A Discourse concerning the Air 's Gravity , observd in the Baroscope , occasioned by that of Dr. Garden ; presented to the Phil. Soc. of Oxford , by the reverend Dr. Wallis , President of that Society .
April , 14 , 1685 .
THE Discourse of Dr Garden ( read at our last meeting , ) concerning the different state of the Air , in respect of its different gravity , hath in it a great deal of very ingenious speculation .
And what I then said to it , upon the first reading of it , and what I am now saying again to the same purpose , is not to contradict it , or detract from it , but to add to it ; as a notion which I have long since considered , and judge it capable of further improvement .
The notion of the Air 's weight and spring , hath been so well settled , by innumerable Experiments of this present Age ; that hardly any considering Person doth now doubt of it .
And it hath chased away from before it , the notion of Fuga vacui , formerly received ; by showing us an efficient cause , of those effects , for which before we could only pretend to a Final cause .
The first occasion ( that we know of , ) of introducing it , was , from Galileo 's discovery , that water , by Pumping , was not to be raised higher then about three or four and thirty foot ( or not much more , ) of our English measure .
Which was a certain argument , that the cause of those effects ( commonly ascribed to Fug a Vacui , ) was but of a finite strength : whereas , if natures shunning a Vacuity had been the true cause , it was to have operated without stint .
Where upon this Lyncean Philosopher ( as he was called , ) did , out of his great sagacity , guess happily at the counter ter-ballance of the Air 's weight , as the true cause .
And that therefore Air , which was before thought to be a light body , was but comparatively so , and had indeed a positive gravity , though less then that of other bodies which we are conversant with .
This notion , was happily pursued by ( a Successor of Galileo , ) Torricellio ; who did rationally argue ; that , if the Air 's counterpois was sufficient to raise and sustain water at that height , and but to that height ; then must it be a just counterpois to a lighter Liquor at a greater height , but , to a heavier Liquor , at a lesser height .
And making an essay thereof in Quick-Silver , found it to succeed accordingly : and , in a just proportion to the respective gravities of those fluids .
And he hath , by this means , made the experiment ( commonly called the Torricellian experiment , ) much more manageable with Quick-Silver ( in Vessels of about 29 Inches , English measure , ) then before it was , with water , in much taller Vessels .
In pursuance of this notion , we find , by several sorts of Baroscopes ( or weight-wisers , ) not only that the Air hath gravity , but that it hath a different gravity , at different times and places ; according as its counterpois is able to sustain Quick-Silver at different heights : sometimes a little lower then 28 Inches , sometimes a little higher then 30 Inches , and at other times at some middle hight between these , here with us .
Which different weight of the Air , or Atmosphere , may reasonably be supposed , partly to proceed from , and partly ( as Dr. Garden well intimates , ~ to give occasion of difference in the weather and winds .
The particulars of his discourse ( having not the Paper with me , and having but heard it once read , ) I may possibly mis-remember .
But , as to the main drift of it , ( being a notion not wholly new to me , ) I think I do not mistake .
That there is , in our Air , a body more subtle then are the Fumes and Vapours mingled with it , in our lower region , and which with it do make up that heterogeneous mixture which we commonly call Air ; I think to be very certain .
But whether that subtle body , be ( as Dr. Garden seems to suppose , ) much heavier , then our common Air ; I much doubt .
And do rather think it is not ; not having hitherto observed any cogent experiment , either to prove it heavy , or elastick .
But it may , for ought I know , be void as well of weight as spring : and , what we find of either , in our common Air , may be attributed to the other mixtures with it .
I know that this notion ( of the greater weight of that subtler matter , ) hath , by some , been made use of , to solve that ( surprising , ) experiment of Quick-Silver ( well cleansed of Air , ) being sustained in a Tube inverted ( after the manner of the Torricellian experiment , ) at a much greater hight then the usual standard ( of 28 , 29 , or 30 , Inches , even to the height of 40 , 50 , 60 , or even 70 , Inches ; being steadyly managed , and with great care .
But I confess I am not satisfied with that reason : and think that it may better be accounted for otherwise , or else we are yet to seek for the true cause of it .
