VIII .
A Proposal concerning the Parallax of the Fixed Stars , in Reference to the Earths Annual Orb .
In several Letters of May the 2d , June 29 .
and July 20 1693 .
from Dr. John Wallis to William Molineux Esq ; SIR , I Am obliged to you for two Books which you have been pleased to send me , that of your-Sciothericum Telescopicum , and that of Dioptricks ; which you have performed so well , that I have not been better satisfied with any that I have seen of that Subject .
I should not so long have neglected to return my Thanks for them , but that I thought a Letter of bare Thanks to be too empty , unless I had somewhat else to send with it .
You will , I hope , give me leave ( though I have not had the opportunity of being personally known to you ) to suggest a Speculation , which hath been in my Thoughts these Forty Years or more ; but I have not had the opportunity of reducing it to Practice , as being not so well stored with necessary Instruments of that kind , nor much exercised to Telescopick Observations .
And though I have many Years since suggested it to others , yet neither have they had leisure or convenience of putting it in Practice .
It is concerning the Parallax of the fixed Stars , as to the Earths Annual Orb .
Galileo complains of it a great while since ( in his System a Cosmicum ) as a thing not attempted to be observed ved with such diligence as he could wish , and I doubt we have the same cause of complaining still .
I know that Dr. Hook and Mr. Flamstead have attempted somewhat that way , but have desisted before they came to any thing of Certainty .
What hath been done to that purpose abroad I know not .
Galileo hath suggested divers things considerable in order to it .
As to the times of Observation ; That it should be when the Sun or Earth are in the Tropicks , or as near thereto as may be : Because at those times , if any , will be the greatest difference observable in their Meridional Altitude .
As to the Stars to be observed , That they should be such as are as near as may be to the Pole of the Ecliptic : For such as are in the Plain of the Ecliptic , or near unto it , though they may be sometime hearer , sometime farther from us , ( which might somewhat alter their apparent Magnitude , if it were so much as to be observable ) yet it would little or nothing alter the Parallactick Angle , as Galileo doth there demonstrate .
He notes also , that in a business so nice , the ordinary Instruments of Observation ( though pretty large ) would be insufficient ( he doubts ) for this purpose , and doth propose , that by the side of some Edifice or Mountain , at some miles distance , the setting of some noted Star ( as that of Lucida Lyrae ) might be observed at those different times of the Year , which might be equivalent to an Instrument whose Radius were so large .
Which were a good Expedient if Practicable ; but I doubt the Density of our Atmosphere is so great , as that it will be hard to discern a Star just at the Horizon , or even within some few Degrees of it : And that the Refraction would be there so great , and so uncertain , as not to comply with so curious an Observation .
That which occurred to my Thoughts upon these Considerations , was to this purpose ; That some Circumpolar Stars ( nearer to the Pole of the Equator than is our Zenith , and not far from the Pole of the Zodiac ) should be made choice of for this purpose .
And in case the Meridianal Altitude be discernably different at different times , so will also be their utmost East and West Azimuth , which may be better observed than their Rising or Setting : And this will be not obnoxious to the Refraction , as is the Meridional Altitude ; ( for though the Refraction do affect the Altitude , yet not the Azimuth at all ) ; and we may here have choice of Stars for the purpose ; which in Observations from the bottom of a Well we cannot have ; being there confined to those only which pass very near our Zerinh , though very small Stars .
I would then take it for granted , as a thing at least very probable , that the Fixed Stars are not all ( as was wont to be supposed ) at the same distance from us ; but the distance of some , vastly greater than of others ; and consequently , though as to the more remote , the Parallax may be undiscernable ; it may perhaps be discernable in those that are nearer to us .
And those we may reasonably guess ( though we are not sure of it ) to be nearest to us , which to us do appear biggest and brightest , as are those of the First and Second Magnitude ; and there are at least of the Second Magnitude , pretty many not far from the Pole of the Ecliptic , ( as that in particular , in the Shoulder of the lesler Bear ) : And in case we fail in one , we may try again and again on some other ; which may chance to be nearer to us than what we try first .
And Stars of this bigness may be discerned by a moderate Telescope , even in the day-time ; especially when we know just where to look for them .
The manner of Observation I conceive , may be thus : Having first pitched upon the Star we mean to observe , and having then considered ( which is not hard to do ) where such Star is to be seen in its greatest East or West Azimuth ; it may be then convenient to fix ( very firm and steadily on some Tower , Steeple , or other high Edifice ( in a convenient situation ) a good Telescopick Object-glass in such position , as may be proper for viewing that Star .
