I. A Discourse concerning the Methods of Approximation in the Extraction of Surd Roots .
By John Wallis , S. T. D. and Savilian Professor of Geometry at Oxford .
THE several Methods of Approximation , which have been mentioned of late Years , for Extracting the Roots of Simple or Affected Equations , gives me occasion of saying somewhat of that Subject .
It is agreed by all , ( and , I think , demonstrated by the Greeks long ago ) that if a Number proposed be not a true Square , it is in vain for to hope for a just Quadratick Root thereof , explicable by Rational Numbers , Integers , or Fracted .
And therefore , in such cases , we must content our selves with Approximations ( somewhat near the truth ) without pretending to Accuracy .
And so , for the Cubick Root , of what is not a perfect Cube .
And the like for Superior Powers .
Now the Ancients ( being aware of this ) had their Methods of Approximation in such cases ; whereof some have been derived down even to this day .
Of which we shall speak more anon .
But since the Methods of Decimal Fractions ( as they are now wont to be called ) have come into Practice , it hath been usual to prosecute such Extractions ( beyond the place of Unites ) in the places of Decimal Parts to what Accuracy we please ; whereby the former Methods of Approaches have been ( not so much forgotten , as ) neglected .
Not that if such Approaches by Decimals were always the most speedy , or the most exact ; ( for no Man doubts but that ~ is a more Simple , and more Intelligible Notation of that Quantity , than 0.125 , or 125/ 1000 : And 1/ 3 , not only a more Brief , but a more Accurate designation of the Square Root of 1/ 3 , than 0.333333 , &amp;c. ) But , because Fractions reduced to the Decimal form , are more convenient for subsequent Operations , when there is occasion for a further Progress .
Mr. Newton 's Method of Approximation for the Extracting Roots , even of Affected Equations , I have given some Account count of in my English Algebra ; and somewhat more fully in the Latin Edition : where I give an Account also of Mr. Raphson 's Method ; which I need not here repeat , because it is to be seen there .
Since which time , Monsieur De L'agny hath published his Method of Approximation , principally for single Equations , or Extracting the Root of a single Power .
And Mr. Halley hath since improved this Method , with a further Advantage ; especially as to Affected Equations .
But I need not repeat either of them , because they are both published .
That of De L'agny in a Treatise by it self ; and that of Mr. Halley , in the Philos. Transact. Numb. 210 , for the Month of May , 1694 .
These may all , or any of them , be of good use ( each in their own way ) for making more speedy Approaches , and by greater Leaps , in many cases , than Vieta 's Method ( prosecuting the Extraction in Decimal Parts ) pursued and improved by Mr. Oughtred and Mr. Harriot of our own , and by others abroad ; especially as to Simple Equations , if we suppose such Extractions to be pursued to the full extent .
As for instance , if we would Extract the Root of an imperfect Sursolid , ( or a Power of five Dimensions ) to have its Root true as far as the sixth place of Decimal Parts .
In order to this , we are to add ( or , suppose to be added ) six Punctations of Ciphers , ( or , six times five Ciphers , that is Thirty Ciphers ) beyond the place of Unites in the Number proposed .
If now we pursue the whole Operation to the utmost of those Thirty places , the Work would be long and tedious .
But if we make use of Mr. Oughtred 's Expedient , ( for Multiplication , Division , Extraction of Roots , and other like Operations , ) by neglecting so much of this long Process , as is afterward to be cut off and thrown away as useless , ( which , I think , is generally practised ) the Work will be much abbridged , and the Advantage of the other Methods much less considerable .
That is , If ( for ascertaining the sixth place of Decimal Parts ) we add six Ciphers ( instead of thirty ) and one or two more ( the better to secure what from the consequent places may in the Operation be transmitted hither ; ) and ~ sue the Operation thus far , neglecting the following place ( which are not likely to influence the Figure due to the sixth place of Decimal Parts of the Root sought : ) this long Process will be much shortned .
