IV .
An Account of aBOOK An Account of Dr. Burnet 's Book , Entitled , ARCHEOLOGI AE Philosophicae , sive Doctrina Antiqua de Rerum Originibus .
Libri duo .
Londini , Typis R. N. Impensis Gualteri Kettilby ad Insigne Capitis Episcopi in Caemeterio Paulino .
1692 .
IN this Treatise he endeavours to discover what were the Sentiments of the Ancients concerning the Origin or beginnings of this visible World , of which he conceives Men in all Ages have had a true , if not a Divine Knowledge , as well as of a Divine Power , and of the intermediate Order , Vicissitudes and Ends of all things .
And that Pythagoras was not the Inventor of the Mundan System ascribed to him , but the Conveyer only of it from the Orientals , ~ , to the Grecian Schools , where yet it received lesser Improvement as to particular Explications , then it has by the Modern Inquisitions , ( as he conceives ) though yet he grants that our Histories of their Opinions are very imperfect , yet as the Magnificence of a Structure may be judged of by its Ruins , so in general we may have some Idea of their Doctrines by the Fragments of them which are yet to be found in the Grecian Writers , as well Historical as Fabulous , or Muthical and Poetical .
By all which he endeavours to prove , that most of the Ancients held very much the same Notion concerning the beginning of things with that delivered by Moses in the beginning of his Writings , with which , he conceives , also that his already published Theory is consonant .
It was his Design also to have written a general Body of Philosophy , but the sense of his Age and approaching Death seems to have made him desist , and to satisfy himself with what he hath hitherto performed in the preceding Books , and in this which he seems to make the Seal and Consummation of the former .
He divides the whole Discourse into two Books .
In the first he endeavours to discover what were the most ancient Doctrines of all Nations concerning the beginnings of things , in general .
But in the Second he endeavoured to collect all such Passages amongst them as seemed most consonant to , and confirming of the Doctrines delivered in the first part of his Theory where he had omitted taking notice of them , though in the Second Part he hath intermixed them with the Theory throughout , which therefore did not need any such a Supplement .
In the First Chapter he enquires whencethis Knowledge is to be fetched , which he conceives to be all from the Postdiluvian Records , which were all conveyed by Noah from the Antidiluvian , and dispersed amongst his Posterity .
Next he enquires where any Footsteps are to be found of it among these .
And since he finds the Ancients divided the Nations of the World into Four Heads , comprehending the whole Race of Mankind , to wit , the Scythians towards the North , the Celti towards the West , the AEthiopians towards the South , and the Indians towards the East .
He follows the same Order in his Enquiry .
And amongst the first he finds no ancient Footsteps of their Philosophy , and doubts whether ever they had any : Tho ' Abaris is said by Suidas to have written a Theogonia ; and a Septentrional Mythology hath been of late published , favouring much of Antiquity .
Amongst the Celti he finds Philosophy to have been all along , viz. among the Druids and Semnothei ; of whom yet we have but a dark Account , that they professed to understand the Order and Motions of the Heavens , and the Will of the Gods ; and that Strabo says , they taught the Worlds Periods by Water and Fire , and held a transmigration of Souls , as the Pythagoreans ; tho ' they are thought to have much preceded him , and to have been the most ancient for Mythologick Theology .
Of this Class were what Philosophers were to be sound anciently among the Germans , Britains , Spaniards and Italians ; of some of which Strabo affirms , that they had Poems of their Laws , &amp;c. of 6000 years standing .
Those among the Hetrusci , Diodorus Siculus says , studied Philosophy : And Plutarch says , they had the Notion of the Annus Magnus , or Periods of Revolutions , and that the Romans had their Sacred Rites from them .
Among the AEthiopians the Gymnosophists were famous ; but we can find very little information what their Philosophy was .
They were Celebrated indeed for their Laws , Government and Converse with the Gods , and had a very ancient use of Letters ; and had Colledges of Priests which taught Philosophy and Theology .
These are said by Lucian to have been the first Astronomers , and to have taught the Egyptians .
But as to the Theory of the Earth , there is nothing of theirs to be found .
And indeed , most of the Ancient Authors that writ purposely of them are now no more to be found .
Having passed over these three Heads without making much Discovery to his purpose , he in the Third Chapter comes to the Orientals or Indians , comprehending all the Asians ; and some of their Neighbours , as the Egyptians and Greeks .
He begins then with the most Eastern Nation , the Seri or Chineses .
cilsus and Dionysius call them Atheists , because they had no Idol-Temples or Worship ; and Barbarians , because they had no Commerce with other Nations .
So that it seems little of their Learning was known to the Ancients ; though of late years they have been much better known , to have very ancient Histories , and some that mention the Flood and the beginnings of things .
But by what we can learn , their Physiology is much inferior to what was known in the Western Parts , as was also their Mathematicks , being all of their own Production , and not borrowed from any besides .
Contrary to that of the Greeks , Romans , and other Europeans , who derived all from others .
Passing from these to the South , he meets with the Brachmans , Philosophers celebrated in all Ages for their Devoting themselves wholly to Contemplations , of unknown Original , but yet worthy to be more diligently enquired into , both for their Eminency in Physiology and Astronomy , though both were wrapped up and veiled under Mythology : Yet they had some Notions concordant with the Greek .
Strabo also says , That they held the World to have been generated , and was corruptible ; That it was formed out of Water , but the rest of the Univrese from other Principles .
The chief of these were most honoured , and absolutely free , neither Governing , nor Governed by any .
This is the Sum of what can be found amongst the Ancients concerning their Natural Philosophy .
In the Fourth Chapter he enquires concerning the Assyrians and Babylonians , who were the first Empire after the Flood : These are accounted the first who cultivated Literature and had Public Schools at Babylon , which continued so till the time of Nebuchadonozer and Daniel .
These Learned Men were called Chaldeans and Magi ; and the chief of them were Physiologers and Astronomers , and studied lawful Arts , as may well be concluded ; for that Daniel accepted the Presecture of them : These excluded the Astrologians and Diviners from their Habitations .
