F. 1 .
2 3 4 F. 11 .
Philosoph : Transact. F. 9 .
F. 7 .
F. 8 .
56 F. 12 .
F. 10 .
La vana speculatione disingannata dal senso : Lettera Risponsiva circa i Corpi Marini , che Petrificati si trovano in varij Luoghi TerrestriDi Agostino Scilla Pittore Academico della Fucina , in Napoli , 1670 .
4to .
With short Notes , by a Fellow of the Royal Society .
IT will not , I suppose , be wondred at , that a Book which has been so long printed , should now be taken notice of in these Transactions , since it appears to be so little known , even by those who have written upon the self-same Argument , that some late Writers who seem to have omitted nothing that Nature and Books could help them to , to carry on their Work , seem never to have seen it .
Otherwise in all probability they would have named this Author , among those who have taken pains to prove , that the Shells , or Stones in likeness of Shells which are found up and down upon the Surface , and in Hills and Quarries of the Earth , were once real coverings of enclosed Fishes , or have been formed in those Shels which were instead of Molds to the liquid matter that got in after the Fishes were consumed .
This Signior Scilla has not only taken pains to prove , but has brought more Arguments in proof of it , than had been brought by those that appeared upon that Subject before him .
His way of Writing shows little Art , and less Learning , which he owns himself a Stranger to , being by Profession a Painter of Messina , who delighted much in designing and painting all Rarities of Nature which were brought to him , or which he could collect .
The great variety of Shells found either in the neighbouring Hills , or brought to him from Malta , led him into a dispute with some Virtous of his acquaintance , concerning their Original : Some asserting that they were formed at first by a plastical power in the Earth ; he on the contrary being of Opinion , that they were real Shells thrown by an Inundation , at one time or other , upon the Earth : The proving of which Assertion is the subject matter of this Trearise .
After a great deal of prefacing spent in Verbose Civilities , after the manner of Modern Italian Writers , he begins to enquire into the generation of Minerals and Metals , which he believes to be generated by a penetrating Juice or Vapour arising out of the Bowels of the Earth , which alters and turns all manner of Earths into it self .
So that if in Alum works ( for example ) after they are exhausted , Sand , or Gravel , or Dirt be thrown into the Pits from whence the Alum was dug , by the penetrative and alterative quality of the Aluminous Vapour , they will by degrees be changed into such a substance as had before been dug out of the self-same place .
He says he has found Clods of Earth and Gravel which have been so put in , which as they have been more or less distant from the fountain of Alum , from whence these Vapours did exhale , were more or less impregnated with Alum : Nay he pretends that by breaking several of these Clods whilst they were thus digesting , he has discovered the steps by which Nature works in the whole process of this Maturation .
The Fossil Salt in the Mountains of Ragalmuto in Sicily is in his Opinion made after the same manner ; for after the Peasants have wrought a Pit , if they fill it up again with the loose Earth which they find hard by , in a short time it will be so condensed and purified , that for brightness it will not be distinguishable from that which was dug out not long before .
After which manner also he supposes that the harder Minerals are produced .
This Hypothesis is advanced in order to what he has to say concerning the original of those Shells and formed Stones which are found upon the Earth ; thereby to invalidate the Argument of those who pretend that they are formed by a vegetative Virtue in that particular Soil , which determines them to that peculiar and regular shape : To which he now proceeds .
He begins with supposing that Malta , from whence the greatest quantity of these supposed Petrifactions come , was made an Island , as we now see it , some time after the Creation ; and that it was once a heap of liquid Mud replenished with Shells , Teeth , &amp;c. which ( as he afterwards explains himself ) settling promiscuously according to its Gravity , hath made that Island a heap of Earth , Stones , Shells , Teeth , and the like , as now we see it .
He supposes that this Collection of Matter was occasioned by a Flood , let the Causes of that Flood have been what they will , either an irruption of the Ocean into the Mediterranean , or an inundation of the Tuscan Sea driven that way by vehement Winds , or any other Cause assigned by Authors ; which ( namely that the present state of the Isle of Malta , was caused by a Flood ) being granted , he thinks he may be allowed to affirm , that which every Mans Reason must acknowledge to be highly probable , namely that an infinite variety of things which were born up by the violence of the Waters were carried along by them , some to one place , and some to another .
