Philosophical Transactions N~202 .
Fig:1 .
Fig:2 .
Fig:3 .
Fig:1 .
BC F K HL III .
Dr. Mullineux his Account of a Stone of an extraordinary bigness , spontaneously voided through the Urethra by a Woman in Dublin .
WOmen are made by Nature of a more nice Composition , and weaklier Frame than Men , and are therefore liable to many Infirmities that Men are not the least subject to .
Yet in one of the most painful that afflicts the Body , the Stone in the Bladder , they have much the advantage , and are more rarely troubled with it than Men .
For among the two vast Collections of Stones , that amount at least to several Thousands , kept together in the Hospitals at Paris l ' Hotel Dieu and la Charite , cut out only of such as come thither to be cured , not one in an Hundred , I might safely say more , is taken out of a Woman .
This remarkable difference must certainly proceed from the Urinary Passage in this Sex , being shorter , larger , and more apt to dilate ; so that for the most part , when Gravel , or a sort of viscous claiy matter , which I take to be the chief Cause of the Generation of the Stone , falls into the Bladder , it is suddenly and easily discharged , ever it can cohere together and form a Stone of any large Bulk , which cannot so frequently happen in Men , by reason of the narrowness , crookedness , and length of the Passage of the Urethra However it sometimes comes to pass , that even in Women , either from a more depending , or less elevated Posture than usual in their Bladder , or that the matter forming the Stone adheres to some part of its Membranes , so that it cannot fall in the Urinary Passage , till its own Bigness or Gravity forces it thither , Stones of a very considerable Bulk are generated .
Of this we have lately had here in Dublin a very remarkable Example : One Margaret Plunket alias Weldon , to give her her Maiden Name according to the Irish way , the Mother of Five or Six Children , Cozengerman by her Mothers side , who was the Lord Netherfield 's Sister , to my Lord Tirconnell , born in the County of Mead , about Sixty Years of Age , now living in Churchstreet , Dublin , on May 29 .
1691 .
voided through her Urinary Passage , by the help of Nature alone , without the use of Remedies , or any forcible means whatever , a Stone of this Shape and Size , somewhat resembling a hard Pear a little pressed or flatted .
V. Fig. 1 .
Its Circumference measured the longest way is 7 Inches and ~ , round about where it was largest 5 Inches ~ ; its Weight at present , according to Troy Pound , ~ , ~ , ~ , gr. 6 .
for it has lost considerably both of its first Bulk and Weight by many little Fragments breaking off from the smaller end A , where it is much softer , smoother , whiter , its parts more porous , and so incoherent , that the least force severs them : Whereas the bigger end B , as far as the Stroke ccc passes , is of a very different Texture , much more close and compact , covered with a yellowish shining Crust , ruff , granulated , and as hard as the best Portland Stone .
This different Texture of Parts in one and the same Stone , observable in most of this kind if they be of a large Size , proceeds , I am apt to think , from the same constant Bed or settled posture of the Stone in the Bladder , whereby some parts of it are more exposed to imbibe the Moisture of the Urine as it falls or settles in the Bladder than others ; and by this sort of Maceration are kept soft , whilst those parts that lie higher towards the upper Region of the Bladder remain dry , harder , and gather a sort of gritty Crust , as we find most soft Stones do , that are dug out of the moist Earth , when exposed a while to the dry Air .
It seems to me very probable , that Stones when they come to be of a large size , keep much one and the same posture in the Bladder at all times , there not being room in so pliant and membranous a Body , that always contracts it self to the least Dimensions it can , to allow a Stone of any considerable Bulk ; for the Case is different in those that are small , to tumble or change its Situation very much .
But however this Conjecture may prove true or false , it is undeniable , that some Stones from their way of Generation must of necessity remain fixed and immovable in the Bladder ; being closely joined and united to the very substance of its Membrane , of which sort there are several Examples recorded by Scenkius , and other Collectors of Observations : And I 'm persuaded this Stone I am now describing may be reckoned among them : For about the larger end , where it is marked dd d , there still closely adheres several thin Films and carneous Filaments , which manifestly show it was formerly united by this part to the membranous Substance of the Bladder , and that lately by its own Weight , or some other Accident , it was torn away , and fell into the Urethra , through which it was voided ; and hence it was that this Woman , as she her self told me , never suspected her self , till very lately , at all troubled with the Stone .
For these Three Months past , whilst it was sticking in the Urinary Passage and coming away , she has suffered great Pains , and a perpetual Strangury , or an involuntary dropping of her Water from her ; and this Infirmity still continues , by reason the largeness of the Stone has over-stretch 'd the Fibres that compose the Sphincter of the Bladder in its Passage through it , whence their Tone is so relaxt , they have lost all power of Retention : And for this Reason , I find all Women that void Stones this way , of any considerable bigness , are constantly attended with this Weakness .
But this Trouble is fully recompensed by the Remission of her Pains , which , since the Stone came away , are so abated , that she can walk about , and is now able to come abroad .
It is very extraordinary that so large a Stone should be naturally voided by the Bladder ; and I have read but of very few that come nigh the bigness of this , which I have now in my Possession , and keep among some other natural Productions , as a curious Rarity .
Thomas Bartholine in his Centuria Ia Hist. Anat .
Observat .
71 .
sets down the Description and Figure of a very large Stone as he thought , though he says it was but Ovi Gallinacei magnitudine , that came from a Woman as this did .
And Daniel Angelus in the Miscellan .
Physico-Medic .
Germanic .
An. 1676 .
Observat .
195 .
gives the Figure of another Stone , much of the same size with Bartholine 's , spontaneously discharged the same way .
Likewise Petrus Borellus Centuriae Secundae Observe .
