IV .
The manner of making Steel , and its Temper ; with a Gue~ at the way the Ancients used to Steel their Picks , for the cutting or hewing of Porphyry .
Communicated by Martin Lister , M. D. and S. R. S. IN the Philosophical Transactions , Numb. 93 .
p. 6015 .
amongst other Desiderata 's and Queries , are these : To endeavour to retrieve the Art of Hardning and Tempering of Steel , for cutting of Porphyry , &amp;c. We know not which way to rough-hew Stones of that untractable hardness .
Those famous and stupendious Monuments of Antiquity , the Egyptian Obelisks are of Porphyry , and most of them curiously Carved with a vast number of Figures , one way of Writing of the Ancient Egyptians : These Witness the Facility that Nation had of graving in Porphyry ; a Stone which no Tool will now touch , nor nothing less affect , than Emery or Diamant Powder .
Mr. Ray assures us , That all the Obelisks of Rome , that are Graven with Hierogly phicks , are of one and the same kind of Stone , viz. a Marble of a mingled Colour , Red and White , very hard , and hath not in so many Ages suffered the least by the Weather .
Something there is certainly lost in this Age , as to the manner of Steeling of Tools : I should be glad , if by any Conjecture of mine , I could help to extricate and retrieve it .
To this Purpose , let us first see what Steel it self is , and how made : and then we shall best guess at the applying of it , in the making of Tools .
As for the moderns , there is great abuse in this Manufacture , and the Processes now used by most Nations , are fraudulent , and a poisoning of Iron , by certain Mineral Salts , rather than a true making of Steel .
The most Ancient Account , is that which is given us by Aristotle , Meteorologicor .
l. 4 .
c. 6 .
which yet is very obscure and imperfect .
The Passage is this ; Wrought Iron it self may be cast so , as to be made Liquid , and to harden again .
And they are wont to make Steel thus : For the Scoria of Iron subsides , and is purged off by the bottom .
And when it hath been often defaecated and made clean , this is Steel .
But this they do not often , because of the much wast , and for that it ~ much Weight in fining .
But Iron is so much the more excellent , the le~ Excrement it hath .
Thus far Aristotle .
This Account is a little confused , and not well understood : It is indeed true , That Iron is still better , the more it is purged .
So in our Furnances in England ; those Bars which are wrought out of a Loop , taken up out of the Finnery Harth , or second Forage , are much better Iron than those which are made in the Bloomary or first Harth , because those are more purged of the Dross , and accordingly give double Price .
Also , it is as true , that even wrought Iron may be melted as oft as you please .
Again , Iron , as ost as it is melted and purged , looseth much of its Weight .
But after all , Iron of it self , how oft soever it is purged and refined , it will never become Steel ; yet of this so purged , the best Steel doubtless may be made .
And this is the most favourable Construction that I can make of this Passage of Aristotle .
In the next place , we shall give you the best account how true Steel is made at this Day , waving all fraudulent processes .
The manner is this , faithfully described by Agricola ( de re Metallica , lib. 9 .
) And to confirm to you the Antiquity of it ; this way of making Steel is by Kircher said to be now in use in the Island of Ilva , a place famous from all Ages , even from the times of the Romans , for that Metal alone , down to our Days .
` Make choice of Iron which is apt to melt , and yet ` hard , and yet which may easily be wrought with the ` Hammer : For although Iron , which is made of Vitri ` olick Ore , may melt , yet it is soft , or fragil , or eager .
` Let a Parcel of such Iron be heated red hot , and let ` it be cut into small Pieces , and then be mixed with that ` sort of Stone which easily melts ; then set in the Smiths ` Forge or Harth , a Crucible , or Dish of Crucible Metal , ` a Foot and a half broad , and a Foot deep ; fill the Dish ` with good Charcoal , and compass the Dish about with ` loose Stones , which may keep in the Mixture of Stone , ` and Pieces of Iron put thereon .
` As soon as the Coal is thoroughly kindled , and the ` Dish is red hot , give the Blast , and let the Workman ` put on , by little and little , all the Mixture of Iron and ` Stone he purposes .
` When it is melted , let him thrust into the middle of ` it 3 or 4 , or more Pieces of Iron , and boil them there ` in 5 or six Hours , with a sharp Fire ; and putting in ` his Rod , stir often the melted Iron , that the Pieces of ` Iron may imbibe the smallerParticlesof the melted Iron , ` which Particles consume and thin the more gross Parti ` cles of the Iron Pieces ; and are , as it were , a Ferment ` to them , and make them tender .