But to this his Adversary objected , that formed Stones have been frequently found , such as the Bucardites of Imperati , and others like some sort of Turbens or Periwinkles , which being all of a hard stony substance , could never have been Shells .
These , says he , are made of Mud condensed in Shells , which were the Molds in which these Stones were formed : and therefore we need not be at a loss to conceive how these Stones should ever contain an Animal within them , since they took the place of the Animal that was wasted away , whilst they were only liquid Paste , which hardning afterwards would retain their Form , when the Crust that covered them , and that gave them their shape , was mouldred away .
And whereas it was further objected , that great quantities of Shells are found in Malta , which are foreign to those Seas : That ( says he ) is of no force , since it is well known that every South-Easterly and Easterly Wind throws whole Boat-loads of beautiful Shell-Fish are ever taken by Fishermen upon those Seas .
Now he comes to particulars .
He begins with the Lapides Bufonitae , which he proves to be the true Grinders of the Sargus Dentex and Aurata , and other Fishes of that Tribe , which have round Dentes Molares , to grind the Shells that they find at the bottom of the Sea , that they may come at the Flesh upon which they live .
Now to make this beyond contest , he produces the natural Jaw-bones of these Fishes , with their Teeth within them ; and compares those Teeth with the Bufonitae , of which there are as many sorts , as there are species of Fishes , which have round , hard Jaw-Teeth .
( a ) .
The great Numbers of Glossopetrae sent to him from Malta , some entire , some corroded at the Root which never had a Crust over it , some bruised , some whole , do as plainly show their Original as the Bufonitae did before : For upon comparing he finds that they are not so much very like to , as the very same with the Teeth of Sharks and other Fishes of the Dog-kind .
Nay he appeals to the Senses of all Manking , whether great Numbers of Testaceous Substances , that he is ready to produce , taken out of Mountains and Rocks , were not originally coverings of Animals of their respective kinds , since the very bruises which they received by the weight of the Ambient Matter , as it grew harder , and consequently pressed more heavily upon them , are still plainly visible .
Some of the Echini being robbed of their Prickles , and loosned in their Joints , which being naturally membranous , easily part , being corroded by the humid [ and perhaps acid ] substance in which they lay .
( b ) .
And whereas it may be objected , that these Shells may grow by little and little , and consequently some may be tenderer than others , as not being exactly formed ; he says he can show Lumps of Stone excessively hard full of Conchae , Turbens , Scallops and the like , where , within some of them , all the parts of the Animal it self may be distinctly observed ; which is not so very rare neither , but that he has several times observed it .
This , says he , puts the Original of these Shells out of doubt ; since they happened to be closed before the liquid Mud could get in and corrode the included Animal , and afterwards harden into the exact form which its Matrice must of necessity give it : Whereas the others being first filled with Mud , which hardned into a stony consistence after the Animal was quite wasted , gave occasion to some Persons who had not seen great varieties of Shells and formed Stones of that sort , to doubt of their Original .
He reasons also from the several Lamellae , of which these Land-shells are composed , which are coated over one another in such a manner , that they may be parted into very thin and subtle Plates , such as Sea-shells of that kind are made up of .
But it was objected , that in those Beds where these Shells are found , generally speaking , most of one sort are found together , from whence it has been concluded that they are first formed in those Beds where they are found .
Whereas he pretends that this proceeds only from the Motion into which the Waters were put during the Deluge ; it being well known that if Egg-shells , Straws , Pebbles , Shells and several other dissimilar substances be put into a great quantity of Water , and this Water be afterwards moved violently and irregularly , those dissimilar Bodies will after a great many Shocks and impediments , upon the settling of the Water , subside according to their Figure pretty nearly together , and consequently will be thrown into great Heaps , some here , some there , according to that determination which the rolling of the Waters gave them .
The Places where these several Substances are thus separately found , are as he thinks invincible Arguments in proof of his Opinion .
The Soil of Malta is Marl , which is a natural Balsam for the Glossopetrae , that otherwise would have been soon wasted in loose Sand .
