plexus 's , several Branches are emitted that go to the Heart and other Parts , sufficient for continuing the circulation of the Blood , which has occasioned some to run into a mistake , thinking the Circulation is to be explained some other way , then by the Influx of the Animal Spirits into the Nerves , which they endeavour to prove by an Experiment on a Dog , of tying the Intercostal and eighth pair of Nerves , before they enter the Cavity of the Breast , and yet the Dog shall live two or three Days thereafter .
This Experiment they take for a sufficient Demonstration , but except they can the all the vertebral Nerves , or at least the the Nerves at their entrance into the Heart , their Experiment is not so convincing ; but if in this case the Animal shall be found to live any considerable time thereafter , then the Circulation must be explained some other way : But the Symptoms that ordinarily happen , even upon tying the Intercostal and eighth pair , is an evident Proof of the contrary , for the Animal is taken immediately with Convulsions .
There are a Million of difficulties arising from this little Subject , obvious to every one that reads the Story ; ry ; which it will be needless to name , and far less will I pretend to explain them : I shall only make a Quaere , Whether all the Parts of this Child were entire in the Ovum ?
Or , if the Brain and Cerebellum have been carried off by the strong forceof Imagination , or by some Accident or Corruption whatever of these obtain ; I am apt to believe , all the Parts were once entirely framed for the tracing the eighth and ninth pair of Nerves and Intercostal , who take all their Origin from the Medulla oblongata , seems to be a Proof of it , and how far the force of Imagination goes , and what Influence it has upon Children , we have several Instances : and I shall have occasion to cite one or two Cases below .
The Learned Malpighi and others have compared the Seed of a Plant , with that of an Animal : And Laurentius Bellinus , in his late Treatise , Ad Archibaldum Pitcarnium , de Motu cordis , &amp;c. speaking of Generation , has these Words , Et quum videant , aut videre sibi videntur semina Plantarum , nihil aliud esse quam illas ipsas plantas , quae ex iis seminibus nasci , Germinare , Provenire , produci , generari dicuntur , ita ut nil sit in planta quae producitur , quod prius non fuerit in semine quod producit &amp; planta dicenda sit solum semen majus &amp; in majorem magnitudinem Extensum , &amp; omnes parts quae continentur , in planta continentur in semine &amp; in utrisque sunt ejusdem ordinis , ejusdem perfectionis , ejusdem operandi modi hinc constituit , etiam in seminibus Animalium rem , eodem modo concipiendam esse , &amp; semen eorundem dicendum atque existimandum , nihil aliud quam parvum corpus Animalis constans , ex omnibus &amp; iisdem partibus , eodem modo dispositis perfectis atque operantibus , &amp;c. Hence I infer , that all the Parts of this Faetus were once entire and perfect , whatever way they came to be wanting afterward it being evident , that a Faetus has not the use of the Senses .
Likewise it is much controverted , whether a Faetus does respire while in utero materno , there being only a continued Circulation from the Mother to the Child , and from the Child to the Mother , by means of the Placenta and Cordon , so that the Lungs of the Mother serve for both , and that the Blood circulates a much shorter way by the Canal of Communication and ForamenOvale without passing the Lungs , then it does after the Birth , the Child having then the proper use of its own Lungs , the former Passage being so Mechanically stopped by a Valvule , that the Blood quite alters its former Channel or Course , as I have seen it to my great Pleasure and Satisfaction , demonstrate on several Faetus 's dissected on that account in the private Lectures of Monsieur Du Verny .
And that the thing may appear more clear , I shall mention two Opinions that obtain most as to the Nourishment of a Faetus .
The first is , That there are a number of Glands in the Internal Tunic of the Matrix , which all the time of Child-bearing filter and separate from the Blood , a white Liquor , like unto Chile , that is received by the Glands of the Placenta ( which is nothing but a heap of Glands and Vessels ) that are joined with those of the Matrix ; hence in Brutes they can separate the Placenta from the Matrix without the effusion of Blood , but only of that white Liquor , the umbilical Veins and Arteries being distributed to all the Glands of the Placenta ; so that the capillary Veins receive that Liquor with the Blood , and carry it to the Vena Porta of the Child , from thence to the Heart , to be distributed through the whole Body ; and what is superfluous , is carried back to the Placenta by the umbilical Arteries , and so continues to circulate from the Placenta to the Child , &amp; vice versa .