To these Pythagoras resorted to learn the Motions of the Heavens , and the Original of the World , saith Justine .
~ and ~ .
These were then under the Persians , but the remainders of the Chaldeans and Babylonians .
However , nothing is left of their Opinions but what Diodorus has hinted , That they believed the Matter of the World Eternal , but its Form , Order and Ornament to be constieuted by Divine Providence .
And further , That they believed the Earth to be of the Form of a Schiff or Tray : Only he speaks of their Antiquity , and of making Astronomical Observations many Ages before Alexander .
This is all that is intelligible : All the rest concerning their Oracles of Ziroaster , &amp;c. is nothing but Canting , and a Jargon of Scraps of we know not who .
It is pity we have lost the Works of Berosus , who had written their Opinions .
In the Fifth Chapter he speaks of the Persian Magi , who cultivated Physiology as well as Theology .
These had a Theogonia like the Greeks ; and from these Pythagoras learnt the Origin of the World , and the Motions of the Heavens .
These taught likewise the Periods and Renovation of the World .
The Prince of these Magi was Zoroaster , of which he judges there were two .
The Persians held the Elements , Stars and the Heavens to be Gods ; and worshipped most the Sun among the Stars , and the Fire among the Elements : And under the Nature of Jupiter they comprehended the whole Circuit of Heaven .
They , as well as the Greeks , Romans and Hebrews , continually nourished the Fire .
And the Egyptians as well as other Nations much honoured it .
The Persians supposed this Fire to have fallen from Heaven ; and the Stoicks called it Jupiter , into which all things resolved .
Thus their Theology was Physeology , and all their other Rites may be in the same manner resolved ; of which Herodotus has given a plain Account : In which he particularly takes notice , that in their Sacrificing they sung their Theogonia , which our Author conceives to be of the Origination of things .
Of Zoro~ , Pliny relates that he left Two Millions of Verses , expounded by Hermippus .
The Arabians mention Twelve Volumes , each filling a whole Bulls Hide of the Writings of Zoroaster to be left to the Magi .
Suidas mentions divers Books of the same , concerning Dreams and Astronomical Productions , and Four Books of Natural Philosophy ; but all are lost ; and what goes under his Name are all Fictitious , except one Fragment preserved by Plutarch out of Theopempus ; another by Porphyrius in Antro Nympharum , out of Euhulus ; and a third by Eusebius , out of a Persian Book , which he will have Zoroaster 's .
As the beginning of these Magi was unknown , so was their end ; yet some remained to the time of Alexander ; and it is believed they fell with the Persian Empire ; and all that had been written concerning them is also perished Such were Hermippus Smyrnaeus , Pallas , Osthanes , Eubulus , Theodorus Mopsuestenus , Hermodorus Pla'onicus , Antesthenes or Rhodonis , Zanthus ~ , Sotiones , Dinon , Theopompus , Eudemus Rhodius , and Clearchus Solensis .
In the Sixth Chapter he enquires after what is to be met wirh-among the Arabians and Phaenicians .
The First is Job , whom he makes an Arabian , before the time of Moses , who had the knowledge of Letters , and of the Heavens , and many other parts of the Creation , besides that of the Worship of the true God .
This Knowledge lasted to the time of Solomon , as appears by the Queen of Sheba : Nay , till the Birth of Christ , as appears by the Magi that came to Worship him .
The Zabii he makes to be some of the ancient Arabs , among whom Abraham was bred .
These boast of having the Religion of Noah .
To these , Porpbyry says , Pythagoras went : And P liny affirms the same of Democritus : But these since that time have degenerated , and have taken up the Grecian Learning ; though they had also translated into their Language the Ancient Learning of the Egyptians , Persians and Chaldeans ; but these were burnt by the Sarazens .
What Writings yet remain among them are thought not older than Eight or Nine Hundred Years .
The ~ among the ancient Arabs held the World Eternal , and the Soul mortal .
Hence their Proverb , Uteri pariunt , Sepulchra deglutiunt , The Womb makes , the Tomb takes .
Next for the Phaenicians , he finds them very ancient , and early knowing in Letters , Arithmetic , Astronomy , Physiology , Navigation , Foreign Trade and Planting .
Thales and Zeno were Phaenicians , and to them went divers of the Greek Philosophers .
Stabo says , that Moscbus found the Hypothesis of Atoms before the Trojan War .
The Philosophy before the Trojan War was all by Tradition , but after that came in the Rational and Disputative .
Nothing remains of Sanchoniathon 's Philosophy , but that he had studied the Kosmogonian of Taautes , deducing the World from the ancient Chaos , and a precedent ~ or Matter .
He wrote also divers other Philosophical things ; but they , as well as all the other Authors that wrote of the Phaenicians , as Theodotus Hypsicrates and Mochus , Hestieus , and Hieronimus Egyptius are wholly lost .
In the Seventh Chapter he enquires what Footsteps of ancient Physical Learning is to be met with among the Hebrews , and in their Cabala .
First he notes , that Lactantius wondered why Pythagoras and Plato went to the Egyptians for Knowledge , but not to the Hebrews ; which is an Argument they were not then considerable for that kind of Knowledge ; that is , Physical and Mathematical .
What they had was contained in their Cabala , which they pretend to have received from Moses .
But whatever it were at first , it hath been much depraved with Rabbinical Figments and Chimera 's : Such are the Mystical Numeration by the Letters of Words ; such are the Magical Spells derived also thence ; such the expressing common Notions by a sort of Mystical Words , or Characters , or Numbers , to make it more wonderful to such as do not understand it .
Which was a trick made use of also by Pythagoras in his Symbols , by the Egyptians in their Hieroglophicks , and by the Hermeticks in their Cant : All which , if the Veil were removed , would appear empty Nothings , being of no other use , but to amuse the Ignorant and conceal their own Defects and Emptiness .
They divided their Cabala into Nominal and Real .
