Philosoph. Transact. Number 162 .
~ BD Fig:4 BC Fig:1 Fig:5 .
FFS ACE A Fig:6.B D C Fig:9 .
25 69 .
~ occid orient BE MD II~ ~~ Fig:2 .
occid orient RMQ 20 PE N~~ CANS occid orient S~ A new and easy way of demonstrating some propositions in Euclid by the learned Mr.------Ash .
a Member of the Philosophical~Society of Dublin for promoting natural knowledge .
THe Preeminence of Mathematical knowledge , and the certainty ofits way of reasoning are manifest from the few or no controversies between the Professors thereof ( especially in pure unmixt Mathematicks ; ) and from the easy discovery of paralogisms .
Some of the reasons of which certitude may be these : because quantity , the object about which it is conversant , is a sensible obvious thing , and consequently the Idaeas we form thereof are clear and distinct , and daily represented to us in most familiar instances ; because it makes use of terms which are proper , adaequate , and unchangeable ; its axioms and postulata also are very few and rational .
It assigns such causes and generations of Magnitudes as are easily apprehended and readily admitted ; it rejects all trifling in words and Rhetorical schemes , all conjectures , authorities , prejudices , and passion ; Lastly so exquisite an order and method in demonstrating is observed , that no proposition is pretended to be proved , which does not plainly follow from what was before demonstrated , as is manifest in Euclid 's Elements .
Now as a farther instance of the evidence of Mathematical Theoremes , I believe it were not difficult to demonstrate any one of Euclid 's independently from the rest , without precedent Lemma 's or propositions ; as an essay of which I will here subjoyn some of the most useful , and upon which the solution of most problems , especially Algebraical ones , do depend , and those also in the most various and different parts of Geometry , viz. concerning the properties of angles , , circles , triangles , squares , proportionalls , and solids .
The Propositions which I will endeavour to demonstrate thus independently dently shall be these ; the 32d , and 47th , of the 1st book , most of the 2d , and 5th books , the 1st , and 16th of the 6th , with their Corollaries .
In order to demonstrate the 32d , I suppose it known what is meant by an angle , triangle , circle , external angle , parallels , and that the measure of an angle is the arch of a circle intercepted between its sides , that a right angle is measured by a quadrant , and 2 right angles by a semicircle .
I say then ( in Fig. 1 .
) that in the triangle AB C , the external angle BCE is equal to the 2 opposite internal ones AB C , BA C ; for let a circle be drawn , C being the Center , and BC the radius , and let CD be drawn parallel to A B , those 2 lines being always aequidistant will both have the same inclination to any 3d line falling upon them , that is ( by the definition of angle ) they will make equal angles with it , for if any part of CD ( for instance ) did incline more to BC then did AB , upon that very account they would not be parallel , it follows therefore that the angles ABC , BCD are equal also BA C= DC E , because AE falls upon 2 parallels , but the external angle BCE= BCD + DCE which were before proved to be equal to ABC , BAC ( Q. E. D. ) hence may be inferred as a corollary , that the 3 angles of every triangle are equal to 2 right ones , for the angles ABC + BCE are measured by a semicircle and therefore equal to 2 right angles , Corollaries also from hence are the 20th 22d and 31st of the 3d book which contain the properties of circles~ whose deduction from hence being most natural and obvious , I omit .
In order to demonstrate the 47th , I suppose the meaning of the terms made use of to be known ; and that 2 angles or superficies are equal when one being put on the other , it neither exceeds , nor is exceeded : this being allowed , I say the sides about the right angle are either equal or unequal , if equal ( as in Fig. 2 .
) let all the squares be described , the whole figure exceeds the square of the Hypothenuse BC by the 2 triangles M , U , and exceeds also the squares of the other 2 sides AB .
AC .
by the 2 trianL 2 gles gles ABC , and S ; which excesses are equal , for M is equal to ABC , the 2 sides about the right angle , being 2 sides of a square , upon AB by supposition equal to AC , and the 3d side equal to BC , therefore the whole triangles are equal .
after the same manner S and U are proved to be equal , therefore the square of CB is equal to the square of the 2 other sides QE D. But if the sides be unequal ( as in Fig. 3d ) let the square ~e described , and the parallelogram LQ completed , the whole Figure exceeds the square upon C , by 3 triangles X , R , Z , and exceeds also the square LA , AD , by the triangle ABC , and the Parallelogram P. Q. which excesses I say are equal , for Z is equal to ABC , the side OC=BC , CD=AC , the angle D=A , and OCD=BCA , which is manifest by taking the common angle ACO out of the 2 right angles BCO , ACD , therefore by superimposition the whole triangles are equal .