` Let the Workman now take one of the Pieces out of ` the Fire , and put it under the great Hammer to be ` drawn out into Bars , and wrought , and then hot as it is , ` forthwith plunge it into cold Water .
` Thus Tempered , let him again Work it upon the ` Anvil and break it ; and looking upon the Fragments , ` let him consider whether it look like Iron in any part ` of it , or be wholly condensed , and turned into Steel .
` Then let the Pieces be all wrought into Bars ; which ` done , give a fresh Blast to the Mixture , adding a little ` fresh Matter to it , in the room of that which had been ` drunk up by the Pieces of Iron ; which will refresh and ` strengthen the remainder , and make yet purer , the Pieces ` of Iron again put into the Dish : every which Piece , let ` him as soon as it is red hot , beat into a Bar upon the An ` vil , and cast it hot as it is into cold Water .
And thus I ` ron is made into Steel ; which is mnch harder and whiter ` than Iron .
Being now certain what Steel is , and how it is to be distinguisht and differs from Iron .
In the last place , we will consider , if yet any thing can be found in the Ancients , which may hint to us any defect in our Tools , and how that may be remedied .
There is but one place that I know of to this purpose , which may give us any sight in our Enquiry ; and that is in Pliny , ( lib. 34 .
c. 14 .
) where speaking of Iron , he says , Fornacum maxima differentia est : in iis equidem Nucleus ferri excoquitur ad indurandum aliter , alioque modo ad densandas incudes malleorumve rostra .
From this Passage it should seem , that the Ancients had one way to make Steel , and another way to harden or temper their Tools , particularly such as Picks and Anvils .
Also it is plain , That Nucleus Ferri was melted down in both .
Again , the difference was in the Furnaces , that is , in the manner of ordering of the Iron to be made into Steel , or for the superlative hardning of the Heads and Bitts of Tools , and not in the Matter of which they were made ; for both was done by excocting them in molten Iron .
I suppose none will doubt , but by Nucleus Ferri , must be meant well purged Iron ; the same which Aristotle calls ~ ~ : For why else should he tell us that Wrought Iron it self may be made Liquid , so as to harden again ; that is , according to our Phrase , cast again into Sow-metal , if it was not to explain to us the manner of making of Steel ; which yet plainly is his design .
It remains then , that we show the different manner or use of this Liquid Iron ; and we have no other light in this matter , but what two different Phrases afford us , viz. ad indurandam Aciem , and that of ad densandos incudes malleorumve rostra .
The first difference then , in my Opinion , is to be understood , of making Steel Bairlic ; which they did probably after the Precept above delivered ; that is , not only boil the Iron in its own Sow metal , or Liquid Iron , but hammer it also , and after quench it in cold Water .
And this Opinion those other Words of Pliny in the next Chapter favour , Ferum accensum igni , nisi duretur ictibus , corrumpitur : And again , aquarum summa differentia est , cui subinde candens immergitur .
And this way was sufficient for Sword-Blades , and Knives , Razours , &amp;c. The other difference is in the Steeling their Tools : that is , they boiled their Tools in Sow-metal , to such a degree of Hardness or Temper , as was requisite , and did not afterwards hammer them .
And this seems to be implied in the Phrase Densare , for indeed , altho ' it generally be said , that Iron is purged and refined for the making of Steel , yet according to the last and truest Process , the matter is plainly otherwise ; for Iron this way made into Steel , becomes a kind of Electrum , and is filled with an exceeding brittle and hard Body of its own Nature ; Iron being spungy and not close ; for which purpose the refore , the Word densare is by Pliny aptly and elegantly used .
And this way was used when the strongest temper and hardness was required ; as to Picks and Anvils .
There might be divers reasons given for this last usage ; as first , that there is far greater ease in working Iron , than Steel into any Figure , that being far softer and more ductible and loose .
Again , it is certain , and the Ancients in the passage last quoted do testify as much , that Iron by ignition is spoilt or corrupted , so that the oftner it is purged , tho ' it were Steel it would the more relent .
Whence knowing well , that in making their Tools out of Steel , they could not but considerably loose it and abate of their temper ; they therefore first shaped them , and then gave them a strong Body of Steel and Temper together , and so had nothing else to do but to finish them on the Grindstone and Hone , to set the point or edge .