The Nominal was Triple , Gemmatria , Notaricon , and Themmura , p'ainly Modern and Barbarous Names .
All consisted in shuffling the Letters of Words mixed with Number .
Reuclin yet says , that the Jews affirm , that thereby may be sound out all the Knowledge of Moses and Solomon , as well Divine as Humane , and that Solomon himself received all his Knowledge thereby .
The real Cabala they make Two-fold , i. e. The Doctrine of Sephiroth , and the Doctrine of the Four Worlds .
They make 10 .
Cabalistick ~ , viz : the Crown .
2 .
Wisdom .
3 .
Prudence .
4 .
Magnificence .
5 .
Severity .
6 .
Pulchritude .
7 .
Victory .
8 .
Glory .
9 .
Foundation .
10 .
Kingdom , by which what they mean the Author understands not .
They pretend they are Emanations from God , and that they are Numbers emanating from the infinite Verity .
He spends some time in examining each , and their branchings out into divers other Subdivisions .
But upon the whole he concludes , That the further he proceeds the more Obscurity and Confusion he meets with .
Next he examines the Doctrine of the Four Worlds , to wit , Azilath , Briah , Jetzirah , Ashiah , i. e. the Worlds of Emanation , Creation , Formation and of the Fabric ; before all which they put the Ensophick , or Infinite World , from which all the other do spring .
Upon a more deligent Enquiry into the Contents of these mystic Doctrines the Author seems to think them all Cheers , and concludes with the Words of Christ , Men love Darkness rather than Light , because their Deeds are evil .
Every one that doth Evil hates the Light , left he should be discovered ; but he that doth Truth , comes to the Light , that his Deeds may be manifest ; suspecting all those affected Obscurities to be devised by them to conceal nothing else but their own Ignorance and Deceit .
The Author proceeds further with examining other parts of the Cabala : But upon the whole he finds nothing rational , or containing any real Knowledge .
But he conjectures , that the most ancient Cabala , before it was confounded and defiled with Fables , might contain somewhat of the Origination of things , and their Gradations ; but as it has been in time changed and augmented by imaginary Fables , and blinded with impertinent and nonsensical Explications , it is now become a confused Mass of Incongruities and Absurdities .
But by examining these Dregs , he conceives that the Ancients might hold , That before the Creation all things had their being in God ; and that from him they flowed or emarated when first made , and that they will all flow back into him when they are destroyed , which he conceives was also the Opinion of the most Ancient Philcsophers ; and that there would succeed other Emanations and Regenerations , and other succeeding Destructions and Obsorptions to all Eternity , as it had been from all Eternity ; that Nothing was produced out of Nothing ; and that the things produced never return to Nothing , but always have their Subsistence in God .
Which Sense , if it doth not contain , he conceives it may be looked upon as Salt that hath lost its Savour , which is good for nought , but to be thrown out of Doors .
But if it contains any solid Knowledge , it ought to be manifested or condemned otherwise to perpetual Darkness .
But left it might deceive the Ignorant , he cautions them to be lead by no Authority that is not Divine , nor by any Reason that is not clear and manifest .
Before he leaves this Head , he enquires concerning the ~ , a Sect among the Jews , not unlike in their Manners to the Indian Brachmans .
All that these had of Philosophy , says Philo , was of God , and of the Generation of things : But what that Knowledge was does not appear ; but he conceives it is to be learnt from the Brashmans , with whom they agreed .
From these he passes on ( in the Eighth Chapter ) in his Search for the ancient Learning amongst the Egyptians , where he finds it very ancient , and much celebrated by the Hebrews , who extol both Moses and Solomon , the one for knowing , the other for excelling it ; and by the Greeks , as from whence they had derived their Knowledge .
Upon a stricter Enquiry into it , he finds it to be first Geometry , as old as the overflowing of the Nile , upon which account it was invented ~ but he thinks they were but Land Meters ; and that the Greeks , as Thales and Pythagoras did make it Speculative .
2 .
Astronomy .
But this the Chaldeans knew ; nor doth it appear which were the first ; but he conceives both were very ancient , but rude and imperfect , and much improved afterwards by the Greeks .
However , he believes they had a true Knowledge of the System of the Heavens , and understood the Motions of the Planets , &amp;c. Yet he thinks that they did not understand them so well , as to reduce their Motions to Calculation .
They are said also to have cultivated Music and Physic , but these also without Theories , and only by Tradition .
And tho Herodotus says , they had for every Disease a particular Physician : Yet both these were much more improved by the Greeks .
They are said by others to be the Inventers of Chemistry .
Lastly , That they were knowing in Physicks or Natural Science ; that is , the Cosmogonia , Theogonia , or Theologia , which they looked upon as the same Science .
They held the Earth to be formed out of the confused Mass of the Four Elements , or out of the Chaos ; and a two-fold Destruction of it , one by Fire , another by Water ; That the Earth was of an Egg form ; and that we call the Pythagorick System was the oldest of all others , but kept among their Arcana .
Their most Celebrated Philosopher was Hermes Trismegistus ; though when he lived , or what he thought and writ is not known .
Those that bear his Name are fictitious .
But among the multitude of his Writings , his Cosmologia , mentioned by Philo Biblius , is lost .
The Egyptians preserved their Learning by their Priests , who had Colledges in divers parts of Egypt .
They had it inscribed on Obelisks , and written in Books .
The Babylonians had Celestial Observations for 720 Years ~ on burnt Tiles .
Democritus transcribed his Morals from a Babylonian Column .
The Columns of Hermes in Egypt are famous , on which were inscribed his Doctrine .
From these the Greeks and Phaenicians had much of their Knowledge , and Manetho his Sacred History .
Amianus Marcellinus says , these Columns were placed in subterraneous Valuts , and were there before the Flood .
Manetho and Josephus assert the same of theirs , both possibly the same .
In their Books were written their Laws , their History and their Philosophy .
Some things were communicable , others were Arcana , not to be devulged .
They had also a two-fold way of Writing , one Common , another Sacred .