22 .
mentions a Stone , but gives no Figure of it , voided by a Girl through her Urinary Passage , Ovi Anserini magnitudinis , as his own Words are , which I suppose was much of the same size with this of ours .
But Nicolaus Tulpius in his more elaborate Observe .
Lib. 3 .
cap. 7 .
gives an Account of a Woman 89 Years of Age , that voided a Stone , of which he gives you an accurate Figure , full as broad , somewhat longer , and almost ~ heavier than this I have described ; yet she lived after it , and was so well as to walk abroad .
I mention these several Examples , not only to illustrate and confirm the Truth of our present Story , even to the most incredulous ; but as so many Arguments , from whence I think , one may reasonably inser , That no Woman need be obliged ever to undergo the painful and hazardous Section of the Stone ; though some among the Ancients describe the particular manner how the Operation is to be performed in this Sex ; as AElius Tetr.4 .
Sermon 4.~ cap.99 .
And among the Moderns , Monsieur Tolet Traite de la Lithotomie , Chapit .
15 .
page .
122 .
For since Nature by her own Power , without the Assistance of any Help or Remedies , could disburthen her self , and force away such large Stones as these here described , why may we not probably conclude , That even those still of a larger , if there be any such bred in Women , as one may well question , since all those Accounts of Stones of prodigious Bulk bred in the Bladder , are related of Men only ; as if Nature kept somewhat the same Rule of Proportion in these sort of Productions , as she observes generally in the Stature of Men and Women : I say , why may not they be brought away , by putting the Body into a convenient Posture , and so by the Hand and Fingers forcing the Stone into the Urinary Passage , which Application of relaxing and strongly emollient Remedies , may be so dilated , as to give a free Passage to the Stone without any forceable Section ?
But this I leave to be determined by such , who lighting upon proper Subjects , may have occasion hereafter to try the Success of this Practice , which if found to answer Expectation , may be of solid and real use .
July 14 .
An. 1691 .
SInce my writing the foregoing Account , Mr. Thom .
Proby , an ingenious Chyrurgion of this Town , has lately in two Instances of Fact , successfully demonstrated the Practicableness of what I then proposed only with Probability , touching the Extraction of Stones bred in the Bladders of the Female Sex without any Incision , as well those of a large , as those of a smaller Magnitude .
The first Instance is the more remarkable , as well for the Girls being very young , and by consequence the Passage of her Urethra strait and small , as that the Stone was extraordinary long , and considerably large for one of her Years .
The annexed Figure expresses exactly enough both its Shape and Bigness .
The Child 's Name was Sarah Cooke , about Six Years old ; for some Years past she had been so miserably afflicted with the Stone , and a perpetual Incontinency of her Urine , that her Parents at any Hazard were willing to attempt relieving her of so violent a Pain , and so foul a Distemper .
Whereupon , June the 8th , 1693 .
the Child being placed in a convenient Posture in a Man 's Lap sitting across a Table , with her Arms tied down to her Legs by a sort of Bandage usual in these Cases , the Chyrurgion first past his Catheter into the Neck of the ~ , that it might empty it self of all Urine , before he inserted his Dilatory Instrument , or his Speculum Vesicae as one may call it , with which he extended the Urethra as much as possibly he might with safety , and without putting the Child to extraordinary Pain ; afterwards by help of a Directory and Forceps gently thrust into the Bladder , he brought away the Stone without any manner of Incision in about 3 or 4 Minutes time from the passing in of his first Instrument , and put the Patient to so little Pain during the Operation , that when it was over , and she laid quietly a-bed , she slept without any Opiate 7 or 8 Hours together , as she had not done in many Months before , and is now perfectly well and at ease .
Whether hereafter the Sphincter of the Bladder may restore it self , and become so strong , that she shall not be liable to a Stillicidium Urinae as heretofore , the only Inconvenience that may be feared at any time can attend this sort of Operation , is uncertain as yet , since it is so lately performed ; but being so young a Child , and the constant Cause of the Relaxation of the Sphincter , the Stone in the Bladder being ing now wholly removed , it is probable she may recover it , and not be subject to this Weakness as heretofore .
The other Instance is a Child something elder , about 10 Years of Age , her Name Elizabeth Mortimer , who has been troubled with an Involuntary distilling of her Urine , and other painful Symptoms of the Stone for these three or four years past ; but on June the 12th,1693 .
was happily relieved by the extraction of a large Stone near as big as a Pigeons Egg , after the same manner and method as before described , and with as good Success , though not altogether with as quick Expedition .
From these Examples one may reasonably conclude , That those of intermediate Years as well as Childhood and Old Age , are capable of undergoing this Operation of Extraction of the Stone with Safety : And I make no great doubt to assert , That it is the only proper and secure way of freeing the Female Sex from the Stone in the Bladder , and that such should never be persuaded to undergo the Section upon any account , since the Stone , if it be not of an immoderate bigness , may be extracted by dilating only the Neck of the Bladder ; and if it be of so large a Bulk ; ( as I have reason to think it never , or very rarely is in this Sex ) as that it cannot be drawn out this way ; then the Section , if the Surgeon be so bold as to venture on it , must be made so wide , as wholly to cut through the short Neck of the Bladder , and to divide likewise some part of its thin membranous Substance , which is known to be of the most dangerous consequence in cutting the Stone , and to be avoided as certain Death to the Patient .
I have added the Figures of the Three Stones I have here mentioned , all expressed as big as the Life .
That Mark Fig. 1 .
is the Stone spontaneously voided by the Old Woman .
Fig. 2 .
was taken out of the Child Six Years Old .
And Fig. 3 .
was brought away from the Child Ten Years Old ; both these without any Section .