Besides , Malta lies low if compared with the Mountains of Sicily , so that it is no wonder that Sharks Teeth , which are heavy Bodies , should first subside , and consequently be found there in great quantities , whereas with all his diligence , Signior Scilla could never find but five upon the Sicilian Mountains , and those extremely thin , and without any Osseous Matter within them , but filled with a light and subtle Matter ; tho ' he does not question but in time he may be able to find , at the foot of these Hills , some Glossopetrae which may equal those of Malta .
And this , according to him , is the Reason why in Malta it self , the Echini and Echinitae are chiefly found upon the strand and above ground in view , all round the Island ; for they are both lighter than the Glossopetrae , and by reason of their Figure would more easily float and be buoyed up upon the Water , whereas the Glossopetrae being both specifically heavier , and of a closer contexture of parts , sunk deeper into the Earth .
But if there were no other Argument , the situation of the Glossopetrae in their Beds from whence they are dug , puts their Original out of controversy : Middling ones here , small ones there , great ones in a third place , without any sort of order and regularity : Some with their Roots uppermost , others directly downwards , others across : vast numbers broken , every one with a different Inclination , all plainly proving how they first came thither , since had they grown there at first , their Roots would have been all downwards , unless we should frame to our selves a different Notion to the Production of Glossopetrae , from any thing else in Nature that is generated and increased from some one fixed Seminal Principle .
And , besides , were there such a seminal Principle , it is not likely that it should be common to Glossopetrae and Shells too ; and yet Shells of all sorts , and in all positions are very often found in the Clay amongst these Glossopetrae .
It is objected however , that the Glossopetrae may be easily taken out of their Beds by their Sides , or at the Point ; whereas at the Base they adhere very closely , from which there often comes forth a plain Root , which is oftentimes longer than the Glossopetra it self .
This , says .
Signior Scilla is a plain proof of my Assertion .
For that Root is not made by Nature to suck out [ or rather convey ] any nutritive juice into the Glossopetra from the Mud , but from the Jaw of the Shark where it originally grew .
It was no wonder therefore that their sides and point , which are naturally very hard and smooth , did not stick so firmly to the Mud , or Stone wherein it was lodged ; but it would have been a wonder if the Root , which in all Sharks Teeth is very spongious and very porous , had not been filled with liquid Mud , that would easily have fixed it in its Bed , when it once began to harden .
And accordingly he appeals to all that ever compared Sharks Teeth and these Glossopetrae together , if they be not exactly like , some hard , some soft , some incrustated towards the point , some quite thro ' ; with every one a spongious Root , where they are inserted into their proper Muscle .
His Adversary had asked , Why the Black and Ash coloured Conchae and Turbens , are only found in the Chalk and Clay , and not the White ones which are dug out from among the Rocks ?
To which he answers , That those which are found in the Chalk and Clay , are not true Turbens or Conchae , but Stones formed like them : Whereas those that are found in Rocks are real Shells , which are enclosed and so preserved in the Rocks .
One Turbinites which his Adversary had sent to him , was a clear Evidence of this Matter .
For it was molded within a Spiral Shell , which turned into it self , as all the turbinated Kind constantly do , the inner Twirls of which Shell were preserved entire amidst the lapideous matter , when the outward ones had been quite worn off ; from whence he positively concludes that all these formed Stones , which seem to resemble Testaceous Animals of the turbinated and bivalvous kinds , were actually cast in the real Shells of those Animals , and were never in another form besides that in which we now see them .
But it is objected , Glossopetrae are natural Chrystallizations of Salt ; to which he makes this reply : That then the whole substance would be all of a piece .
Salt would be Salt as well within as without ; a Granite and a Topaz is a Granite and a Topaz throughout : Diamonds and Rubies are Diamonds and Rubies all over : they are aggregates of similar Particles which compose the whole Mass , be it greater , or be it less ; whereas these Glossopetrae ( c ) like all other Vegetables , are made up of various and dissimilar Corpuscles , put together in such a manner , as is peculiarly subservient to the end for which they were made .
Accordingly the Cortex is of one Substance , and the Medulla of another , and that lodged in proper Cells , with a Root distinct from them both ; ( d ) .
