A Letter from Mr. William Musgrave Fellow of New College Oxon : and one of the Secretaries of the Royal Society , to the Learned Dr. Martin Lister , wherein He endeavours to prove that the Lacteals frequently convey Liquors that are not White .
Honored Sir , THAT considerable Experiment of Yours , made for altering the colour of the Chyle in the Lacteal Veins , ( which I have found to succeed , by injecting a pint of a Decoction of Stone-blew , into one of the Intestina tenuia of a Dog , kept fasting 36 hours &amp;c. ) does not only claim my assent to the Conclusion you draw from it , viz. That a color 'd Liquor may find admittance into the Lacteal Vessels ; but also has ( in part ) been the occasion of my inclining to an Opinion , That the Lacteals frequently convey liquors which are not White : In Confirmation of which Proposition , I must beg leave First to give you an account of some Experiments I have lately made , relating to this matter ; and secondly to offer at some Deductions from them : The Experiments are of three kinds ; I. I kept 2 Dogs fasting , one 48 hours~ the other 3 days , and then opened them ~ in both a considerable number ( above 20 , where fewest ) of the Lacteals appeared Pellucid , like Lymphatics ; only not so full and turgid , as those under the iver are generally , or as the Lacteals themselves are sometimes , seen : I cut several of them in each Dissection , and immediately a Transparent liquor flowed out of the Orifice .
2 .
A Dog , which had neither eaten , nor drank , in three days was suffered to lapp a quart of common water ; an hour after ~ , he was opened ; the Lacteals showed themselves in a great number ( perhaps above 60 , ) all ~ , from the liquor contained in them , as in the former Experiments : part of the water was supposed to be ~ the stomach and small Guts ; for the quantity of water seen there , was ~ greater , then that in the primae viae of either of the Dogs killed fasting .
This Experiment was repeated with very little alteration in the trial , and the same success as before .
3 .
Another Dog , after three days fasting , had a peice of fat Meat given him ; an hour and half after which , he lapped ( about ) a Quart of common Water , and half an hour after this , was opened .
I first tied the Ductus Thoracicus ; then examined the Lacteals ; which ~ in as plentiful a number , and as full as ( perhaps ) they were ever seen in this Species of Animals : eight , or ten , of them at the first opening of the Dog , appeared perfectly white ; very many of a faint diluted white ; but most of them were Pellucid ; especially at the latter end of the Dissection ; by which time , several , which at first were either of a lively , or of a fading White , were now grown transparent : that I might satisfy my self as to this difference in the colour of these vessels , I opened the ~ ~ , and Ileon , in several places ; and found the water was got as far as the Caecum ; and had carried down diverse little parcels of the meat with it ; by which means the liquor seen in the Lacteals , at the first view of them , was either of a perfect , or of a diluted white , or else pellucid , according to the mixture of the meat with the water in the guts .
I ordered about 3 pints of broth to be given a Dog , which had been kept fasting 24 hours , and opening him 4 hours after this , I observed the lacteals , beginning at the Duodenum , ( with which the other small guts , and stomach ) was very much distended with the matter of the last meat : all the Lacteals , that I saw at first , were of a perfect white colour ; several of which I pressed between my fingers , drawing them from the circumference toward the Center of the Mesentery , by which means I found , that the Chyle , contained in these Vessels , appeared White , when it ran in a shallow stream , as well as when it filled the Lacteals : Viewing the rest of these Vessels along toward the Caecum , I observed , that , near the middle of the Intestinum Ileon , they began to be of a more diluted white , and a little farther , they were really pellucid , and as turgid , to appearance as those that were White ; after which turning back again toward the stomach , I saw the same Vessels ( I think ) in as great numbers as at first ( perhaps above 80 ) but the colour of most of them was changed , for they were all now pellucid : some 3 , or 4 which I at first cut a sunder for my better enquiry into the white Chyle contained in them at that time , being limpid together with the rest .
The same thing succeeded in a Dog kept fasting 2 days , and then opened 3 hours after he had lapped 3 pints of Milk , part of which was seen in the stomach of the Dog : about 15 of the Lacteals , arising from the Duodenum , were white ; above 100 , proceeding from the Intestinum Jejunum , and Ileon , were , more , or less , transparent ; as also were those of the Duodenum at the latter end of the operation .