This was written with Hieroglyphics .
The Brachmans have not only a different Character , but a different Language to preserve their Philosophy .
These ~ were strict Concealers of their Secrets , as many Authors complain of them .
Nor was Pythagoras admitted without being first Circumcised , and otherwise qualified .
The Esseni , and others of other Nations , as Persians , Syrians , and Indians , adminiitred Oaths , &amp;c. of Secrecy .
They further obscured their Knowledge by Symbols , ~ and Fables , in which the Greeks also follow 'd them , as did also most other Nations in the Histories of their Gods , of which kind he gives divers Instances .
Among these are the Mythologies of the Prophers in the Old Testament , and the Parables of Christ in the New .
This Mythologick Genius Salustius calis Divine ; and it is plain Myhologies were made use of by the Ancients to conceal their knowledge from the Vulgar , and yet preserve it safe for the Learned .
Nay , Divine Providence doth so conceal both Divine and Natural Knowledge , that this or that part becomes known to this or that Man in one Age , which hath lain absconded to all preceding .
This Mythologick was the most ancient Learning among the Greeks , as he proves by several Testimonies ; yet was it first received from the Egyptians .
This causes him to enquire whether the Works of Hermes were so writ , and he finds by a place quoted by Eusebius , that they were first written plain , then turned by the Son of Thabion into ~ , and then transcribed into Greek .
So that plain Writing was before Mythologick ; and it is probable those that have it Mythologically , had it before pure ; and that the Additions that have been added to the first Fables , have obscured , if not quite obliterated the concealed Sense He propounds and answers two Objections , by which he shows the Inconsistency of Men 's Actions with their Knowledge , and so Apologizes for the Egyptian Idolatry , and their Astrologick and Magic Practices .
Last of all , he enquires how the Egyptians came to lose this Learned State they had kept for so many Ages , which he shows to have proceeded from their being conquered and overun by divers Nations ; as by the Persians under Cambises and some succeeding Kings , by whom it began to decay .
And by the Romans , who burnt the Alexandrian ' Library , with which their Learning was also much destroyed ; and by the Conquest of the Saracens totally extinguished .
Amongst the lost Historians of the Egyptian Learning , Manatho was the chiefest , as appears by Testimonies now extant , next Sanchoniathon , then Asclepiades , Petosiris , Hecateus , ~ , and Cheremon , and many others .
These are Losses , but nothing to be named with the loss of the Library of Ptolomeus Philadelphus , wherein many Myriads perished in a moment , containing the Sum of all Egyptian , nay , and all Oriental Learning too , in all probability .
In the Ninth Chapter he enquires concerning the Graecian Philosophy , of which , that he may the more fully give you the History , he produces sufficient Proof to show it derived from the Egyptian ; not that he denies the Grecians to have much improved several parts thereof : That they learned their Geometry , Astronomy and Arithmetic from the Egyptians , Chaldeans , and Phaenicians , Herodotus , Plato , Aristotle , Diodorus , Strabo , Laertius , Achilles Tatius , and others their own Authors do testify .
It is said , Semiramis , who lived Eight Hundred Years before the Trojan War , built a high Tower in Babylon , on the top of which the Astronomers made their Observations , at which times the Greeks had not the use of Letters .
Moreover , Calisthenes sent into Greece from Babylon Celestial Oservations for 1900 Years before Alexander 's time .
And Epigenes found Observations at Babylon for 720 years , and others were brought of 480 , as Pliny relates ; these were inscribed on baked Bricks : Whereas the Greek Observations began with Hipparchus and Ptolomy .
Yet though the Histories were furnished by the Barbari , the reasons of their Motions were invented by the Greeks .
But though they improved the Mathematick Arts , yet they vitiated the Physicks , which they also received from them .
That the Greeks had these from the Barbari , Clemens Alexandrinus and Eusebius both testify ; as doth also Porphyrius and Josephus , sephus , and Diodorus Siculus , who affirm the Greeks most eminent for this Learning .
As Orpheus , Thales , Pherecides , Pythagoras , Solon , Plato , Eudoxus , all setcht it either from the Egyptians or Phaenicians .
Nay , the very knowledge of Letters was first brought into Greece by Cadmus not long before the Trojan War .
Whereas Learning flourished in Assyria , Egypt , Phaenicia , Arabia , Ethiopia , India , and among the Celti long before that time .
There were two states of Grecian Philosophy .
The first , which was the oldest , most of which was wrote in Verse , treated of the Cosmogonia , or Origination of things , by Thamyras , Linus , Orpheus , Museus , ~ .
Also Thales , ~ , Empedocles , Paramenides , and some others , whose Fragments are collected by Steevins in his Poesis Philosophica : All which Poetic Writers did mythologize the Cosmogonia , Homer only excepted .
This the Author proves by several Testimonies ; and adds , That Orpheus was the first that brought Learning into Greece ; that asserred the Oval Form of the Earth , the Form the Author assigns to his Antidiluvian Earth : That he lived not long after the time of Moses , and was the Founder of the Grecian Theology , es Moses of the Hebrew ; and that both accommodated the Ceremonies to the Capacity of their respective People .
That is , Orpheus instituted such a Religion as he could , not what he would , wanting the Divine Assistance of Miracles which Moses had .
He was feign to make use of Music and pleasing Mythologick Stories to allure his People from Barbarity to Government and Society .
For which purpose it was of very great benefit , and generally made use of not only by Poets , but Legislators and Physiologers .
Orpheus excelled in all these , and first taught the Grecians , Religion , and the Rewards and Punishments of another Life , which he proves by Heathen and Christian Testimonies .
But among these must be distinguished what he taught the Vulgar from what was his Secret Doctrine , for that he had both the ~ ~ ~ .
Suidas says , he held the Heavens to be formed of the AEther , and the Earth out of the Chaos , before which he placed Time as the measure , but he makes them both coeval ; whereas others of the Ancients separate them by a multitude of Ages .