Besides , says he , Nature sometimes produces monstrous and defective things .
An Animal sometimes wants a Limb , a Tree is without some principal Branches , a Fruit may want some of its chiefest parts , Yet still we may observe that Nature supplies and covers that defect with a Skin , or Bark , or Rind , so that it never appears torn off or rent to the naked Eye , as it would , if it were torn off by a Hand , or cut off with a Knife .
This is Natures constant course ; which evidently shows that the Lusus Naturae , ( as these are erroneously called ) were never produced in the Earth ; since all the bruises and fractures , which they have met with , are apparent without any disguise to hide them , as Nature always employs to hide the Effects of her own irregular Productions .
He argues likewise from the Beds in which they are found , wherein , Gravel , Clay , Teeth , Bones , Shells of all sorts lay confused in one Mass .
As also from the impressions which they leave behind them in the Marl , even to the minutest Lines and Craks in the Tooth , which appear exactly in both , like an Impression upon Wax , and the engraving on the Seal which made it .
The Apophysis also , or Processes in the Glossopetrae demonstrate their Original , were there nothing else ; since they exactly answer to those in Sharks Teeth , whereby every Tooth is inserted into his Neighbour in the living Animal ; with those parts porous , and those spongious that are so in the Tooth of the Fish .
Nay whereas Sharks Teeth are mortissed into one another ~a manner , that a man may easily tell which belongs to which side , which lie near the Throat , which near the Snout , which lie to the Right , and which to the Left .
And whereas in a Sharks Jaw , the Teeth on the Left Side will not fit on the Right , nor those above serve below ; so that upon seeing a Tooth , one may tell which Side , and what Jaw it belongs to : He has observed every one of these things in his Glossopetrae , which punctually answer in every part to the several ranks of the Teeth of living Sharks .
His Cuts at the end of his Book , which are very beautiful , make these Arguments of his , very convincing .
He has drawn a piece of Marl , wherein a Glossopetra , a Lapis Judaicus ( e ) , a piece of a Scallop-shell that would part into Lamellae like the Sea-shells of that kind , and a rotten peice of Bone lie all confusedly by one another .
He produces the Crust of an Echinus Spatagus lying in its Bed of Marl , which within was filled with Marl , and encrusted with it without .
This Shell meeting with an accidental pressure , was cracked ; these cracks do clearly show that it was an original Shell , and also the Reason how it came to be so cracked ; since thereby it appears that the Shell yielded as far as the enclosed Marl would give it leave .
And whereas it has been objected that Echini Spatagi are very rarely seen , and yet that great Numbers of this Species of Echinitae have been found in Malta : This to Signior Scilla is no objection at all , he himself having in less than an hours time taken them up by hundreds in the Port of Messina .
He produces an Echinites whereon appeared the five Lines from one common Centre , within which , upon breaking it , he found five correspondent Cells , and the place for the Mouth exactly agreeing to an Echinus taken out of the Sea .
He produces likewise part of a Jaw-bone of a Dog Fish lying in a Bed of Stone , with three Teeth in it : Tis partly rotten , partly sound ; porous with Channels for the Marrow in the midst , covered without with a hard osseous Crust , peculiar to the cartilagineous kind : Upon the same Bed there are also little Shells , and many round Knobs proper to that sort of Dog-Fish , ( f ) which seem to be beginning Teeth , called by the Maltesi , Serpents Eyes .
From these Observations our Author proceeds to philosophize upon the Phenomenon ; and taking it for granted that these Land-shells are the remains of a Deluge , he enquires into the contexture of that Soil wherein they are chiefly found .
His Habitation being at Messina , gave him better opportunities to make his enquiries there : In pursuance of which he observes that the Mountains near that City consist of Strata , which lie in this Order , first Gravel , then middling Sand , then very fine Sand : That the Lines described by these Strata , are all Horizontal , with a small declivity towards the Sea ; which declivity going thro ' all the Strata , proceeds in his opinion from the original inclination of the Floor or Basis on which these Strata were at first laid : That after three Layers of Sand and Gravel of different finenesses , come three other Layers in the same Order with the former ; first Gravel , then coarser , then finer Sand again , and so on several times one after another .