But we have no need of this particular notion , in the present discourse , and therefore need not be here solicitous about it : and shall therefore proceed without it .
The Air being , as hath been said , of a different gravity , in different times and places , ( arising I suppose , from the different kinds and quantities of the Fumes and Vapours and other particles which are ingredients in it , and the different force of the Suns heat acting thereupon , increasing or allaying the spring thereof , and otherwise , ) we are therefore to consider of the Air as a fluid who 's parts are in some places heavier , and others lighter .
And therefore much of a like nature as if they were different fluids , of different specific gravitiies ( as the word is now a-days , ) or ( as it was wont to be called , and , I think , better , ) Intensive gravity , one from the other : ( as , when we say , an Ounce of Lead , is intensively , though not Extensively , heavier then a Pound of Cork .
) Now when several fluids , or several parts of a fluid , are thus of different weights ; they will ( from the general nature of heavy fluids , ) when undisturbed , change places with one another , till the heavier becomes lowest and the lighter highest .
And this , not only as to the minuter parts ; as is observed in Chemical precipitations , or the sinking of Sand in water , or its smaller earthy particles which subside in a muddy sediment , and the like of other Liquors when at rest , and the atoms ( as they were wont to be called , ) flying in the Air when disturbed , but subsiding in the form of dust when at rest .
All which according as they be smaller do ( Caeteris Paribus , ) subside more slowly ( as dust slower then a clod of Earth , and Filings of Gold slower then a lump of it , and thin Plates of Lead laid horizontally , then either a round Bullet of the same weight , or those Plates in a contrary position set edgewise , ) and ought by statick principles ( as is easily demonstrable , ) so to do .
But , much more , as to larger parcels .
As when Oil , Wine , Water , Beer , or other the like Liquors , are put together in the same Vessel ; as will be observable to the Ey , especially when their colours are considerably different .
Thus , if a Bucket of Water , be hastily taken out of a Pond , or a large Vessel full of it , the vacant place will be presently supplied with Air ( as the nimbler fluid , ) &amp; then with Water flowing ( by a declivity , ) from the higher parts , and ( because heavier , ) thrusting out the Air ( which had prepossessd the place , ) till it come to a due Equipois .
And the same ( from a like reason , ) must happen , if some parts of the same Liquor , do accidentally acquire ( by expansion or otherwise , ) a greater degree of lightness then the other parts ; those lightned parts ascending , the heavier subside .
As when Water , Beer , or other thin fluids , be gradually heated by a fire underneath ; the lower parts , being first warmed , ascending to the top , while the colder and heavier subside ; whence we find , in such cases that Bubbles do arise , and that at the top is warmer then that at the bottom .
But in case what is warmed , be of a thicker consistence , so as that the parts cannot readily shift places , that at the bottom will be hotter ; and in case it be heated by fire over it , there will ( I suppose , ) be not such bubbling ( or not so much of it , ) that at the top being first heated .
From such consideration as this , Dr. Garden doth well observe , that some parts of the Air being thus ( by rarefaction , or increasing the spring thereof , or otherwise , ) become lighter then others ; these heavier parts , rushing into the places of those lighter , may cause a wind as from such parts ; ( in like manner as , on a like occasion , a Tide or Current would arise in water ; ) and other accidents of a like nature .
And contrariwise , on a contrary occasion .
And this I take to be very true , ( though such accidents happening very variously and uncertainly , will cause such confusion of motions , and disturbance of each other , that it will be hard to reduce them to a regular adjustment .
) But I add thereunto , that the Earths diurnal motion , compounded with its annual , ( if we admit that hypothesis , as most do now a-days , ) the one in some parts accelerating , in others retarding the other ; and its difference in different times of the year , ( by reason of the obliquity of the Zodiac to the Equinoctial , ) and in different times of the month ( because of the Moons different position , which is an Appendance to the Earths motion , and doth thereby differently affect it , ) and according to the different place of the Earth and Moon , as to the Aphelion or Perihelion of the one , and the Apogaeum or perigaeum of the other : seem to me to be of much greater consideration , not only as to the Ebbing and Flowing of the Sea , ( which I take to depend principally thereon , but to be variously modified also by the various positions of the continent on which it beats , ) but as to the Winds also : especially the briezes and Trade-Winds ; which at certain times of the day , or of the year , or of the month , are observed to blow constantly ( or most frequently , ) from such or such a Coast .