And if we further consider , what Preparative Operations are to be made in some of those other Methods , before we come to the prescribed Division for giving the Root desired ; the Advantage ( though considerable ) will not be so great as may at first be apprehended ; especially as to Affected Equations , in which the Parodical Powers have great Coefficients .
As will soon appear in Practice , if we come to apply them to particular cases .
But , without disparaging these Methods ( which are really considerable , and well worthy encouragement ) that which I here intend , is , to show the true Foundation of the Methods used by the Ancients , ( however since neglected ) and the just Improvement of them .
Which though Anciently scarce applied beyond the Quadratick , or perhaps the Cubick Root , ( for with the Higher Powers they did not much trouble themselves ) yet are equally applicable ( by due adjustments ) to the Superior Powers also .
I shall begin with the Square Root : For which the Ancient Method is to this purpose .
From the proposed Non-quadrate ( suppose N ) subtract ( in the usual manner ) the greatest Square in Integers therein contained ( suppose Aq .
) The remainder ( suppose B=2 AE + Eq ) is to be the Numerator of a Fraction , for designing the near value of E ( the remaining part of the Root sought A+E= ~N , ) whose Denominator or Divisor is to be 2A ( the double Root of the subtracted Square ) or 2A+1 ( that double Root increased by 1 ) the true value falling between these two ; sometime the one , sometime the other , being nearest to the true value .
But ( for avoiding of Negative Numbers ) the latter is commonly directed .
This Method Monsieur De L'agny affirms to be more than 200 Years old : And it is so ; for I find it in Lucas Pacciolus ( otherwise called Lucas de Burgo , or de Burgo Sancti Sepulchri ) Printed at Venice in the Year 1494 ( if not even sooner than so , for I find there have been several Editions of it .
) And how much older than so , I cannot tell : For he doth not deliver it as a new Invention of his own , but as a received Practice , and derived from the Moors or Arabs , from whom they had their Algorism , or Practice of Arithmetic by the Ten Numeral Figures now in use .
And it is continued down hitherto in Books of Practical Arithmetic in all Languages , which teach the Extraction of the Square Root , and ( therein ) this Method of Approximation , in case of a Non-quadrate .
The true ground of the Rule is this : Aq being ( by Construction ) the greatest Integer Square contained in N , it is evident that E must be less than 1 ; ( otherwise not Aq , but the Square of A+ 1 , or some greater than so , would be the greatest Integer Square contained in N. ) Now if the Remainder B=2 AE + Eq be divided by 2 A , the Result will be too great for E , ( the Divisor being too little ; for it should be 2A+ E , to make the Quotient E. ) But if ( to rectisie this ) we diminish the Quotient , by increasing the Divisor , adding 1 to it , it then becomes too little ; because the Divisor is now too big .
For ( E being less than 1 ) 2A+1 is more than 2A+ E ; and therefore too big .
As for instance ; If the Non-quadrate proposed be N= 5 , the greatest Integer Square therein contained is Aq =4 ( the Square of A= 2 : ) which being subtracted , leaves N-Aq =54=1=B=2AE+E q. Which divided by 2A= 4 , gives 1/ 4 : But divided by 2A+1=4+1= 5 , gives 1/ 5 .
That too great , and this too liitle for E. And therefore the true Root ( A +E=~ N ) is less than 2 1/ 4 = 2.25 , but greater than 2 1/ 5 = 2.2 : And this was Anciently thought an Approach near enough .
If this Approach be not now thought near enough , the same Process may be again repeated ; and that as oft as is thought necessary .
Take now for A , 2 1/ 5 = 2.2 , whose Square is 4.84 = Aq , ( now considered as an Integer in the second place of Decimal Parts .
) This subtracted from 5.00 , ( or , which is the same , 0.84 the excess of this Square above the former , from I which was then the remainder , ) leaves a new remainder B= 0.16 : which divided by 2A= 4.4 , gives.16/ 4.40 = 2/ 55 = 0.03636 + , too much .
But divided by 2A+1= 4.5 , it gives.16/ 4.50 = 8/ 225 = 0.03555 + , too little .