This he supposes to have proceeded from repeated Tides : From whence he concludes , that the Water coming with great violence , sustained whatsoever came in its way ; but upon its going off , the force abating , it let fall the terrestrial matter that subsided according to its specific Gravity ; and that these repeated flowings and ebbings of the Water happened during some one very great Inundation , the Time whereof , or its Cause , he does not determine .
He observes that these Shells are not found certainly in such or such particular places , but casually some here , some there , just as the rolling of the Waters happened to carry them , and accordingly they subsided , where-ever the strength of the Waters Motion , by which they were buoyed up , abated .
Gg2 He He says that all the Hills about Messina are not made up of such loose Sand , some consisting of a hard Rock , others of a white Tophus , or a dirty Marl ; in all which one may observe either the former Order of the Strata , or horizontal Lines of different Bodies and different Colours .
He observes that the Land-Shells differ in hardness and consistency according to the Matter in which they lie : An Echinus petrified in a Tophus , is not so hard as another Echinus petrified in a Rock ; so that according to the disposition of the ambient Matter , they acquired a greater or a less degree of hardness ; and in some they continued just as they were at first ; all which he urges to show , that these Land-shells could not be Petrifactions made in Water , according to the common Notion of the Word .
Having thus laid down his Hypothesis , he subjoins several of his own Observations ; which ( as he supposes ) put this Question beyond Dispute .
I. He observes , that there are no Sharks Teeth found any where at Land but in Malta ; the Glossopetrae in other places are small , or light the Cortices of large ones .
This he resolves into specific Gravity , and the different make of Sharks Teeth , of which some are quite hard , others only cortically so ; these last are filled with a mucilaginous juice ; such were those three that he found upon the Hills near Messina , which were filled with fine soft Marl , instead of that Mucilage wherewith they had been naturally replenished .
II .
He broke great Numbers of petrified Echini , and other Bodies naturally hollow , which were filled only with such Marl as that they lay in , or else fragments of Shells , Sand , Pebbles , Spines of the Hystrix Marinus , and such like stuff .
And he affirms that he nor no Body else did ever see within these Shells any thing but what might get in at the Mouths of the Echini ; which shows , that after the Membranes which closed the Mouths of the Echini were worn , thro ' the Chalk , and other little Bodies mingled with it , got in and filled the Cavity , now void by the wearing away of the Body of the Shell-Fish it self .
III .
He examined the petrified Vertebres of the Spines of Fishes , which he found exactly to correspond in their several Articulations both into each other , and into the Ribs which issue from them , with real Vertebres of Fishes found at Sea .
IV .
He examins some testaceous Bodies , that he found in Calabria , which exactly answer to the Dentales of Aldrovandus , and according to him , are found only in hollow Stones at the bottom of the Sea , unless they are at any time thrown upon the Shore by great Waves .
V. He produces the Claw of a Sea-Crab found in the Hills near Messina , with a piece of a Scallop-Shell clutched within it .
VI .
Also a Stone in which pieces of Coral , and all manner of Shells were disorderly petrified , as chance had laid them , and in some the Animal it self petrified within , so that one might discern the small interior Membranes proper to each Shell .
Others in the same Bed , were full of the Matter in which they lay : others half full of a pellucid Flour like Crystal ; others again had a sediment of turbid Matter ; all which Spars and Sediments , let the position of the Shell , which contained them , have been what it would , gravitated at first exactly towards the lowest part of the Shell , as it was there situated ; which plainly shows that they once were fluid , and carried thither by their own weight .
VII .
He produces pieces of petrified Coral , which tho ' they had lost their Red Colour on the outside , yet had a reddish tincture within , as all that Species of Coral has ; from whence he concludes , ( 1 .
) That Time had begun to destroy them .
( 2 .
) That the Accidents of the place rather concurred to their Destruction than Generation .
VIII .
As also pieces of Fistulous Coral , which tho ' they were broken in the Tophus , yet might be put together just as they were naturally joined together in the Sea .
IX .