And I am not sure , that the body of Earth and Water ( or Terraqueous Globe , ) is exactly spherical ( allowing only for the small inequalities of Hills and Dales , which in a body of that greatness , are in considerable , ) but may have somewhat of an oblong spheroeid , having a longer Axis from Pole to Pole , then at the Equator .
And though this cannot be much ; because of the Earths shadow in the Moons Eclipse appearing circular , and the descent of heavy bodies being always ( as to sense , ) in a perpendicular to the Horizon : yet , if it be but little , this ( with the compound motions before mentioned , ) will give the Air a considerable disturbance .
To which I may add also , that we are not sure , that the Seas and continents ( which are of very different comparative weights , Earth being heavier then Water , ) are so adequately adjusted the one to the other , as that its center of gravity ( by which a plain passing divides it into parts aequiponderant , ) is the same with its center of Magnitude ( by which it is divided into parts equally great , ) which if it happen to be otherwise , will ( with the rest , ) make the confusions of the Air 's motions yet greater .
From the comparative weight or lightness of the Air at different times , he deduceth also the rising or falling of Vapours in it .
As if , when such Fumes or Vapours , or other the like matters , are lighter then the Air , they ought ( according to the exact rules of Hydro staticks , ) to ascend therein ; but , when heavier then so , to fall down .
And this certainly ( caeteris Paribus , ) is to be admitted also .
Only I add thereto ; that these statick principles do chiefly take place , when things are otherwise at rest and quiet .
But when they are in commotion , it is many times much otherwise .
And , in such cases , we must , beside the respective gravity , take into consideration , the force , impulse , or impetus , that is superadded to the respective gravity of the parts or matter .
Thus , if a Bottle be shaken , the sediment at the bottom , ( though heavier , and for which cause it did before subside , ) will be mingled with the supernatant ( finer and lighter , ) Liquor .
And , if a room be swept , it will ( as we use to speak , ) make a dust : that is , the small Earthy particles of dust , will rise and mingle with the Air : not because they be lighter then it , ( for we see that , at leisure , they will subside again , ) but because , by a force upon them , they be put into motion .
So in a Jetty of Water ( in artificial Water-Works , ) the water is thrown up into the Air to a great height ; not because it so becomes lighter then the Air , but because of the force impressed .
( To say nothing of a Bullet , shot upward into the Air .
) And Bottled Ale , when opened , flies many times upward to a great hight ; and sometimes blows up the Cork , to release it self from confinement .
And , in the late Fire of London , not Papers only , but other things of greater weight , were mounted into the Air , and there carried a loft for many miles , and so taken up at more then Twenty miles distance .
And this I take to be the cause of Fumes , Vapours , and other like matters ( most of them , )which ascend in the Air , not because lighter then it , but because impelled upward out of the bowels of the Earth , or from the superficial parts of it , either by some subterraneal heats or other ferments that put them into-motion , and force them upward ; where they remain suspended in the Air , so long as that force continues , or the force of others sent after them on the like errand ( which rather impells them farther , then gives them leave to fall , ) till either such force abate , or the great weight of so many things suspended , doth overpower , not only the Air 's weight , but the strength of that , that impelled them .
And that there are such Fumes and other like matter projected upwards , from the Bowels of the Earth , and some of them with great violence , is undeniable , not only from Earthquakes , and other eruptions ( with great noises , ) as well of Vapours , as of Burning Mountains ; but even Poisonous Steams ( and others , ) in Mines , and Bubbling springs ( where Bubbles of Air are seen to make their passage through the Water , ) and other perspirations of Air or Vapour through cranies or small passages of the Earth , discoverable by Steams ( whereof some will take fire at the light of a Candle , ) or by the moving of Leaves and other light things laid on the mouths of such private passages , and by many other means .
