IV .
An Extract of a Letter from Bernard Connor , M. D. to Sir Charles Walgrave , Published in French at Paris : Giving an Account of an Extraordinary Humane Sceleton , whose Vertebrae of the Back , the Ribs , and several Bones down to the Os Sacrum , were all firmly united into one solid Bone , without Joynting or Cartilage .
SIR , HAving lately seen part of an Human Scleton , all the Bones whereof were so united as to make but one continued Bone without Articulation , I thought it might be acceptable to the Curious to be presented with some Account thereof .
This was not an entire Sceleton , consisting only of the Os Ilium , the Os Sacrum , the five Vertebrae of the Loins , ten of the Back , five entire Ribs on the right side , and three on the left ; the bottoms or ends of the other were closely united to the transverse Apophyses of their Vertebrae .
The Vertebrae of the Neck , the Claviculae and Sternum were wanting .
All these Bones , which Naturally are 38 , each separate and distinct from another , were here so straightly and intimately joined , their Ligaments perfectly Bony , and their Articulations so effaced , that they really made but one uniform continuous Bone ; so that it was as easy to break one of the Vertebrae into two , as to disjoint or separate it from the other Vertebrae , or the Ribs , or the Os Sacrum from those of the Ilia .
Nor could I observe any greater distinction between all these Bones than is usually seen in Adult Persons between the Os Pubis , the Ischion , and Ilium , which are but one entire Bony Substance .
The Roots of all the Ribs made but one equal , smooth , and plain Superficies with the Vertebrae and their Apophyses .
The Oblique Apophyses of all the Vertebrae were so confounded and lost , that it was not possible to observe any marks of them .
The Cartilagineous edge of the Vertebrae themselves was turned to perfect Bone .
In short , they were as entire as a Sceleton cut out of the same Piece of Wood by a Carver would be .
Being willing to see if these Vertebrae were united throughout their whole Diameter , or at the edges only , I sawed two of them asunder at the Commissure , and found this uniting did not enter above two Lines deep , and that afterwards their middles were separated as they usually are , and touched each other only at the edges , which was raised up a little above the middle part .
On the left side at half a fingers breadth from the Vertebrae , two Ribs were joined together for the space of an Inch , and afterward run separated and parallel like the rest , to the Sternum .
The Figure of this Trunk was crooked , making part of a Circle , the Spinae making the Convex , and the inside of the Vertebrae the Concave part of this Segment .
If the other Vertebrae of the Back and Neck had been preserved , and had bent in the same Curve , they would have made near the half of a Circle .
The direction of the Ribs was unnatural , for instead of terminating at the Sternum in Parallel Semicircles nearly Horizontal , their Extremities where they reached the Sternum , dipped so much down toward the Hypogastrum , as to touch the sides of the Ossa Ilium .
This Trunk had been found in some Church-yard or Charnel-House , as appeared by its dark red Colour and dryness , and seemed to be of a grown Person , the Bones being of a Proportion and Thickness equal to those of Old Men .
The Vertebrae of the Loins were larger than those of the Back , as they Naturally are ; there was no unnatural bunching out , their joining together very regular , no one Vertebra standing out beyond the other , either before , behind , or on the sides .
The Cavity for the Spinal Marrow had no fault but its bending Figure .
The Bones of the Os Pubis were separated as usually .
The Socket or Cavity of the last Bastard Rib on the right side being smooth and polished , seemed as if that Rib had not been so firmly united as the rest .
In the extremity of the Ribs next the Sternum , the usual Cavities for the Cartilages to move in , were observable , which as it seems by this were not Bony , nor continuous with the Ribs .
It was a surprising sight to see the sport of Nature in the Fabric and hardening of these Bones , which Naturally move upon one another , are separated by Cartilages , and held together only by Cords and Ligaments , and chiefly that the Ribs should be thus joined with the rest , which are perpetually raised in Respiration , and whose Motion is upon the Vertebrae as its Centre ; and we see motion hinders the lips of a Wound from closing , and a broken Bone from uniting .
Fontanus reports it as a very strange thing , that he once happened to see three Ribs joined together .
And Pausanias makes mention of one Protophanes , in whose dead Body all the true Ribs were found to be united : But it is much more extraordinary to find all the Ribs and Vertebrae but one continued Bone , than to find the Ribs joined , for they may be said to move all alike , and still parallel to each other ; so that they being always kept at the same distance , need but increase and grow broader to meet and unite .
Thus far I have endeavoured to give our Author 's sense almost Verbatim , it being mostly matter of Observation , but the remainder of the Letter being only deductions and Reasonings thereon , I shall only give a short extract It is hard to give a Mechanical Reason of this so secret and hidden a matter ; though it is really as certain it must depend upon some Physical Cause ; and to offer at some reasonable Conjecture , the Author examines whether these Bones were thus united while the Faetus was in the Mother 's Womb while the Person was living , or after its Death in the Ground : Though the two last Opinions appear most likely to some Persons , yet he allows neither of them ; for as to the Earth , it is either pure and Elementary , ot impregnated with some Principle capable to produce the Effect .
Pure Earth being made up only of fryable , porous , irregular Particles , can but suck up the superficial Moisture of the Ligaments of this Trunk , otherwise by Evaporation in the Sun Ligaments and Cartilages would become Bony ; and the Earth is never so stiptique as to procure so intimate an Union .
If you will say , the Earth was impregnated with some Principle , it must be either Water , Sulphur , or Salt ; neither of which seem proper to cement Bones : All know that Water and Sulphur are so far from hardening Ligaments , that they rather soften and relax by their slippery and fluid Particles .