The true Value ( between these two ) being 2.236 proxime , whose Square is If this be not thought near enough , Substract this Square from 5.000000 : The Remainder B= 0.000304 , divided by 2A= 4.472 , or by 2A+1= 4.473 , gives ( either way ) 0 000068 - ; which added to A= 2.236 , makes 2.236068- , somewhat too big ; but 2.236067 + would be much more too little .
Which gives us the Square Root of 5 , adjusted to the sixth place of Decimal Parts , at three steps .
And by the same Method , if it be thought needful , we may proceed further .
It were easy to compound the Process of two or more steps into one , and give ( for the Rule ) the Result of such Composition .
Which would make it seem more Intricate and Mysterious , to amuse the Reader : But I choose to make it as plain as I can ( and therefore keep the several steps separate , ) that the Reader ( for his satisfaction ) may clearly see the true ground of the Process .
But of this enough .
Proceed we now to the Cubick Root .
For which ( consonant to the Quadratick ) the Rule is this : From the Non-Cubick proposed , ( suppose N , ) subtract the greatest Cube in Integers therein contained , ( suppose Ac : ) the remainder ( suppose B=3AqE+3AEq+E c , ) is to be the Numerator of a Fraction for designing the value of E , ( the remaining part of the Root sought A+E=~c N. ) To this Numerator , if ( for the Denominator or Divisor ) we subjoyn 3A q , the Result will certainly be too great for E , because the Divisor is too little : ( For it should be 3Aq+3AE+E q , to give the true value of E. ) If , for the Divisor , we take 3Aq+3A+ 1 , it will certainly be too little , because the Divisor is too great .
( For E , by construction , is less than 1 .
) It must therefore ( between these limits ) be more than this latter .
And therefore this latter Result being added to A , will give a Root whose Cube may be subtracted from the Non-Cubick proposed , in order to another step .
This Approach I find in Wingate 's Arithmetic , Published in the Year 1630 , and must therefore be at least so old ; how much older I cannot tell .
But if , for the Divisor , we take 3Aq+3 A , ( or even less than so ) the Result may be too great ; or ( in case B be small ) it may be too little , ( and oft is so .
) Which comes to pass from hence ; because E ( by Construction ) is less than 1 ; and therefore 3AE less than 3 A ; and perhaps so much as that the addition of Eq will not redress it .
And when it so happens , 3Aq+3 A , is a better Divisor than 3Aq+3A+ 1 , ( or even somewhat less than either .
) But because it doth not always so happen ( though for the most part it doth ) the Rule doth rather direct the other ; as which doth certainly give a Root less than the true value , whose Cube may always be subtracted from the NonCubick proposed .
The design being to have such a Cube as ( being subtracted ) may leave another B , to be ordered in like manner for a new Approach .
But , for the most part , 3Aq may be safely taken sor the Divisor .
For , though the Result will then be somewhat too big , yet the excess may be so small , as to be neglected ; or , at least , we may thence easily judge what Number ( somewhat less than it ) may be safely taken .
And if we chance to take it somewhat too big , the Inconvenience will be but this , that B for the next step will be a Negative .
Of which case we shall speak anon .
Thus , for instance ; if the Non-Cube proposed be 9= N. The greatest Integer Cube therein contained is 8=A c , ( whose Cubick Root is A= 2 .
) Which Cube subtracted , leaves 98=1=B=3AqE+3AEq+E c. This divided by 3 Aq = 12 , gives 1/ 12 = 0.08333 + , too big for E. But the same divided by 3 Aq +3A+1= 12 +6+1= 19 , gives 1/ 19 = 0.05263 + , too little .
Or if but by 3 Aq +3A = 12 +6= 18 , it gives 1/ 18 = 5/ 90 = 0.05555 + , yet too little .
For the Cube of A+ 0.06 , = 2.06 , is but 8.742 - , which is short of 9 .
And so much short of it , that we may safely take 2.07 as not too big : Or perhaps 2.08 , ( which if it chance to be too big , it will not be much too big ; of which case we are to speak anon : ) And , upon trial , it will be found not too big ; for the Cube of 2.08 , is but 8.998912 .