And to such causes I do principally attribute the Origin of Winds , and the ascent of most other things , which , from this lower World , mount into the Air .
And , without this , the comparative gravity of the Air and them , would give us but a lame account of them .
There is yet another notion suggested , which is also very considerable as to this affair : which is , the weakening or strengthening the spring of the Air .
That Water hath ( of it self , ) nothing of spring or Elasticity ( otherwise then by reason of some Airy parts , or other elastick bodies , which may be included within it , ) is generally held , at least none considerable , such as by any experiments hitherto made , can be clearly evinced so to be .
But , that the Air ( such Air at left as is the common Air which we are conversant with , ) is Elastick ; is , I think , out of doubt : the experiments which prove its spring , being so many and evident , beyond exception .
And , that this spring of the Air , is some times stronger , and sometimes weaker , I think is undoubted also .
And , that the spring of the Air , is strengthened both by compression , and by heat , but in a different manner .
If the same quantity of Air be compressed into a lesser room , the spring is certainly stronger .
As is undoubtedly seen in the Wind-Gun , and other compressive Engines .
And from hence it is , that Air , of the common texture with the external or open Air , if it be ( retaining its own texture , ) included in a close Vessel ( as in the AirPump , ) whereby it is excluded from communication with the external Air , and defended from the pressure of it , doth yet sustain Quick-Silver in a Tube ( after the Torri~ellian manner , ) at as great an hight , as the open Air by its counterpois would have done .
Which cannot be by its weight ( which , in this cause , is but small ; and not equal to that of a cylinder thereof contained to the height of the Atmosphere ; ) but by its spring only ; which is now pressed to as great a degree as it was in the open Air ( by such weight as was then incumbent on it , ) or would be now , if so again exposed .
( Like as that of a Fleece of Wool would be , if confined to the same dimensions it had , when a great pile of Fleeces was incumbent on it .
) But if some of this Air so included ( in the Air-Pump or such other close Vessels , ) be Pumped out , whereby the residue thereof hath a greater room to possess then before ithad , ( namely , as much as before the whole of it did possess , ) the Quick-Silver will presently subside , because the spring of the Air which did before sustain it , is now ( by expansion , ) become weaker .
Again ; the same quantity of included Air in a close Vessel ( so as not to communicate with the external Air , ) will , by application of heat to it , have its spring strengthened , and drive its counterpois farther off , or ( if need be , ) compress it .
As is to be seen in Thermoscopes of all sorts .
Whether , by strengthening the Air 's spring ( in that discourse , ) he means that of the former or the latter way , I do not well remember .
Nor , whether he apply it to the increasing , or diminishing , of its intensive weight .
But it may be reasonably accommodated either way .
If the spring be strengthened by compression ; it is manifest that the intensive gravity must be thereby increased : because the same quantity of Air , and consequently of weight , extensively taken , is now contracted into a lesser room , which therefore must be intensively heavier , ( as being the same weight in a lesser bulk : ) Now this may possibly , as a greater pressure or stronger spring , force up the Vapours under it with a greater impetus ( according to the notion I mentioned before , ) and so make them fly higher : ( unless we should suppose , it may be relieved , by shortening the height of the Atmosphere : ) but not so as to make them lighter ; but rather the contrary , as pressing them closer : much less to make them ( as the phrase is , ) specifically lighter then is the Air it self ( though thus compressed , ) and it leaves less room to receive them between the particles of the compressed Air , as being now thrust closer together .
If the spring be strengthened the other way ; so as by heat it uses to be : this doth rather diminish its intensive gravity , by thrusting its parts further asunder , and so possessing a larger room .
Now in case this Air be , by a close Vessel , confined so as not to expand upward ; it will certainly press the harder on the stagnant Quick-Silver under , and make that in the Tube rise higher .
But in case it be unconfined , as in the open Air , it may as well relieve it self upward , by making the Atmosphere , in this part so much higher .
Nor is there any necessity , as to the subjacent parts , that the Atmosphere should be every where of the same height .