Nor does he think Alkali 's or Acids are capable to turn to Bone .
First , Alkali 's being bristly , stiff , and inflexible , are properer to separate than unite ; as is seen by putting a piece of a Ligament into any Alkaline Salt .
And Secondly , Acids are most proper to break the Texture , and divide even the hardest Bodies , and upon Experiment Cartilages are dissolved in them ; besides , could this Effect have been produced in the Earth , why was not the whole Body turned to Bone ?
Our Author gives several other Reasons for his rejecting this Opinion , touching upon the manner of Petrifaction , which he says , is by the little Acid Aculei , which being in a fluid state , insinuate themselves into and stop up the Pores of the petrified Bodies , rendering them more compact .
He attempts the cause of the crooked and bending shape of his Sceleton ; and having rejected several , as a Hurt or Blow , the Rickets , Old Age , &amp;c. he concludes it must proceed from the first Formation of the Faetus in the Womb , from the Eggs not having sufficient room , or being accidentally pressed by some abcess in the Womb or elsewhere , so that the Carima of the Back-bone instead of running strait was bent into a Circle , and kept the same Figure when at full growth that these Bones had taken when soft and tender .
Having given this Reason for the crookedness of the Back-bone , he thence deduces the situation of the rest , as the drawing down of the Ribs and Sternum to the Ossa Ilium : And from these Vertebrae and other Bones being thus pressed upon each other , and so rendred unmoved , he shows the cause of their being united into one Bone , the Pores of such tender Parts being easily stopped , so that the Blood and other Humours could not pass , and upon that Account the Cartilages of the Vertebrae becoming dry , united into one piece .
By the same Reason the Ribs being pressed against the Vertebrae for several Months , and without Motion in the Womb , could receive and admit little or no Moisture between them , whence their Cartilages became hard and united , and in time Bony , as several other Bones of the Body do though they were but Gristles when in the Womb .
He proceeds to make some Remarks upon his Sceleton , as that necessarily the Body of this Person must have been immovable , that he could neither bend nor stretch himself out , rise up nor lye down , nor turn upon his Side , having only the Head , Feet , and Hands moveable .
The great difficulty seeming to be in the Respiration , how that could be performed when the Ribs were thus immovable : He endeavours to obviate this by observing , first , how little motion of the Breast is necessary to continue the motion of the Blood through the Lungs , as is visible in Hysteric Fits , &amp;c. Again , the Ribs of his Sceleton , though fixed at the centre , might yet be moved at the ends , and so the Thorax enlarged by a much less strength than that of the Muscles used for that purpose ; besides the Diaphragm , the chief Organ of Respiration in this Subject , was free in its acting ; and it is likely this Person breathed very short , the quickness of the Returns supplying the defect of a large draught of Air at once .
He adds , that possibly the Foramen Ovale might continue open , and that by it and the Arterial Canalis the Blood might pass from the Cava to the Aorta , but a part of it passing through the Lungs : He confims this by an Observation he lately made in a Girl of four or five Years old , in whom the Foramen Ovale was but half closed up , and in the form of a Crescent .
To this our Author adds another Observation of the Bones of the Thigh and Leg growing together in an Adult Person , the place of their joining being much more solid than any other Part .
These Bones were so bent at the Knee , as to make an acute Angle , yet were they without any Exostosis , Rottenness , Fracture , or unnatural Figure .
It is more surprising to find the Knee , whose motion is free and large , to be thus united , than that of the Ribs of the Sceleton , whose motion is obscure , and scarce sensible .
Some thought this might proceed from an Ulcer in the Knee , which our Author will no ways grant , an Ulcerous Matter being not fit for the joining of Bones together ; and adds the Observation of a Person with an Ulcer in the Knee , which made such havoc , that the Thigh and Leg hung together but by the Skin .
These Bones seemed too sound to suppose the Person had a Wooden Leg , which by continual Kneeling upon might make the Bones unite ; besides , this Accident is no more likely to befall a Person using a Wooden Leg , than any other , since the Musculi flexores &amp; extensores Tibiae act alternately in each step , which is sufficient to hinder the growing together of the Joint .
From this Observation our Author confirms what he had before advanced of the Bones being united in the Womb , concluding that this proceeded from the Knee of the Faetus being too much bent and pressed against the Thigh-bone , and so united as he had explained that of the Back-bone and Ribs .
He concludes all with granting , that some Persons of an hot Temperament have their Aorta near the Heart Bony , the Sinus 's of the Brain , or the like ; that some Cartilages and Ligaments become Bony in very old Men , that some parts of the Body may have acquired some degree of Bonyness , which afterwards become more solid by drying in the Earth : Nevertheless he is not satisfied how his Subjects should become Bony in some and not in other Parts , except it be granted that the Fibres of some Parts were from their first formation in the Womb more united than others , which afterwards gave occasion to their Ossification .
Fig. I. Represents the Sceleton with the Vertebrae of the Back and Ribs united .
aaa a , bbb b , c c. The Vertebrae of the Neck , Back , and Ossa Illium , all joined together .
ddd d. Several of the Ribs united to the Back-bone .
Fig. II .
The Thigh and Leg-Bones united together at the Knee .
gg g. The place where the Os Femoris and Tibiae were united .
~ Fig:1 B Fig:3 aa F e b b Fig : page :14 b b C c AE b f d d d Fig : 2 .
d a c g g cg a O eA a Philosophical Transactions .
n:o 215 .
E E WL E C LGMM l S E E XB K D O++ +