In like manner X is proved equal to ABC , also R ; and the parrallelogram PQ to be double of the triangle ABC ; thus the excesses being proved equal , the remainders also will be equal , viz. the square of BC to the square of AB , AC ( Q. E. D ) manifest corollaries , from hence are the 35th and 36th of the 3d book , also the 12th and 13th of 2d .
And here I shall observe that by this Method of proving the 47 .
I. Eucl .
tis manifest that that proposition may be demonstrated otherwise then Euclide has done it , and yet without the help of proportions , which Peletarius denied as possible .
The first 10 propositions of the 2d book are evidently demonstrated , only by substituteing species or letters instead of lines , and multiplying them according to the tenor of the proposition ; thus to instance in one or two ; in Fig. 4 call the whole line A , and its parts B and C therefore A=B +C and consequently AA=BB + CC +2 BC which is the very sense of the 4th of the 2d book .
Thus also ( in Fig. 5 ) let a line be cut into equal parts F , F , and let another line S be added thereto , tis manifest that 4 FF +4SF+2 SS=2 FF +2 FF +2 SS =4 SF , which is the 10 proposition of the same book , Almost the whole doctrine of proportionals , viz. permutation , inversion , conversion , composition , division of Ratio s , and proportion ex aequo , and consequently the most useful propositions of the 5th book are clearly demonstrated by one definiton , and that is of similar or like parts , which are said to be such as are after the same manner or equally contained in their wholes ; thus ( in Fig. 6 ) the Antecedents A and C are either equal to their consequents or greater , or less , if equal , the thing is manifest , if less , then ( by the definition of proportionals ) A and C are like parts of B and E , therefore what proportions the whole B and E have to one another , the same will A and C have , which is permutation , likewise E : C : : B : A which is inversion ; so also if from proportionals you take like parts , the remainders will be proportional , whence conversion and division are demonstrated ; and if to proportionals you add like parts , the wholes will still ~e proportional , which is Composition &amp;c. If the antecedents be greater then the Consequents , the Consequents will be like parts of them , and the demonstration exactly the same with the former .
The first of the 6th book is proved by considering the generations of Parallelograms , which are produced by drawing or multiplying the perpendicular upon the basis , that is , takeing it so often as there can parts and divisions in the base : therefore ( in Fig. 7 ) the same proportion that RX single , hath to NX single , the same hath RX multiplied by XZ , that is , rep~ated a certain number of times , to NX multiplied by XZ , that is , repeated the same number of times ; which is as much as to say RX~ NX : : par : RZ : par : NZ ; now that this proportion also is true in oblique angled parallelograms , is proved , because they are equal to rectangled ones upon the same basis and between the same Parallels , as does thus independently appear ( in Fig.7 ) the triangles RQX and MPZ are equal , for RX=MZ , QX=PZ , RM=Q~ ~ adding to both MQ , RQ=MP , if therefore from these equal triangles you take what is common viz. MLQ , the remainders will be equal RXLM=QLZP ; to both which add XLZ , and the whole parallelograms will be equal , RZ=QZ ( Q. E. D. ) that triangles also having a common basis , are in the proportion of their altitudes does hence follow , because they are the halfs of parallelograms upon the same basis , this also is true , and the demonstration exactly the same in prisms , Pyramids , Cylinders , and cones , having the same basis .
To prove the 16th of the 6th I suppose ( in Fig. 6 .
) the 4 lines A , B , C , E. to be proportional , that is , granting A and C to be the lesser terms , the same way that A is contained in B , so is C in E , and that D is the denominator of the ratio , ~twill follow then that B is made up of A , multiplied by D , and E of C multiplied by D , so that AD=B , and CD=E , draw therefore the extremes upon one another , that is A upon CD and the means , that is , C upon AD , the factors being the same , I say the products ACD and CAD are the same and consequently equal ( Q. E. D. I know not whether it be worth the while to add somewhat ( tho altogether impertinent to this present subject ) concerning Mons : Comier 's problem which he lately proposed with ostentation enough to all Mathematicians to be solved , as if it contained something new , whereas tis no more then the old business of doubling the Cube a little disguised , this has been shown by several , but by none ( I think ) after the algebraical way , or so briefly as follows in Fig. 8 .
A : 2 X : : X : 2 X/ A q=P per 8 .
6 .
Aq +2 AX ---2Xc/ A=4Xqq/ Aq per 47 .
I. Aqq +2 AcX ---2 Xc A=4X qq Aqq +2 AcX=4 Xqq +2 Xc A resolving which aequation A+2 X : 2A+4 X : : Xc : Ac : into an Analogy .
that is , Xc ( the cube upon X ) is 1/ 2 of Ac ( the cube upon A )

