II .
An Account of a Gentleman 's being Cut for the Stone in the Kidney , with a brief Enquiry into the Antiquity and Practice of Nephrotomy .
NEphrotomy restraining its Signification to Cutting in the Kidney for the Stone , is an Operation which hath been hitherto so little practised , and always thought to be attended with so much difficulty and danger , that very few of those Authors who have treated of the Diseases of the Kidnyes , and particularly of the Stone there , have thought it worth their while to mention it ; and they who have , have done it generally to condemn it .
Some indeed have imagined , that Hippocrates in his Book De Intern .
Affect .
hath commanded the Operation ; where , enumerating the Diseases of the Kidnies and their Cure , he hath these words , Quum autem intumuerit &amp; elevatus fuerit , sub id tempus juxta renem secato &amp; extracto pure , arenam per urinam cientia , sanato .
Si enim sectus fuerit , fugae spes est , sin minus , morbus homini commoritur : and Sinibaldus in particular , Antiph .
Hippocr .
4 .
l. 5 .
upon these words of Hippocrates , who he tells us ( as Macrobius had done long before ) tam fallere quam falli nescit , is so solicitous to have this unknown Practice , as he calls it , Revived , that he passionately exhorts the French and Roman Surgeons to make the Experiment upon Brutes , that they might with greater dexterity and readiness perform it upon Men ; but with Submission , he seems to infer more from Hippocrates 's words , then upon a due Examination they will be found to bear , not considering , as he ought , the Conditions which Hippocrates requires ; for to say nothing of ~~~ ~ , ~ renem secare , as himself , Mercurialis , Foesius , and others have rendred it , or ad Regionem renis , as J.Martinus ; who , if I mistake not , is the single Person that hath expressly Commented upon this Book of Hippocrates , but deduces no such Practice from these words ) but admitting it in as large a sense as he will , and that Hippocrates did intend ( as I suppose he did ) that we should cut in renem as Fr. Rossetus Translates it ; yet I say , if he had considered the Conditions which Hippocrates 's requires to precede the Operation , there would be no such occasion to Practice upon other Animals , to render a Man dextrous when acting ( according to Hippocrates Directions ) upon Humane Bodies : for it is not sufficient that we take our Indications only from the common Symptoms of the Stone , be they never so grievous and never so evident ; but there must be an Apostem too , ~~ ~ , says he , and that is to manifest it self externally by a Tumor ~~~ ~ ~ .
And then indeed , the necessity and reason of the Operation are so obvious , and the Difficulty so little , that no Man ought to decline it .
I quarrel not with Sinibaldus , or the rest , for proposing this or any other Operation , whereby the Art of Healing may be advanced , or the Miseries of Mankind relieved ; but for perverting this passage of Hippocrates , and abusing his Authority to Countenance a Practice which I am confident Hippocrates knew not , and in this place , nor , for any thing that appears in any other , neither advised nor intended .
Of Apostems in the Kidnies , occasioned by an Inflammation ( for from an Inflammation to an Abscess , the transition is easy ) and from other Causes exclusive of the Stone , and of Matter discharged thence by opening , examples are so frequent , that there is nothing wonderful in that Case ; and any Man who hath missed , or is surprised at an Instance of that in his own practice ; may be supplied with variety enough , from many of those Authors who have made it their business to Publish Observations .
And most of those who have written of Nephritic Diseases in general , have taken care to deliver the manner of treating them , tho ' it be not the design of their Writing to furnish us with particular Cases .
Nor do we want Instances of Apostems in the Kidnyes , occasioned originally from the Stone there , and manifesting themselves by a Tumour , upon opening of which , Stones have been discharged with the Pus , or have been soon after removed , and this is the very Case which Hippocrates supposes , and upon which he justly advises the Practice .
Some Observations we have of Stones which have gradually wrought themselves out of the Kidney , without any preceding abscess , an instance of which ( to mention no more ) we have in Tulpius , l. 4 .
Obs. 28 .
( whose Authority when he writes from Autopsy , I take to be as unquestionable as any Mans ) of a Person who having long laboured with the Stone in the Kidnyes ( which was hereditary to him ) had at length one discharged through his Loins , which occasioned a Fistula , through which his Urine continued to flow with the Pus for a long time ; for the healing of which , after many fruitless Attemts , all that they could effect , was only to close the external Orifice , which locking in the matter , forced it into the Abdomen , which throwing him into a Fever killed him .
And this , among other mischiefs , Tulpius makes use of , as no mean Argument against the Practice of Nephrotomy .
But whatever some Men have inferred from Hippocrates , it is my Opinion , that we have no manner of Evidence , that Nephrotomy was practised in his time , or in many Ages after .
For Celsus ( who , by Heurnius his leave , is valuable for someD dd2 thing thing besides the Purity of his Stile ) is silent in the matter , altho ' he be so particular and accurate in his Discourse of cutting for the Stone in the Bladder .
And Galen himself , whose way is to say all he can upon his Subject , and is copious enough upon Diseases of the Kidnyes , especially the Stone , mentions it not ; which , had it been in use in his Days , or perhaps before him , would hardly have escaped him .