Empedocles makes all the Stars to be Fires , but Orpheus to be Worlds ; the Author supposes the Planets were meant .
As the Moon was therefore called ~ , which Orpheus first asserted Habitable , proved by Proclus , as also that the Oval Earth was to be destroyed by Fire , and then to be renewed .
Before he leaves this Head , he answers the Objections of Cicero , and more especially Gerard Vossius , who would persuade that there never was any such Men as Orpheus , Museus or Linus , whose Arguments the Author thinks no ways cogent or to be regarded , since there are so many positive Proofs to the contrary both in Heathen and Christian Writers .
In the Tenth Chapter he enquires among the Greek Philosophers that succeeded Orpheus : And first amongst the Ionicks .
These are the Second kind of Physiologers , who wrote expressly and in Prose , not in Verse and Mythology , as the former .
These were Thales and his Ionicks , Pherecydes , Pythagoras , Zenophanes , Parmenides , Leucippus , Democritus , Empedocles , Plato , and others , to Epicurus and Aristotle , in whom ended Philosophic Antiquity ; except some Fragments among the Stoicks .
Thales was a Phaenician , but received his Knowledge from Egypt , and was famous for Geometry , Astronomy and Physic , and asserted the Immortality of the Soul ; and first writ a Discourse of Physicks , without Mythology or Theology .
Nothing of his Assertion sertions remains but only that all things were generated out of Water .
Which is agreeable to St. Peter and Moses .
Possibly more particulars of his Doctrine may be found among his Followers , Anaximander , Anaximenes , ~ , Archelaus .
Anaxagoras then makes a mind to Regulate Matter , and move it , and was therefore called ~ .
He ranges the four Elements by Gravity , and is said to have introduced Vortices .
As for the Heavens , the Ionians much promoted the Knowledge of them ; i.e. They held the Heavenly Spaces to be AEther ; the Stars , Fire ; the Planets opaque Bodies : That the Moon had Hills and Vales , and was Habitable , and that it was enlightned by the Sun , which was a most pure Fire .
He held also the Rotation of the Earth , as also the Annual Motion about the middle of the World , as Tneon Smyrneus affirms .
To show the Reason why it is so difficult to find what were their true thoughts , He quotes this Passage of Plutarch .
This Doctrine ( that is , concerning the Heavens ) was not celebrated and famous , but hidden and kept secret , and it was discoursed of with great Caution among a few under an Oath of Secrecy ; for Philosophisings concerning the Heavens would not be endured , because those seemed to restrain and bind up the Divine Numen to Causes without Reason , and to blind Powers , and to involuntary Effects ; upon which Account Protagoras was banished , and Anaxagoras put in Irons .
Socrates also for the Name of a Philosopher was put to Death .
Whence the Author observes , that in all Ages it has been very dangerous for Philosophers to speak plain Truth amongst the Vulgar .
In the Eleventh Chapter he enquires concerning the Doctrine of Pythagoras and the Italic Philosophy , where he finds that either Pythagoras wrote nothing , or if he did , even the History of them is lost : So that nothing of his Physiology is remaining save only his Theory of the Heavens , which is called the Pythagorick System ; he placing the Sun in the Centre , and the Earth moving round it ; the Moon as an Anticthone or opposite Earth enlightned by the Sun , the Comets to be above the Air , or between that and the Planets ; that the Heavens were fluid AEther , and the Stars so many Worlds .
We know not his Sentiments about the Cosmogonia , or Terrestrial Productions , for he more busied himself about Celestial Speculations , and about Abstracts and Intellectuals .
as did also his Followers , who treat of the Anima Mundi , consisting in Harmony indivisible and divisible the same , and an other ( as they Phrase it ) and such other Airy Notions as have no Foundations in Nature .
But Ocellus Lucanus , another Pythagorean , makes the World Eternal , both for Matter and Form , as he does also the Race of Mankind .
But indeed there is little in this Author that favours of Pythagoras his Doctrine ; and Plato differs wholly from him , asserting the World to be made by God , and to be corruptible .
Yet it must be granted that both the Pythagoreans and Platonists incline to make the Matter Eternal , but the Form Variable ; and they had both their Vulgar Doctrines , and their Secret Doctrines .
And though the Author cannot find any but common sense in his Mystical Numbers , yet he thinks there might be somewhat more , which is now lost to Mankind : The chief of these was his Tetractis , the Seventh was not Ignoble , but the Tenth the Noblest and most perfect of all .
But of the Reason and Signification of these neither any of the Ancients nor Moderns give any Satisfactive Solutions or Explications .
Yet all the Ancients assert this to be the Doctrine of Pythagoras .
And therefore after having run over many of their thoughts , the Author thinks that Numbers will produce nothing but Numbers , not Things ; and that converting things all to Arithmetical Operations was in the Pythagoreans and Platonists a failure , not unlike that of the Peripateticks , of turning all into Logical terms .
Pherecides Pythagoras his Master , writ a Theogonia .
And Empedocles , one of his Scholars , asserted the Sun to be a Mass of Fire , and the Stars to be fiery , and the Earth made of the four Elements , united by Love , and separated by Strise .
It is uncertain whether Pythagoras wrote or no , but certain that Philolaus , Archytas , and Eudoxus di~ .
And it is said Plato bought three Books of Philolaus , whence he took his Timaeus .
Archytas is said to have written many things , but all are lost but a Fragment about Mathematicks .
Eudoxus also , and Empedocles , but all are now lost .
The Writings also of Aristotle concerning the four Pythagorick Elements are lost , and some others .
So are the Writings of Aristoxenus , Heraclides , Neanthes Hermippus , Syrianus Didymus , and Eudoxus .
Also Moderatus Gaditanus , Alexander Polyhistor , Androcidus , and others .
In the Twelfth Chapter he enquires concerning the Opinions of the Eleatick Sect , and of the Stoicks .
This Sect was Founded by Zenophanes in the times of Anaximander , and consisted of a Mixture of various Nations and Opinions .
