A discourse concerning the Sepulchral Lamps of the Ancients , showing the possibility of their being made divers ways , read before the Philosophical Society of Oxford , May the 7 .
1684 .
by Robert Plot LL. D. Director of Experiments to the said Society .
Mr. President and Gentlemen , YOU may well remember that at the last meeting , I showed you that the downy part of the Mineral called Linum Asbestinum , Earth-flax , or Salamanders Wool , would make , and do the office of a Weik tolerably well ; it having burnt from about nine in the morning ( being still supplied with Oil ) till about four in the afternoon ( about what time that Session broke up ) without sensible diminution : yet it was objected that upon other trials a friability had been found in it , which argued some sort of consumption ; and that allowing it invincible in the fire , yet there might be some danger of its being clog 'd by the impurities of the best Oil that could be got , or any way prepared .
To the first of which Objections it was then answered , that there was no such absolute necessity of making use of that Wool , but that another Weik might be contrived , against which that exception could not lye ; such as a Metallin Wire , especially of the best refined Gold ( whose prerogativeit is , not to be diminish't by fire ) that will lick up Oil as well as any other Weik , and so make a perpetual flame , provided it be supplied with a perpetual Oil : this I must consess I have often heard asserted , but never applied my self to the trial of the Experiment , till I received your commands to do it the last week ; in execution whereof I found that in a Faggot of Wire made of anneal 'd Iron , of a sutable bigness for a Weik , it would not succeed by any manner of means I could readily think of ; nor have I much reason to think it will , after the most mature deliberation , either in Wire of Silver or Gold ( though I dare not pronounce the contrary till trial has been made ) the nature of them all seeming not much different , as to this particular .
If therefore it be necessary , that we must have a perpetual Weik for the making such perpetual Sepulchral Lamps , as were used by the Ancients , I think we must stick to the first kind , made of Linum Asbestinum , or Salamanders-wool ; which if it any way can be supplied with a perpetual Oil ( as I shall presently show you ) I hope you will not judge me far from effecting the matter .
Now that there may be such a Bitumen or inexhaustible Oil , I shall not need to trouble you with the Testimonies of old Authors , or carry you into Italy , or other foreign parts : for will you but allow me an inconsumable Weik , I will carry you no further than Pitchford in Shropshire , where there is a Naphta or liquidbitumen ( a Specimen whereof I have here to show you ) that constantly issues forth with a Spring there , and floats upon the Water : this I would have separated before it joins with the water into a ductus of its own , and so conveyed to the place , thought most convenient for such a Lamp , into which it should as perpetually distill , as it does now into the fountain ; which I doubt not but you will allow may be done , without any great matter of difficulty : and if so , we have an Oil , as everlasting as our Weik : nor need we to fear any extinction if enclosed in a Tomb or Vault under ground , in never so damp or moist a place ; it being the Characteristic of a bitumen , to burn best where there is moisture , as is evident upon affusion of water upon Sea-coal .
And this is one way I have thought of , that such a perpetual Sepulchral Lamp might possibly be contrived .
But if you will be so strict with me , as not to allow this to be a perpetual Weik , or that it is probable one should be made any other way ; as unlikely may it seem to most ( that I say not to this Society ) that there was ever any such thing as a perpetual Lamp ; notwith standing the Testimonies of St. Austin , Plutarch , Pliny , Ludovious Vives , Baptista Porta , Licetus , Pancirollus , and divers others , whereof some are said to have burnt a 1000 , some 1500 years .
But I dare not think so many , and so very good Authors , have all imposed upon us , or that it is almost possible that so many notable instances as are brought for them , should all be false .
Much rather therefore shall I determine ( than wholly explode the thing ) that the liquor of these Lamps did burn without any Snuff or Weik at all , as we see Camphore and most bitumens will , it not being ~ ( that I remember ) scarce in any of the relations of these Lamps , that they were found with any Weiks , whence both the inconveniences above mentioned attending a Weik , ipso facto cease .
It only therefore remaining that we find out an inexhaustible Oil , which conveyed to a fit vessel might cause such a Lamp ; why may not our bitumen at Pitchford serve the turn ?
which no question will burn without a Weik , as well as any other liquid bitumen : for I begged not above in this instance the favour of a Weik out of necessity , but that I was willing to show the probability of its being done as many ways as I could .
All the objection I can foresee that is likely to obtain advantage against such an Experiment , is that such a Lamp as this , would as likely burn in the open Air , as in an enclosed damp Vault , whereas the Lamps of the Ancients did nourish their flame best , where there was most want of Air , only in close Vaults and Tombs , and were presently extinguish't upon the least immission of External Air , these being qualities necessary , and almost always asserted as concomitants of the Ancient Sepulchral Lamps .