And at a due distance from it near the Ground , build on purpose ( if already there be not any ) some little Stone Wall , or like place , on which to fix the Eye-glass , so as to answer that Object-glass : And having so adjusted it , as through both to see that Star in its desired Station , ( which may best be done while the Star is to be seen by Night in such situation , near the time of one of the Solstices ) , let it be there fixed so firmly , as not to be disturbed , ( and the place so secured , as that none come to disorder it ) , and care be taken so to defend both the Glasses , as not to be endangered by Wind and Weather .
In which contrivance I am beholden to Mr. John Caswel M. A. of Hart-hall in Oxford , for his Advice and Assistance ; with whom I have many Years since , communicated the whole matter .
This Glass being once fixed ( and a Micrometer fitted to it , so as to have its Threads perpendicular to the Horizon , to avoid any inconvenience which might arise from diversity of Refraction if any be ) the Star may then be viewed from time to time ( for the following Year or longer ) to see if any change of Azimuth can be observed .
This I thought fit to recommend to your Consideration , who do so well understand Telescopes , and the managery of them ; not knowing any who is more likely to reduce it to Practice .
If you shall think fit to give your self the trouble of attempting the Experiment , and that it succeed well , it will be a noble Observation , and worth the Labour : And , if it should miscarry , the charge I hope would not be great .
But when I suggest ( as a convenient Star for this purpose ) the shoulder of the lesser Bear ( as being the nearest to the Pole of the Zodiac of any Star that is of the first or second Magnitude ) , I do not confine you to that Star ; but ( without retracting that ) suggest another ; namely , the middle Star , in the Tail of the Great Bear , which ( though somewhat farther from the Pole of the Zodiac ) is a Brighter Star than the other , and may be nearer to us .
But I do it principally upon this Consideration : namely , That there is adhering to it a very small Star , ( which the Arabs call Alcor , of which they have a Proverbial saying , when they would describe a sharp-sighted Man ; That he can discern the Rider on the middle Horse of the Wayn ; and of one who pretends to see small things but over-look much greater ; Vidit Alcor at non Lunam plenam ) : Which Hevelius in his Observations , finds to be distant from it about 9 Minutes , and 5 or 10 Seconds : So that besides the advantage of discovering the Parallax of the greater Star , if discernable .
The difference of Parallax of that and of the lesser Star ( being both ~ within the reach of a Micrometer ) may do our Work as well .
For if that of the greater Star be discernable , but that of the lesser be either not discernable , or less discernable .
Their different distances from each other at different times of the Year , may , perhaps ( without farther Apparatus ) be discerned by a good Telescope of a competent length , furnished with a Micrometer , if carefully preserved from being disordered in the Intervals of the Observations ; and discover at once , both , that there is a Parallax , and that the Fixed Stars are at different distances from us , wherein , that I be not mistaken , my meaning is not , that the Instrument or Micrometer should be removed for the observing of the lesser Star ; but that ( when the Azimuth muth of the greater Star is taken ) by a Micrometer ( consisting of divers fine Threads parallel and transverse ) may ( at the same time ) be observed the Distance of the two Stars , each from other , in that Position ( both being at once within the reach of the Micrometer ; ) which distance ( the Instrument remaining unmoved ) if it be found ( at different times of the Year ) not to be the same ; this will prove , that there is a different Parallax of these two Stars .
This latter part of the Observation ( of their different distances at different times ) I suggest , as more easily practicable though not so nice as the former .
For it may be done , I think , without any further Apparatus there than a good Telescope , of ordinary form , furnished with a Micrometer , ( this being carefully kept unvaried during the Interval of these Observations .
) And if this part only of the Observation ( without the other ) be pursued ; it matters not though the two Observations ( near the two Solstices ) be , one at the Eastern , the other at the Western Azimuth ( whereby both may be taken in the Night-time , ) for the distance must ( at both Azimuths ) be the same , if after observing the Azimuth of the greater Star it be necessary to move the Micrometer for measuring its distance from Alcor that may be done another Night ( and it is not necessary to be done at one Observation ) for that distance cannot be discernably varied in a Night or two .
I shall give you no farther trouble at present , but subscribe my self , Sir , Yours , &amp;c.