Cardan indeed , De libr .
propr .
p. 149 .
ed. Lugd. mistaking Hippocrates with the rest , reckons it inter deperdita , and is pleased ( with his usual rudeness ) among other Operations , to attribute the loss of this to Galen , and for no other reason , but because he omitted to mention it .
But this from a Person whose Candor and Judgment are not always without exception , without better Arguments , is of little import ; especially if we remember how pleased he seems , with every advantage which he fancies he hath over him ; how frequent he is in exposing him , and with what contempt he often uses him , not considering how very open himself lies in almost all his own voluminous Writings : And yet this surmise of Cardans ( or whoever else dreamed before him ) was Authority sufficient to an Author as fantastical as he , Dr. Meric .
Casaubon in his Censure of the Royal Society , to reproach the memory of Galen , and with just as much reason and equity .
But if his Silence be all the reason they have ( and there is no other imaginable ) then are Celsus and Ruffus , who preceded him , and Araeteus , who was at least his Contemporary , equally to be blamed , But indeed there are no footsteps that I canDiscover among any of the Greek or Latin Physicians , some of which being very fullupon allNephritic Cases , cannot be supposed universally to have omitted so important a Practice , had it been in use among them : Tho ' an Abscess in the Kidnyes , and the Method of Cure , be , what several of them do mention , as well as the Moderns .
The first light which I can pretend to discover of the Operation , as practised in our Case , is among the Arabians , tho ' even by them with an intention to discourage and deter all Men from the Attemt ; for Serapion , who is placed by Wolfgangus Justus , betwixt the Tenth and Eleventh Century , tho ' by Ren .
Moreau three hundred years earlier , gives his Opinion of it thus ; Tract .
4 .
c. 22 .
Quidam antiquorum praeceperunt lapidem renum extrabi cum ferro incidente retro super latus duorum iliorum in loco renum .
Ego autem video quod haec .
audacia est difficilis vehementer &amp; administratio istius curationis est maxim periculosa &amp; suspecta de morte .
Who these Ancients were that advised , I confess to be beyond my Conjecture ; it being , as I have said , to be found in none of their Writings , which have remained to our times ; unless we may be allowed to say , that he also had misunderstood Hippocrates , as some have manifestly done since .
Betwixt 12 and 1300 Avicen had much the same Opinion , both of the Practice and the Practitioners ; Sunt qui laborant extrahere ipsum per incisionem ilii &amp; per dorsum .
Sed est magnus timor in eo &amp; operatio ejus qui rationem non habet .
Page .
361 .
ed. Ven .
1562 .
The difference of their Sentiments being only , that one thought it the Undertaking of a Mad-man , the other of a Confident Fellow ; but from Avicen 's Words , there is some colour to believe that it was practised in his Days , tho ' undoubtedly , if it were , from his talking so slightly of it , it was only by Persons of a mean Character , such perhaps as our Mountebanks , who having no regard or concern for the lives of Men , and little Reputation of their own to loose , venture boldly , and sometimes successfully , upon those things which wary and more judicious Men avoid .
But , notwithstanding Avicen 's words , that it was very rarely , if at all , practised among the Arabians themselves , I think a Man may very reasonably infer , from the general Silence of all the rest of their Writers .
Among the Moderns , as well as I can inform my self , Fr. Rossetus libr .
de partu Caesareo seems to have been the first ; who , to make that Operation , for the sake of which he wrote his Book , obtain , by relating others which were Analogous , began seriously to advise the Practice ; tho , after all his ~ , he is not able to produce one Instance , either of his own or other Mens Experience , where they were not first invited and directed by a visible preceding Tumour .
He seems either not to have met with , or not to have believed that extraordinary Case in Caelius Rhodiginus var .
lect .
l. 3 .
c. 12 .
of a Woman , who having for a good while been afflicted with a load and pain in the Region of her Kidnyes ; scratched with that rage and impatience so long with her Nails , till she made a Wound so large and deep , as to discharge eighteen Stones magnitudine quanta in tesseris visitur .
And very justly does he reject that Account in Parey , l. 24 .
c. 19 .
as a Story whose authority was remote and suspicious , and the manner of the Relation altogether uninstructive .
For tho ' Mezeray in his History takes upon him to tell us that the Kidney was opened , yet all that can be learned from Parey , who Transcribed it from the same Author , from whom without doubt , Mezeray took it , ( viz. Enguerrand de Monstrelet dans ses chroniques depuis l'an 1400 .
jusques en l'an 1467 .
Printed at Paris 1572 .
) amounts to no more than this , that there being a Criminal , who had been long subject to Calculous Pains , condemned to Dye , the Physicians , upon pretence that it would be for the Benefit of Mankind , obtained leave of the King that they might open him alive , and inspect the parts affected ; which having done , and placing them all right again , they stitched him up , and the Man survived , but no Account where they opened him , what parts were Diseased , or what they observed .
But from Parey 's Relation , most certain it is , if there be any certainty in the Story at all , that they did not cut into the Body of the Kidney .