By the Second Opinion they pretend that the Umbilical lical Vessels are dispersed through the Placenta , and that the Capillary Veins of the Placenta are anastomosed with the Capillary Arteries of the Matrix , from whom they receive the Blood that is carried to the Child for its Nourishment , and the remainder is carried back by the Umbilical Arteries which are anastomosed with the Veins of the Matrix ; so that the Circulation is made from the Mother to the Child , and from the Child to the Mother , by means of the Placenta and Umbilical Vessels .
Which of these Opinions are the most probable , depends upon the Anatomy of the Parts ; but any of them will serve my turn , Viz .
to prove there is a continued Circulation from the Mother to the Child , and from the Child to the Mother : And to confirm it , I shall produce Two or Three Experiments which I had occasion to see performed .
The first was on a Faetus , by Monsieur du Verny , where by blowing into the Umbilical Vein , and tying the Arteries ; a little after the Umbilical Arteries were distended .
The second Experiment performed also by Mr. du Verny , was upon the Dissection of the Uterus of a Woman newly brought to Bed , by blowing into the Hypogastrick Artery , the whole Vessels were filled , and the Matrix blown up ; and for a farther Trial he made an inspection , by which the Liquor came forth at the Orifices of the little Glands , which are dispersed through the Matrix .
This Experiment cannot be performed but only in such cases .
The third Experiment I see performed by Monsieur Bidloo , Professor of Anatomy at Leyden on a Faetus , whereby an Injection of Wax into the Umbilical Vein , the whole Vessels were filled both Veins and Arteries , at which he was a little surprised , being contrary to his Doctrine .
I could instance several other Experiments , but this is sufficient to prove there is a continued Circulation from the Mother to the Child , and from the Child to the Mother ; so that a Faetus seems not to respire but by the Mother .
As Monsieur Merry in the Memoires de l'Academic de Science has confirmed by several Experiments .
The first was upon Two Tortoises , by tying their Jaws strongly together , and sealing their Nose and Throat with Spanish Wax , to try how long they could live without breathing : The first lived One and thirty days , the other Thirty-two .
Another Experiment was by laying open the Sternum of a Dog , who died a little after ; but having lifted that of a Tortoise , it lived yet Seven days .
Altho ' their Reasons seem to be strong , that a Tortoise can live so long without breathing , having the Canal of Communication and Foramen ovale always open , yet Monsieur Merry pretends they are not concluding , but by other reasons quite different ; and that is by the continued circulation , as we have said above , as he has several times observed in Accouchemens : That the Cordon by which the Faetus is tied to the Placenta , was so pressed , that the Blood could not pass from the Mother to the Faetus ; and that the head of the Faetus is engaged in the passage , the Faetus is choaked in a very little time ; but if the head is come forth , the Faetus dies not , altho ' the Cordon be strongly compressed by the rest of the Body .
To conclude this Discourse , I shall mention a few Observations of the like cases .
The first is by Monsieur Mauriceau in the 4th Edit .
of his Book , Des Maladies des Eemmes , p. 115 .
where he gives an account of one extraordinary Birth that happened in the Year 1665 , it had neither Cranium Cerebrum nor Cerebellum , but in place of those , a lump of fleshy substance very red , about the thickness and largness of a Placenta covered with a single Membrane very strong , all other parts were sound and well proportioned .
The second happened in the Year 1671 , when he was called jointly with Monsieur Lamy to the House of a Midwife in the Fauxbourg St. Germain , where there was a Girl brought to bed of a Child like unto the former .
They being called to give their report , what was the cause of the Childs death , and having examined all Circumstances , and amongst others , that ~ a sudden fright after she was a Month Conceived , by seeing her Lover fall from a Window Two Stories high , and by which she imagined his head was all bruised : They made their report that the Fright was the cause .
Page .
116 .
He mentions another of the same nature that happened in the Year 1672 , which he was brought to see by Monsieur Angury in the ; Cloister of Notre Dame .
Monsieur Peu also in his Book De la Pratique Des Accouchemens , p. 67 &amp; 68 .
relates one of the same nature that happened in the Year 1682 .
The Child lived about a quarter of an Hour .