But the laws of Staticks , as to the subjacent parts , be equally preserved without it , ( the greater altitude compensating for the levity of the parts , ) as when a Portion of the Sea , is covered with a Fleet of Ships ; the under parts are equally pressed , partly by water , and partly by Ships , though the tops of the Ships over someparts be higher then the surface of the water over others .
Only , in such case , the upper part of the Atmosphere , being fluid , may flow collaterally over the other parts on either side if lower .
And so , at leisure , ( if thus remaining , otherwise indisturbed , ) reduce it self to an equal height in all parts .
Like as the Sea would do , in a perfect calm , though otherwise its waves and billows are far from being in all places perfectly plain and even .
But however , though the spring fortified by heat , may thus relieve itself upward , ( yet because it presses every way , ) it must endeavour the like downward also , and thereby press harder on what is under it ; and because it will require time to work upward gradually before the effect reach the top of the Atmosphere ; and because , by such dilatation of its parts , more room is left in the intervals to receive what is forced : it is reasonable to believe , that , in such cases , the pressed vapours ( caeteris paribus , ) may rise more copiously then when the spring of the Air ( for want of heat , ) is less strong .
The rather because the same heat which thus fortifies the spring of the Air , doth also rarify the Vapours and make them lighter : and may also fortify the subterraneal heat ( or what ever else it is , ) that drives them up .
Notwithstanding all which , we have more rains in winter ; which should argue , that more Vapours do then arise to supply them .
But I suspect that , in this whole business ( of strengthening the spring , ) there may be a fallacy put upon us .
And what we think to be done upon the open Air ; is indeed done upon the Quick-Silver ; or rather upon the Air latent therein .
My meaning is this .
We find that in very hot weather , and also in frosty weather , the Quick-Silver in the tube commonly stands very high ; from whence we are apt to conclude , that therefore the outward Air presses very hard on the stagnant Quick-Silver , without the tube .
Wherein I am not satisfied .
For we are to consider , that , in filling the Tube with Quick-Silver before it be inverted , if great care be not used to cleanse it from Air , many aerie particles will remain mixed with it ; which , while their spring is weak , are easily pressed by the weight of the Quick-Silver close as hardly to be discerned otherwise then by the effect ; but when , by the external heat , their spring is strengthened , they expand themselves , and cause the Quick-Silver , wherein they are , to swell in bulk , without increasing its weight ; and consequently to stand higher though not to press heavier .
Of this I had manifest experience , when ( many years since ) I did for five or six years together constantly observe the height of the Quick-Silver in the tube , and kept a register of it , and of the weather with it:and did for two or three of the first years observe , that in very hot weather the Quick-Silver commonly stood very high .
But , for some of the latter years , I found it much lower in hot weather then in those former years .
Of which I satisfied my self with this account ; that , in those former years , the Tube having been but latel filled , the aerie parts remaining in the Quick-Silver , being by the heat expanded , made the Quick-Silver to swell and stand higher : but , when the Quick-Silver , by divers years standing unmolested , had by its own weight cleansed it self , and forced that Air ( which had been in it into the upper part of the glass ; it now ceased to make the Quick-Silver swell higher , but rather ( by expanding it self in the upper part of the glass , )pressed the Quick-Silver downward .
And I suspect , that others ( without heeding it , ) may have been in like manner imposed upon , as I was ; especially while their Baroscope hath been but newly prepared , and not well cleansed of Air .
And the same account , perhaps , may serve for its standing so high in frosty weather .
Water , we know , though it contract with cold , yet when it comes to Frieze doth expand it self .
( Which makes Ice lighter then water , and to swim on the top of it .
) Now whether this be purely of it self , or ( in part at least , ) from the particles of Air lodged in it , may not perhaps be so easy to determine .
However , if there be the like effects on Air , as on water , ( namely , that it expands with Friezing ; )or if , in the QuickSilver there be lodged particles of water as well as of Air ; we have , either way , an account of this Phenomenon .
For , then , the small particles , whether of Air , or water , lodged in the Quick-Silver , being thus expanded by friezing , will make the Quick-Silver swell , and so stand higher , without increasing its weight ; and consequently , without arguing a greater weight of external Air pressing on the stagnant Quick-Silver .