Together with some of the Jointed Coral of Imperati , which resembles the Shank-bones of Animals ; this also jointed right , tho ' the pieces were found apart in the Tophus .
X. He compared some of the Echini Spinis longissimis of Aldrovandus , with the Shells of those Echini found at Messina , and in Malta ; and he found them to agree exactly .
He observed the same situations and dimensions of the Mammillae , and the Spines which turn upon them , as upon a Pivot ; and when broken , the same Ligatures of every part of the Crust , which covers the Animal .
XI .
He produces one Echinus , bruised in the Tophus in which it lay , wherein after he had washed off the tophaceous particles that it was filled with , he found several of the Spines that had formerly been upon the Crust : As also a Spatagus , with the Prickles on , which he found in a Valley in Calabria .
He concludes at last with taking notice , that all the Echini , or other Land-shells , that he had found bruised upon the Calabrian or Messinese Hills , or had been brought to him from Malta , were bruised by a perpendicular pressure : This he explains thus ; The Crust of all Echini has two Centers , one directly opposite to the other ; so that if they happened to lie in the liquid Mud , in such a manner , as that the lowest Center was perpendicular to the Horizon , they were bruised , so as not to lose their circular Figure ; only they were much compressed .
If they lay on one side , they were squeezed out of that shape , and the Membranes of the Ligatures parted from each other variously , according to the variety of the situation of these Shells in the Mud at that time .
All which plainly shows , that as the Mud dried , the super-incumbent Weight pressed perpendicularly upon the enclosed Bodies , which were then compressed together in that posture they then happened to lie in : And were more or less compressed , according as the Mud got into their Cavities in greater or lesser quantities , and as it dried , propped them up on the inside against the pressure of the Matter in which they lay Short Notes upon the foregoing Account ; by a Fellow of the Royal Society .
( a ) page .
4 .
MR Willughby says the Sargus has none of these round Teeth , which he calls tubercula Ossea , and makes that one of the Characteristicks to distinguish it from the Sparus , and Scarus , and other Fishes of that Tribe .
However I retain the word , because Scilla 's word is Sargo ; and perhaps Willughby 's Sargus may not be Scilla 's Sargo , or , which is more probable , he might overlook that particularity in that Fish which he dissected .
( b ) ibid. By these testaceous Substances , which he here speaks of , he means the Crusts of the Echini , of which he has given us so many curious Designs in the annexed Figures .
He seems to think that the Echini Marini are of the testaceous Kind , as also several very great Naturalists have thought before him .
Gesner , after Aristotle , in his Nomenclator Animantium Aquatilium , ranges them with the Conchae , Cochleae , Scallops , Purpurae purae , and the rest of the testaceous ribe ; and yet he owns that Rondeletius reckoned them among the Crustaceous Kind , and accordingly discoursed of them after Crabs and Lobsters , just before he treated of those Animals , which are confessedly testaceous ; wherein he followed Pliny , who was of the same Opinion before him .
And they certainly were in the right , tho ' for want of stating the true difference between a Crust and a Shell properly so called , the due place which the Echini ought to hold in a Natural History of Shellfish , as the word may comprehend both Kinds , has never yet , that I know of , been ascertained .
A Shell properly is such a hard Substance , as covers an entire Animal , or at least one whole side , without Joints or Ligatures , as in Buccina , Purpurae , Murices , Oysters , Scallops , Cockles , and the like .
A Crust is such a hard Substance as covers only one particular Joint of the enclosed Animal , so that in the whole Crustaceous Tribe there are as many Shells upon every Animal , ( if I may be allowed to use that word in a larger sense ) as there are Joints in that Animal .
This is plain in Crabs , Lobsters , Cray-fish , and shrimps ; for which Reason Crustaceous Animals may truly be called Multi-testaceous , and the other simply testaceous , or bi-testaceous .
And therefore as in Scaly Fishes , every Scale has a correspondent Muscle , to which , by a particular Tendon it is annexed ; so all Crustaceous Animals have particular Muscles , which are inserted into every Crust ; all which Crusts are also connected each to the other by common Membranes , which here are in a more especial manner necessary , because they do not lie imbricatim upon one another as Scales do .