The Doctrine he held was , that there were infinite Suns , and infinite Moons like ours , which he said was habitable , but that they were all Eternal .
Parmenides held them to be formed out of Fire and Earth , and Men out of Clay .
They agreed much with the Ionick Sect. Leucippus and Democritus were of this Sect , who introduced Atoms .
Leucippus acknowledged the Motion of the Earth on its Axis , and that when the fluid Mass settled into a Globe , it was covered by a dry Skin , which growing thicker , formed the habitable Earth : He supposes the Axis also at first right , but altered afterward ; both which are consonant to the Author 's Theory .
Democritus was an Auditor of Leucippus , and had travelled Persia , Arabia , Ethiopia , Egypt , and India , to improve his Knowledge among the Learned of those Countries , and has written many Books , though all lost .
It is said he affirmed the Moon to be a fired Body , but with Mountains , Hills , and Vales ; but the Author supposes only fiery Mountains , such as are on the Earth .
Callimachus wrote of his Opinions .
The Opinion of the Stoicks is Famous for the Future Conflagration of the World .
But little is to be found concerning the Production of it , yet they asserted God to be the Author of it ; but to this they join Matter mixed and of it self without Motion .
This was perishable by the Conflagration , but the Divine Principle Eternal , as they esteemed also the Matter it self , though the Form perished .
So the unformed World they made Eternal , but the formed to have both beginning and end .
They held moreover , of formed Bodies , the Fire to be first , and out of that to be made the other Elements , which again were resolvable into it .
Concerning the Mundane Periods and the Fate of the Stoicks , little need be said in this Discourse , it being well known .
Many Books have been written by and concerning them , but all lost ; yet it is said there is one Ancient Book or Piece of Apollonius Tyrius yet exstant in some Library , but not published , concerning the Opinion and Works of Zeno .
In the Thirteenth Chapter he enquires among the Platonicks , Aristotelians , and Epicureans .
First , he finds the Platonicks like the Pythagoreans , to be most taken up in high Speculations of Abstract Notions , and in assigning Causes of Things to Numbers and Geometrical Figures .
Thus Plato in his ~ makes nothing visible but Fire , nothing tangible but Earth , between these two for their own Union are placed Air and Water .
The Solid Bodies he supposes made up of Triangles ; Fire he makes of Pyramids , consisting of four Triangles ; the Earth of Cubes , consisting of six Squares , and each Square of four Triangles ; the Air of Octotedrons , each side divided into six Scalenes ; then the Water of ~ , consisting of Twenty Triangles , each made up of Scalenes .
To these he adds a Soul , consisting of Numbers and Proportions .
The best Interpretations yet extant concerning it do not make Sense or Reason of it , and at best the Author thinks it but a Lusus Ingenii .
Further , he makes God and Matter to be the two first Principles , to which he adds a third of Idea 's .
But Plato 's Excellency was not for Physicks , but for Morals and Theology .
Divers Writings of the Platonists are out , and some lost ; but these he passes by , since we have the Works of Plato himself .
And now comes to the Dregs of Philosophy amongst the Epicureans and Peripateticks .
From Plato 's time to the present Age he finds nothing of Philosophy , nothing of Discovery , nothing but a Chattering and fruitless Methods of Wrangling .
Concerning the Origination of things , there is nothing found to be met with in Aristotle or his Schools .
They would make the World Eternal , both for Matter and Form ; Men also , and all things else to be so too .
Besides , he does not agree with his own Principles , desposing the four Elements one above the other , but shows not how the Earth seems to be in some parts higher than the Water .
Then for the Heavens he makes Adamantine Orbs , and the Stars like Golden-headed Nails ~stned to them : These Orbs involved he makes to move round the Earth in 24 hours , that is every day .
To this he introduces a contrary Motion for each Planetary Orb from West to East ; the Matter of these he makes incorruptible , but below the Orb of the Moon he puts Fire Elementary , without Light or Heat .
In the middle Region of the Air he puts the Milky Way and Comets .
For the explicating of all other things on the Earth , he introduces Substantial Forms , and Specific Qualities , as insignificant as the Pythagorick Numbers and Harmonies .
Which being so , he wonders why it has been so long approved of by the Christian World .
Then the Author giving a short Catalogue of his Errors , and bids adieu to him , as to a bad Astronomer , a worse Theologe , and the worst of all Physiologers .
His Catalogue is this : 1 .
That the World is Eternal and Incorruptible .
2 .
The Heavens solid , and moved by contrary Motions .
3 .
The Matter of the Heavens Divine and Immutable .
4 .
The Stars to be denser parts of their Orbs , and the Planers to shine by their own Light .
5 .
Light neither a Body nor a Motion .
6 .
Elementary Fire under the Moon .
7 .
The Galaxi and Comets , Meteors .
8 .
The Earth immovable , in the Centre of the World 9 .
Up and down to be founded in Nature immutably .
10 .
The Forms of Animate things substantial .
11 .
Sensation to be made by Intentional Species .
12 .
Rarefaction and Contraction to be made by the increase and decrease of Extension in Matter .
13 .
Providence not to descend below the Moon .
14 .
The Soul to be ~ , and of doubtful Immortality .
Next he visits Epicurus , illiterate , yet of no Vulgar Wit ; he accommodated all things to his Senses , and so his Notions were for the most part absurd and vulgar .
He corrupted only the Doctrines of Democritus and L~cippus .
Upon the whole , the Author thinks his Doctrines not worth considering , but refers the Reader to Gassendus .
He concludes this Enquiry with giving the Names of several that have written of the Opinions of these Grecian Philosophers , and of some that have written their ~ , or Secret DoM m2 ctrines , ctrines , as Pythagoras Zacintheus , Perphyrius , Numerius : He regrets the loss also of many Polyhistorians , as , Theopompus , Phavorinus and Alexander Polyhistor ; also some of the Writings of Deodorus Siculus and Varro .