To which I answer first , that some of the Lamps of the Ancients , cients , did as well burn in the open Air , as in close damp Vaults , as that mentioned by St. Austin in his book de Civitate Dei , which hung in the Temple of Venus always exposed to the open weather , yet was never either consumed or extinguish't .
The Lamp also found in the Tomb of Pallas the Arcadian , slain by Turnus in the Trojan War , was of this kind , which remained burning after it was taken forth , notwithstanding either Wind or Water , with which some did endeavour to quench it .
Now admitting our Lamp at Pitchford should thus burn indifferently under both circumstances , what are we the worse ?
Since I never heard that the Lamp mentioned by St. Austin , or of Pallas , were ever the less esteemed or admired , because they could not be extinguished by the open Air , as most of the rest have been said to be .
But if any body be so wise that He must have an Oil in all particulars answerable to that other sort of the Ancients , that burns best where there is want of Air , and is destroyed by its admission : let Him but go with me into Flint-shire to the Coale-works of Sr. Roger Mostyn of Mostyn in that County , and He may have satisfaction ; where the Miners when they have dugg so deep , that they begin to perceive a want of Air , find a bluish flame to begin to kindle of it self in the fissures of the Coal ( at which , by way of sport , they sometimes light their Candles ) which blazes , and moves up and down continually , and sometimes shines too upon the surface of the water in the bottom of the Pits , showing all the colours of the Rainbow : which yet upon drawing up of the water that annoys the works , and thereby stirring the Air , will leave burning ; but as they sink lower , and are more remote from the day or supert rraneous Air , still increases upon them : whence it plainly appears that this is a sort of fire that so little requires Air for the maintenance of it ; that it burns best when there is least Air , and is extinguished when disturbed by the motion of it ; as the ancient Lamps are said to be , upon the ~ of external Air .
This therefore must be the fire fittest for this sort of Sepulchral Lamps ( for it seems they were not all alike ) for the account whereof , we all stand obliged to an eminent member of this Society , the learned Dr. Bathurst Dean of Wells , and President of Trinity College Oxon .
By whose care the relation of the strange P~aenomena of this sort of fire , stand registerd in the Philosophical Transactions , Numb. 136 .
to all posterity .
Since which it has also been taken notice of , in the Coal-works of Sommerset-shire , by the ingenious Mr. Beaumont ; and by Mr. George Sinclar in the Coal-works of Scotland .
This I doubt not but you will readily allow me to be as probable a material for the Oil of this second sort of perpetual Lamps ; as that of Pitchford was , for the former : But how this , or that , shall be so menaged , as to be put into a Lamp , and this Lamp perpetually supplied , and placed wherever it shall be desired ; as it seems the Lamps of the Ancients might , this fire being sometimes found in little Pots , Glasses or Urns , without any such ductus to them as we required at Pitchford , or might do here ; is a difficulty perhaps not easily conquered .
To which I must confess that I have only this to say , that unless there can be a preparation Chymically made out of these bitumnious materials , which thus naturally take fire of themselves , or preserve it without a~~a small quantity whereof shall maintain so tenuious a flame as that there shall be no considerable consumption of the matter in many years ( such as the flame over the Well , and Earth about it , in one Mr. Hawkley 's ground in Lancashire , that ( like the fire of Plato ) only shines and does not burn ) we must be contented to be tied to the places where these materials are .
But if we can be content to quit these materials , and to think that these Lamps ( as many have done ) did not shine or burn for all the time they were enclosed in these Tombs , but were only kindled by the admission of Air when opened : I have thought of a way not at all liable to any of the defects or inconveniences , of the two former ways ; whereby a Glass of liquor enclosed in another ( like the Urns of Olybius ) upon immission of external Air , shall certainly shine , thought it did not so before .
And it is this : take a small Phial , into which put a little of the liquid Phosphorus ( which you all know , if the Phial be stopped , shines not at all , the external Air being excluded from it ) include this in another Glass , as suppose the recipient of an Air-pump , out of which if the Engine be stanch , so that the Air may be well exhausted , the solid Phosphorus it self , will leave off shining in ten hours time , though in the Summer-quarter ; and the liquid in fewer , so that it shall shine no more , than when the bottle containing it , is stopped with a Cork ; and both of them will be extinguished proportionably in a yet less time , if the Air be taken from them in the Winter season ; as has been frequently experimented by my worthy Friend Frederick Slare M. D. and shall again be repeated as soon as I can procure a nice Air-pump fit for the purpose .
Now let such an exhausted Recipient with the included Phosphorus , be placed in a Tomb or Vault which are commonly dark , and if ever found , and the outer Glass broken ( as usually such things are , by ignorant Men employed in digging ) possibly there will appear , upon immission of the Air , as good a perpetual Lamp , as some that have been found in the Sepulchres of the Ancients , tho in all probability of a different kind , from all , or most of them .