2 .
This being the Relation of matter of Fact , let us now , in the second place , examine , what is the Consequence , what the Effects , of all this slaughter .
1 .
The Experiments of the first kind do sufficiently prove , that the Lacteals convey not only Chyle ( which results from aliments lately taken into the stomach , and may be called Liquor Novitius , ) but also another humor separated ( as is most probable ) from the blood , and now returning to it again ; which ( by means of the aforesaid Experiments , ) may be seen purely by it self , without any mixture of Chyle with it .
As to the place , where this liquor Refluus ( for so we will hereafter term it ) parts from the blood ; particularly whether it be a Lympha , properly so called , arising in the musculose Veins of the Intestines ?
Or whether it be a liquor emptied into the hollow of the Stomach , and Intestines , from the Pancreas , Glandularum plexus Fragiformes , and perhaps the Liver ; or thirdly whether it proceeds partly the former , partly the latter , way ; is a a Question not easily determined .
Caspar Bartholin , who looks on himself ( and it may be justly enough ) as the first observer of the Lacteals appearing sometimes limpid , like Lymphatics , has these words in favour of the former of those Opinions ; having spoken before of the glandulose Tunics of the Intestines .
He says [ si verum sit , quod magnam veri speciem habet , Lymphatica ab aliis partibus non glandulosis oriri , has ( scilicet lacteas ) ab Intestinis Lympham superstuam revehere dicam .
] Diaphragmatis structura page .
95 .
But as far as I can judge at present , it seems not unreasonable to derive at least part of this Liquor from the hollow of the ~ ; if we consider , that the Pancreas , and Glandularum Plexus Fragiformes , ( not to mention the Liver ) do daily discharge a liquor into the Intestines ; which ( considering that Dogs , after three days fasting , will as I have often observed , have very hard faeces in their Intestina Recta ) we cannot well dispose of any other way , then by saying , it reenters the blood by the Lacteals , and is that very liquor , which conduces to the making some of them appear transparent after so long a fast .
2 It seems probable , from the same forementioned Experiments of the first kind , That the Lacteals are very seldom , or never , all empty at the same time ; for tho the Chyle flows only in certain Tides , or Flashes , pro ratione Ingestorum ; yet the Liquor Refluus , running in a more constant stream , does , when there is no Flash of Chyle going in , keep the Lacteals from being absolutely empty .
3 .
But , to come nearer to my purpose , tis farther evident from the same Experiments , that this Liquor Refluus is , in its own nature , transparent ; and passes such thro the Lacteals , after long fasting , when no Chyle is mixed with it ; which is no inconsiderable step to the making out of my Proposition , if we recount how long , and how often , very many Quadrupeds , beside Men , do fast from all forts of aliment ; during which time , after the Chyle of the last Meat , or time of drinking , is all mixed with the blood , we may suppose that this pellucid Liquor Refluus , goes alone into the Lacteals .
4 .
The Experiments both of the second , and third kinds , seem to intimate , that a great part of the Chyle it self is , in its journey thro the Lacteals , altogether Limpid : against which if it be objected , that some of the Lacteals were , in a like manner , pellucid , in all the Experiments of all the three kinds , and therefore it does not appear but that they may be fill d with a liquor Refluus in the 2 last cases , as well as for certain ) they were in the first Case ; to this Objection , beside what may be answered from the extraordinary number , and fulness of the limpid lacteals in the 2 last kinds of Experiments , comparing these Vessels with those of the same sort seen in the first kind ( which comparative excess cannot be imputed to any cause so reasonably , as to the matter given the Dogs a little before the Dissections of the 2 last kinds ; ) beside this I say , it may farther be replied , that in all the Instances of the 2d and 3d Cases , a considerable quantity of aliment was taken in by each Dog , not long before his Death ; That some of this matter was seen in the primae viae of every one of them when dead ; ( an argument it was not all Distributed ; ) That there is no way , certainly known , by which liquors are discharged the primae viae , in this Species of Animals , beside Vomiting , Seige , and by the Lacteals ; and that ; seeing neither of the 2 former took place , it may not be unreasonable to suppose , That part of this matter was , at each dissection , in its way thro the Lacteals to the blood ; all the operations being at such distances from the time of the matter 's being taken in , at which most liquid aliments are observed to swell up the Lacteals .