Now whereas some allege some few others that have been famous for Philosophy in other parts of the World , yet not what they knew or maintained ; and there being no Monuments remaining of such their Knowledge , the Author leaves them in the Obscurity he found them , and thinks he has performed his designed Undertaking to seek what there could be found worthy of preserving among the Ruins and Relicts of the most ancient Philosophers , more particularly relating to the Beginning of things , and has left no quarter unsearched , nor omitted any thing which he judged material to this purpose ; though other Particulars not pertinent , whether bad or good , he has omitted , as being impertinent .
To end this Disquisition , in the Fourteenth Chapter he enquires concerning the Beginning of the Barbarick Philosophy ; that is , whence the Egyptians , Ethiopians , Chaldeans , Phaenicians , Arabians , Indians , and other Orientals obtained their first Knowledge .
There are two Opinions concerning it : One , that they were invented by themselves ; and the other , that they were taught by Moses or Abraham .
The Author approves neither of these .
Not the first , because he meets with no Mention of Experiments , or Observations , or Reasoning and Demonstrations , or Method , or particular Explications ; but what was known was Traditional and Positive .
Not the Latter , because this Learning was eminent long before those times ; for that Moses was bred up in the Schools of Egypt , and for that the Ethiopians were much preceeding to the Egyptians .
Besides the Instance of Job , who is thought by the Author to have much preceded Moses ; for that he takes no notice of the Jewish Laws , Ceremonies or Sabbath , yet was he one that worshipped the true God ; and for that the Age of his Life was above 200 years , and he offered his own Sacrifices without a Priest .
Upon the whole therefore the Author thinks it was conveyed to Mankind by the Sons of Noab , and by him from the Patriarchs of the Antidiluvian World .
These are the principal Matters treated of in the First Book .
IN the Second Book the Learned Author designs to make use of such Testimonies as he can find amongst the Fragments of the most ancient Philosophy , to confirm the Doctrines of his Theory of the Earth , delivered in the First Book thereof , for that he has not therein alleged such Testimonies to confirm it , intermingled with the Discourse it self , as he has done in the Second , but framed the whole from the Idea he had of the Nature of the things themselves .
And whereas in the former Book of this present ~ he ~ inquired after the Ancient Doctrines concerning the whole , or the Universe : In this he restrains his Search after such Doctrines as more particularly concern the Formation and Fabric of the Earth only .
In the first Chapter then he finds that the Production of this World out of a Chaos was the most general , and the most ancient Doctrine of all the Learned , both Theologers , Physiologers and Poets .
He begins with Moses , and shows , that his Tohu and Bohu was the same that the Ancients called Chaos .
And the Apostle , Heb .
11 .
3 .
does so interpret it , and most of the Christian Interpreters understand it so also , as do the Hebrews .
As to other Nations , they either deliver it expressly , as the Philosophers ; or Mythologically , as the Poets .
The Philosophers differ only , for that some ascribe the Formation to a Mind , others to Chance .
He brings several Proofs of it from Phoenicians , Egyptians , Greeks Romans , Persians , and from divers other Authors very famous among the Ancients ; but others , as Orpheus , Empedocles and Hesiod made ~ and Love to Operate in the Separation and Union of the parts of the Chaos .
In the Second Chapter he enquires what Form they assigned to the Primogeneal Earth , and what Estates it was to undergo .
First , For the Form , that it was differing from the present .
Here first he proves , by the Testimony of St. Peter , that there was a three-fold state of the Earth , viz. the Past , Present and Future .
By the Past he shows was meant the ~ , and by the Future the New Heaven and New Earth , which he proves by two passages in Isaiah , and one in the Revelation .
This he shows was also mentioned by St. Paul in the 8th of the Romans , upon which Passage he insists much to prove , that the Apostle meant this three fold state of the Earth ; and alleges the Judgment of the Fathers , Tertullian , Irenaeus , Origin , Hierom , Chrysostom , and others to confirm it .
And then endeavours to answer such as had assigned other Expositions of the Word Creation , of which there are three sorts .
One would have the Fallen Angels to be understood , which he shows could not be the meaning , since they are not to be restored .
Others would have by Creatures to be understood Men : But that cannot be the Sense , because the Creature and Men are distinguished in the very Text .
Thirdly , Those that would have the Gentiles to be meant , are the farthest of all from the plain Sense which he makes to be ( the formed World , ) and that it is to pass thorough three States , a former , a present , and a future .
In the Third Chapter he brings Authority to prove the Primigeneal Form and Situation of the Earth , and wherein it differed from the present , of which the Ancients had manifest Knowledge .
The first he alleges is that of St. Peter , 2 , 3 , 6 .
where he says the Words are opposed to those who asserted the state of the World to be the same as at first : And adds , that St. Austin in expounding these Words of St. Peter , doth so understand them ; to wit , that not only the old Earth perished in the Flood , but the Heavens also .
He next enquires wherein the difference is between the former and the present , and finds St. Peter there describing the ~ , to assert it to be out of the Water , and to stand by the Waters ; that is , ( says he ) to be placed above the Waters , and be sustained by them .
And by this he explains Psal .
136 .
6 .
Prov .
8 .
27 .
but brings no further Proof of his Doctrine .
In the Fourth Chapter he enquires concerning the Nature , Manner and Causes of Deluges , but chiefly of the Universal .
Here he repeats what he has said concerning the quantity of the Water requisite in his Theory , and quotes also what Isaiah says in describing a general Deluge , who makes a kind of Earthquake to precede it , for the Eruption of the Waters out of their Womb , and several other places and Commentators upon them , who all seem to mean Earthquakes .
Then he enquires what are the Causes of particular Inundations , which he makes Three .
( i. e ) 1 .
The Irruption of the Sea upon the Low Countries .
2 .
Great ~ .
3 .
Eruptions of Waters out of the Body of the Earth by Earthquakes : Of each of these he brings Examples out of History .
The first is Strabo 's Description of the manner of making the Dead Sea where Sodom and Gomorrah formerly stood by an Earthquake .