If this first step be not near enough : This Cube subtracted from 9.000000 , leaves a new B= 0.001088 , which divided by 3 Aq = 12.9796 , gives 0.000084 - ; which will be somewhat too big , but not much .
( For E is now so small , as that 3 AE may be safely neglected , and Eq much more .
) So that if to 2.08 , we add 0.000084 - , the Result 2.080084 will be too big , but 2.080083 will be more too little .
( As will apC 2 pear pear if we take the Cube of each .
) So that either of them , at the second step , gives the true Root within an Unite in the sixth place of Decimal Parts .
But when I say , Taking the Cube of each , ( which I do , that the thing may be more clearly apprehended ) it is not necessary that we trouble our selves with the whole Cube .
For , Ac being already subtracted , for finding B=3 AqE+3 AEq+Ec , we have no more to try , but whether 3AqE+3AEq+Ec be greater or less than B , according as we take 0.000084 , or 0.000083 , for E. Which may conveniently be done in this manner : Take 3A + E , and Multiply this by E , ( or E by it ) so have we 3AE + Eq. To this add 3Aq , and Multiply the whole by E , ( so have we 3AqE + 3AEq + Ec , ) to see whether this be greater or less than B. That is , in the present case , if we take E= 0.000084 , and add to this 3A = 6.24 , then is 6.240084 = 3A + E. This multiplied by E= 0.000084 , is 3AE + Eq=0.000524+ .
To which if we add 3Aq = 12.9792 , it is 3Aq+3AE+Eq = 12.979724 .
Which multiplied again by E= 0.000084 , is 0.0010902 += 3AqE + 3AEq + Ec , which is more than B= 0.001088 .
But if we take E= 0.000083 , and proceed as before , we shall have 3AqE + 3AEq + Ec = 0.001077 + , which is less than B= 0.001088 .
And therefore ( if we subtract that from this ) the Remainder , 0.000011 , will be another B for the next step , if we please to proceed further .
Hitherto I have pursued the Method most affected by the Ancients , in seeking a Square or Cube ( and the like of other Powers ) always less than the just value , that it might be subtracted from the Number proposed , leaving Ba Positive Remainder ; thereby avoiding Negative Numbers .
But since the Arithmetic of Negatives is now so well understood , it may in this ( and other Operations of like Nature ) be advisable , to take the next greater ( in case that be nearer to the true value ) rather than the next lesser .
Of which I took notice in my Commercium Epistolicum , Epist .
19 .
Jan. 2 .
16578 .
in a case more intricate than this is .
And which I elsewhere advise , in seeking the Greatest Common Divisor of two Numbers , in order to the abbridging a Fraction , or otherwise .
According to this Notion , for the Square Root of 5 , I would say , it is ( 2 + ) somewhat more than 2 ; and enquire , How much more ?
But for the Square Root of 8 , I would say , it is ( 3 - ) somewhat less than 3 ; and inquire , How much less ?
Taking ( in both cases ) that which is nearest to the just Value .
Thus , in the Cubick Root before us ; I would take for E ( in the last Enquiry ) 0.000084 ( where , for the next step , we have B= -0.000002 , ) rather than 0.000083 + ( where , for the next step , we should have B=+ 0.000011~ ) In the latter case , we are to Divide B=+ 0.000011 , by 3Aq = 12.980236- , to find ( by the Quotient ) how much is to be added to 0.000083 .
In the other case , we are to Divide B=+ 0.000002 , by 3Aq = 12.980248 , to find ( by the Quotient ) what is to be abated of 0.000084 .
So have we 0.000011/ 12.980236 = 0.00000085 + to be added to 6.240083 : Or -0.000002/ 12.980248 = 0.00000015 + to be abated of 6.240084~ ( Or it may suffice , in either , to Divide by 1298 + , or even by 13 .
- , without being encumbered with a long Divisor ) either of which gives us , for the Root sought , 2.08008385 proxime .
True ( at the third step ) to the Eighth place of Decimal Parts .
And if this be not near enough , the Cube of this , compared with the Number proposed , will give us another B for the next step .