But when Parey inserted into the Margin , Superat haec narratio non modo omnem admirationem sed &amp; fidem , he might as well have added , &amp; lectione vix digna .
But notwithstanding Rosset 's Zeal to bring this Operation into use ; and tho ' he urges Hippocrates 's Authority to justify the cutting into the Kidney , he is yet so ingenuous as to acknowledge Praesente tumore , nec aliter , Hippocratem imperasse sectionem .
And as plausible as his Reasoning may seem , it does not appear , that he hath been able to gain many Proselytes to his Opinion ; the sense of those Authors who have mentioned it ( who are not many neither ) being generally against it , and concluding in effect with Riolan .
Ench .
Anat .
l. 2 .
c. 28 .
Nisi natura monstrante viam atque praeeunte , nefas est tentare nephrotomiam ; tho ' in his younger and more daring years , he seems of a quite different Opinion , when in another place without those Restrictions he pronounces , Renes vulnerari &amp; incidi posse , indicium est nephrotomiam secure administrari posse .
Altho ' it appears to be the concurrent Opinion of those Authors who have treated of Wounds in the Kidnyes , that if they penetrate the Pelvis they terminate in Doath , yet if they had lived to have beheld the Experiment which I am about to relate , performed by so great a Man with so good success , they would , no doubt , have made their Prognostic with more caution and reserve , and not so Magisterially have exploded the But to detain you no longer with a Digression , be pleased to receive the History as I had it from Mr. Hobson himself , who was the Person upon whom the Experiment was made , and for any thing that falls within my Knowledge .
The First , This Gentleman , who was Consul for the English at Venice , having been long afflicted with the Stone in the Kidney , was at length attacked with a Fit of that Duration and Violence , that it reduced him almost to Desperation ; and finding no Relief from any means that had been used , he determined to apply himself to Dominicus de Marchettis , who , as Ch. Patin in his Lyceum Patavinum tells us , was Primarius practicae Extraordinariae Professor at Padua , a Famed and Experienced Practitioner there , the Son of Peter , both well known to the Learned part of their Profession .
To this Person Mr. Hobson , under the greatest Extremity of Pain imaginable , addressed himself , imploring of him , that having made use of all conceivable means , and the best advice that was to be had in Venice , without Success , he would be pleased to cut the Stone out of his Kidney , being fixed in his belief that no other Method remained capable of Relieving him ; adding that he was not insensible of the Danger ; but that Death it self was infinitely more eligible , than a Life in that Misery , under which he had long and did then Groan .
Marchetti seemed very desirous to have declined it , representing not only the extreme hazard , but as he feared the impracticableness of the Operation , that it was what he had never attempted , and that to proceed to it , was in effect to destroy him : But Mr. Hobson persisting that if he refused it , he would never desist till he found out one who would do it .
Marchetti was at length , by his Resolution and Importunity prevailed upon to undertake it ; and having prepared him as he thought convenient , he began with his Knife , cutting gradually upon the Region of the Kidney affected , so long , till the Blood disturbed and blinded his Work , so that he could not finish it at that attemt : wherefore dressing up the Wound till the next Day , he then repeated and accomplished it , by cutting into the Body of the Kidney , and taking thence two or three small Stones , he dressed it up again .
From this Instant he was freed from the Severity of his Pain , and in a reasonable time was able to walk about his Chamber , having been in no danger , either from Flux of Blood or Fever .
Marchetti continued to dress the Wound for a considerable time , but was not able to close it up , it soon becoming Fistulous from the continual flowing of the Urine through the Sinus ; but being in all other respects restored to his former Health and vigor , and the Matter discharged being little , he took leave of the Professor , and returned to Venice , under the Care and Management of his Wife ; who , one Morning as she was dressing the Sore , fancied she felt something hard and rugged as she wiped it ; upon which , Examining a little more carefully with her Bodkin , which served her instead of a Probe , she found it to be a Stone , of the Figure and Magnitude of a Date Stone ; which being removed , he never after complained of the least uneasiness in the part .
About Ten Years after this he returned to London , where the Learned Dr. Tyson , and my self , were , by Dr. Downs , who had known him formerly in Venice , invited to see him , which we did at the Castle-Tavern in Pater-Noster-Row ; where , after we had received this Account from himself , he gave us the Satisfaction of viewing the Sore , which continued open , and permitted me without any ComE ee plaint plaint ( the Callosity being great ) to pass my Probe so far into the Sinus , that we concluded it reached into the Kidney : the Matter it then discharged was but little in quantity , but always diluted with and smelt strong of Urine .
The Orifice would sometimes close for three or four Days together , and then the Matter made its way through the common Passages with the Urine , yet without any difficulty or Pain .
There is no question , but that there was a Coalition of the Kidney , and the Muscle Psoas .
When we saw it he applied nothing to the Orifice but a clean Linen Rag , which had a strong Urinous Scent .
He was then as able in appearance , to perform all the Functions of life , and to undergo any Fatigue , as any Man of his Years ; being then , I conceive , upwards of Fifty , and was the next day to ride Post forty or fifty Miles .
I have heard that he is since dead , but could not be informed of what Disease .