Secondly , A passage in Amianus ~ about the sinking and drowning of places .
Another out of Diodorus Siculus concerning the City of Atlantes , and of Strabo for Eubaea .
Another out of Ziphiline in the Life of Antonius Pius , of the loss of the City of Cyzicum .
Another out of Diodorus Siculus about the loss of Bura and Helice .
Another out of Pausonius of the Loss of the City Idea .
Then he mentions the Ogygian and Deucaleon Floods .
Of Deucalians he remarks a notable passage out of Lucian .
In the Fifth Chapter he enquires whether there be any Record among the Ancients that may confirm his Conjecture about the right Situation of the Earth to the Sun .
Whence proceeded a perpetual Equinox without differing Seasons : For this he looks for the Description of the Golden Ages , viz. in Plato 's Phaedo , where he says , under Saturn the Motions of the Heavens were uniform , but under Jupiter there was an ~ of the Heavens to the posture they are now in , which was the Cause of all the Evil that followed .
He speaks also of its Renovation , or being restored to its former state .
Of these things we have an imperfect Account , by reason of the length of Time past ; but these and greater , or more wonderful things have happened .
Next for the Earth , Plato says it was equilibrate without ~~~ ~ .
Further , he makes the Seasons all temperate , which gave Men long Lives .
He makes also an Abyss to receive the Water trajected through the Earth ; but the Surface of it he makes smooth , and adorned with various Colours and Gems , as the Prophets and Sacred Authors do the New Hirusalem .
In the Sixth Chapter he enquires concerning the changed Position of the present Earth : For this he has a Cloud of Testimonies beside Plato , to wit , Anaxagoras , Empedocles , Diogenes , Leuceppus , Democritus , who all speak of the changed Situation of the Earth 's Axis , whose Testimonies he has elsewhere mentioned .
Among the Inventions of the Astronomers , the Obliquity of the Zodiac and the Seasons of the Year are ascribed to Thales ; which is an Argument it had not been so from the beginning .
But the Histories of the Progress of Astronomy , written by Eudemus and Theon Smyrneus have perished , which might have afforded more cogent Arguments .
Here he mentions what Ovid , Virgil and Homer have said to this purpose , in describing the Golden Age and the Elizium of the Dead .
From the Poets he passes to Plutarch 's Description of the Fortunate Isles , which is a more modern Name for the Elizium , and agrees much with the Paradisical Earth .
And another out of Diodorus Siculus , of the Island Tabrobana ; which he supposes to be for the same purpose .
From these Heathens he comes to the Jewish and Christian Writers , describing Paradise and the Garden of the Lord ; who do much agree with the Heathen Descriptions of the Golden Age .
He quotes Is .
Abarbanil upon the 2d of Genesis , and Aben Ezra ; also Maimonides upon the 10th Chapter of the Sanbedrim ; Manasseh Ben Israel on the Creation , and Abraham Ecchellensis concerning the Testimonies of the Jews and Arabians .
Then for the Christians he brings Tatianus : He quotes also Suidas , and sums up all with Bellarmine 's Conclusion , That there was a perpetual Spring , and another Course of the Sun then at present .
He adds , that Aristotle thought the short and uncertain Life of Creatures proceeded from the Oblique Motion of the Sun in the Zodiac : And that Mantuan says , it was the Opinion of the ancient Astronomers .
He adds also a Passage of Orpbeus preserved by Proclus to the same effect .
In the Seventh Chapter he discourses of the Description which Moses gives of Paradise , and of the state of Nature in the New World ; which is in general , That Moses accommodated his History to the Capacity of those for whom he writ , and that all he has said is not to be taken in a strict literal Sense .
Then in the Eighth Chapter he speaks of the manner of the Interpretations of the Expressions of Moses concerning the Hexameron , which is consonant to his Thoughts in the Seventh .
And in the Ninth Chapter he endeavours to answer those who would have it to be literally understood .
And in the Last Chapter he propounds what things are worthy to be considered in order to the making a right Judgment of the whole ; and more particularly , of what he hath more freely delivered in the preceding Chapters .
He desires his Readers therefore to consider the Use and Style of the Eastern Sages .
2 .
The mean and dull Apprehensions of the Israelites at the time when Moses writ .
3 .
What Learned Commentators have said of this matter .
4 .
What we are to think of the Great God , and what Thoughts concerning him are worthy , and what beseeming .
As to the First , These Orientals did for the most part deliver their Doctrines in Mythology , ad captum Vulgi : But they had also a more Secret Doctrine , which they delivered only to such of their Schools as were of a more clear Understanding .
So that though many vulgar Opinions have been ascribed to them , yet they were such as were delivered for the Vulgar , but that they had others reserved for the more intelligent .
So Iamblicus and Laertius relate some Notions of Pythagoras , which accorded with the Vulgar Opinion of the Heavens ; yet it is plain he held the other Doctrine .
The Jewish Doctors say , the Law speaks with the Tongues of Men ; that is , with a Vulgar Style , yet they had their Cabala to conceal their Mysteries : Nor was this Foreign to the Christian Schools .
Secondly , The People of Israel when Moses writ were of dulland uncultivated Understanding , not fit for Natural Speculations or Divine Contemplations .
Thus much Manasseh Ben Israel says , and so does Moses Maimonides .
This he conceives to be the reason why Moses so wrote the History of the Creation .
Thirdly , Commentators both Jews and Christians have asserted , That many things in that History are not to be understood Literally but Allegorically : For this , besides Philo Judeus , who makes it all Allegorical ; and the Cabalists , whom he passes by , he names R. Moses Egyptius for a solid Author asserting it , and Josephus ; as also Aristobulus , quoted by Eusebius , who is of the same Sentiment , as were many of the Christian Fathers which he cites at large .
Fourthly , As to such-as do not adhere to the Literal Sense , he admonishes them that they do not admit any thing unworthy of God or of our Religion .
Printed for S. Smith and B.Walford , Printers to the Royal Society , at the Princes Arms in St. Paul 's