And so onwards as far as we please .
Now , what is said of the Cube , is easily applicable to the Higher Powers .
I shall omit that of the Biquadrate ; because here perhaps it may be thought most advisable , to Extract the Square Root of the Number proposed ; and then the Square Root of that Root .
But if we would do it at once , we are from N ( the Number proposed , being not a Biquadrate ) to Subtract Aqq ( the greatest Biquadrate contained in it ) to find the Remainder B= 4AcE + 6AqEq + 4AEc + Eqq .
Which Remainder , if we Divide by 4Ac , the Quotient will certainly be too big for E , ( though perhaps not much : ) If by 4Ac+6Aq+4A+1 , it will certainly be too little ( for reasons before mentioned ) And we are to use our discretion in taking some intermediate termediate Number .
And if we chance not to hit on the nearest , the Inconvenience will be but this , that our Leap will not be so great as otherwise it might be .
Which will be rectified by another B at the next step .
For the Sursolide ( of five Dimensions ) we are , from N ( the Number proposed , being not a perfect Sursolide ) to Subtract Aqc ( the greatest Sursolide therein contained ) to find the Remainder B=5 AqqE + 10 AcEq + 10 AqEc +5 AEqq + Eqc .
Which ( as before ) if we Divide by 5 Aqq , the Result will be somewhat too big , ( because the Divisor is too little : ) If by 5Aqq+10Ac+10Aq+5A+1 , the Result will certainly be less than the true E. The just value of E being somewhat between these two , where we are to use our discretion , what Intermediate Number to take .
Which according as it proves too great or too little , is to be rectified at the next step .
If , to direct us in the choice of such intermediate Number , we should Multiply Rules or Precepts for such choice , the Trouble of observing them , would be more than the Advantage to be gained by it .
And , for the most part , it will be safe enough ( and least trouble ) to Divide by 5Aqq , which gives a Quotient somewhat too big : Which we may either Rectify at Discretion ( by taking a Number somewhat less ) or proceed to another B , ( Affirmative or Negative , as the case shall require ) and so onward to what exactness we please .
( Which is , for substance , in a manner coincident with Mr. Raphson 's Method , even for Affected Equations .
Thus , in the present case ; If the Number proposed be N= 33 , then is Aqc=32 , and B=33-32= 1= 5AqqE + 10 AcEq 10 AqEc +5 AEqq + Eqc .
Which if we Divide by 5 Aqq = 5~16 = 80 , the Result 1/ 80=0.0125 , is somewhat too big for E , but not much .
And if we examine it , by taking the Sursolide of 2.0125 , or of 2 1/ 80 , we shall find a Negative B ( for the next step ) but not very considerable .
Or if we think it considerable , we may proceed further to another step , or more than so .
The like Method may be applied ( and with more Advantage ) in the Higher Powers , according as the Composition of each Power requires .
And the same Method may be of use ( with good Advantage ) in long Numbers ( if duly applied ) even before we come to the place of Unites , for the same will equally hold there also .
Which the Reader may easily apprehend without a long Discourse upon it .
How far this Method may be coincident with some of those before mentioned , I do not trouble my self to enquire ; nor whether , or for what causes , all or any of those may be more eligible .
My design being only to show the true Natural ground , from whence such Rules of Approach are ( or might have been ) derived ; and by which ( if there be occasion ) they may be examined .
And if I have done this , it is what I did propose .
In Affected Equations ( especially where the Coefficients are great , and some Affirmatives , others Negatives , ) the Cases will be more perplexed .
And to Multiply Rules for each Case , would ( I conceive ) increase the Trouble , with no great Advantage .
Which therefore I leave to the Prudence of each ( as occasion shall require ) to take some Intermediate , between a greater and a lesser .
Or if they please to accommodate that above mentioned ( out of Commerc .
Epistol .
) to the present case , which is there applied to a Case not less intricate .
Or to make use of some of the Methods delivered by others to this purpose .
Where this ( withal ) is to be considered , That such Affected Equations are capable of more Roots than one , according to the Number of Dimensions to which they arise .