As plain as this seems to be , Aristotles definitions of Crustaceous and Testaceous Animals , or , ( as he calls them ) ~ and ~ have been universsally versally acquiesced in ; and they being insufficient have caused this whole matter , ( by the generality of Naturalists , even in this Age , ) to be misunderstood .
( 1 .
) Crustaceous Animals , ( ~ ) says Aristotle , are soft within and hard without , but whose covering is not apt to be parted by contufions , tho ' one part of it may easily be torn from the other : ( So I understand his ~ ~~ ~ ) .
( 2 .
) Testaceous Animals ( ~ ~ ) are soft within and hard without , whose covering may be bruised or broken to pieces , tho ' its parts are not liable to be torn from each other ) ~~~ ~~~ ~ .
) The Consequences which Aristotle puts into his Definition as Characteristicks , necessarily arise from the Doctrine already delivered .
For when that Shell is but one , as in the whole testaceous kind , it may be bruised , or it may be broken , according as it is more or less brittle , but torn asunder it can never be .
Whereas in the whole crustaceous kind , the coverings which are over every several part , as Claws , Feet , Back , Belly , and Tail in Lobsters , are joined each to other by Membranes , which , tho ' tough , may be torn asunder , when the particular Crusts , here as well as in the testaceous kind , cannot .
According to this Distinction it is plain , that Echini are truly Crustaceous Animals , for they move upon their Spines , which demonstrates that their Covering is ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ moved by parts ; and indeed every Spine is rivetted into its proper Crust , which also by consequence must have its peculiar Muscle , that guides the motion of the Spine , whereby the Animal rolls about which way soever it pleases .
It being peculiar to this Tribe of Animals alone , for any thing yet known to the contrary , that its progressive motion is by turning or rolling upon its Spines , and not walking as all Animals , that have Feet , properly do .
Which Motion of theirs ( if we ( 3 .
) may believe Monsieur Menage ) has given occasion to an old French Proverb , a la venue des Coquecigrues , i. e. when Echini walk , by which they would intimate , that that particular thing concerning which it is made use of , shall never come to pass .
Besides , it is plain by ocular Inspection , that all the Crusts of these Animals are united by Membranes , as they are in Crabs and Lobsters .
Scilla 's Draughts , some whereof are here annexed , put this Matter out of doubt ; from which it evidently appears , that Echini are properly crustaceous Animals in the strictest acceptance of the word .
( c ) page .
188 .
By Vegetables he means Substances , which increase from praeexistent Seed , as all Plants and Animals properly do .
( d ) page .
189 .
This will be fully understood , if one consults Steno 's Anatomy of a Sharks-Head , which is annexed to his Elementorum Myologiae Specimen .
( e ) page .
190 .
These Lapides Judaici , which Signior Scilla often calls Bastoncini di San Paolo , or St. Paul 's Batoons , are Spines of some Species of Echini , of which he gives the Figures , which are not found upon our Shores , and are ( perhaps ) of the Pelagian Tribe .
( 3 .
) Dictionnaire Etymologique .
v. Coquecigrue .
( f ) page .
191 .
Signior Scilla calls this Dog-Fish , Pesce Vacca ( the Cow-Fish .
) It being described by no Naturalist ( that I know off ) before him , its hereunto annexed from our Authors Draughts , some of which , for their great exactness and curiosity , it was thought fit to Copy .
Vide Fig. An Explication of the said Figures in the Plate , with further Remarks thereon , By another Fellow of the Royal Society .
Fig. 1 .
THE Head of the Pesce Vacca , drawn from the Life , with the Teeth in both Jaws .
It seems to be of the long cartilagineous kind , akin to the Dogs or Hound Fishes .
Fig. 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 .
The Teeth of the same out of their Sockets .
These are found petrified in Beds up and down the Island of Malta , with those of Dog-fishes , Sharks , Pesce Aquila , &amp;c. Fig. 7 .
A Jaw of a Fish called Dentex , with the round grinders ; the like Dentes Molares are observed and drawn by the Author in the Jaws of other Fishes , as the Aurata and Sargus , with several Bufonitae lying by them .