But farther , whoever shall insist upon this Argument , if he derives his liquor Refluus from the Musculose Tunics of the Intestines , is liable to the objection before mentioned against that opinion ; if from the Pancreas , Glandularum Plexus Fragiformes , and Liver , will find it no easy thing to account , why this liquor should be admitted the Lacteals , and the water ( taken in specie in the Experiments of the 2d kind ; as also in the first Instance of the 3d kind ; and included in the broth given in the second instance of the third kind ) should be excluded ; altho in some of these Instances it was seen to have almost reached the Caecum : especially si ce it is sufficiently proved , That Decoctions of Indigo and Stoneblew ( of which Decoctions far the greatest part is Water ) have found the way into the Lacteals .
Now if it be not too precarious to suppose , That the Liquor , seen in the Pellucid lacteals of the 2 last kinds of Experiments , did , in a great measure ( for I by no means exclude the liquor Refluus ) consist of the matter lately taken in before the Dogs were opened ; we may with good reason imagine , That water , drunk on an empty Stomach , ( as it was in the second Case ) by several other Quadrupeds , and Men , as well as Dogs , will pass the Lacteals , not under a white colour , but rather Pellucid ; and these Cases are not uncommon amongst us ; particularly this seems to hold true in those , who drink great quantities of Diuretic Mineral Waters , in the morning , fasting ; of which suppose any person takes and Evacuates , 3 Quarts , by Urine , in the forenoon ; and , with his dinner , and in the afternoon , drinks 3 Pints of Bear , or the like ( allowing that all the Chyle produced from what he takes in at dinner , and in the afternoon , amounts to 2 Quarts , and that these 2 Quarts of Chyle are perfectly White ; which in all probability is not true ; yet , I say , according to this favourable account ) three Pints of Pellucid , for 2 of white Chyle , will pass the Lacteals in this person , in 24 hours .
And what is here said of Water , is not unlikely to be true ( mutatis mutandis ) of several other liquors , as Wine , Bear , &amp;c. at least so far as that they may not pass white thro the Lacteals , which is sufficient for my purpose .
Again , if this principle be true , the third kind of these Experiments will go yet farther and argue , That the whole quantity of Chyle , arising from some sorts of Meat , and Drink , taken either at , or near , the same time ; or from some sorts of Meat taken alone ; is not always white ; for the Lacteals , which appeared perfectly white in the several Instances of the third kind , were far inferior in number to those that were Pellucid in the same Dissections : But the proportion of the White , to the Diluted , and the Pellucid , Chyle , depends upon so very many Circumstances , ( as the quality of both meats , and drinks ; the distance between the time of their being taken ; and the proportion tion of one to the other ) that it seems almost impossible to determine it .
From the Premises it appears , there is some reason to induce us to think , that the Lacteals frequently convey Liquors , which are not white ; and that Chyle may ( not improperly ) be divided into three sorts at least , viz. White , Pellucid , and Intermediate to these ; contrary to the opinion of those Anatomists , who thought it to be ~ white , as that word is contradistinguisht to [ Pellucid ] ; altho by [ Chyle ] They understood ( as I likewise do ) the Effects of Drink , as well as Meat , Concocted .
This ( Sir !
) is the ~ of what I shall trouble you with at present , concerning this subject ; an account of which I here send you , having been assured , it will meet with a welcome at your hands ; and indeed the whole being a Building on your foundation , the right and Title of it does of Consequence belong to You : But that which gives the greatest encouragement to the writing of this Letter , is , that I know I write to one , who has Candor to excuse , as well as Judgment to discover , my Errors ; to the former of which I must of necessity be obliged , and am not averse to the latter ; but shall rather be glad , if I may know your sentiments concerning the matter in hand , which way soever they shall tend , whether to a Confirmation , or a Confutation of this Opinion .

