An answer to some Quaeries proposed by Mr. William Molyneux , concerning Lough-Neagh : by Mr. Edward Smyth , Fellow of Trinity College in Dublin .
1 .
WHether Lough-Neagh hath really the quality of petrifying Wood ?
To this I answer , that no experiment , or observation yet made , ( that I can hear of ) can prove the Lough has this petrifying quality ; or that the water do 's any way help or promote the petrification ; for that two experiments made by a Gentleman of worth and good credit ( whose Estate lies contiguous to the Lough , and whose curiosity prompted him to a more diligent search into this matter ) plainly prove the contrary .
For about 19 years ago , he stuck two Holly-Stakes ( a wood which all agree will soonest petrifie in this Lough ) in two several places of the Lough , near that place where the upper Band enters into it ; and that part of the stake , which for so long time has been washed by the water , remains there without any alteration , or the least advance towards petrification ; as for that part of the stake which is covered by the mud or earth , he has not yet looked on it , but promises to do it this Summer , taking advantage of the fall of the Lough , and that too , which report make 's the weakest , and most unfit for this operation , may seem not to conclude universally of the whole Lough ; yet are a reasonable cause of doubting that , which ought to be , yet never was backed by any faithful experiment ; and I therefore believe it fabulous ; for that had the Lough any such Virtue , it would most probably be diffused in some measure through the whole .
This is true of those Lakes whose peculiarities are related by Varenius ; and this seems evident vident from the very nature of liquid bodies ; for the parts of all liquid bodies being in a constant motion , and mixing with one another , any Virtue received in one part , must necessarily be diffused through the whole , at least in some degree , but the stakes in this experiment had not suffered the least alteration last Summer , though they had been almost three times seven years in the water .
2 .
Whether this Quality be equally diffused throughout the whole Lough , or be more strong in any particular parts thereof ?
Because there have been no certain experiments made upon all parts of the Lough , and much time required to make this trial we cannot expect a speedy resolution of this Quaery ; Report for the West side , and Dr. Boat ( an Author for whose fidelity I vouch not ) in his Natural History of Ireland , tells us that as his Brother informed him , who lived in those parts , that water has especially this Virtue about those places , where the Black water discharges it self into the Lake , but confesses he never could find any person who himself had made the trial , and therefore had this information from report , or some other way equally uncertain : so that there is still good reason to believe the water is wholly destitute of this petrifying quality .
3 .
What woods are petrified by the Lough ?
or whether only Holly .
That not only Holly , but also Oak , and some other wood has been petrified about this Lough , and in the soil adjacent , I have sufficient grounds to conjecture on this account ; because some Fishermen ; being tenants of a gentleman from whom I had this relation , told him , they had found buried in the mud of this Lough great trees , with all their roots and branches petrified ; and some of that bigness , that they believed they could scarcely be drawn by a teem of Oxen .
They broke off several branches as big as a mans leg , and many bigger , but could not move the great trunk .
If we may credit this relation , we must allow some other woods to be petrified beside Holly , for Holly never grows to that bigness ; the largest trees being scarcely by a third part so big ; so that allowing for the unexactness and unfaithfullness of the Fishermens relation ; we have grounds to believe this wood was other then Holly ; my chief reason for guessing it Oak is the bulk ; no trees in that country , these expected , growing to that prodigious bigness : besides there is much timber found in the mud on sand on the banks , such as Deal , &amp;c. but no Oak , so that I believe what Oak was undermined by the water , was covered with mud , and so petrified into Stone , and of this sort might that be which the Fishermen found ; for if some part of that ground which is now covered by the water , was formerly wood , as is on good grounds believed by those that live therabouts , as it is probable there was much Oak in the wood , so it is probable there is much buried in the Lough ; Deal , and other trees are found here without any alteration , but what they might suffer in any other water .
4 .
Whether the wood or Holly , brought from other places , be as apt to be petrified , as what grows in the grounds adjacent to the Lough ?
If , as I shall make out in my answer to the last Quaery , this virtue of petrifying do s certainly , if not solely reside in the soil contiguous to this Lough , most certainly trees that imbibe some of this petrifying Virtue , or these Lapideous particles with their nourishment , as being already disposed for it , will be more easily altered into stone .
5 .
What time is requisite to petrifie a piece of a determinate bigness , I heard of no experiment which can resolve this Quaery , but what report tells us of seven years is certainly a fable as to the water , I know of no body who has made trial of the soil .
6 .
Whether any has seen the same body partly wood and partly Stone ?
I was informed by two Gentlemen of the North , that this may be frequently seen , who alleged they themselves had seen the same body , wood , and stone .
But the only reason for thinking so , being the diversity of colours which might well enough proceed from several degrees of petrification , we may probably think them deceived : for they made no experiments on that part which they reputed wood .
They further told me that part of the body which touched the surface of the water was the partition between the petrified and unpetrified part of it ; this further confirms me , they were imposed on .
This stone had been often found one part of it rotten and petrified , the other remaining firm and useful : but this it has common with other stones : whether it became rotten in the wood , or stone , may be doubted .
7 .
Whether the Bark has been seen petrified , as well as the Wood ?
The Bark is never found petrified , as I am informed by a diligent Inquirer , but often something rotten about the stone answerable to the Bark .
8 .
Whether any one has certainly made experiment of the Loughs petrifying , by putting a piece of wood therein , and there letting it lie till it was petrified ?
Several pieces of Holly have been put into the Lough , but none , that I ever heard of , was ever taken out in any wise altered .
9 .
Whether there be any Sand-pits nigh about the Lough in which these pieces of wood ( we esteem petrified ) are found ?
I never could hear of any such Sand-pits , nor that this petrifying Virtue was stronger in any such places ; there is a greater quantity of these stones found in the adjacent ground , and when ground is newly broke , ordinarily turned up in plowing .
10 .
Whether the Earth , or Sand about this Lough be endued with this Quality ?
That this Virtue is certainly , if not only , in the ground or soil I judge for these reasons , that there are many stones turned up daily especially at their breaking up new ground ; which we cannot in any probability think were brought thither ; they are often found at two miles distance from the Lough , seldom further , in great numbers , and very deep in the ground ; now for what use and reason they should be brought thither I ca n't imagine : but because there may ~ exceptions against this reason I shall produce another , which I believe will plainly prove this assertion , it being matter of fact .
The Gentleman on whose credit I received this information , had occasion one day to survey a part of his own land , and at a small distance from the Lough , he saw a stump of a tree just digged out of the ground , which by handling of it he found petrified ; his Servant that digged it up , standing by him , told him he had just rooted it out of the ground : he assured me the roots and all were stone , and altogether like those stones that are ordinarily found and go by the name of LoughNeagh stones .
This certainly proves the soil to have this petrifying Virtue , which was never yet proved of the water .
This Gentleman was of opinion these were Lapides sui generis , 'till this observation convinced him : and I believe the wood , which I before mentioned that was found by the Fishermen petrified , ows its petrification to the soil and not to the water .
But that these stones were once wood is I think very certain , for they show the plain vestigia of wood , they likewise burn , cleave ; filings of this stone thrown in the fire emitt a fragrant smell : they cut kindly with a knife , though not so easily , as other wood : but had they none of these properties , the instance now alleged , I think , is as convincing as Demonstration .