These convex osseous Tubercules are found commonly petrified in Malta , and are called there Serpent 's Eyes They are of the same kind with our English Bufonites or Toadstones , which Dr. Merret first declared to be the round Jaw Teeth of the Lupus Marinus or Wolf Fish of Schonfeld .
See Mr. Rays Travels , p. 321 .
these Bufonitae are properly called by Mr. Lbwyd , Ichthyodontes Scutellati .
Philosoph. Transact. N. 200 .
p. 751 .
Fig. 19 .
Fig. 8 .
The petrified Teeth of Dog-Fishes and Sharks , ( called Glossopetrae ) lying in several postures and situations in their Beds of Earth .
These , with all the foregoing , may be reduced to Mr. Lhwyd 's Classis of Ichthyodontes .
Fig. 9 .
A Sea Urchin , with long Prickles , Hystrix Spinis longissimis Imperati .
The Fishermen of Sicily often brought it alive to the Author .
The Spines break off , and are easily disjointed .
Of the Echinites the Author hath drawn above 18 Species .
Fig. 10 .
A Sea Urchin found petrifi 'd ( Echinites ) in white Stone , on the Rocks and Hills near Messina , with some stony Spines or Prickles lying by it ; The Teats or Pivots ( on which they have been inserted ) lie naked and broken off .
See Mr. Ray 's three Physico Theological Discourses , Tab. 3 .
page .
162 , 163 .
Fig. 11 .
A mass of petrifi 'd Sea Urchins , one entire , another bruised , with the stony Prickles broken off , and lying by in the same Bed ; there may be as many Species of this sort of figured Stones , or petrifi 'd Spines , as there are of the Echini Marini themselves ; some short , thick , roundish , and cannulated ( as the Lapis Judaicus ) other long , slender , tuberculated , and ragged ( as St. Paul 's Batoons in Malta ) all belonging to the several Echinitae and Ombriae .
See the Riccio Marino in Pietra , Imperati Istor .
Natural .
Venet .
edit .
1672 .
p. 586 .
and his Chapter dell Pietre Giudaiche , page .
575 .
576 .
These may come within the Classis of the Spondylites .
Fig. 12 , 13 .
Petrifi 'd Vertebres with their Articulations and Insertions , with the Ribs , See Fig. 13 .
These may be reduced to Mr. Lhwyd 's Tribe of Ichthyospondyli ; for Stones resembling Vertebres , and other Bones of Fishes , See Mr. Ray 's Travels , in the Preface , and p. 116 , 294 .
The Entrochi and Asteriae come under this division .
Fig. 14 .
Petrifi 'd Dentalia and Cochlites found lying in the same Bed , in the Rocky Mountains of Calabria .
N. B. That Dr. Robert Hooke published some Observations upon this Subject in his Micrographia , p. 109 , 110 , 111 , 112 .
and afterwards discoursed of it at large in several of his public Lectures in Gresham College ( which the Public have long expected , and still desire from him ) before Steno , Scilla , and Boccone , communicated their curious Observations to the World .
See Philosoph. Transact. N. 32 .
page .
628 .
also N. 72 .
page .
2186 to page .
2190 .
See M. Denis his Memoirs and Conferences , ( printed with the Journaux des Scavans ) An. 1672 .
Mem. I. Also the Italian Giornate di Literati Ephem .
5 .
of the same year .
See Dr. Hook 's Lecture upon Springs page .
48,49 , 50 .
But above all , Justice is to be done to that Noble Natural Philosopher Fabius Columna , who hath two admirable Discourses upon the several parts of Aquatic and Terrestrial Animals , as also of Plants , which he himself observed to be dug up in the Mountains of Andria , Apulia , and other Places ; and thereupon remarks how they were left there by the General Flood ; why in some places they remain uncorrupted , in others wasted , and mouldred , in others only by their impressed Figures , and exact Forms .
That they all answer in every delineation , and every part the very Bodies they resemble , and are truly the very same Species .
See Columna in his Observe .
Aquat .
&amp; Terrestr .
Cap. 21 .
page .
43 to page .
55 .
Also de Purpura , Dissertat .
de Glossopetris , page .
31 to page .
39 .
4to Rome impress 1616 .

